Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two

463 replies

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 22:39

Original thread here.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4446999-To-think-so-many-middle-class-clothes-are-ugly?pg=40

I admit I am hardly a style guru. But when I joined Mumsnet people talked about lots of companies I had never heard of like Toast. So I followed links of clothes posted and looked at the websites mentioned. And was shocked at how ugly so much of the clothing was.
Shapeless grey dresses. Black loose trousers teamed with black tunics which make the model look like she is a member of a cult. Shapeless brown t-shirts.
They are just so ugly. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
StEval · 09/01/2022 17:48

Encouraging women to poke fun and be snide and nasty about what others wear isnt gently laughing at yourself or others though Op.

Perhaps you lack self awareness or your self esteem is poor?

Your threads are horrible, really mean and you encouraged others to join in.

mathanxiety · 09/01/2022 17:02

See also, 'That's an interesting skirt/trousers/top...'

mathanxiety · 09/01/2022 17:00

It means WTF.

Malibuismysecrethome · 09/01/2022 16:58

What does being asked where you bought something mean? ^^

RedHot22 · 09/01/2022 16:57

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

I was a pattern cutter for five years. I like Cos because of the clever pattern cutting. They look deceptively simple, but are quite complex. You need a degree in engineering to iron them. There’s nowhere on the Hight Street that does this apart from them.

So from a construction point not all their items are shapeless. Some of them are ingenious.

That’s really interesting and probably explains why they need to be tried on and not judged by how they look on the hanger
mathanxiety · 09/01/2022 16:53

But surely OP, if people are giving these women a 'lot of compliments' on how they look a fair few people don't think their clothes are actually ugly?

I never get any compliments on what I wear. I very occasionally get asked where I bought something I wear, and I have been around long enough to know what that means Smile

I agree with @Enough4me.
Plus £130 for a black bin bag!

I sometime find myself thinking - to myself, in my own head, @threadpolice - 'What was she thinking?' when I see other people's outfits.

We're allowed to poke fun gently here.

Mankyfruitbowl · 09/01/2022 16:33

Yes, the irony! But quite a few Toasters have come on to say that they aren't in fact mega-rich wood nymphs, so by implication they are just... what? I refer back to the shapeless, sludgy, given-up comments.

Frenchfurze · 09/01/2022 15:33

@Mankyfruitbowl

I love Cos clothes, but am still able to have a chuckle at the way the clothes are styled on their website (which frequently looks ridiculous and/or a bit pretentious). It's not about not having a sense of humour, or pretending not to notice target demographics.

I think what some of us are objecting to is the characterization of the Toast tunic-wearers as sexless, "frumpy" given-up-on-life women with more money than sense. That's where it stops being "light-hearted" for me. I'm still enjoying a lot of the other posts re. style analysis though, particularly Arseinthecoopwindow's.

But the Toast women (Toasters?), as well as being hopeless frumps who’ve ‘given up’, are also being characterised as the complete opposite — women who invest huge amounts of money and time in maintaining an unusually youthful and attractive ‘wood nymph’ appearance and whose shapeless, muted dresses are consciously chosen to give the false impression they ‘just woke up like that’.

That’s what’s amusing me on this thread!

koalacat · 09/01/2022 15:31

When I was travelling in Pakistan in my 20s, I wore shalwar kameeze with sandals which was as plain and shapeless as possible (didn’t want to attract attention as a lone woman). You just buy the fabric in a market and they make it up for you. It was quite liberating actually. Never really felt the same way since Grin

Mankyfruitbowl · 09/01/2022 15:17

I love Cos clothes, but am still able to have a chuckle at the way the clothes are styled on their website (which frequently looks ridiculous and/or a bit pretentious). It's not about not having a sense of humour, or pretending not to notice target demographics.

I think what some of us are objecting to is the characterization of the Toast tunic-wearers as sexless, "frumpy" given-up-on-life women with more money than sense. That's where it stops being "light-hearted" for me. I'm still enjoying a lot of the other posts re. style analysis though, particularly Arseinthecoopwindow's.

koalacat · 09/01/2022 15:08

And yes, shops have their target demographics. I looked at that Toast website and Ive seen that kind of look around. I sometimes go out to Richmond and I’m sure I’ve seen that shop there. Also there is a Cos there. I don’t go in those shops personally, but I can see that it would suit some people. I was in a restaurant in Richmond with a friend the other day and there was a grouch of women in the next table. All probably 60 plus and wearing that kind of wide linen trousers / cashmere wraps kind of look. I have to say, they all looked fabulous - glowing skin and I don’t know, they just seemed happy and comfortable in their own skins and enjoying life. Good for them. So if shops like Toast are targeting that demographic, why try and make these slightly older ladies feel like frumps?

koalacat · 09/01/2022 14:53

It’s not about not being able to laugh at ridiculous clothes on the high street, or understand that shops target certain demographics. You could say that about anything.

It’s all the ‘middle class’ nonsense. What’s that about? This is about the fourth or fifth thread since Xmas. There was even one about whether it’s ‘middle class’ to use the term ‘Father Christmas’ rather than ‘Santa.’

What will it be tomorrow? Can’t wait..,

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/01/2022 14:40

Yes it is isn’t it?Grin

No one really knows why. Suprised dresses don’t have long trains at the moment considering where we are economically!

RoyalFamilyFan · 09/01/2022 14:38

@Cornisharchitect @Enough4me Yes I have left it too. You cant have fun threads on MN anymore it seems.
And to those who don't get light-hearted fun threads - I like quirky clothing and posted something I really like. Absolutely nobody agreed. But that is fine, I know my choices are quirky. Those who wear the clothes I posted photos of must know they are not mainstream choices.
And the middle-class thing is about who the marketing is aimed at. Every clothing firm has that demographic. So Bon Marche is largely aiming at older working-class women. It does not mean all older working-class women wear their clothes, but that is their target demographic.
I do wonder at the joylessness of not being able to gently laugh at yourself and others.

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 09/01/2022 14:38

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Just back to add my two pe’north.

Hemlines drop when the economy isn’t good. Hence prairie dresses.

1920’s postwar boom short hemlines
1930’s recession long hemlines
1950’s post war rationing ballerina length hemlines
1960’s boom mini skirts
1970’s recession maxi dresses
1980’s bubble, ra ra, minicrin
1990’s recession, long baggy dresses

Etc etc.

This is so interesting:)
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/01/2022 14:37

I was a pattern cutter for five years. I like Cos because of the clever pattern cutting. They look deceptively simple, but are quite complex. You need a degree in engineering to iron them. There’s nowhere on the Hight Street that does this apart from them.

So from a construction point not all their items are shapeless. Some of them are ingenious.

forinborin · 09/01/2022 14:18

(2) those who think that Toast or Cos wearers wear these clothes because they are so convinced of their own goddess-like beauty that the clothes are saying ‘Fuck you, I’m so gorgeous I don’t even have to try, so my sludgy, loose clothes are a kick in the teeth to those of you whose first question is always ‘Is this flattering? Does it make me look pretty?’’
I don't think that is exactly what was meant. From my perspective, at 35+ the difference between women who spend substantial money and effort on their appearance and those who don't is already very visible, and I think frumpy outfit choices are supposed to balance it off a little bit, in the "Ah, I just woke up like that", rather than "look at me, ain't I just gorgeous!" sense.

I mentioned an ex-model friend, who is early 40s. Her monthly upkeep cost is around £1500 (last time we discussed this topic, which was pre lockdown), and time-wise is almost equivalent to a part time job. She wears exactly those shapeless muted frocks, and looks very natural, with that wood nymph look, and looks late 20s max. On occasions when she dresses up / puts a lot of makeup on, you actually start noticing all other things she's done to herself (plastic surgery, all lifts/threads/fillers/hair tricks etc).

SocialConnection · 09/01/2022 13:58

In summer I tend to wear dresses and skirts right down to the ankle or linen trousers, mainly because my legs are meh and I prefer them covered, plus I don't like too much direct sun. I like upper arms covered too. But I do like a fitted waist and a low v neck. I enjoy theatre, costume drama, fantasy, steampunk, reenactment, so I probably think I live in another time!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/01/2022 13:57

Just back to add my two pe’north.

Hemlines drop when the economy isn’t good. Hence prairie dresses.

1920’s postwar boom short hemlines
1930’s recession long hemlines
1950’s post war rationing ballerina length hemlines
1960’s boom mini skirts
1970’s recession maxi dresses
1980’s bubble, ra ra, minicrin
1990’s recession, long baggy dresses

Etc etc.

Cornisharchitect · 09/01/2022 13:31

It definitely isn’t a fun thread anymore…
Great while it lasted OP Smile

Alcemeg · 09/01/2022 13:10

I feel really bad now 😪

It's the cost of these garments, though... they just seem joyless.

But then I suppose that just goes to show that what brings one person joy means nothing to another.

If I had all the money in the world to spend on clothes, I'd install Vicky Gill in my wardrobe. I could build her a little shelf in there, perhaps with a sleeping bag, and take her food now and then, in return for dressing me like a spangled fairy on a daily basis.

koalacat · 09/01/2022 13:03

Imagine if someone started a thread about “Working Class Ugly Clothing” citing Primark or Tesco. That would be very unpleasant indeed wouldn’t it?

Enough4me · 09/01/2022 13:00

I'm going to stop watching this thread. OP - nothing to do with you but the fun element has been killed!

koalacat · 09/01/2022 12:56

If the OP had posted, ‘AIBU to notice a trend towards bland, shapeless clothes,” that would be another matter entirely.

No - this was yet another attempt at a sneering, put-down “middle class” thread. Same as the one the day before (when someone was in about starting their own “Working Class MN.” Same as the one the day before that.... something about “middle class women who choose to but second hand things..”

I don’t even wear these clothes - but I can see it for what it is.

What will it be tomorrow... “Middle Class shopping trolleys?” Hairstyles? Pets?

It’s almost as if somebody is obsessed?

Frenchfurze · 09/01/2022 12:55

@Mankyfruitbowl

Yes, I'm interested in fashion and trends too, but there's definitely a sneering tone in many (not all!) of these posts aimed at the wearers of the clothes and their supposed motivations, and not the clothes themselves.

(I don't even own any Toast, but if I did, I'd be feeling quite attacked!)

I do own Toast and Cos garments, and I don’t feel attacked, I’m just trying to tease out the logic of some posts, especially

(1) the ones who say Toast and Cos wearers are more used to getting compliments despite wearing clothes the same posters view as shapeless and hideous and

(2) those who think that Toast or Cos wearers wear these clothes because they are so convinced of their own goddess-like beauty that the clothes are saying ‘Fuck you, I’m so gorgeous I don’t even have to try, so my sludgy, loose clothes are a kick in the teeth to those of you whose first question is always ‘Is this flattering? Does it make me look pretty?’’