Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be saddened, and yet also angry, that the Harry Potter 20th Anniversary Reunion show totally blanked JK Rowling?

295 replies

SkyBlueBlues · 08/01/2022 14:13

I mean, she did create the bloody thing! Hmm

Just watched it. 100 minutes of the young cast who were the main characters (Harry, Ron, Hermione, Malfoy, Neville Longbottom, The Weasley brothers, etc,) gushing over one another. Laughing and hugging and kissing, and reminiscing and brushing tears from their cheeks, as they whispered 'we're family... always have been, always will be.......'

Not ONE mention of the woman who created it all, and gave them the lives they have now. In fact many people were interviewed, including Ralph Fiennes, Helena Bonham Carter, Gary Oldman, Robbie Coltrane, Bonnie wright, Alfred Enoch, Toby Jones, Mark Williams, Jason Isaacs, etc. Not ONE of them mentioned JK Rowling.

All we got featuring JK, was two 10 to 15 second clips of footage from an interview she did 3 years ago. The narrator mentioned her ONCE! That's it! None of the 'stars' mentioned her, or thanked her for ANYthing. As I said, Harry Potter exists because of HER. Yet she was not deemed worthy of a mention or a thank you.

AIBU to think it's sad and also bloody infuriating, that she has been blanked in this manner? IMO, it's clearly because of the accusations of her being 'transphobic,' (which I don't think she is frankly,) and I am dismayed and somewhat disgusted, that these young people whose careers exist because of JK Rowling, are now treating her like a pariah.

I am a huge fan of Harry Potter, both the books and the films, and this has sullied it all for me now.

OP posts:
Crowdfundingforcake · 08/01/2022 18:34

Skaterchick, I've now read all the articles you linked to above but still can't see anything that would suggest JKR is transphobic. Could you please write out the actual transphobic words she had written/spoken on this thread, just so there's no room for prevarication.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 08/01/2022 18:34

Why have you missed the “pointed nose” and “dark, slanted eyes” bit?

So do some humans Confused

wigglerose · 08/01/2022 18:33

I didn't watch it bit she's never come across as the type of person who'd do that type of thing to be honest. I bet she either got some money for it and let them get on with it or they already had the rights so it had nothing to do with it.

She's never come across as someone who thinks the cast owe their careers to her either.

CalishataFolkart · 08/01/2022 18:32

@DrSbaitso

For example, nowhere in this comment have I accused her of being anti-Semitic.

And nor have you given any information that suggests she is. Her description of goblins is that they're pale skinned with long digits and round heads. So what?

Why have you missed the “pointed nose” and “dark, slanted eyes” bit?
RuggerHug · 08/01/2022 18:31

Yeah the whole British cast thing that's bandied about.....Irish people aren't British in case people don't realise.

ninnynonny · 08/01/2022 18:24

And still the single sentenced, ill informed,, unbackupable ( I know it's not a word, but it's all I can think of), words fall on to the page

DrSbaitso · 08/01/2022 18:24

For example, nowhere in this comment have I accused her of being anti-Semitic.

And nor have you given any information that suggests she is. Her description of goblins is that they're pale skinned with long digits and round heads. So what?

DrSbaitso · 08/01/2022 18:21

@amijustparanoidorjuststoned

She shouldn't have been so transphobic then, should she.
What did she say that was transphobic?
amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 08/01/2022 18:20

She shouldn't have been so transphobic then, should she.

YouSetTheTone · 08/01/2022 18:17

Whether or not JK Rowling should have featured in the reunion about the films is basically neither here nor there. People are splitting hairs over whether she should have been there or not based on her actual involvement in the filming/ casting etc. The salient point is that this is a high profile successful woman who has been slighted, abused, maligned, punished because she has declared that ignoring the fact that sex is real has negative impacts on women. The reason we are all discussing this is because the actors in the reunion have by and large participated in this misogynist treatment towards her.

What JK Rowling has stated is undeniably true. We have seen the consequences of replacing sex with gender: in women’s prisons, in women’s sport, in women’s rape counselling services, in prizes and awards set up for women in order to redress inequalities in the workplace.

If standing up for women’s rights is perceived as ‘transphobic’ then logically this means that being pro trans rights is anti women’s rights. There is a clash and this does need to be discussed. Why aren’t Emma Watson, Rupert Grint and Daniel Radcliffe being held to task for being homophobic and misogynist? Because that’s the consequence of believing that gender identity is more important than sex. You erase same sex attraction and the ability of women to define themselves as adult human females.

JK Rowling is a true feminist icon and I have absolutely no doubt at all that in years to come she will be recognised as such.

CalishataFolkart · 08/01/2022 18:16

@CaveMum

The thing that makes me laugh is that TRA’s are simultaneously claiming that she both a) didn’t have enough involvement in the films to warrant much of a mention in the 20th anniversary special and b) was entirely responsible for the art department portrayal of the goblins in the film due to her high levels of control and influence 🤣

They can’t have it both ways!

Physical appearance

Goblins were short and fair-skinned, as they spent very little time outside. They had very long fingers and feet, dome-shaped heads and were slightly larger than house-elves. Griphook, one of the hundreds of goblins working at Gringotts, had a bald head, pointed nose, and pointed ears. Some had dark, slanted eyes, and some goblins even wore pointed hats.[4]

From Harry Potter wiki.

“Saying it without saying it” is a way of saying “dog-whistle.” People rarely say the quiet part out loud but we all know what they mean.

For example, nowhere in this comment have I accused her of being anti-Semitic.

yourhairiswinterfire · 08/01/2022 18:15

BBC News - Maya Forstater: Woman loses tribunal over transgender tweets

That judgement was overturned and Maya won at appeal.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-57426579

aSofaNearYou · 08/01/2022 18:14

@SkaterChick

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/news/harry-potter-jk-rowling-transphobic-terf-b1974984.html

BBC News - JK Rowling responds to trans tweets criticism
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-53002557

BBC News - Eddie Redmayne speaks out against JK Rowling's trans tweets
www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-52975994

BBC News - Maya Forstater: Woman loses tribunal over transgender tweets
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-50858919

For those of you who wanted links. These are just a few. Jk Rowling is utter trash, just because she claims she isn't transphobic and writes an essay saying she isn't and she loves her trans friends it doesn't mean she isn't.

People can be willing to learn and change, but she continues to tweet transphobic comments so clearly she isn't willing to learn.
People dont just dislike her for no reason.

And the actors in the film's owe no loyalty to her, I am grateful to the first person who took a chance on me and allowed me to work and a baker. I don't owe my career as a pastry chef to them.
They should be prasised for using their platform to support trans people.

People aren't willing to listen to her pertinent points about women and children's safety either, they aren't willing to learn. If you want to criticise someone, make sure you're not being hypocritical while you do it.
Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/01/2022 18:10

Só as usual no actual quote of what JKR said just links to news stories

The only way to believe JKR is transphobic is of you believe men who present as female are actually women

And if you believe that then facts are clearly not your friend

LuckyMeISeeGhosts · 08/01/2022 18:10

@BurntO

She was mentioned a lot but she isn’t exactly popular. I don’t think half the cast would have appeared in it had she she been involved. Sorry!
And funnily enough, none of them would be there in the first place if it weren't for her!
SkaterChick · 08/01/2022 18:08

www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/news/harry-potter-jk-rowling-transphobic-terf-b1974984.html

BBC News - JK Rowling responds to trans tweets criticism
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-53002557

BBC News - Eddie Redmayne speaks out against JK Rowling's trans tweets
www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-52975994

BBC News - Maya Forstater: Woman loses tribunal over transgender tweets
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-50858919

For those of you who wanted links. These are just a few. Jk Rowling is utter trash, just because she claims she isn't transphobic and writes an essay saying she isn't and she loves her trans friends it doesn't mean she isn't.

People can be willing to learn and change, but she continues to tweet transphobic comments so clearly she isn't willing to learn.
People dont just dislike her for no reason.

And the actors in the film's owe no loyalty to her, I am grateful to the first person who took a chance on me and allowed me to work and a baker. I don't owe my career as a pastry chef to them.
They should be prasised for using their platform to support trans people.

TheHamburgler · 08/01/2022 18:03

I see the Daily Mail (who originally reported that she was not invited, then confirmed that she actually was) is frothing because JK Rowling was only mentioned ten times.

But the OP says she was only mentioned once?

I haven’t see the show, but that seems like a significant disparity?

And if 10 isn’t enough, what would have been?

DrSbaitso · 08/01/2022 18:02

So did she create their fabulous, glittering careers or inflict dreadful actors on us all who would never have got a break otherwise?

I've actually always been disappointed with the child cast, since seeing Film 1 and how absolutely shite they were.

DrSbaitso · 08/01/2022 18:01

Is anyone starting a campaign against Thomas Harris over The Silence of the Lambs?

I remember a line in the book (don't recall it in the film but it's been a while) in which Hannibal tells Clarice that Buffalo Bill isn't transgender, he just thinks he is. That might have worked back then, but now, it's accepted that anyone who thinks they're trans is, so Bill is indeed a trans woman.

Is there any outrage about this?

CalishataFolkart · 08/01/2022 17:57

@WabbitsAndWeasels

I'm not going to comment on the frequency with which she was mentioned in the special (I haven't watched it) but with regards to the 'disloyal' behaviour of the actors there has to be a point in time where these adults should be allowed to say what they want. She is the author of a children's book series, they acted in the adaptation, the adaptation couldn't be made without the books but it doesn't been they have to absolutely agree with everything she says forever more. If it had come out she supported fox hunting or something similar and they said they didn't would people be so outraged?

They also don't owe her their careers, some have only acted in small parts (or nothing) since Harry Potter, others are regularly working as actors. Some got their big break in Harry Potter and are recognisable because of it, Daniel Radcliffe had already done several not insignificant acting roles before being cast as I sure some other young actors had. Do you owe your first serious employer everything you have worked hard for since? Do you support everything that boss does and says? Or are you allowed to acknowledge your own hard work and have your own opinions?

Yep.

There’s a lot of posts talking about how much she was involved in the films so deserves credit for them as well, then another bunch of posts talking about the “desperately wooden” child actors and how they’re mediocre now. So did she create their fabulous, glittering careers or inflict dreadful actors on us all who would never have got a break otherwise?

Worship JK and they’re part of the magic, talent notwithstanding; disagree with her views and they’re wooden and shit and should return the fee.

Carriemac · 08/01/2022 17:56

JK Rowling is HP. Every bit of it owes itself to her . She magnificent and those actors are pathetic .

YesIReallyHave · 08/01/2022 17:52

An invitation was extended to Rowling to participate, but her team determined the archived comments from the writer were adequate, EW has learned.

@Lockheart the second link quotes the first link and the first link doesn't really say where they got the information from. I can't imagine her team talking. However, she probably did decline - I wouldn't want to make nice with them either. But we will never know for sure. The fact that both HBO and JKR are silent on this means they probably quietly reached a legal agreement about it all.

Lockheart · 08/01/2022 17:48

@TheHamburgler

Wow, I posted without reading the full thread.

I’m sorry but this J K Rowling martyrdom is getting a bit crazy.

Last week it was her fans saying that the Guardian has rigged a vote, that didn’t exist, to prevent her from winning an award, that didn’t exist.

This week it’s anger that she wasn’t more involved in the reunion special - after she declined to be in it.

Nuts.

I'm staring to despair of the recent strains of GC activism on MN. I owe my GC position to MN from several years back (I've been here since 2012) and integrity seems to have declined somewhat.

Recently the rigour and critical thinking seems to have gone out of the window. The behaviour I see from many posters, ready to believe anything anyone says and go totally overboard with it regardless of whether it is actually true, reminds me more of ignorant Twitter TRAs than intelligent feminists.

Whatever happened to "when they go low, we go high"?

Zezet · 08/01/2022 17:45

Then again, for many of us, the only reason we haven't completely gone off the HP universe is the fact that at least they've distanced themselves from JKR...

sst1234 · 08/01/2022 17:43

@Snugglepumpkin

JK Rowling has created something that will provide jobs for people in this country for decades if not far longer.

Look at the legacy of similar creations & see how they add to the economy as well as the cultural wealth of this country.

Beatrix Potter & her world.
Tolkein & his.
Mark Baker & Neville Astley (think you don't know them? They created Peppa Pig)
A A Milne - Winnie the Pooh
Andrew Lloyd Webber - so many musicals
Shakespeare, Dickens, Austen there's many more.

These creations year after year bring tourists to the country & have massive retail sales worldwide (Peppa Pig generates over a billion a year all on it's lonesome)

She has added to the treasure chest of British creativity & this benefits the whole country.
Creativity is one of the few things this country still 'manufactures'.

Now, I've phrased that badly because I am not a financial expert but there would be no massively profitable 20th Anniversary Reunion without her.
Not a one of those people would have been paid a penny, not one of those actors would have become household names for being part of her creation, the people behind the cameras would have been looking for other jobs, the people making licenced merchandise, spin offs etc... would have been spending that money elsewhere.

I know, not all the money comes to the UK but if you are a British actor, surely you've noticed that these parts are some of the few where you don't have to always be the stuck up baddie who gets defeated by the plucky American & that isn't some obscure British film that doesn't do as well as a Hollywood Blockbuster.

My brain isn't working today & I can't think how to put this eloquently but this woman created a new sport that is played across the world.
A NEW SPORT, just as an aside while doing something else.

JK Rowling is a national treasure & she is STILL WRITING.
STILL producing more & just as nobody could predict how big Harry Potter would become, you don't know if she will go on to create something that eclipses that creation.

I don't personally even like her books but I can respect her success & see that many other people do.

The fact that she does all this while actually having the personal integrity to stand up for what she believes in when it would be so easy for her to just take the money & sit back is even better.
She also does that while NOT actually hurting transpeople no matter how offended some people may feel.
She could.
She could write terrible things, create characters who belittle anyone different & because of who she is it would get out to the world but she doesn't ever do that.

Of course she should have been in the show.
It couldn't exist without her.

Completely agree. The woman is a powerhouse. A true British icon. Daniel who and Emma what’s name will be a footnote in history compared to what JK has achieved.