Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think that a perfectly harmless and hilarious thread shouldn't be deleted

159 replies

SeeMyLanyardAndWeepBitch · 08/01/2022 08:06

Just because the poster is new and on (what we suspect might be) a bit of a wind up? I mean what actual rules are broken and what harm done?

PLEASE DON'T DELETE THIS THREAD FOR BEING A TAT. I am referencing a previous deleted thread, but my point is less about that thread and more about the prevailing culture on here these days concerning what is considered off limits.

The thread I have in mind wasn't offensive, just daft. A spoof. No person with a protected characteristic (or humble but doughty shop worker) was offended, harmed or triggered in the making of said thread.

Are spoofs and very obvious tongue in cheek wind ups no longer to be tolerated on MN?

This place has changed. Sad It used to be fun. We could all take a joke once. What has happened?

YANBU: This place has changed. Way too serious now.

YABU: I am a sanctimonious Guardian reading arse who sees no humour in anything.

OP posts:
SilverRingahBells · 08/01/2022 12:49

I think I've seen that done a couple of times, when most of a banned poster's threads get deleted but one gets left where MNer hand them their arse in particularly strong form. It's rare though. The OP of the thread I quoted above was a classic lazy journalist who had one of their threads removed "I just saw a woman change her baby's nappy on a cafe table, tell me your examples of anti-social parenting" but the other was left to stand as an example for others.

Ninkanink · 08/01/2022 12:49

Yes... and that’s fine for that one thread.

Not so fine for other threads.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 12:41

@AlternativePerspective

There must be distinction between obvious trouble makers and those wanting a light hearted laugh. except as MNHQ said, this was a persistent troll, and although this thread may have been funny, they have posted unpleasant troll threads in the past, in which case it stands to reason that none of their posts should be allowed to stand.
I agree, you can't say 'well you are a persistent unpleasant returning troll but this thread is quite funny so we'll let it stand' that makes no sense.
Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 12:39

This is why Hide Thread is a good function TBF. Or report and Hide thread without even commenting.

AlternativePerspective · 08/01/2022 12:39

There must be distinction between obvious trouble makers and those wanting a light hearted laugh. except as MNHQ said, this was a persistent troll, and although this thread may have been funny, they have posted unpleasant troll threads in the past, in which case it stands to reason that none of their posts should be allowed to stand.

SilverRingahBells · 08/01/2022 12:38

Sparklingbrook I just meant that on threads about funny threads absolutely everyone of that vintage always seems to make a point of saying they didn't find PB funny at the time. I'm the only person who ever confesses to having been amused.

LavenderAskew · 08/01/2022 12:36

But so what if they are tedious to you daisychain? You can click out and continue your tedious search through the dross but others might find it funny and attempt witty comments themselves. If people don't it dies a death and goes away - disappears onto page 2 and beyond.

There is no need to demand they don't exist or get banned. You can't only deal with one style of humour and ban other types. There's things that have posters claim to be weeping with laughter about that I don't even find vaguely funny. Leave them to it if it's harmless.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 12:36

I think that's it @Ninkanink everyone reacts differently to threads.

I remember my first troll thread when I fist joined. Titled 'Dan Snow Boss'. I was completely sucked in, all the drama and live updates, very fast moving (like they always are i know that now) The OP was posting outfits and we had to choose, she was updating from this guy's loo and everything. Then it disappeared. I could not believe it, i wanted to know what happened!

But it was creative writing , nothing more. Lesson learnt.

queenrollo · 08/01/2022 12:34

I've been here so long I remember when all this was fields (and Friday night bum sex)

It's definitely changed a lot, though I'm not wearing rose tinted glasses because it's always had it problem posters. It definitely felt a lot more fun and lighthearted though.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 08/01/2022 12:33

If a thread is sufficiently outlandish so as to make you think WTF? This can't be real?' but it does NO actual harm, then what does it matter whether it's a troll or a spoof or a genuine poster just being a bit weird?

Things that look like harmless fun to most people aren't always harmless fun to everyone.

Do we need to be infantalised and micromanaged over everything we read,

MN mods investigate if someone complains about the thread. I don't know what the thread was, I don't know who complained or why, if it was reasonable to complain or not. But someone must have done. We manage ourselves.

Ninkanink · 08/01/2022 12:30

To me penis beaker, Sistine chapel and snapped & farted are all in the same vein: maybe mildly chuckle-worthy if you read them in real time, but not hilarious imo and not really classics-worthy either. But that just depends on one’s individual tastes.

On the other hand I loved the multi-thread parking thread and really wouldn’t have minded if it had been made up because it genuinely made me happy and I really enjoyed the story. I’d’ve been really annoyed if it had been deleted.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 12:23

@SilverRingahBells

The penis beaker poster was a MNer of very long standing with no previous trolling history. She might have been making something up because she was bored of course.

I realise that it's now The Law to say that you never found it funny, but actually I thought the first couple of hundred posts before the entire internet dropped in and added their own inferior attempts at humour were properly LOL funny - it was one of those threads where I handed my phone over to DH and said "you must read this".

I don't think it's the law to say you didn't find it funny. Humour is quite a personal thing and the OP didn't appeal to me. I was the only person that didn't understand 'Snapped and Farted' either. I think it was all made up as an attempt to get a laugh though. All a bit try hard, like a lot of threads now in Classics.
daisychain01 · 08/01/2022 12:21

@LavenderAskew

Trolls who write things such as they have critical ill twins, or their husband has terminal cancer or about an abusive relationship should be deleted. As with the perverts who want to hear about teenagers having sex or posters' knickers.

But someone posting pretending they are Pollyanna, a seagull or Voldermort don't need to be surely? I mean maybe they wont be but now these type of threads are full of posters reporting, spitting renom and complaining. (Always had these posters, but I there just seem to now be in the majority.)

I know all above is fictional but one's harmless all be it potential unfunny.

Those people who pretend they are Pollyanna, or who screech at the Sistine Chapel etc, are really tedious, and "look at me" attention-seekers. Yes I expect there will be people who clamour for the thread to be made a "MN Classic" but there is no doubt it's all fake and contrived and there are many who don't think they are even vaguely clever or amusing.

I expect HQ let a few odd ones stand to show willing, but if they allow them all to remain then it could set a trend and their forum loses credibility. If the OP posts then abandons MN completely, HQ will want to clear away their mess, they probably have a policy about abandoned threads where the poster deregisters (guess). Having to sift through the dross in the Active list to get to something meaningful is tedious imo. There are plenty of witty, amusing, observational comments embedded in real threads.

SilverRingahBells · 08/01/2022 12:08

The penis beaker poster was a MNer of very long standing with no previous trolling history. She might have been making something up because she was bored of course.

I realise that it's now The Law to say that you never found it funny, but actually I thought the first couple of hundred posts before the entire internet dropped in and added their own inferior attempts at humour were properly LOL funny - it was one of those threads where I handed my phone over to DH and said "you must read this".

Thethreecs · 08/01/2022 12:08

TBH I can't believe the amount of people who fell for it, it was clearly a wind up. Once leafy suburb was mentioned I laughed. Although I did laugh out loud when a poster asked what a lanyard was and a reply was 'A yard that keeps lans in', genius. 😂😂😂

ilovesooty · 08/01/2022 12:03

@bagheaven

YANbU it's a joke - this site is like a children's website sometimes not grown adults.

It's like the site doesn't want any kind of free speech anymore.

I'm sure there are other sites more to your taste.

Presumably MNHQ delete threads because people report them.

Ninkanink · 08/01/2022 12:02

I’m blaming it on a variety of factors.

Including the people who think no one should ever be slightly upset, feel slightly bad, or be slightly made fun of. Ever. Those people never learn to understand sarcasm and perfectly good humour. Then they want to run around policing all the rest of us when we’re just fine, thanks.

(I didn’t think penis beaker was funny at all, tbf)

LavenderAskew · 08/01/2022 11:59

Trolls who write things such as they have critical ill twins, or their husband has terminal cancer or about an abusive relationship should be deleted. As with the perverts who want to hear about teenagers having sex or posters' knickers.

But someone posting pretending they are Pollyanna, a seagull or Voldermort don't need to be surely? I mean maybe they wont be but now these type of threads are full of posters reporting, spitting renom and complaining. (Always had these posters, but I there just seem to now be in the majority.)

I know all above is fictional but one's harmless all be it potential unfunny.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 11:53

So we are blaming all this on the new members that Penis Beaker going viral caused?

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2022 11:49

@Sparklingbrook

I thought Penis Beaker was a troll, and a load of made up rubbish, I read the OP rolled my eyes and hid it. Now it's in Classics and gained MN a load of new members. So they don't always get deleted.
Yes and those new PB members are the credulous fools who don’t understand irony!
Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 11:42

I thought Penis Beaker was a troll, and a load of made up rubbish, I read the OP rolled my eyes and hid it.
Now it's in Classics and gained MN a load of new members. So they don't always get deleted.

Lipity · 08/01/2022 11:42

Pirate sex wouldn’t last more than 2 pages before it was deleted these days

I agree OP, so what if it’s bollocks, if it’s not hurting anyone just let it be

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 08/01/2022 11:38

Are we not intelligent enough to know the difference? Do we really need protecting from people start bizarre conversations to provoke a reaction, so long as it's not bullying or hateful in content?

Apparently not. That's why we have to put (lighthearted) in thread titles.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 11:31

@JanuaryBluehoo

Thanks, sparkling.

I've been here over a decade now, so I know the ropes Smile.

It's a drag on amusing threads where talented writers turn minutea into hilarity.

That's good then, you know to report. Smile

There's a lot of 'talented writers' on here I can't argue with that.

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2022 11:31

its got to the point where anything funny is called a troll thread.

I disagree with that. there's been a lot of funny threads that aren't trolls.

Yes but the threads are still covered in idiotic trollhunting comments because some posters don’t understand irony