Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Aldi isn’t the answer to everything?

285 replies

ShirleyPhallus · 08/01/2022 16:27

On pretty much every thread here to do with food and drink within about 2 posts someone pops up with “I get mine from Aldi and it’s amazing”. On literally every thread like this it’s praised like it’s the best thing ever. See also Lidl.

Anyway, I went to an Aldi this week on the back of all the MN love and it’s just a cheap supermarket. Not the answer to my prayers. Am I missing something? Am I being unreasonable? (Answer is no fyi)

OP posts:
Momicrone · 09/01/2022 09:26

No, there are no aldis near me

MarshmallowFondant · 09/01/2022 09:24

@HoldingTheDoor

Are you near Glasgow?

I am. Milngavie.

Me too!

Will do the secret MN wave next time I'm in Aldi.

Terfydactyl · 09/01/2022 09:09

@JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn

I've tried Aldi but couldn't get everything I needed and the fruit and veg went off very quick. I'm on a strict budget and do a food plan every week so want what's on my list. I shop at sainsburys and find their budget range is often price matched with Aldi anyway. Sainsburys have also sent me lots of money off coupons this week. My food shopping for all meals this week (3 meals a day for 2 people) was £41. I was happy with that.
I just checked our receipt for this week and it was £40 and that included 4 bottles of wine. Also for two people. In there was also 2 lamb leg steaks all the veg we need and a kilo of minced beef. And a kilo of chicken wings among other stuff From aldi. But I did say way back in the thread that each store is different. Theres another aldi that we used to visit when we lived elsewhere and it was absolutely crap. There was nothing I'd buy in it. Doing the math in my head (never a good idea) we saved at least £30 if we had done the shop in morrisons. I do know our shopping bill had crept up to a hundred quid plus a week in morrisons. I persuaded DP we should give the new aldi a try for 12 weeks. See if we liked enough to make it worth the swap and see if we saved any money. Our first shop there I threw anything I liked the look of in the trolley. I figured we should do the same in aldi as I had done in morrisons. It came to about £55. We liked most of the stuff. The things we personally dont like luckily are store cupboard items and once in a while we get that at morrisons if we are passing it. So we are saving around £50 a week. That's a third holiday for us. A huge amount. But our nearest aldi has pretty good perishables. They last a week and that's enough for us. I imagine if my nearest aldi was shit, then I wouldnt have been able to do this.
FluffyBooBoo · 09/01/2022 04:34

I saw cucumbers in Aldi for 70p when I can get a whole one in Tesco for 43p

You aren't comparing like with like. Cucumbers are one of the items that tesco match aldi on price with. Tesco's and Aldi's normal cucumbers are both 43p and their large ones are both 69p.

GreenWheat · 09/01/2022 04:27

Aldi sell food of an acceptable quality at low prices. This is bound to be what lots of people want so not surprising that many people are Aldi fans. Personally I hardly ever shop there because as PP have said, for me it's impossible to get my full shop. I guess it depends what you buy on a regular basis.

DockOTheBay · 09/01/2022 03:30

@Peaseblossum22

I'm not a fan either , whenever I go I come out with a bar of chocolate and some jam and thats about it except maybe something random from the middle aisle. I honestly don't know how people manage to do a whole shop there or do you just adjust your menus to what they have in stock?
They sell fruit, veg, meat, bread, milk, eggs, cereal, herbs and spices... I don't really buy much more than that.

Occasionally there will be a weird ingredient that I have to get from waitrose like tamarind paste or bulgar wheat but aldi have 90% of normal food. What is it that yours doesn't have for your full shop?

BarkminsterBlue · 09/01/2022 03:26

@megletthesecond

It's useless if you have allergies. The fruit and veg goes off quicker than other supermarkets.
By far the worst supermarket for allergies (at least for nuts and peanuts) is M&S. Everything is labelled as ‘may contains’.
knitnerd90 · 09/01/2022 03:06

[quote PattyPan]@knitnerd90 I don’t think that can be right - I thought TJ’s was supposed to be really good, more akin to Waitrose, and having lived in an Aldi Nord area of Germany I can assure you it’s crap, much worse than Aldi Süd and U.K. Aldi. Moving within Germany to the Aldi Süd area was a huge relief 😂[/quote]
Nope - 100% positive it's AIdi Nord - has been covered in the media here.

Trader Joes isn't comparable to any UK supermarket (am British living in the USA). It's like Aldi in that they specialise in own brand products. It's also like Aldi in that it varies somewhat from branch to branch (produce is inconsistent). It's got a lot of good things, especially ready meals and snacks which most American supermarkets don't do very well. People are very devoted to it, but I could never do all my shopping there (or at Aldi for that matter).

The other Trader Joes speciality is atrocious parking lots.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 09/01/2022 01:37

I've tried Aldi but couldn't get everything I needed and the fruit and veg went off very quick. I'm on a strict budget and do a food plan every week so want what's on my list. I shop at sainsburys and find their budget range is often price matched with Aldi anyway. Sainsburys have also sent me lots of money off coupons this week. My food shopping for all meals this week (3 meals a day for 2 people) was £41. I was happy with that.

uggmum · 09/01/2022 01:16

I might nip in to my local Lidl for milk or bread.
But I like to do my main shop in Sainsbury’s
It's lovely and quiet. Very few people. Big aisles. I self scan which makes it easier. Better than having my food thrown at me by an over exuberant assistant.
I look out for fewer food miles and more 'conscious' brands.
I just find it a better experience overall.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/01/2022 00:59

@Bagelsandbrie

Chocolate is the answer to everything.
their dark chocolate is very good
PattyPan · 09/01/2022 00:55

@knitnerd90 I don’t think that can be right - I thought TJ’s was supposed to be really good, more akin to Waitrose, and having lived in an Aldi Nord area of Germany I can assure you it’s crap, much worse than Aldi Süd and U.K. Aldi. Moving within Germany to the Aldi Süd area was a huge relief 😂

SockFluffInTheBath · 09/01/2022 00:18

Am I being unreasonable? (Answer is no fyi)

Grin

Our Aldi is very good, the fruit & veg is very fresh and much better than our Tesco’s equivalent. I can normally get 95% of my list in there, better than Waitrose which seems to be all gold-plated apples, mince, and weird ready made things. We’re not on a budget but in our area Aldi is the best for fresh stuff (meat from the butcher) and house items. I can do my big weekly shop in 30 mins which is a massive added bonus.

JackieWeaversZoomAc · 09/01/2022 00:13

I've been tracking my grocery expenditure for 15 months or so and I can tell you I save loads of money shopping at aldi & lidl. If I only shop there for my main shops I spend £100-£160 pcm less than if I do some shops at Tesco or Morrison's

Rinoachicken · 09/01/2022 00:02

I would love to be able to shop in Aldi or Lidl, but him either of my local ones does any gluten free stuff.

I’m time poor and if I can only shop for 3 of the 4 people in the household then there’s no point, so I go elsewhere where I know they have GF options.

Fortunei · 08/01/2022 23:53

I hope I’m not a snob and keep visiting both Aldi and Liddl after doing my regular shop in another supermarket, but there is nothing appealing in them for me. I look for something unusual , something I wouldn’t find in my regular supermarket
The choices are limited in both
Nothing inspires me there

yoshiblue · 08/01/2022 23:47

I tend to pop in for a few bits but agree fruit/veg is generally rubbish, I don't like the meat either.

I used to do a split shop between Aldi/Sains (on the same shopping sq in my suburb) but since Sains have reduced a lot of prices to match them (or get close) I do the majority of shopping in Sains now.

phishy · 08/01/2022 23:41

YANBU, I don’t get all the Aldi and Lidl love at all.

I do all my shopping between Asda and Tesco and I find it similar value to the Aldi and Lidl.

If I ever drive past (they’re on the opposite side of town), I’ll pop in and see what’s on offer but invariably I just come away with Greek yoghurt.

ListeningButNotHearing · 08/01/2022 23:18

Personally I think Aldi is great/has fantastic products. I save approx. £40 a week = £2k a year.

crazyjinglist · 08/01/2022 22:55

Well of course it's just a cheap supermarket- that's the whole point. Whenever you compare a supermarket with other ones, there are going to be some products you like better, some you don't like as much and lots which you like the same. So Aldi has some fab stuff, some crap stuff, and everything else is just... normal, like in any other shop. The difference is, Aldi saves me about £30 a week compared with the others.

I'm a decent cook and there aren't that many ingredients I regularly use that I can't buy there. But in any case, some weeks I pop next door to lovely Booths to get the few bits and bobs I prefer from there or can't get in Aldi.

GADDay · 08/01/2022 22:48

I am with you OP.

Aldi fruit and veg are rubbish. They may be cheap but I have never bought perishables that go off so quickly. Bread is the cheapest, nastiest type available.

The knockoff products are just inferior imo.

Finally - having my groceries flung at me at the checkout is more than I can bear. I have had some terrible back issues and going to Aldi was a nightmare - trying to repack the trolley at comedic speeds is not fun.

Confusedmeanderings · 08/01/2022 22:47

I think, as other posters have said , that the quality varies between stores. In addition, i think personal circumstances come into it a bit. When I was working, I either wanted to be able to do my entire shop online and have it delivered or to be able to dash in and get everything I needed in one visit. Aldi and Lidl are no good for that, although Aldi does have click and collect. Now I am retired and have more time, I shop mostly in Lidl and pop over to the Sainsburys next door for things I can't get in Lidl. Its certainly cheaper that way. I also think it takes a while to figure out what you do like and what you don't. For example, I am not a fan of Lidl's cheddar - now I know that it always goes on the Sainsbury's list. If you're busy working or busy with a Young family you don't have time for that though.

LeSquigh · 08/01/2022 22:43

There are a few things that are worthwhile from both but not enough to make it worth a visit if I am not going in that direction anyway. My DP uses Aldi quite a lot but I rarely like the stuff he gets. Even if it was all decent there is so limited choice that I wouldn't be able to get everything I need without doing a top up shop in Sainsburys. We have a big Aldi and also a big Lidl within 5 miles but there just isn't a big enough range of products in them.

QueenOfHiraeth · 08/01/2022 22:40

I'm a supermarket slut, I get about a bit Grin, and have plenty of supermarkets in travelling range so feel qualified to comment here.
I live roughly half way between relatively new and fair sized Aldi and Lidl, both are ok and have some good stuff but the fruit and veg at both goes off far quicker than other places despite looking good. I have also had meat that has shrunk to almost nothing when cooked from both so I tend to use them for cupboard and freezer stuff. Their cakes, sweets and chocolates rarely taste as good as I hope they will.
I also find anything I save I often fritter in the middle aisles
Asda and Tesco are cheaper than Sainsburys which I find has a smaller range of products
Booths and Waitrose are dearer. I prefer Waitrose myself and could spend a fortune as they have so much lovely stuff.
Cheapest of all here is Food Warehouse (it's like Iceland but bigger) but most of their stuff is processed and frozen

mogsrus · 08/01/2022 22:30

It’s our go to store, the only thing we can’t get on with is own brand toothpaste, otherwise it’s just food like any of the others and we will eat absolutely anything