Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?

214 replies

Confrontayshunme · 08/01/2022 22:52

A road near our home was closed to create a Low Traffic Neighbourhood during the first lockdown. Children at the local junior and high schools have benefitted hugely in road safety, the cycle and scooter racks were overflowing and the pollution was measured recently as 40% less (in an area with 3 schools).

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning. The day after it reopened, half of the bikes and scooters were gone due to safety concerns. Even my coworker who said it made her cycle to work easier and safer was hugely relieved that she doesn't have to go an extra 10 minutes out of her way when driving.

Anyway, I just despair for the planet if adults and people riding in heated, air conditioned, comfortable, waterproof music players can't possibly leave the house 10 minutes earlier to allow our community's children just one intersection's worth of safety and convenience. Plus, the level of pollution driving our children all these miles (when they could be exercising or improving their mental health) inside a car shortens their lives so there isn't any time saved overall anyway!

And before the pile on commences, I realise many people are not able to use alternate transport or active travel due to physical disability or huge distances and I wouldn't include them in this.

OP posts:
bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 15:54

I used this link to double check my ( flaky) memory

www.cycling-embassy.org.uk/wiki/cycling-is-not-practical-for-the-transportation-or-commuting-needs-of-most-people

But I think the ONS collect such data

Horst · 09/01/2022 15:48

To do the school run for my primary children as one of the parents who live the furthest away I don’t hit 10,000 steps till after I’ve walked there, walked back, done some shopping and some housework.

My dh could drive it there and back in 10minutes. Parents who live two streets away drive the school run. So I’m going to guess the pp is correct.

My dh drives 10miles on country roads with no public transport to work and the same back each day. His dad drives the 30 seconds from his house to the local Tesco and back.

TInkyWlnky · 09/01/2022 15:45

bordermidgebite where is your data from?

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 15:40

20% of car journeys are under 1 mile -there and back you would still not have done 10000 steps

38% of journeys under 2 miles

These are journeys which could help ease congestion and improve health if we could get people walking and cycling more

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 15:35

The idea is that drivers are forced to use the main routes leaving more residential areas safer

Yes more traffic on the main routes that are meant to have it

And making it easier for people to leave the car behind -

if done correctly you end up with fewer cars on the main road also because you have quieter safer options for none car users

Joined4this · 09/01/2022 15:26

Op I agree. Trying to do zero waste/recycle walk etc as much as possible. Yes, big companies do account for the majority of the damage. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try our hardest too.

RunningInTheWind · 09/01/2022 15:24

Oh, and your employer covers your train ticket.

RunningInTheWind · 09/01/2022 15:24

I spent 20 years living in The Netherlands - which, for the uninitiated is NOT the same as “Holland”.

Public transport and bicycles may work in the “randstad” - but to equate that to “lazy Brits” is unfair when the randstad is 1) flat and 2) has the public transport options of London.

TimBoothseyes · 09/01/2022 15:23

All those drivers taken an extra 10 minutes obviously had to drive a different route. So it's ok if all the traffic is directed to somewhere else to become someone else's problem, but it's awful when it happens in your street? Those who were affected by the diversion are probably heaving a sigh of relief at not having to deal with all the extra traffic.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/01/2022 15:04

If it was taking drivers another ten minutes in the morning, you can bet that it was taking people who rely upon public transport another 45 minutes to an hour.

CuteOrangeElephant · 09/01/2022 14:53

No it's not a car free paradise. But what works so well for our family is that we personally do not need a car whereas we never had that option in the UK.

Eleganz · 09/01/2022 14:51

Depends if the solutions that cause the inconvenience actually work.

Low traffic zones in UK cities don't solve problems because they don't take cars off the road, they just move the congestion to other parts of the city and often make the air quality worse in those locations too.

People can also crow about the Netherlands all they like, but, having worked there extensively then it is a really mixed bag in my opinion. Yes, there are great areas for bikes and pedestrians and good public transport links but there is also horrendous traffic with long standing traffic jams and their associated air pollution as well. It is not a car free paradise as some people in the UK like to make out.

There are plenty of things we should be doing such as installing insulation, renewable heating, EV charging infrastructure, public transport investment, continuing to decarbonise the grid, etc. All of which will all have more impact that shutting off a few roads.

CuteOrangeElephant · 09/01/2022 14:49

Oh and one thing you see over here a lot is adapted (electrical) bikes for people with a disability. It means they have a lot more freedom of movement than if they had to rely on public transport.

CuteOrangeElephant · 09/01/2022 14:48

I moved to Holland last year and the difference with the UK is astonishing. We don't need a car here, everything is done on bike, public transport and very occasionally we use a car sharing scheme car.

They have made several streets around here low traffic and it is actually faster for me to cycle to the train station than take a car.

This could be done in the UK but it requires a significant cultural shift.

wonderstuff · 09/01/2022 14:38

I find your story really sad op. In Belgium and Holland bikes are prioritised and it’s safe for children to cycle which has huge benefits for health and well-being. We absolutely need to stop prioritising cars. I get so frustrated that so many people don’t get it.

Where I live the number of car drivers who think nothing of leaving their engine running to heat the car and deice the windows! At my school the buses are rubbish and cycling is pretty dangerous so parents drop of their kids, every morning huge queues of mostly massive cars dropping teens off at the door, the council absolutely could do more but I get the impression most are happy with the status quo.

I have no way of getting to work without a car, but when the petrol ran low, and as it keeps rising, I’m thinking more about an electric car. Even as someone quite keen to be environmentally conscious actually hitting my wallet is a serious motivator.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/01/2022 14:38

@SoManyOptions I’m the same as you, work in rural community nursing covering a wide rural area, the way things are going they want more and more people kept at home so that’s not going to change. I’ve had people tell me well the nhs will just need to give you a car, that’s laughable when currently there is one pool car between 8 of us and some teams don’t have one at all. Also the pool car can only be used for work so I wouldn’t be able to get my kids to school or get to appointments etc.

The bus service where I am is really regular but it’s the time it actually takes to get anywhere where there are shops, hospital etc. I recycle, I don’t have a tumble dryer, I buy my milk in glass bottles from a machine across the road. My car is a small 1.2 petrol, I cannot afford an electric car currently and don’t live in a house with a drive or anywhere to charge. Unfortunately the people who make decisions don’t have a clue about rural living

FanGirlX · 09/01/2022 14:35

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

In my experience people are much more likely to tell others to inconvenience themselves tp prevent climate change than inconveniencing themselves.
Absolutely this.

Look at Prince Harry. Fixing climate change, one private jet at a time.

Horst · 09/01/2022 14:30

People are lazy and will do anything that make their life easier. Our dishwasher died so we didn’t bother to replace it, our dryer recently dried and we have decided to not replace that either because we can and will dry more outside and brought an airer for inside.

We grow a lot of our own fresh food and I personally don’t drive so walk the children to school, we also don’t holiday aboard.

Most people wouldn’t do half of that because it’s not a holiday unless you get on a plane or it’s 10 minutes faster to drive than walk. It’s laziness.

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 14:28

Short sighted & scared of change

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 14:27

@bordermidgebite

Our economy will collapse as a result of climate change

We face the choice of trying to adjust the economy in a controlled fashion or just let it. Collapse

It will. But humans are short sighted.
bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 14:26

Our economy will collapse as a result of climate change

We face the choice of trying to adjust the economy in a controlled fashion or just let it. Collapse

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 14:24

Our economy would entirely collapse if we did what actually needs to be done to stop climate change. It would be pleasant for any of us.

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 14:24

(well designed )Low traffic zones push traffic to better places, typically reduce average travel times ( at the expense of rat runners ) And make it more likely that people will leave the car behind

Loads of European cities have done this successfully

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 09/01/2022 14:09

LTNs don't help, they only misplace traffic.

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 14:06

The low traffic stuff is actually trading childrens health , ability to exercise safely and breath clean air against the profit making adults who want to live in a car based economy

Climate change will require , or more likely force , much bigger changes on everyone but we certainly won't minimise the scale of changes by going "you first " to China whilst driving our cars to earn money to spend in chinas factories

It's sad because I suspect that living a slightly slower , more "experience the moment lifestyle " , focussed on family and friends not big houses snd the corporate bottom line would probably make people happier

Yes I do know that unless you have money behind you , you are caught in the rat trap with no option but to line your bosses pockets to keep food in the table - but if people could at least recognise the trap we might have a chance of changing things