Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?

214 replies

Confrontayshunme · 08/01/2022 22:52

A road near our home was closed to create a Low Traffic Neighbourhood during the first lockdown. Children at the local junior and high schools have benefitted hugely in road safety, the cycle and scooter racks were overflowing and the pollution was measured recently as 40% less (in an area with 3 schools).

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning. The day after it reopened, half of the bikes and scooters were gone due to safety concerns. Even my coworker who said it made her cycle to work easier and safer was hugely relieved that she doesn't have to go an extra 10 minutes out of her way when driving.

Anyway, I just despair for the planet if adults and people riding in heated, air conditioned, comfortable, waterproof music players can't possibly leave the house 10 minutes earlier to allow our community's children just one intersection's worth of safety and convenience. Plus, the level of pollution driving our children all these miles (when they could be exercising or improving their mental health) inside a car shortens their lives so there isn't any time saved overall anyway!

And before the pile on commences, I realise many people are not able to use alternate transport or active travel due to physical disability or huge distances and I wouldn't include them in this.

OP posts:
Alayalaya · 10/01/2022 09:56

Even in the summer I often see imported strawberries and raspberries. If that’s what’s on the shelves then that’s what I have to buy. Virtually everything has plastic packaging too, I have no choice.

Yes I buy out of season veg because they’re on the shelf. If they want people to stop buying them then they need to stop stocking them.

CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 09:48

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Alayalaya · 10/01/2022 09:20

Unfortunately we can only use the resources that are available! Supermarkets don’t offer food without plastic packaging or British-grown veg. We can only buy what’s on the shelves. We can’t cycle to work unless jobs are available close to home. I’d love an allotment to grow food but there’s a 20 year waiting list and the council isn’t creating any more. Etc.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 10/01/2022 09:12

@CurtainTroubles

Read the current thread about Morrison’s removing the BBE date on milk and you’ll see just how unprepared people are to be inconvenienced. People can’t even be bothered to smell their milk before drinking it.
My worry about this is about having to chuck a load of short-date milk away. We buy for the week so we don't have to drive to pick up more (I can't walk to the shops as too far). I'm really happy with this move in other ways but as I've pretty much never had milk which smells OK after the use-by date I'm not sure this is the great carbon saver people are making out.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 10/01/2022 09:11

Anybody living in one city and working in the other - and commuting in every day - really must see the futility and massive waste (of time, money and resources) in not moving home nearer work or getting a job nearer their home.

I work in a niche role. There are no jobs nearer my home. I commute 15 miles. To get to work I'd need to walk 30 minutes to the train, sit on the train (which is only about 30 mins) and then walk 30 mins up hill to work. I have arthritis and can't do that. It would cost 40K to move house with stamp duty and agency fees and still would need the 30 min walk up hill as we'd need to live near a school because no-one else would be able to drive my kids to school and I start work at 8. It's really not as simple as people make out. I moved here 25 years ago and I've been in my role for 9 years so the home came first. I can't do my job via zoom. Better public transport is what would be needed. Much better.

CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 09:09

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Notthemessiah · 10/01/2022 08:37

@FreedomFaith

You've only just realised this?

People are selfish. It's never going to happen unless the change is forced. That's always been obvious. For every one person you manage to convince to be green, you've got 100 more people not being green in very drastic ways. And they will not be convinced or stopped.

Climate change will never, ever happen unless we make drastic changes. It literally has to become a dictatorship for the world to follow the precise rules that would be necessary, and people would just have to die if they can't cope with it. It would almost be survival of the fittest again really.

Never gonna happen. Enjoy your life. Smile

We don't need to convince people, we need the change to come from the governments we elect that are supposed to do this kind of thing for us - that look after and benefit society and citizens as a whole.

They need to force the companies doing the polluting and the exploiting for the profit of a very small percentage of people.

Unfortunately our political system is run for the benefit of the people with the money and isn't fit for purpose. The politicians in charge are neither brave enough, motivated enough or intelligent enough to do what needs to be done.

Capitalism may have raised the standards of living for many people on the planet (while also killing and exploiting millions) but it has taken us as far as it can and it is now clear that the balance has tipped and it is now taking us downhill at a fairly rapid rate. It's running out of resources to exploit, clearly increasingly unfair and will lead to massive environmental and societal change (and not for the good) unless we find a way to stop it.

FreedomFaith · 10/01/2022 07:20

You've only just realised this?

People are selfish. It's never going to happen unless the change is forced. That's always been obvious. For every one person you manage to convince to be green, you've got 100 more people not being green in very drastic ways. And they will not be convinced or stopped.

Climate change will never, ever happen unless we make drastic changes. It literally has to become a dictatorship for the world to follow the precise rules that would be necessary, and people would just have to die if they can't cope with it. It would almost be survival of the fittest again really.

Never gonna happen. Enjoy your life. Smile

Maireas · 10/01/2022 07:06

@ParsleySageRosemary

I do agree, but to be fair, Holland is flatter. Where I live, it's incredibly hilly, and the only cyclists are those sporty endurance types.

That's an endlessly repeated excuse. There are hills across the lowlands (thinking of the Benelux, all of which countries are better at promoting cycling than the UK). There are flat areas across Britain. The flat areas of Britain are not more cycling-friendly than the UK on the whole.

The Netherlands got where they have by having the will to do so, and legislating for it, and doing it bit by bit. It didn't happen overnight. It will never happen here because it will never start. Britain's poverty of mind and culture is disgusting.

It's not an excuse. You can cycle up these hills if you are very fit. That's not everyone. Good public transport is a better solution.
CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 06:53

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

realhousewifeofmodor · 10/01/2022 05:44

I find it completely bizarre how posters here are harping on about electric cars, reducing private car ownership etc. Those things are all well and good but if everyone stopped using cars now then we wouldn't see any change in the planet for 100 years.

Reducing our methane output is much more of an immediate priority as it will have a much faster impact and something needs to change now.

In short- we need to stop eating meat. Full stop. Drive an electric car and feel smug about cycling to work all you like- if you eat meat then you're a massive hypocrite.

Christmascardsontheshelf · 10/01/2022 05:20

Fairly sure @Notthemessiah is the messiah as they are speaking pure truth

Christmascardsontheshelf · 10/01/2022 05:12

@mumda

Have you removed your central heating and stopped eating anything not grown without air miles?

The inconvenience will be huge. Starvation, mass exodus from lands due to flooding fire and pestilence. Followed by wars over water and food.
It will indeed be the end of days.

I don't think people are wrong to carry on and ignore it all.

COP26 is just one in a long list of annoyances where the rich tell the poor how to live but refuse to change their own behaviour.

These kind of comments make people NOT change their behaviour or stand up for what they believe in. No, not many people can eat food solely from the UK because most shops don't sell food from here. No most people don't eat plastic free because same reason. we use plastic loads, despite trying our damn hardest to drop it. Its not my fault or the OPs fault. its the governments fault and they are probably so happy that we are pointing fingers at eachother rather than pointing fingers at them
RunningInTheWind · 10/01/2022 05:03

Grin I am not paying a fucking electric taxi to take me the 100+ mile round trip to Tesco.

ElftonWednesday · 10/01/2022 03:35

My point is why are people regularly travelling that far at all, though? I know that a lot of journeys are necessary or desirable; but so many people seem to travel hundreds of miles for work every single week - mostly for office/executive-type roles. It's like the internet and Zoom had never been invented

If anything the last two years has shown us that there is nothing like being there in person, and that there is real value in seeing people face to face. We may not travel as much for work and the tech certainly has its own benefits, but we will still travel.

ElftonWednesday · 10/01/2022 03:30

Yes and no, it depends how inconvenient. If greener tech is cheaper and better than the less sustainable altermative then it's a no-brainer for people to use it/buy it due to convenience and cost.

RantyAunty · 10/01/2022 03:22

If the top 100 polluting companies of fossil fuels did their part, that would be enough.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2022 03:19

One anomaly with common thinking, though, is that public transport is good whereas private transport is bad; but taxis are always included in 'public transport', with the frequent perception that taxi-users are self-regulating and only travelling in cars when the journey necessitates it.

20 years from now - maybe even 10 - personal car ownership will seem like such a laughably bizarre relic of history. If you don't need to drive a car yourself, you don't need to park it particularly close by - or actually own it.

Car travel will consist of an app ordering a car to come to you, take you where you're going and then disappear afterwards. Yes, they will all be electric, but all of that electricity still has to be generated - often via very dirty methods.

Although it may be better overall, proclamations of 'zero emission' transport aren't much different from describing 2-for-£4 jumpers as '100% child/cheap labour exploitation-free' - just because the person who served you in the UK supermarket isn't a child or personally being paid pennies per hour.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2022 03:10

You are very much misinformed. By cutting London-Scotland journey times by around an hour, it brings them to within the threshold where rail can make serious inroads into the airlines' slice of the market. Airlines are particularly bad polluters. The potential has been demonstrated by Eurostar. When services to the continent first commenced, there was a drop in airline demand. When HS1 was finally completed in 2007, demand fell to less than half. Eurostar's figures meanwhile soared far above the numbers poached from the skies, generating economic activity. www.airlineratings.com/news/trains-versus-plane-eurostar-almost-halved-airline-demand/

I'm no expert, as I haven't flown anywhere for 24 years, but have airports now moved into convenient city/town centre locations and got rid of all of the requirement to turn up a long time before your flight and go through rigorous security checks?

My point is why are people regularly travelling that far at all, though? I know that a lot of journeys are necessary or desirable; but so many people seem to travel hundreds of miles for work every single week - mostly for office/executive-type roles. It's like the internet and Zoom had never been invented.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2022 03:05

Look at Prince Harry. Fixing climate change, one private jet at a time.

Absolutely. To paraphrase Maya Angelou, 'when somebody clearly shows you what they really believe, understand them'.

Even aside from actually travelling from across the world to Glasgow, instead of doing it all online, Joe Biden temporarily importing multiple vehicles from another continent makes it obvious that he doesn't personally believe a single word of it. When the various royals urge us to all live sustainably, irony dies a thousand deaths.

Talking of royalty, Prince Philip went on for decades about how we urgently had to reduce the population otherwise it was curtains for us all. He even made a 'joke' in very poor taste about wanting to be reincarnated as a virus that killed millions of people. James Lovelock was exactly the same. Both the fathers of four children, so they obviously sincerely believed what they passionately preached to others about....

DdraigGoch · 10/01/2022 01:45

@Magnited

The WCML is congested only twice a week *@DdraigGoch*
Care to elaborate? Exactly when is "twice a week"? Because I only travel off peak (I go to London to see shows) and Avanti's trains are busy at most times.

Network Rail have designated the stretch between Camden South Junction and Ledburn Junction to be officially "congested infrastructure". Avanti are asking for an extra Liverpool path, and LNW are asking for an extra Northampton path. This is in spite of prices being set to stifle demand. Network Rail cannot fulfil these requests. HS2 changes that.

MeltyFireSurround · 10/01/2022 01:00

Where I am the traffic just increased in other (less leafy) areas so the route planning for road closures definitely needs to be looked at in relation to the network as a whole

DdraigGoch · 10/01/2022 00:55

@Joined4this

Op I agree. Trying to do zero waste/recycle walk etc as much as possible. Yes, big companies do account for the majority of the damage. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try our hardest too.
It's worth noting that almost all of the top 100 biggest polluters are oil giants. So if you reduce your petrol consumption, not only are you reducing the emissions from your tailpipe, but you are also reducing the emissions generated when getting the stuff out of the ground in the first place.

Only consumers can force change in the companies they buy from.

Magnited · 10/01/2022 00:27

The WCML is congested only twice a week @DdraigGoch

DdraigGoch · 10/01/2022 00:20

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning.

That's exactly what the government has pushed ahead with - in the face of huge opposition and hardly a groundswell of public support - with HS2. Carve up miles and miles of countryside for the sake of saving people half an hour (or whatever) when travelling between London and Birmingham.

Occasional travellers have no real need to be bothered about an extra half hour every now and then. Anybody living in one city and working in the other - and commuting in every day - really must see the futility and massive waste (of time, money and resources) in not moving home nearer work or getting a job nearer their home. Meanwhile, millions of us who are now in the position to do so (especially those in the kind of job where it's financially viable to live so far away from where you work) now work remotely from home (or somewhere else nearby).... so what on earth is the desperate, urgent need for it all in the first place?

You are very much misinformed. By cutting London-Scotland journey times by around an hour, it brings them to within the threshold where rail can make serious inroads into the airlines' slice of the market. Airlines are particularly bad polluters. The potential has been demonstrated by Eurostar. When services to the continent first commenced, there was a drop in airline demand. When HS1 was finally completed in 2007, demand fell to less than half. Eurostar's figures meanwhile soared far above the numbers poached from the skies, generating economic activity. www.airlineratings.com/news/trains-versus-plane-eurostar-almost-halved-airline-demand/

In order to reduce carbon emissions, we need to entice motorists from the roads onto trains. Why might these motorists not want to move? High prices will be the main factor, because prices have been pushed up to suppress demand where there isn't capacity available to satisfy it. Increase the capacity (and the WCML is particularly congested) and you can drop prices, thus encouraging more modal shift.

By the way, half of the capital the government spent on HS1 was recovered in one go by selling a 30 year operating concession to a Canadian pension fund. There will of course be further concessions sold within the lifespan of the infrastructure, plus the tax receipts from the extra economic activity. A nice return for the Treasury.