Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two

463 replies

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 22:39

Original thread here.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4446999-To-think-so-many-middle-class-clothes-are-ugly?pg=40

I admit I am hardly a style guru. But when I joined Mumsnet people talked about lots of companies I had never heard of like Toast. So I followed links of clothes posted and looked at the websites mentioned. And was shocked at how ugly so much of the clothing was.
Shapeless grey dresses. Black loose trousers teamed with black tunics which make the model look like she is a member of a cult. Shapeless brown t-shirts.
They are just so ugly. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
steppemum · 08/01/2022 18:34

ChampagneLassie

I'm sorry but I don't recognise this at all.
My mum is in her 80s and spends much more on clothes than I do.
My Granny, who was born in 1910 loved clothes and fashion. Yes she was thrifty, and didn't do disposable fashion, and she woudl repait things (but she wouldn't wear it if it had holes or a bad repair) but she enjoyed shopping for a new dress in her 70s and 80s.
In fact both my Grannies did.

And neither had a lot of money.

ChampagneLassie · 08/01/2022 18:30

@KillingMeDeftly

my mum would still be wearing those 20 years later! (honestly she's wearing things in her 70's she had in her 20/30s!, holes and patched etc

@ChampagneLassie are you Zara Phillips?? Grin

Ha, ha, ha. I wish! Princess Anne wears some fantastic things.
KillingMeDeftly · 08/01/2022 18:26

my mum would still be wearing those 20 years later! (honestly she's wearing things in her 70's she had in her 20/30s!, holes and patched etc

@ChampagneLassie are you Zara Phillips?? Grin

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 18:16

@ChampagneLassie maybe that is the difference. Clothes from my 20s don't fit me anymore.

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 08/01/2022 18:12

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@ChampagneLassie I am in my late fifties. My clothes wear out or get out of shape and I need new ones.[/quote]
Yes - and my mum would still be wearing those 20 years later! (honestly she's wearing things in her 70's she had in her 20/30s!, holes and patched etc) My point was ladies today do buy more clothes I think than the 40/50/60 year olds of 20-30 years ago.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 18:12

@tectonicplates

I'm so fed up of women asking "Why don't you buy men's clothes?" when we complain about quality, because there's a certain amount of sizing privilege involved. I'm 5ft 1 and even most women's clothes are too long for me, so where the AF am I going to find men's clothes that fit me?!

As a short person, I'll give a chance to any company that makes petites (which is an ever-diminishing number). This means I'll often buy things from shops where I wouldn't necessarily have chosen them for the style, if I'd had a choice. That's why I have a couple of things from Land's End (boring but comfortable), and a few plain things from Asos and Boohoo.

Anyone who's very short, very tall, or larger than a size 18/20 knows this. We shop where it's possible to shop, which isn't always where we'd like.

And don't even get me started about ethical/fairtrade clothing companies. They make a much narrower sizing range than high street shops and then what we request more sizes, they claim there isn't a demand when we know full well that there is. If you don't make ethical clothes that for us then you can't go complaining when we buy stuff from Boohoo, who seem to actually want customers.

If it's of any comfort my husband complains that high street options for men are generally very poor quality.
BigHuff · 08/01/2022 18:10

@KimikosNightmare

Can you name some of the brands, please? I did not realise there were so many companies making clothing in the UK - I was very pleasantly surprised to see so many examples on the previous thread!

At the moment a lot of my clothes are from & Daughter , Palava and Edina Ronay. Knitwear from Palava and Eribé. One fabulous dress from Eponine.

I have dresses from a local boutique from a brand called Emperor's New Clothes which recycle fabrics. Jackets from local independent dressmaker or other UK or Irish tweed companies. Max Mara coats which are made in Italy. Lots of tailored stuff from a Dutch shop Pauw. So not all UK.

Shoes are easy to buy from EU producers as Spain, Italy and Portugal have really cornered the market. Not sure if there are shoes made in UK ( There probably are but suspect they might be too utilitarian for my taste)

Thank you for replying! I am kind of amazed that I have never heard of any of these brands.

The dresses on Eponine really are fabulous, although I guess they do underscore my personal preference for more anonymous clothing. Grin

Alcemeg · 08/01/2022 18:07

@ChampagneLassie

Is this growth in modest fashion actually just part of the growth of consumerism generally? My mum largely stopped buying clothes in her 40s just wore the same thing, whereas women in this age range now are more likely to have more disposable income and marketers are targeting that in appealing to that demographic
I think you are right. My mum, now nearly 90, still wears a couple of M&S summer dresses that she bought in the late 1970s. My wardrobe includes some "old favourites" but doesn't quite stretch that far!
RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 18:05

@ChampagneLassie I am in my late fifties. My clothes wear out or get out of shape and I need new ones.

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 08/01/2022 18:01

As in historically "fashion" only really targeted the young and now they're are more brands appealing to older consumers. And with the internet it allows for the more niche targeting. Whilst I don't like the dowdy aesthetic I think, perversely it gives more opportunity for self-expression through styling than buying say a print dress from M&S which 0000s of others will have and you can almost guarantee you'll bump into others wearing same thing.

ChampagneLassie · 08/01/2022 17:58

Is this growth in modest fashion actually just part of the growth of consumerism generally? My mum largely stopped buying clothes in her 40s just wore the same thing, whereas women in this age range now are more likely to have more disposable income and marketers are targeting that in appealing to that demographic

BigHuff · 08/01/2022 17:57

[quote KirstenBlest]White Stuff is ok. As a pp, the finishing, fabric and detail is good.

@BigHuff, try this link
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/style_and_beauty/3667982-If-i-like-Toast-and-Margaret-Howell-with-pics#prettyPhoto[/quote]
Lots of names to look up - thank you!

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 17:51

But UK made fashion isn't necessarily ethical. Look at boohoo

Looking at the prices is a big give away that it isn't ethical. I wouldn't buy clothes that cheap for that reason.

The company’s website states that it puts over 500 new products online every week. An item can go from design to sale intwo weeks. On one day in April 2021 ‘new in today’ items include dresses for under £10 and leggings for under £7. Heavily discounted sale items included a bikini reduced to only £3

These clothes are not designed to last from one summer to the next. Such low prices and quick turnaround times imply Boohoo’s disregard for the planet and workers’ rights

www.ethicalconsumer.org/fashion-clothing/whats-ethical-impact-boohoo-asos-buying-well-known-fashion-brands

Bideshi · 08/01/2022 17:49

[quote IncognitoBurrito]@thepeopleversuswork yeah, I wasn’t really meaning that 70s dress style - more big skirt with tailored blouse and jacket - maybe late Edwardian? I love this lady’s style[/quote]
1920s lady write is spot-on actually. And arty types like Dora Carrington and Iris Tree. Virginia Woolf on occasions. Before lockdown you could go to any private gallery exhibition or preview and more than half the women there would be in Toast or its ilk. That's its constituency.

In the case Toast I think the modesty thing is a red herring. My Toast dress has quite a low neck. But it's a winter dress. It has substance ands sleeves. I live in the country in a cold place and need warm clothes. I'm constantly amazed by pictures of people in tee shirts in their homes winter. When did that become a thing?
And it's not the only style of clothes that I wear-just one of several. I like authentic fabric and don't like pattern, ornamentation or logos. I like scoop necks because I have lovely necklaces (not Pru Leith dos) and although I'm old I sometimes wear short skirts with thick tights because I have good legs.

tectonicplates · 08/01/2022 17:44

I'm so fed up of women asking "Why don't you buy men's clothes?" when we complain about quality, because there's a certain amount of sizing privilege involved. I'm 5ft 1 and even most women's clothes are too long for me, so where the AF am I going to find men's clothes that fit me?!

As a short person, I'll give a chance to any company that makes petites (which is an ever-diminishing number). This means I'll often buy things from shops where I wouldn't necessarily have chosen them for the style, if I'd had a choice. That's why I have a couple of things from Land's End (boring but comfortable), and a few plain things from Asos and Boohoo.

Anyone who's very short, very tall, or larger than a size 18/20 knows this. We shop where it's possible to shop, which isn't always where we'd like.

And don't even get me started about ethical/fairtrade clothing companies. They make a much narrower sizing range than high street shops and then what we request more sizes, they claim there isn't a demand when we know full well that there is. If you don't make ethical clothes that for us then you can't go complaining when we buy stuff from Boohoo, who seem to actually want customers.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 17:44

Can you name some of the brands, please? I did not realise there were so many companies making clothing in the UK - I was very pleasantly surprised to see so many examples on the previous thread!

At the moment a lot of my clothes are from & Daughter , Palava and Edina Ronay. Knitwear from Palava and Eribé. One fabulous dress from Eponine.

I have dresses from a local boutique from a brand called Emperor's New Clothes which recycle fabrics. Jackets from local independent dressmaker or other UK or Irish tweed companies. Max Mara coats which are made in Italy. Lots of tailored stuff from a Dutch shop Pauw. So not all UK.

Shoes are easy to buy from EU producers as Spain, Italy and Portugal have really cornered the market. Not sure if there are shoes made in UK ( There probably are but suspect they might be too utilitarian for my taste)

BakeOffRewatch · 08/01/2022 17:41

@toddybell

I've just come across this thread and my take:

I spent years working out to get to a certain size and then maintain that size so that I could fit into clothes I was told (magazines, etc.) would suit my shape, make me look stylish/hip/current, etc. then I got pregnant and gained a lot of weight. I've tried and tried to address the weight issue and have lost some but have also come to terms with the fact that I'll never have the body I once had which means all of my old wardrobe (which I still can't get rid of- quality pieces which cost me a small fortune) has gone to waste. Since having the DC, I've discovered the Toast/Seasalt/Ganni/Shirin Guild style suits me much better- I can move about freely, not be self conscious, for example, about VPL, wearing shape wear underneath, etc. and I find it liberating. I probably look like a sack of spuds when people see me but I genuinely don't care- I feel much happier in what I wear now than I did in my slimmer days when everything was planned and coordinated and may have restricted what I was able to do (e.g. run for the bus!). The slouchy look suits me fine. I'm not here to win any fashion awards (confession: I still wear Uggs).

Is this… me? Huge suitcase full of size 8 and 10 Reiss, Burberry, Boden, Ted Baker (before they became more high street-y), Sandro, Maje, Kooples under the bed. I’m now creeping to size 16. I’m back at work and dreading going back to office and this shapeless stuff is exactly what I’m looking at, it’s quality fabric and “stylish”. I would look ridiculous going to work in polyester jersey new look stuff, not looking down on it, it’s what I wear at home. I have no idea what to wear.
KirstenBlest · 08/01/2022 17:38

White Stuff is ok. As a pp, the finishing, fabric and detail is good.

@BigHuff, try this link
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/style_and_beauty/3667982-If-i-like-Toast-and-Margaret-Howell-with-pics#prettyPhoto

Momicrone · 08/01/2022 17:29

Why so many threads putting downers on other people's style, live and let live

Alcemeg · 08/01/2022 17:28

Sorry, me again just spotted this as an example of what I mean by White Stuff attention to detail e.g. I love the assorted buttons and the way the lining has been finished. (Lined skirt, £9.23 buy it now price secondhand on eBay)

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
PattyPan · 08/01/2022 17:26

@RoyalFamilyFan

But UK made fashion isn't necessarily ethical. Look at boohoo.
Agreed. There are a lot of labour abuses going on in the Leicester textiles industry.

Ethical Consumer magazine did a guide to clothing a couple of issues ago for anyone who is interested in shopping ethically. They did rankings for general/high street brands and separately for brands marketed as ethical/sustainable. The best high street brands were Patagonia, Reformation and Nobody's Child and the ones to avoid were Amazon (unsurprisingly), Boohoo, Misspap, Pretty Little Thing, Shein and Primark.

BigHuff · 08/01/2022 17:20

@KimikosNightmare

So - stupid question maybe -how are people viewing things in terms of sustainability, working conditions etc - is this a factor for many?

It's not a stupid question. It's important for me. My favourite brands are made in the UK or EU. I don't buy Toast because most of their stuff isn't.

Can you name some of the brands, please? I did not realise there were so many companies making clothing in the UK - I was very pleasantly surprised to see so many examples on the previous thread!
Alcemeg · 08/01/2022 17:18

^ cashmere not cotton!! d'oh

Alcemeg · 08/01/2022 17:17

Ahhh I am glad it's not just me who likes White Stuff! their clothes were ridiculed on another MN thread and I had no idea why. To me, they are colourful, comfy, quirky/retro, use lovely fabrics (often with silk or cotton included for extra softness), and I like their attention to detail -- there's often a little trimming like unusual buttons or embroidery. Last but not least, I can get my hot little hands on them cheaply! Just a quick check on eBay (used but good condition) came up with zillions of choices. A few samples here (size 10): hoodie £7.99 (bid, but offers accepted), dress £10.50 (buy it now price), sage green velvet skirt £9.99 (buy it now price). Cheap and cheerful ticks the boxes for me!

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
KirstenBlest · 08/01/2022 17:15

The MH clothes don't have hanger appeal but they are great when you wear them. Toast is a bit like that.

I rate M&S footwear too. They look good and aren't expensive. Same goes for jeans

I don't understand the MN hatred of M&S. I think the stuff is good. What is stocked at each store does vary and perhaps it's that I am going to M&S in London that is the difference

I have things from New Look (London again), Tu, Zara, Dorothy Perkins, Topshop etc. I buy most things 2nd hand