Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think that a perfectly harmless and hilarious thread shouldn't be deleted

159 replies

SeeMyLanyardAndWeepBitch · 08/01/2022 08:06

Just because the poster is new and on (what we suspect might be) a bit of a wind up? I mean what actual rules are broken and what harm done?

PLEASE DON'T DELETE THIS THREAD FOR BEING A TAT. I am referencing a previous deleted thread, but my point is less about that thread and more about the prevailing culture on here these days concerning what is considered off limits.

The thread I have in mind wasn't offensive, just daft. A spoof. No person with a protected characteristic (or humble but doughty shop worker) was offended, harmed or triggered in the making of said thread.

Are spoofs and very obvious tongue in cheek wind ups no longer to be tolerated on MN?

This place has changed. Sad It used to be fun. We could all take a joke once. What has happened?

YANBU: This place has changed. Way too serious now.

YABU: I am a sanctimonious Guardian reading arse who sees no humour in anything.

OP posts:
DappledThings · 08/01/2022 20:52

[quote CaptainNancy]@DappledThings Oh thank you for that link! It was lovely re-reading that.
I might crack open Winter Holiday this evening Wine[/quote]
Winter Holiday is my favourite. I really wanted to name my daughter Dorothea after Dorothea Callum but DH found it too fussy.

afizzysweet · 08/01/2022 18:35

I am gutted that the bohpeemian rhapsody thread from a few days ago was taken down

bagheaven · 08/01/2022 18:32

@wankywomble

Totally agree! And those who say 'reported'. The stuff about 'looking into it' is a load of rubbish too. I have had a thread delete that was genuine and no one contacted me when actually I wanted them to explain and defend my position. At times it feels like MN is complicit in silencing women
Totally agree @wthey also seem to masters in the art of silencing discussion around race too.

Very angry that a thread once got taken down about speaking up when racism had been witnessed by the OP in a social situation. How a thread like that could have been deleted was very disappointing

Propagandalf · 08/01/2022 18:09

A few days ago, there was a thread called "To be bloody glad I don't live in the US?"

Another thread popped up "To be bloody glad I don't live in the UK?"

They were discussing the negatives of those 2 countries.

I then made a parody thread called "To be bloody glad I don't live in the North Korea?"

All 3 threads got deleted, citing "MNHQ deleted this thread because it was a TAAT."

I think people need to chill sometimes.

YANBU OP!

FangsForTheMemory · 08/01/2022 17:57

YABU: I read the Guardian but I'm neither sanctimonious nor an arse (although I HAVE an arse and very large it is too).

Maybe you shouldn't stereotype people?

HTH.

ilovesooty · 08/01/2022 17:55

[quote bagheaven]@ilovesooty just because someone reports something it doesn't mean it should be taken down though. MN should assess the situation and not get overly sensitive at topics that 'may cause offence' because the person isn't talking about something light hearted [/quote]
Yes I see that, but what I meant was that unless posters do report MNHQ often won't realise there's anything to assess.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 08/01/2022 17:52

In fact MN could edit the title to say "warning - this may be a troll" but leave it up.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 08/01/2022 17:51

@shrunkenhead

Hard to say as I didn't read the deleted thread! I do find that MN seems to delete any thread I'm remotely interested in. And the message "we've taken this down while we look into things" comment is annoying as they never return the thread after they've "looked into it"! I'd prefer a better explanation too as to why threads are deleted, rather than the lazy general breaking MN guidelines excuse.
Totally agree with this. And why delete - why not just lock it (not sure if that is even possible though).
CaptainNancy · 08/01/2022 17:43

@DappledThings Oh thank you for that link! It was lovely re-reading that.
I might crack open Winter Holiday this evening Wine

wankywomble · 08/01/2022 16:57

Totally agree! And those who say 'reported'. The stuff about 'looking into it' is a load of rubbish too. I have had a thread delete that was genuine and no one contacted me when actually I wanted them to explain and defend my position. At times it feels like MN is complicit in silencing women

TheHoptimist · 08/01/2022 16:55

[quote daisychain01]@TheHoptimist is that the one where the OP is all set, flat is prepared and ready to move into, cue the tension and the countdown... etc. If so OMG![/quote]
When I am being charitable I thin that it must be escapism- they must be stick in a crap life and want to escape. When I am being uncharitable I want to scream at the people being sucked in.

BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 08/01/2022 16:43

@JanuaryBluehoo

There was a really jokey thread in Christmas, are you giving your staff a tip.. Very clearly taking the mic out of people who employ staff.. From the past.. Unfortunately the fun suckers who were unable to detect the irony got their teeth into it and sucked it dry.
Was that one deleted? Shame, it reminded be that I hadn't tipped the pot-boy.
TheHoptimist · 08/01/2022 16:41

[quote daisychain01]@TheHoptimist is that the one where the OP is all set, flat is prepared and ready to move into, cue the tension and the countdown... etc. If so OMG![/quote]
Yes, there have been at least 3 if not more. Slight twist but they have the same writing style. They also revisit and stoke the thread with a drama whenever it dies down.

daisychain01 · 08/01/2022 16:38

@TheHoptimist is that the one where the OP is all set, flat is prepared and ready to move into, cue the tension and the countdown... etc. If so OMG!

TheHoptimist · 08/01/2022 16:33

The BF and the lanyard went overnight

Yet the I am leaving my husband and have a flat troll come back every few months (using the same language) and sucks everyone in. Only been deleted once.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 16:26

Yes I agree about the celebrity threads. Why would MN want to even take the chance of getting legal action over one if they can nip it in the bud straight away. Plus it must have had something not quite right to be reported in the first place.

AlternativePerspective · 08/01/2022 16:21

I will never get over a thread being deleted because the poster had said Adele seems arrogant these days. people need to bear in mind though that when someone posts something derogatory about a celebrity that celebrity has the power to threaten legal action against the owners of the site.

The situation with Gina ford was years ago and MN really were threatened with legal action over comments a poster made about her.

Nowadays a lot of celebs employ social media experts to trawl the internet for their name and to, where possible, prevent negative comments from being allowed to stand.

We have no idea who may or may not have threatened HQ in the past, but I think it’s fair to say that if a thread is posted with derogatory and possibly defamatory comments it is in HQ’s best interests to remove it if it is flagged to them.

Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 14:51

@Sparklingbrook I agree but some of the decision making of moderators is poor

That's all down to opinion isn't it I suppose. What one person thinks is a poor decision someone else will think that's the correct one?

I'm not saying I know the answer. A fully moderated site like Nethuns? There's too many reports for just one moderator presumably? Then you have the whole 'Nightwatch' thing going on...

KeepTwirling · 08/01/2022 14:49

Chat and Aibu have become boring - full of posters mainly repeating thread topics. Probably why so many rush to troll threads because they're the fairly interesting ones.

bagheaven · 08/01/2022 14:45

@Sparklingbrook I agree but some of the decision making of moderators is poor.

I will never get over a thread being deleted because the poster had said Adele seems arrogant these days.

I mean the moderator must have either been a huge Adele fan and biased or have the poorest decision making skills ever.

Utterly ridiculous

daisychain01 · 08/01/2022 14:37

@LittleBearPad

I expect HQ let a few odd ones stand to show willing, but if they allow them all to remain then it could set a trend and their forum loses credibility. If the OP posts then abandons MN completely, HQ will want to clear away their mess, they probably have a policy about abandoned threads where the poster deregisters (guess). Having to sift through the dross in the Active list to get to something meaningful is tedious imo. There are plenty of witty, amusing, observational comments embedded in real threads.

Why does a thread have to be meaningful? Or every board have to be credible. Baby feeding, infertility, SEN and similar should be. Chat is just for shite on the interweb surely!

Chat and AIBU have definitely become shite, that's for sure Grin
Sparklingbrook · 08/01/2022 14:34

[quote bagheaven]@ilovesooty just because someone reports something it doesn't mean it should be taken down though. MN should assess the situation and not get overly sensitive at topics that 'may cause offence' because the person isn't talking about something light hearted [/quote]
I am sure MNHQ do assess the situation and act accordingly. Although there's not just one moderator is there. Presumably they are allowed to make the decision they deem fit for each individual thread. So it's not a case of 'MN' being 'overly sensitive' as a whole, it's many decisions each day having to be made by many people.

bagheaven · 08/01/2022 14:31

@ilovesooty just because someone reports something it doesn't mean it should be taken down though. MN should assess the situation and not get overly sensitive at topics that 'may cause offence' because the person isn't talking about something light hearted

nalabae · 08/01/2022 12:53

Yanbu

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2022 12:49

I expect HQ let a few odd ones stand to show willing, but if they allow them all to remain then it could set a trend and their forum loses credibility. If the OP posts then abandons MN completely, HQ will want to clear away their mess, they probably have a policy about abandoned threads where the poster deregisters (guess). Having to sift through the dross in the Active list to get to something meaningful is tedious imo. There are plenty of witty, amusing, observational comments embedded in real threads.

Why does a thread have to be meaningful? Or every board have to be credible. Baby feeding, infertility, SEN and similar should be. Chat is just for shite on the interweb surely!