Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid with DH over night wakings

166 replies

HolidayLovers · 08/01/2022 08:19

DH and I have had a system, since DD was about 4 months old, that I cover any night wakings from Sun-Thurs and DH does Fri and Sat. I am currently SAHP with a small bit of freelance work, and DH is wfh. This is clear and never been questioned. We revert to taking it in turns every other night when on holiday and had a holiday over Christmas. But this week we have been back to normal with me on "night wakings duty" since Sunday.

DD is 18 months but having a sleep regression and nightmares requiring us to rock her back to sleep. I have been up 3 nights this week for a number of hours. Last night (Fri) she cried but DH kept sleeping. After I while I patted him and alerted him to get crying. He said it didn't sound too bad so he wouldn't be getting up. She got worse and worse until long story short after 30 minutes I told him to go and look after his daughter. (I know I could have gone but I just felt like it was his responsibility and it's not fair on me.) he then started saying that he didn't remember this rule about him doing weekend night wakings. This was utter rubbish as we've done it for the whole time. But he kept saying he wouldn't go.

In the end I was fuming and told him so. He went in her room and picked her up but she was screaming by now. After a few minutes I looked in and her had her sat up - as if he wasn't even trying to cradle her back to sleep. She saw me and called for me so in the end of course I ended up looking after her. She was really upset and it took me 2 hours to get her back down, plus she woke again an hour later.

My back has been in muscle spasm this week due to lifting her and the buggy, and DH knows this too and knows I need to rest my back this weekend.

I'm still fuming! He's now having his lie in, as we each get one lie in at weekends. I was tempted to switch the light on at 6.30 and start debating whether it's really ever been agreed that we each get a lie in, but I didn't.

How do I handle this today?

OP posts:
HolidayLovers · 08/01/2022 09:34

Yeah we need to sort the sleep

OP posts:
MindyStClaire · 08/01/2022 09:33

Completely agree the split isn't fair - he should be doing half the nights. I have an 18 month old and WFH. I know which day is easier and it's not yours OP.

Talk to him today. My DH really loves and needs his sleep and can be a grumpy arse when I wake him to take a shift with ours. But in the cold light of day he acknowledges that and tells me not to take no for an answer during the night because he's not a dickhead and wants to pull his weight.

If it's a one off, chalk it up to a bad night and move on. If it's common or part of a bigger picture have a Conversation about it today, and book him in for Sunday night.

pictish · 08/01/2022 09:26

[quote supersonicginandtonic]@StellaGibson118 I think You'll find I said rocking her to sleep isn't good. They're both going to end up with bad backs. They need to look at better ways. Over an hour of rocking a toddler is going to be exhausting. You can help a baby sleep without that 🙄[/quote]
I do agree with this. Sorry.

I wouldn’t entertain rocking a tot for an hour in the night. I’d be looking for, and finding other solutions and did. I’m just not selfless enough to go through that nightly…not at 18 months. Providing comfort of course I did…hold for an hour, no.

AlexanderArnold · 08/01/2022 09:24

Actually, I think he had a different perspective. Have you asked him rather than just getting angry? It sounds as if he considers that eighteen months is old enough to at least weather some crying and see if your dd will settle herself, or learn to gradually. That's not unreasonable. It may not be your approach, but if you are splitting night duties your approach can't prevail all the time and he also needs to make judgement calls.

Not on for him to question your routine in the middle of the night, but also not on for you to override his view that space to self settle is needed at this point. Or Calpol in case it's molars coming through?

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2022 09:23

[quote supersonicginandtonic]@StellaGibson118 I think You'll find I said rocking her to sleep isn't good. They're both going to end up with bad backs. They need to look at better ways. Over an hour of rocking a toddler is going to be exhausting. You can help a baby sleep without that 🙄[/quote]
This^^

Rocking an 18 month year old for an hour isn’t sustainable. A cuddle then sssh pat whilst their lying down, for example, is.

Bushkin · 08/01/2022 09:22

He’s being a dick but I also wouldn’t be rocking an 28 month old for hours in the middle of the night. Does she self settle at bedtime?

scaredsadandstuck · 08/01/2022 09:20

He was a twat, especially if this has been an explicit - i.e. spoken about and agreed -arrangement for the last year or more. Has it? Or is it more of an unspoken rule? Regardless you've now got an opportunity to have a proper chat and (re)agree the rules. Maybe it would be better for him and you to change things around a bit and maybe he covers one week night in exchange for a weekend. I can see after working all week (acknowledging you also have a huge job on your hands being a SAHP which isn't a mon- Fri thing) he might like to know he's got one weekend night where he's not getting up. And you might like having one week night 'off'. Essentially you need to have a chat today to sort it out and agree explicitly - put it on the fridge of you need to - who's doing what. Good luck!

supersonicginandtonic · 08/01/2022 09:20

@StellaGibson118 I think You'll find I said rocking her to sleep isn't good. They're both going to end up with bad backs. They need to look at better ways. Over an hour of rocking a toddler is going to be exhausting. You can help a baby sleep without that 🙄

HolidayLovers · 08/01/2022 09:18

I suppose I went into the room as she sounded so distressed. It's not her fault.

OP posts:
StellaGibson118 · 08/01/2022 09:15

^ 18 months isn't too old to help your child back to sleep, people have just lost all sense of nurture.

There's a few problems here. One that he didn't get up. Two that you are clearly so spent out with him/caregiving that you let your daughter become inconsolable when you were awake just because it wasn't your turn. You need to talk to each other. Everyone gets bone-achingly tired when kids are young but neither of you should have left her that long for the sake of an argument. She likely woke up again because of how distressed she was when she went to sleep.

He 100% should have got up in the first place/much sooner, especially as he was the one getting the lie-in. My ex would do the absolutely zero attempt to get them back to sleep too, it pissed me off so much.

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 08/01/2022 09:12

If he doesn't remember the agreement maybe it's time to negotiate a new one where you alternate night wakings and he does fifty/fifty.

Does she wake every night? DH and I now have a system whereby you're on 'duty' every night until there is a disturbed one, as DS largely sleeps through unless he's ill. He was up in the night last night with an upset stomach we both got up initially (around 11 so not late) because he was very upset and had an accident, needed a shower and bed changed etc, but then DH took him into our bed and got up when he needed the toilet in the night and I went into the spare room. So it's my turn tonight.

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2022 09:11

I think you need to agree a new system - maybe alternating nights.

In the end I was fuming and told him so. He went in her room and picked her up but she was screaming by now. After a few minutes I looked in and her had her sat up - as if he wasn't even trying to cradle her back to sleep. She saw me and called for me so in the end of course I ended up looking after her. She was really upset and it took me 2 hours to get her back down, plus she woke again an hour later.

However having got him up you then didn’t agree with his approach and screwed your self over by going to check up on him.

You both need a different way to get her back to sleep

Im2022 · 08/01/2022 09:11

How to handle: You need to “remind” him of your routine. He should be alert and listening, seeing as he’s had a nice well rested sleep 🙄.

But during the moment, I would have brought the baby into bed with me and told him to p off.

PiffleWiffleWoozle · 08/01/2022 09:10

The fact he was denying the agreement would send me round the bend.

However you went in to the room when you didn’t need to and made the decision to stay. That bit you had control of.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 08/01/2022 09:10

@GoodnightGrandma

I was a SAHP and my DH never got up once in the night or morning. He made it such hard work that it was easier to do it myself !
It's not a competition as to whose husband is the most useless.
Nomorecoco · 08/01/2022 09:09

I have similar issues, and when he refuses and tries to go back to sleep I make sure to make enough noise to keep us both awake. I've kicked him out to sleep on the sofa sometimes too.

dottiedodah · 08/01/2022 09:09

I would be having a very firm discussion Im afraid! He has no more right to sleep than you! Your previous arrangement has worked well for the last year and a half ,so what he thinks its "done " now or something ! Remind him firmly of his agreement .

IDontKnowWhyAye · 08/01/2022 09:08

Refuses

IDontKnowWhyAye · 08/01/2022 09:08

Kitchen table Talk time this evening. Start by agreeing to take it in turns to talk and no raising voices. Then agree new rota. If he reduces he really doesn't give a shit and you have a DH problem.

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 08/01/2022 09:07

Ah I don't know. We had a rule that whatever was said in anger in the night was cancellable with a quick apology the next. None of us tended to be t our best. He was 3/4 asleep and a bit crap and I was tense and snappy.

If you have an otherwise good relationship I would suggest you have a grown up conversation and have a plan for the future.

supersonicginandtonic · 08/01/2022 09:05

I would be looking at addressing her sleep to be honest. 18 months is too old to be holding and rocking a child Back to sleep. You're both gonna end up with bad backs. I'd start looking at gentle ways of her learning to self sooth.
Also wouldn't it make more sense for you both to get a lie in and do a night shift per weekend?

DreamerSeven · 08/01/2022 09:04

@oviraptor21

I'd say it depends. Yes it sounds like he is gaslighting and that is not acceptable. But ..... for me there is a question mark over whether the original arrangement was fair. He works presumably 5 days a week yet both his days off he does the night shift. Unless he's got a very cushy job and you're not a FT SAHP then personally I think 1 night shift and 1 lie in each per weekend would be more fair. And yes I was a SAHP - except for when DC were very young (less than 4 months-ish) this is how we split it.
I was thinking the same, the weekend split doesn’t sound fair to me. It’s not on to change the rules in the middle of the night though which it appears is what he’s done.
AnneLovesGilbert · 08/01/2022 09:04

@GoodnightGrandma

I was a SAHP and my DH never got up once in the night or morning. He made it such hard work that it was easier to do it myself !
You know that’s not okay though right?
GoodnightGrandma · 08/01/2022 09:02

I was a SAHP and my DH never got up once in the night or morning. He made it such hard work that it was easier to do it myself !

oviraptor21 · 08/01/2022 08:57

I'd say it depends.
Yes it sounds like he is gaslighting and that is not acceptable.
But ..... for me there is a question mark over whether the original arrangement was fair. He works presumably 5 days a week yet both his days off he does the night shift. Unless he's got a very cushy job and you're not a FT SAHP then personally I think 1 night shift and 1 lie in each per weekend would be more fair.
And yes I was a SAHP - except for when DC were very young (less than 4 months-ish) this is how we split it.