Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?

214 replies

Confrontayshunme · 08/01/2022 22:52

A road near our home was closed to create a Low Traffic Neighbourhood during the first lockdown. Children at the local junior and high schools have benefitted hugely in road safety, the cycle and scooter racks were overflowing and the pollution was measured recently as 40% less (in an area with 3 schools).

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning. The day after it reopened, half of the bikes and scooters were gone due to safety concerns. Even my coworker who said it made her cycle to work easier and safer was hugely relieved that she doesn't have to go an extra 10 minutes out of her way when driving.

Anyway, I just despair for the planet if adults and people riding in heated, air conditioned, comfortable, waterproof music players can't possibly leave the house 10 minutes earlier to allow our community's children just one intersection's worth of safety and convenience. Plus, the level of pollution driving our children all these miles (when they could be exercising or improving their mental health) inside a car shortens their lives so there isn't any time saved overall anyway!

And before the pile on commences, I realise many people are not able to use alternate transport or active travel due to physical disability or huge distances and I wouldn't include them in this.

OP posts:
Momicrone · 10/01/2022 16:02

Alaya, it's not just about saving the planet, less cars on the road makes an area nicer for everyone, especially non car drivers

Momicrone · 10/01/2022 15:59

I' m amazed that people are against schemes like school streets

Alayalaya · 10/01/2022 15:57

100 companies are responsible for 71% of emissions worldwide. It’s ridiculous to pretend that choosing local potatoes or cycling to work makes a difference.

Momicrone · 10/01/2022 15:56

Morningstarling, 'we shouldn't fight nature'? So I guess you must be an anti vaxer, or refuse pain relief for child birth

Phrenologistsfinger · 10/01/2022 15:40

So many people are saying “this won’t affect me”, “It will be my kids and grandkids who suffer” etc. Utter head in the sand nonsense!

The fact of the matter is that it is happening NOW. Migration, refugees, political instability and authoritarianism crop yields falling, rising food prices, unseasonal weather, out of control fires, hurricanes, floods etc. China is buying up farmland all round the world to hedge against crop failures. It is ramping up and will continue to do so but you will all feel the impact. Some of the more doomy predictions include societal collapse within 20 years. Let’s hope they are wrong but it’s not impossible, covid has shown us how quickly ‘normal’ can change.

wonderstuff · 10/01/2022 15:23

Whilst I agree that better legislation is vital, UK has reduced meat consumption per capita by 17% over the last 10 years, we do have the collective power to do something. Look also at the amount of products without or with reduced plastic.

FreedomFaith · 10/01/2022 15:00

That’s actually insane. You don’t have to buy it just because it’s on the shelf. And if you care about the environment you wouldn’t be buying out of season fruit and veg.

And yet someone will and they do. And really, you need to use it once it's here or the trip made to bring it really was pointless.

Your actions mean nothing. Not buying something because it isn't environmentally friendly is pointless. What you want to be done is to stop these things happening. Blaming the consumer helps and achieves nothing. And saying 'but all of us together will stop it happening' is pointless too, because you will never ever achieve that. It's a dream.

TeacupDrama · 10/01/2022 14:37

also last year enough food was profduced on earth to feed 11 million people properly ( ie all nutrients and enough calories) not just poverty levels the population is 7 billion this is a combination of food in the wrong place and waste both at shop industry level and household level
food waste should really only be peeling and inedible parts bones coffee grounds used tea etc it should not be loaves and loasves of bread wonky vegetables and salads and half chickens when just breast was eaten

TeacupDrama · 10/01/2022 14:34

The UK could be more self sufficient in food but we need to pay farmers to produce, not all livestock with cattle sheep on is suitable for growing crops. There will always be some food imports but we import many things that could be grown in UK mushrooms apples potatoes wheat oats we will never be able to grow pineapples and bananas but we do not need to import pork beef lamb or chicken or apples plums etc
fast fashion produces more emissions than all the aeroplanes and ships in the world

Magnited · 10/01/2022 14:25

@MorningStarling

Inconveniencing people isn't a good way to stop climate change. We're already facing massive inconvenience and apparently that's still not enough. My view is life is too short to worry about the future. Most of us will be dead long before the worst effects of climate change become apparent.

People can harp on about needing to save the planet but usually they're only concerned with issues that other people need to address. For example other people need to use less energy, but they themselves should be allowed to watch Netflix even though streaming services waste huge amounts of energy in keeping their infrastructure going. You know the fuss people make about switching the TV off at the wall overnight? How do you think on demand video works? It's on demand because it's always on, being used or not.

People are unwilling to face the very obvious problem. If HUMANS are causing climate change then the solution is to eradicate or significantly reduce the number of humans on the planet. If we culled the population down to a billion or so there would be enough resources for us to continue without inconveniencing ourselves terribly or undergoing dramatic lifestyle changes.

Personally I think humans are incredibly arrogant when it comes to climate change. Other species don't give a shit. What makes us so special? Species come and go, as climate changes they adapt or die. Humans shouldn't fight nature. Our nature is to exploit our resources, this has what has led us to be the dominant species in our solar system. We need to follow our nature, we are the most adaptable species going. We shouldn't try to freeze time, which is effectively what climate activists want, under the unbelievably arrogant misunderstanding that people today are somehow "better" than those that have gone before.

Terribly short sighted. If you culled the population down to 1 billion how would that work other than going back in time (rather than freezing it)? Would the 1 billion have to decide who were going to be the billionaires, the train drivers, the care home staff? It would not be a utopia.

Leaving aside, of course, the fact that you sound a bit like Hitler.

Notthemessiah · 10/01/2022 14:18

That’s actually insane. You don’t have to buy it just because it’s on the shelf. And if you care about the environment you wouldn’t be buying out of season fruit and veg.

But why deny yourself stuff when no-one else around you is denying themselves? You're making no difference and just making life worse for yourself for no real reason.

Everyone else then looks around and thinks exactly the same, which is why saying that this has to be 'consumer-led' or that it's somehow up to all of us to make individual choices will simply not work.

Companies know this - they make token changes that cost them nothing and then say that it's their customers fault for not picking the more expensive green product and so absolve themselves of any blame or responsiblity.

We need to build the actual cost of products into law - the ecological costs, the environmental costs, the labour costs that companies should be paying for rather than exploiting employees overseas.

It won't happen though. It would make the rich poorer and the media (owned by those same people) would wage an information war to convince us that somehow our future still depends on making rich old men (and they are almost all men after all) even richer, when in fact the opposite is true.

MorningStarling · 10/01/2022 14:15

Inconveniencing people isn't a good way to stop climate change. We're already facing massive inconvenience and apparently that's still not enough. My view is life is too short to worry about the future. Most of us will be dead long before the worst effects of climate change become apparent.

People can harp on about needing to save the planet but usually they're only concerned with issues that other people need to address. For example other people need to use less energy, but they themselves should be allowed to watch Netflix even though streaming services waste huge amounts of energy in keeping their infrastructure going. You know the fuss people make about switching the TV off at the wall overnight? How do you think on demand video works? It's on demand because it's always on, being used or not.

People are unwilling to face the very obvious problem. If HUMANS are causing climate change then the solution is to eradicate or significantly reduce the number of humans on the planet. If we culled the population down to a billion or so there would be enough resources for us to continue without inconveniencing ourselves terribly or undergoing dramatic lifestyle changes.

Personally I think humans are incredibly arrogant when it comes to climate change. Other species don't give a shit. What makes us so special? Species come and go, as climate changes they adapt or die. Humans shouldn't fight nature. Our nature is to exploit our resources, this has what has led us to be the dominant species in our solar system. We need to follow our nature, we are the most adaptable species going. We shouldn't try to freeze time, which is effectively what climate activists want, under the unbelievably arrogant misunderstanding that people today are somehow "better" than those that have gone before.

Onionpatch · 10/01/2022 14:01

There is terrible traffic in bits of the netherlands so somebody is driving there! But the cycle ways were great.
I dont know what population the uk could sustain eating locally grown vegan food although i am sure more could be done.

realhousewifeofmodor · 10/01/2022 13:56

@Bucanarab

So the most up to date fuel report from the IEA (2020, so much more recent than what you quoted) shows that in fact agriculture does produce more methane than oil and gas. Obviously both are awful, and with all of the other gases produced included then oil and gas do have more impact, but methane is the key. If we reduce our methane emissions now then we will start to see a positive effect very quickly. If we 'just' try to reduce carbon dioxide emissions then we won't see the effects for at least 100 years, which sadly will be far too late.

This is why it baffles me that people are ignoring the easiest way of reducing the problem- not eating meat!

CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 13:46

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Maireas · 10/01/2022 13:34

Folks can praise the Dutch all they like, the point is that it's far more difficult and dangerous to be a cyclist here.
As I said upthread, and pp have echoed, a decent, reasonably priced public transport system is the only way forward.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 10/01/2022 12:53

I have done my bit for the environment by not having children.

Notthemessiah · 10/01/2022 12:38

[quote FreedomFaith]@Notthemessiah

Thats kind of my point though although didn't make it clear enough. We literally need a dictatorship across the whole world to force companies and countries to behave in a way to help climate change.

The unfortunate side effect of saving the earth though is people will die. There is no possible way to save everyone and the earth, we are not technologically advanced enough to do it. People may say that they need a car for example to get around because they are disabled, that would just have to end full stop. They either get stuff delivered and people visit them, or nothing. It needs to be drastic actions, anything less won't resolve anything at all.

So it won't ever happen. The earth for humans will cease to exist. We will likely die out regardless.[/quote]
I don't think that humananity will die out completely, but it's hard not to realise that we can't go on the way we are going and that there will be a lot less of us around in, say, 100 years.

Wars for dwindling resources are coming and societies will collapse into authoritarianism or anarchy. We are already seeing the beginnings of it with Russia's push back into Ukraine and Eastern Europe, China's increasing activity in Africa, authoritarian populists on the rise across Europe and America.

The sad thing is that we do have the resources and technological know how to provide a reasonable standard of living for everyone in the world if the willpower and leadership was there.

But it isn't, so we're fucked (or rather our children and our grandchildren are) unless we do something radical ourselves.

FreedomFaith · 10/01/2022 11:55

@Notthemessiah

Thats kind of my point though although didn't make it clear enough. We literally need a dictatorship across the whole world to force companies and countries to behave in a way to help climate change.

The unfortunate side effect of saving the earth though is people will die. There is no possible way to save everyone and the earth, we are not technologically advanced enough to do it. People may say that they need a car for example to get around because they are disabled, that would just have to end full stop. They either get stuff delivered and people visit them, or nothing. It needs to be drastic actions, anything less won't resolve anything at all.

So it won't ever happen. The earth for humans will cease to exist. We will likely die out regardless.

Bucanarab · 10/01/2022 11:47

You can make a joke out of it, but it doesn't take away from the fact that eating meat is causing the biggest amount of damage to climate change at the moment

While I don't disagree that people should stop eating meat, or at the very least reduce their consumption, it is not the biggest contributor to methane or any other greenhouse gas.

Animal agriculture accounts for around 30% of all anthropogenic methane emissons, while extraction and processing of fossil fuels accounts for around 33%.

When you look at all ghg emissons energy use is by far the biggest issue, which is why the focus is there.

It should be noted that the screenshot showing energy as 74% is from 2016 data, while the other is from the 5th IPCC mitigation of climate change report in 2014. I realise these are a bit out of date now but the 6th IPCC mitigation of climate change report, which will have the most up to date figures, isn't due until October this year, so have to work with what we've got.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?
To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?
Phrenologistsfinger · 10/01/2022 11:40

@ParsleySageRosemary

I do agree, but to be fair, Holland is flatter. Where I live, it's incredibly hilly, and the only cyclists are those sporty endurance types.

That's an endlessly repeated excuse. There are hills across the lowlands (thinking of the Benelux, all of which countries are better at promoting cycling than the UK). There are flat areas across Britain. The flat areas of Britain are not more cycling-friendly than the UK on the whole.

The Netherlands got where they have by having the will to do so, and legislating for it, and doing it bit by bit. It didn't happen overnight. It will never happen here because it will never start. Britain's poverty of mind and culture is disgusting.

100% agree. When you see how much more active, fit and healthy the dutch are because they default to cycling and walking (even in small towns with less public transport) you really see how backwards the UK is!

It is especially noticeable in the elderly who look miles younger and healthier than the UK. I see it clearly in my Dutch inlaws and their friends etc compared to my own parents and their generation.

The UK is really quite backwards on a lot of levels and I didn’t realise it until I saw how other cultures live.

TeacupDrama · 10/01/2022 10:33

it seems to me like the vast majority of the costs of going green are on the poorest, just like covid the severest consequences were borne by the poor, most likely to be out of work not have a stable job so furlough was 80% of diddly squat not 80% of 50K, if they were working ti was minimum wage discouraged from public transport if you are poor you can maybe buy a second hand car for 1500K to get you to 5am shift start in industrial estate ( no buses ) but there is no electric car that cheap
making flying cars, meat just the preserve of the rich is deeply deeply unfair using price to stop consumption penalises the wrong people
a relatively poor family that eat meat cheaply sausages and burgers and run a small petrol car and live in a flat and go to Spain for some sun every couple of years will still have a much lower carbon footprint than the vegetarian tesla owning couple in a larger house that travel abroad for educational holidays, business and own two bikes which they can safely lock in a shed in their back garden
Eating seasonally and organically costs more
Maybe the better idea is to builds things that last a car/ washing machine/ cooker /sofa that will be repairable and / or functional for 20 years all phones, laptops, PC's lasting 10 years and easily upgrade no changing operating systems to make old ones obselete in 2 years, clothes that last, furniture including kitchens and bathrooms that should last years and years a dining table or wardrobe should last your whole life. 6 months is not a reasonable length of time for shoes to last (with kids they should outgrow before they wear out) but not for adults

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/01/2022 10:22

[quote realhousewifeofmodor]@daimbarsatemydogsbone you can make a joke out of it, but it doesn't take away from the fact that eating meat is causing the biggest amount of damage to climate change at the moment. And yet most of this thread seem to be blissfully ignoring that- or unaware of it. Which is ironic given that the premise of the thread is about people not wanting to be inconvenienced. Keep the light switches turned off?- sure. Cycle to work?- of course. Forego a bacon sandwich?- too difficult apparently. [/quote]
I am not joking - at all. It was an extremely unpleasant experience for everyone around me, as well as releasing large volumes of hazardous gas.

realhousewifeofmodor · 10/01/2022 10:19

@daimbarsatemydogsbone you can make a joke out of it, but it doesn't take away from the fact that eating meat is causing the biggest amount of damage to climate change at the moment. And yet most of this thread seem to be blissfully ignoring that- or unaware of it. Which is ironic given that the premise of the thread is about people not wanting to be inconvenienced. Keep the light switches turned off?- sure. Cycle to work?- of course. Forego a bacon sandwich?- too difficult apparently.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/01/2022 10:08

@realhousewifeofmodor

I find it completely bizarre how posters here are harping on about electric cars, reducing private car ownership etc. Those things are all well and good but if everyone stopped using cars now then we wouldn't see any change in the planet for 100 years.

Reducing our methane output is much more of an immediate priority as it will have a much faster impact and something needs to change now.

In short- we need to stop eating meat. Full stop. Drive an electric car and feel smug about cycling to work all you like- if you eat meat then you're a massive hypocrite.

When I spent a short period as a vegetarian, my methane output could have powered a small town - has anyone factored that in?