Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?

214 replies

Confrontayshunme · 08/01/2022 22:52

A road near our home was closed to create a Low Traffic Neighbourhood during the first lockdown. Children at the local junior and high schools have benefitted hugely in road safety, the cycle and scooter racks were overflowing and the pollution was measured recently as 40% less (in an area with 3 schools).

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning. The day after it reopened, half of the bikes and scooters were gone due to safety concerns. Even my coworker who said it made her cycle to work easier and safer was hugely relieved that she doesn't have to go an extra 10 minutes out of her way when driving.

Anyway, I just despair for the planet if adults and people riding in heated, air conditioned, comfortable, waterproof music players can't possibly leave the house 10 minutes earlier to allow our community's children just one intersection's worth of safety and convenience. Plus, the level of pollution driving our children all these miles (when they could be exercising or improving their mental health) inside a car shortens their lives so there isn't any time saved overall anyway!

And before the pile on commences, I realise many people are not able to use alternate transport or active travel due to physical disability or huge distances and I wouldn't include them in this.

OP posts:
EishetChayil · 09/01/2022 18:07

Let's start with the big corporations. Belgian airlines runs 3,000 empty flights a year just to keep their place in the landing order. That's just one example of the things that need to stop before individual or micro-level efforts will make any sort of impact.

CorneliusVetch · 09/01/2022 18:04

@thecatsthecats

Our LTN was rushed in without consultation, and has simply concentrated the traffic onto one or two roads whilst making private cul de sacs of others.

It absolutely SHOULD be removed, and only returned once a properly thought out way to reduce traffic and increase public transport has been put in place. Not just expect driving commuters to magic up new ways to commute at the drop of a hat whilst creating changes that confer a huge advantage to some parts of the neighbourhood whilst diminishing it for others.

Brilliantly put.
CorneliusVetch · 09/01/2022 18:03

@bordermidgebite

The idea is that drivers are forced to use the main routes leaving more residential areas safer

Yes more traffic on the main routes that are meant to have it

And making it easier for people to leave the car behind -

if done correctly you end up with fewer cars on the main road also because you have quieter safer options for none car users

LTNs are counter productive, unfair and divisive. All the stuff you’re coming out with sounds good on paper but you’re completely divorced from reality.

Obviously fewer cars on the road is a good thing (and I rarely drive). That’s not in dispute. But doing something for the sake of it regardless of whether it makes things worse is crazy.

I have an asthmatic child and live on a residential road, but one which has not been closed while others around it have. The traffic on our road has increased noticeably, worsening air pollution for her. Why is that right or fair? Is her health less important because we don’t live on the more expensive side roads? It’s ok to divert the share of other children’s air pollution onto her so they have less because she has more?

In the real world, LTNs only make things easier to leave the car behind for a very small number of people who can make their entire journey by eg bike within the LTN, otherwise they’re going to have to continue their journey on busy roads when they reach the edge of the LTN. I cannot imagine anyone who is only willing to walk because the road is closed to cars - in fact I would be less likely to get the train to and from work if the road was shut because I have to walk back from the station in the dark and only feel safe because there are lots of cars around. It’s really simplistic to just say shut a few roads and it’ll magically make it easier for people to leave the car at home despite the lack of investment in public transport.

LTNs aren’t about making it easier to leave e car at home, they’re about making it really unpleasant to drive so people don’t want to. But that punishes people with necessary car journeys too. My Grandmother is reliant on home care, three times per day. The carers are always late these days because they’re sitting in traffic. Contesting the roads does a lot of harm, that’s just one example.

OP - you’re conflating issues. Yes people have to be inconvenienced to live more sustainably. That doesn’t mean LTNs which worsen the health of the children who can’t afford to live on the posh side streets and have all the traffic shunted down their road are a good idea. They increase congestion, increase journey times and do not work in their current format. Just because something is inconvenient and causes hardship it doesn’t make it sustainable.

Incidentally i don’t know where you are, but in London the LTNs don’t just cause a 10 minute delay. Main roads are car parks.

ManicPixie · 09/01/2022 17:56

@CliantheLang

Why are you afraid? There are only 2 ways to stop climate change. Either
  1. the Earth loses it's atmosphere or

  2. the sun goes nova.

The climate will change because it's a natural process that has absolutely nothing to do with carbon or human activity. Which is why all the computer-modeled predictions have failed. None of the hysteria has anything to do with science.

Almost every scientist says humans contribute, but sure, I bet your decades of research is much more robust.
Onionpatch · 09/01/2022 17:53

I dont think people do want to be inconvenienced, including me. I think we will get forced eventually.

stairgates · 09/01/2022 17:47

Agree OP, and I dont think anything will be done by government to stop it, its all just gimmicks.

PlanetNormal · 09/01/2022 17:42

It’s naive to imagine most people will be prepared to make serious personal sacrifices, eg giving up their cars or not taking foreign holidays, to reduce climate change. Especially when they see rich, sanctimonious hypocritical politicians & celebrities flying first class while lecturing the little people about saving the planet. Yes, Emma Thompson I do mean you.

The solution lies in improved technology. Genuinely affordable electric cars, buses, vans & taxis running on renewable power are a start. Heavy trucks will need better battery technology to allow realistic payloads & ranges. Aircraft are currently decades away from a practical alternative to fossil fuels. Domestic heat pumps need to actually work and to be affordable to install. They are currently neither. There may be a long way to go, but technology is the only long-term solution.

Brindle88 · 09/01/2022 17:39

YANBU. But far too many people are too ignorant and selfish, and politicians too focused on the next election, for the long-term changes to happen.

Humanity is too stupid and selfish to avert climate change.

Valeriekat · 09/01/2022 17:32

You can't stop it!

Frazzled2207 · 09/01/2022 17:25

Op Agree with you 100%

A few years ago we swapped 2 petrol cars for 1 electric one. I had serious misgivings and yes we have had to change the way we do things but actually We’ve never looked back.

Yet when I try and subtely mention to friends that they could do the same or at least share a car (I get that many families need two cars btw) I just get “but we wouldn’t be able to do x, it would be more difficult to do y”. Yeah it would, you’re right. But unless people can make their own decisions than they can put up with these inconveniences then we’re a bit screwed really.

I live in greater Manchester and there is currently a big uproar about the future clean air zone.
I don’t think the proposed scheme is well thought out at all and there’s lots that’s wrong with it.
But the number of people ranting on Facebook clearly not happy about being inconvenienced in any way is utterly depressing

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 17:23

@Labhra87

It will be much more like few people having cars at all, most people staying very close to home through their life, having one sweter and two outfits and probably no electronic gadgets. Something much closer to the expectations in terms of travel and property ownership that people had pre-1950.

This is me. Well except I do have a 2014 second hand laptop because the internet is pretty essential these days.

This isn't a smug post.

It's because I'm poor.

Many people on benefits or on a really low income live just like me. It baffles me how it's unfathomable to most on MN.

Agreed.
thecatsthecats · 09/01/2022 17:21

Our LTN was rushed in without consultation, and has simply concentrated the traffic onto one or two roads whilst making private cul de sacs of others.

It absolutely SHOULD be removed, and only returned once a properly thought out way to reduce traffic and increase public transport has been put in place. Not just expect driving commuters to magic up new ways to commute at the drop of a hat whilst creating changes that confer a huge advantage to some parts of the neighbourhood whilst diminishing it for others.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 17:19

Some of our descendants will survive many won’t.

Erm, none of us survive. We all die at some point from something.

Magnited · 09/01/2022 17:16

@CliantheLang

Why are you afraid? There are only 2 ways to stop climate change. Either
  1. the Earth loses it's atmosphere or

  2. the sun goes nova.

The climate will change because it's a natural process that has absolutely nothing to do with carbon or human activity. Which is why all the computer-modeled predictions have failed. None of the hysteria has anything to do with science.

Well that's bollocks. Grin

The Nobel Prize in Physics 2021 was for "the physical modelling of Earth’s climate, quantifying variability and reliably predicting global warming”.

Now go and read it.

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 17:07

Our aging population is suffering from a lose it because we don't use it ( in the main) - the cost of inactivity to our health service is immense

We actually use the car once every 3 weeks shopping and once a week carry meat milk and veg up the hill.

We won't be able to do it forever, but it's only in the last year or so that it's become too much for my mother

Yes I have repeatedly said that we need to be able to have the time in our lives to live a more relaxed and healthier lifestyle - that is the trap we are in, working so hard to make ends meet that our health and planet are both suffering , yet somehow no one can devise a way out . We got a man on the moon but poison our kids with fumes and condemn our adults to diabetes etc

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 09/01/2022 16:53

@bordermidgebite

20% of car journeys are under 1 mile -there and back you would still not have done 10000 steps

38% of journeys under 2 miles

These are journeys which could help ease congestion and improve health if we could get people walking and cycling more

This is true but doesn't really take into account our ageing (and therefore less likely to be able to manage this) population or the way that life has been set up such than an extra 'just 15 minutes' cannot be accommodated. Combine that things such as nearest supermarkets not being a million miles away but being unable to carry everything you've bought to/ from the bus stop and the fact that many people do not have the money to buy or space to store a bike and we can see that the infrastructure of our current society does not easily support these journeys being done by bike/ legs rather than car.
sanbeiji · 09/01/2022 16:33

OP your attitude is exactly why climate change initiatives fail.
People go for the low hanging fruit like low traffic zones and encouraging cycles. Which area easy to implement, cheap, but inconvenience people. And then blame the public for being selfish.
The expensive stuff that people would actually use (Like better public transport) isn't done.

How do you know that cycles in other areas weren't inconvenienced as a result of traffic being pushed there?

Also electric scooters are illegal in the UK
www.halfords.com/cycling/advice/are-electric-scooters-legal.html

Most people I know in London don't own cars, there are congestion charges, lots of zones for fines etc etc but fair enough - plenty of ways to get around!

Labhra87 · 09/01/2022 16:23

I rarely buy new clothes, often my sister gives me her old stuff.

The bus is comparatively expensive on benefits (£4.50 when on an income of £70 a week is expensive).

I walk everywhere that is under 4 miles or so each way.

I guess it's inadvertently good for the planet!!

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 16:21

If you act now there is no need to imagine a future within travel and no electronic gadgets

Labhra87 · 09/01/2022 16:18

It will be much more like few people having cars at all, most people staying very close to home through their life, having one sweter and two outfits and probably no electronic gadgets. Something much closer to the expectations in terms of travel and property ownership that people had pre-1950.

This is me. Well except I do have a 2014 second hand laptop because the internet is pretty essential these days.

This isn't a smug post.

It's because I'm poor.

Many people on benefits or on a really low income live just like me. It baffles me how it's unfathomable to most on MN.

bordermidgebite · 09/01/2022 16:17

That's why I think a societal shift is needed - where I wonder if universal income doesn't actually have a place

WishIwasElsa · 09/01/2022 16:12

It's tricky I would like to walk more but I have so little time between getting the kids to breakfast club and then needing to be at work vice versa at end of the day, plus I travel for work often so need car to do that. The reason my time is tight is to fit as many work hours in as possible to make money that we need to live on. I don't know what the answer is in sure it's that way for many

MsTSwift · 09/01/2022 16:02

Some of our descendants will survive many won’t. Been listening to ancient history books most of the population in my area were wiped out around 486 by bubonic plague and climate change a volcano meant there were basically no seasons for 3 years and all their crops failed. Our mistake is assuming our cushy lives and entitlement to survive will continue- it won’t.

TInkyWlnky · 09/01/2022 16:00

bordermidgebite thank you.

Marmite27 · 09/01/2022 15:57

They’ve suggested a low traffic neighbourhood here. It will force cars to go one of three ways, which are already congested. All it will cause is hundreds of stationary queuing cars idling with there engines on and will increase pollution.