Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Aldi isn’t the answer to everything?

285 replies

ShirleyPhallus · 08/01/2022 16:27

On pretty much every thread here to do with food and drink within about 2 posts someone pops up with “I get mine from Aldi and it’s amazing”. On literally every thread like this it’s praised like it’s the best thing ever. See also Lidl.

Anyway, I went to an Aldi this week on the back of all the MN love and it’s just a cheap supermarket. Not the answer to my prayers. Am I missing something? Am I being unreasonable? (Answer is no fyi)

OP posts:
flowersinherhairinjune · 09/01/2022 14:01

It does my head in. I usually shop at sainsburys or m and s because I like the food from there and am not too keen on the food from aldis. Every single time I get a shop, my best friend, my mum, my aunt they say where did you get your shopping? I say sainsburys. Always always get oh you really need to start shopping at aldis, it's fantastic so cheap etc etc. I am so sick of being nagged about where I do my food shopping.

Whitefire · 09/01/2022 13:58

It does not prove that the contents are exactly the same, just because it is made in the same factory doesn't mean it is the same recipe. That is a packing error, not some great proof of the items being the same.

crazyjinglist · 09/01/2022 13:55

I have just done a quick comparison between tomorrow's sainsburys shop and Aldi, on 24 items it was £23.62 in S and £19.39 in Aldi.

Yes, so that would be quite a big saving on my £100 weekly shop.

As to the fact that they use the same suppliers as M&S and Waitrose- yes it doesn't surprise me. It's amazing how easily people are convinced by packaging style (and price!) that what they're eating is higher quality when it actually isn't necessarily.

rooarsome · 09/01/2022 13:55

I can't go a full shop at aldi as the fruit and veg is dreadful quality.
I tried Lidl recently too but actually found it quite pricey- many items I could get in asda for less!

userxx · 09/01/2022 13:54

@GrannytoaUnicorn

The funny thing is, they use the same suppliers as M&S! Quite often you'll pick up an item and it will say M&S on instead of Aldi! The packaging being otherwise identical to the Aldi product. Obviously slipped through at the factory! Usually horrifies the snobs!

I love it when that happens!! The Aldi snobs must be horrified as they only ever shop in M&S! Brilliant.

phishy · 09/01/2022 13:52

I really don’t find the middle aisles of Aldi and Lidl cheap.

I can get that stuff much cheaper at my local market.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 09/01/2022 13:50

It has the same supplier as M&S & Waitrose!

The chicken and sweet corn soup is exactly the same Grin

GrannytoaUnicorn · 09/01/2022 13:47

@RedCandyApple

To think that Aldi isn’t the answer to everything?
GrannytoaUnicorn · 09/01/2022 13:47

@RedCandyApple

I think it’s rubbish and Lidl’s is worse. Would never shop in either


It has the same supplier as M&S & Waitrose! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

GrannytoaUnicorn · 09/01/2022 13:41

Same supplier as Waitrose too as it happens!

To think that Aldi isn’t the answer to everything?
MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 09/01/2022 13:40

@GrannytoaUnicorn

The funny thing is, they use the same suppliers as M&S! Quite often you'll pick up an item and it will say M&S on instead of Aldi! The packaging being otherwise identical to the Aldi product. Obviously slipped through at the factory! Usually horrifies the snobs!
Yes 😂
GrannytoaUnicorn · 09/01/2022 13:39

The funny thing is, they use the same suppliers as M&S! Quite often you'll pick up an item and it will say M&S on instead of Aldi! The packaging being otherwise identical to the Aldi product. Obviously slipped through at the factory! Usually horrifies the snobs!

Whitefire · 09/01/2022 12:22

Ok I can see the savings in meat - but I don't buy a huge amount of meat, and wouldn't buy a leg of lamb for example so I can see why I don't perhaps see the extent of savings.

I have just done a quick comparison between tomorrow's sainsburys shop and Aldi, on 24 items it was £23.62 in S and £19.39 in Aldi.

The things I couldn't get, or an equivalent of: Dough balls, white baton stick, Marigold gloves, Ribena, Shreddies, Packets of mini breadsticks, smarties yoghurts and ski yoghurts. A number of these are for my ds with autism who has a very specific food list, so 'just get an alternative' wouldn't work. (The ski yoghurts are mine as I hate bits)

I will go to Aldi and get some things - dd1 quite likes some of their cereal and it is undoubtedly cheaper overall (though some items were in fact the same prices) it is just never the 50% cheaper for me that many people claim. (and is very dependent on what you buy)

ComtesseDeSpair · 09/01/2022 11:56

I think there have been comparisons done and yes - if you buy very basic foodstuffs, stick to the least fancy fruit and vegetables and don’t eat much meat / fish / cheese, there isn’t always a massive price difference between an equivalent shop in Aldi / Tesco / Sainsbury’s or even Waitrose.

But that’s not how most people want to eat if they have the choice, and if you buy quite a bit of meat and fish, for example, the difference between Aldi and Sainsbury’s / Tesco really adds up. Two large rump steaks are £5.49 in Aldi and £8.99 in the Sainsbury’s next door. The leg of lamb I bought in Aldi yesterday was £16 but £22 in Sainsbury’s. Even “ordinary” meat like chicken portions, mince, pork chops etc are always a couple of pounds cheaper per pack than in Sainsbury’s. (And I really rate Aldi meat - or at least the meat our local store stocks - it’s at least equal quality to or, in the case of the steaks, far better than, what we used to buy from the butcher or in the Hawksmoor steak box.) Add all those few extra pounds up and multiply them to feed a family of 5 or 6 and I think you could quite easily cut at least a third off your usual bill in Aldi. Plus Aldi own brand items are apparently on average 12% cheaper than rival supermarkets’ own brands. That’s a pretty big difference on a large shop.

MooseBreath · 09/01/2022 11:48

The Aldi where I live has produce that goes off really quickly, so I can't do a week's shop there. There's no point in going as Sainsbury's is price-matching meats and pastas, and we mostly buy fresh. The only thing that works out more expensive is tinned food, which is a hit I'm willing to take for the convenience of only one shop per week with a toddler in tow.

The middle aisle of Aldi, while enticing, isn't on my list, so I don't buy anything there. The point of using a cheap supermarket is to spend less!

Whitefire · 09/01/2022 11:31

@babouchette

It's good if the main thing you need to do is save money. I do prefer the choice and quality of products almost anywhere else, but sometimes needs must. A weekly shop for us at Aldi is £40 compared to more like £70-150 elsewhere.
These type of figures never convince me. What are you buying at a different shop that means you spend £110 elsewhere? That is saying that every item you buy is 75% cheaper (and you would need lots of massive ticket items in there as well)

Even the shops own comparison adverts have all own brand items compared against branded items at full price, who shops like that?

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/01/2022 10:14

Ours is amazing quality. I remember many years ago this was the case, but in recent years it's been very good. In fact so good that I'll check for their £1.50 big box bargain of fruit and veg being sold off by the till

See this is not convincing at all. I'm.fortunate to live in a town that has every supermarket. Duplicates of some In fact.

There is no where I would describe as "amazing" quality. Not even m&s or waitrose. All have good things and bad things. Some are more consistent across the board than others. In my case in my town morrisons is probably the most consistent/reliable and edible. So thats where I do a big chunk.of my shopping and out of all supermarkets they have the better meat and fish.

But no where. Repeat no where is " amazing"

The more people who bang on about aldi and lidle being excellent or amazing quality the less convinced I am tbh.

babouchette · 09/01/2022 10:06

It's good if the main thing you need to do is save money. I do prefer the choice and quality of products almost anywhere else, but sometimes needs must. A weekly shop for us at Aldi is £40 compared to more like £70-150 elsewhere.

beautifullymad · 09/01/2022 10:05

@XiCi

I find its a false economy as their fruit and veg goes rotten incredibly quicky so I end up binning a lot of what I buy there. I just don't bother doing a full shop there any more. Occasionally I'll run in and pick up sone wine, cheese and a salmon en croute (which is deliciousand such a bargain). I find Lidl slightly better quality than Aldi.
Ours is amazing quality. I remember many years ago this was the case, but in recent years it's been very good. In fact so good that I'll check for their £1.50 big box bargain of fruit and veg being sold off by the till. This contains items on their dates and multipacks that have split. I can get half my fruit and veg for a week for £1.50.
dottiedodah · 09/01/2022 09:59

UggMum I like SB too .However my one is never "lovely and quiet"! Seems always to be fairly busy . Has price matched with Aldi for a while now anyway

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/01/2022 09:55

I'm also a MN outcast. I hate aldi and lidl.

Used to shop there out if necessity but ut started costing us more than anywhere else as after paying for taxis back amd then having to go somewhere else for the ever increasing list of what we couldn't get and having to oy for taxis back from there too it became a flash economy. Even more so when the fruit and veg would be growing friends and having a party by the time you got it home.

The meat, cream cheese, the peppers and cucumber etc it all just tastes weird. With really odd textures.

Last time I went the broccoli in lidl came with free pets and before that the butter was off. If u screw up butter there's something with with u.

Never again.

Belledan1 · 09/01/2022 09:45

I like lidl and aldi. Lidl is quieter so prefer that. I do find I sometimes go a bit mad as it is so cheap I end up buying lots stuff so spend more. Should stick to a list!

userxx · 09/01/2022 09:40

Love Aldi, have shopped there for about 13 years now. Years ago you'd often be the only one in the store, no problem getting a parking spot!

Whatafustercluck · 09/01/2022 09:29

I used to shop at Tesco but have saved loads shopping at Aldi. OK, the choice isn't as good and the fruit and veg doesn't last as long but pretty happy with it. And their nappies are far superior to Pampers Wink

Seashor · 09/01/2022 09:27

I understand exactly what you’re saying op. Every single time I’ve thought I’d give it a go I haven’t understood what all the fuss is about. I find it depressing actually.