Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two

463 replies

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 22:39

Original thread here.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4446999-To-think-so-many-middle-class-clothes-are-ugly?pg=40

I admit I am hardly a style guru. But when I joined Mumsnet people talked about lots of companies I had never heard of like Toast. So I followed links of clothes posted and looked at the websites mentioned. And was shocked at how ugly so much of the clothing was.
Shapeless grey dresses. Black loose trousers teamed with black tunics which make the model look like she is a member of a cult. Shapeless brown t-shirts.
They are just so ugly. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
SantaClawsServiette · 09/01/2022 22:26

I do agree clothing is in a funny spot at the moment. It reminds me a lot of the clothes in the original Twin Peaks in 1990, and the kinds of things that were popular when I was in high school.

It's not all bad, but some of it is not that easy to wear if you don't have a good sense of how to style them. And some is bad and looks idiotic.

As for the class element, it's not totally far-fetched, there are some items of clothing that seem to be class markers and it's not a new thing. Price point is a significant element maybe?

But I also think age is a huge factor. I looked up one of the brands that someone above recommended, and while I rather liked the punk elements, the cuts would be really unflattering for someone my age, the shoes would ruin my back, and the styles would be inappropriate for my job. Our bodies change as we age and tight low ride (fake) leather pants don't quite cut it as a middle aged woman.

But the droopy baggy clothes are also difficult as they tend to make older women look very dumpy. Often as women age I think more structured clothes are better. And they are think on the ground at the moment without spending on very high end brands.

I would say a word about more modest clothing. I think this is a good thing, and people should not assume that it means suggesting bodies are somehow shaming, It's really quite the opposite, it's about respect for your body and also for the people around you. Most people want to look attractive and put together, but there is really nothing weird about wanting to avoid presenting to the general public in a way that doesn't draw especial attention to our sexiness.

KimikosNightmare · 09/01/2022 21:50

@Cornisharchitect

Well I’m WC and I would love a thread about where to buy clothes other than New Look. We only have New Look and Primark in our local City so it would be nice to know where else to go Smile

I’d like affordable plain and soft fabrics.

I don’t even know what my style is! But I have liked Matalan lately.

I’ve tried buying stuff from Boo Hoo but it was far too long

I thought you said you were an architect?

Apologies, if that's not correct but in what world is an architect "working class" beyond the sense that any- one who is paid for their work is working?

Horological · 09/01/2022 21:45

We will all be older one day and, as you age, your style will change

This is an example of somebody defending an imaginary criticism yet again. My dislike of Cos, Toast and Margaret Howell is nothing whatsoever to do with age. I am nearly 60 myself. I know women my age who wear these kinds of clothes but I am fairly certain it isn't because they have lost confidence. I actually think they feel like they are indulging themselves because of the way these clothes are marketed as being special and exclusive (and of course very expensive). They think it's a treat 'because I'm worth it' kind of thing. Like the art teacher's equivalent of a spa weekend.

borntobequiet · 09/01/2022 21:32

We will all be older one day and, as you age, your style will change

I’m in my late 60s and mine really hasn’t. Neither has my hair, it’s alternately short and long (currently in between) except now it’s grey.

SquirrelG · 09/01/2022 21:20

I said some clothes looked ugly. They do.

In YOUR eyes, that doesn't make them ugly - unless you are in some high position where your job is judging clothing? No, thought not.

Also, although I find the Toast clothes rather expensive and wouldn't spend that much, I do sometimes buy reasonably expensive clothes - but I would rather buy one expensive item that I am going to wear to death than lots of cheap clothes, which won't last, or I will tire of, and which will end up in landfill. BTW - I'm unemployed, whatever "class" that makes me!!!

SquirrelG · 09/01/2022 21:16

There will obviously be older ladies on here who have clothes from that shop. ‘Lighten up’ they are told. Well, maybe they don’t have much confidence for all sorts of reasons. Ageing is hardly a choice either. I can see that. We will all be older one day and, as you age, your style will change. Let’s see what OP is wearing at 60 and how robust she is then to being called ugly or a frump.

I find this rather patronising. I'm 62 and my taste in clothing hasn't changed since I was in my teens - in fact at any stage when 70s clothing is in fashion I'm all in! I certainly haven't lost confidence simply because I am in my 60s, quite the reverse. There is a strange mindset about getting older on MN. I also wear what many on here would call "shapeless" linen dresses - because it is hot at the moment (not in the UK, obviously) and they are far, far cooler to wear than anything else. However, today I am wearing denim shorts and a tee shirt Smile

Horological · 09/01/2022 20:57

I think the OP started the thread to talk about Toast, Cos, Margaret Howell type clothes which are made of sludgy grey linen and worn with clumpy shoes, a scowl, heavy black rimmed glasses and huge necklaces, which is a very specific kind of style and incredibly expensive. Not at all general naice middle class mum clothes like Boden, Joules, Seasalt.

Other people seem to be just posting general chat about where they like to shop and getting indignant and defensive about imaginary criticism.

TheToddlerLife · 09/01/2022 20:40

@Cornisharchitect Try rapanuiclothing.com

Not sure what "class" it falls into but their stuff is simple, lovely soft fabrics and lasts for ages. I'm a big fan!

TheToddlerLife · 09/01/2022 20:38

tps://www.seasaltcornwall.com/ie/trethias-island-aline-cotton-viscose-dress

Plus this one. I'm a similar build and colouring to the woman in the picture.
I wear this dress with black tights, brogue-style ankle boots, a long wool coat and mustard yellow bag. Have had lots of compliments on that outfit.

Someone mentioned Ted Baker and Karen Millen as working class...not sure I agree, I'd say they're MC brands but for very young people - students and young professionals in their 20s. The Ted Baker tote bags were all the rage at my uni.

TheToddlerLife · 09/01/2022 20:26

I kind of agree with the OP, I just can't imagine wearing any of the clothes linked to, I would look ridiculous on my local high street or in Tesco in them. But, taste is very subjective, what is ugly to you might be pretty to someone else.
I don't get the hate for Seasalt, I love their stuff - comfortable, laid-back and pretty, and for someone tall like me, their dresses actually cover my bum and thighs.
I've got these dresses from there and I love them:

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two
Cornisharchitect · 09/01/2022 20:25

Well I’m WC and I would love a thread about where to buy clothes other than New Look. We only have New Look and Primark in our local City so it would be nice to know where else to go Smile

I’d like affordable plain and soft fabrics.

I don’t even know what my style is! But I have liked Matalan lately.

I’ve tried buying stuff from Boo Hoo but it was far too long

koalacat · 09/01/2022 20:25

Yes class is a thing. My point is, there are far more constructive ways of framing the debate. It’s obvious when there is an undertone of spite / bitterness and it’s disingenuous (when this is pointed out) to then try and pretend you were just trying to stimulate an objective debate. Come on. Bollocks to that, frankly.

There will obviously be older ladies on here who have clothes from that shop. ‘Lighten up’ they are told. Well, maybe they don’t have much confidence for all sorts of reasons. Ageing is hardly a choice either. I can see that. We will all be older one day and, as you age, your style will change. Let’s see what OP is wearing at 60 and how robust she is then to being called ugly or a frump.

It’s ageism and yes, calling them frumpy or sexless or whatever is as nasty as mocking a middle aged woman in a Primark lycra top for her bingo wings or for being a chav. None of these slurs are pleasant or, indeed necessary, either way.

TrickyD · 09/01/2022 20:15

I used to love East. I could always find beautiful cotton summer dresses and winter party outfits, lovely velvet jackets and skirts. A lot of their clothes had a boho look to them, they used a lot of Indian patterns.

Sadly it went bust, the shops closed, now everything is online and it is all baggy and droopy though still using attractively patterned fabrics.

But try as I might I cannot convince myself any of it would make me look or feel good. And the prices have shot up.

Luckily, the old stuff was such excellent quality that it has lasted and still fine for parties, holidays or wearing in summer. I have a lovely silk dress and scarf that I bought in 2002 and it is still perfect for hot evenings plus lots of other items bought over the years.

Has anyone mentioned Babipur? As well as crazily overpriced wooden toys they have children’s and adults’ clothes with colourful patterns. Kids’ stuff fair enough, but who wants to be decked out in radishes? It is MC and cultish; if you spot a stranger wearing it, you have to call out “Wankel”, lots of posts on their FB page reporting such sightings.

And the unflattering women’s styles are godawful and would be, even without any vegetables.

Horological · 09/01/2022 20:02

@koalacat
Imagine if someone started a thread about “Working Class Ugly Clothing” citing Primark or Tesco. That would be very unpleasant indeed wouldn’t it?

Yes @Koalacat it would be unpleasant. But totally different to this thread. If you don't have much money you don't have much choice about where you shop and it really would be awful to laugh at that. However, people who shop at Toast or Cos have plenty of money and they choose to buy ugly clothes which look like they have been made out of fabric from a Victorian tip by somebody in their first sewing class. That's the mystery.

It's the difference between punching up and punching down.

OP I totally get what you are getting at and this thread could be great and light hearted but it's crammed full of people who don't get the point and keep going off on tangents about themselves.

Also I cannot stand it when people say they don't see class, or what is class? or we really shouldn't talk about class these days. Absolute bollocks. Class is great big fact of life. Even more so now that ever before. That does not mean I approve of it, just that it is there, staring us in the face with every choice every single one of us makes every day. It is the food we eat, the names we give our children, the clothes we wear, the TV programmes we watch etc. etc. etc. Though, by the way not necessarily to do with income at all.

Cue hundreds of posters claiming that they are above class or that nobody would be able to guess what class they are. Bollocks.

KimikosNightmare · 09/01/2022 19:52

What the OP said in the opening post was

So I followed links of clothes posted and looked at the websites mentioned. And was shocked at how ugly so much of the clothing was

And then repeated"ugly" in almost every post, occasionally substituting, shapeless,
ridiculous, frumpy.

It's perfectly fine for the OP to think these clothes she doesn't like are ugly. We probably all think that about things we don't like.

But the thread was not about "laughing at ourselves" . It was about laughing at these women with so much money and going on and on about why don't they buy something nice. The iteration of why can't they see these clothes are ugly, why don't they buy something nice is the point where it moved on to just getting at /criticising other women.

The subject of tribes, what tribe one is in and how one signifies which tribe is a very interesting topic and that was covered in the thread.

UserBot989 · 09/01/2022 19:48

@mathanxiety

It is incredibly aspirational.

There is a whole tribe out there aspiring to look like that.

repeller.com/menocore-fashion-trend/

Welcome to menocore.

Ha! funny.
Wilkolampshade · 09/01/2022 19:43

I think it's a fairly generally accepted fact that people have differing tastes. I really don't think you can claim absolutes for either 'pretty' things or 'ugly' things, beauty being in 'the eye of the beholder' as we used to say.
Personally, I don't see any ugliness AT ALL in clothes like these. I like their simple lines and lack of unnecessary detailing. In fact I was just pondering what clothes I would call 'ugly' and have drawn a bit of a blank realising it's not a term I would find easy to use in this context. I might think things are too fussy, or too strappy maybe? But they're not really ugly, just (definitely) not for me, I'd look ridiculous in them.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/01/2022 19:12

I don’t think Cos and Toast are that similar.

Toast is very fond of checks and brown.

Cos is a bit starker, but users more colours.

I wear it because it’s minimalist. Not because it’s middle class!

I hate fussy stuff.

RoyalFamilyFan · 09/01/2022 18:57

No not all of Toast. I said some clothes looked ugly. They do.

OP posts:
SquirrelG · 09/01/2022 18:54

OP is not personally attacking any women, she is noting styles that she is not keen on and finds amusing and is wondering what others think.

OP said in her original post that the clothing on Toast and similar clothing websites was "ugly" - in fact that word was used twice, and again in the title- so where are you getting "amusing" from? She is attacking women who dress in a certain way, simply because she doesn't like it.

mathanxiety · 09/01/2022 18:50

It is incredibly aspirational.

There is a whole tribe out there aspiring to look like that.

repeller.com/menocore-fashion-trend/

Welcome to menocore.

SquirrelG · 09/01/2022 18:45

I've just had a good look at the Toast website. Most of the clothes look perfectly nice to me (although I wouldn't pay that much for clothing), and it's making me wonder what type of clothes those who are the most vocal in their criticism are wearing. We all have our own ideas on what we like, and some of us like loose fitting natural fabric clothing - especially those who live in places where it gets hot - and wouldn't be seen dead in tight fitting synthetics, yet we don't feel the need to start threads about how ugly those clothes are. Live and let live I say - I don't judge other people's clothing choices.

SouthernFashionista · 09/01/2022 18:06

So many hideous outfits posted. The original Toast dress that sparked the whole chat - why can’t they use an attractive model? I’m not being disingenuous, why have someone who looks they’re about to head off to a funeral having spent the last month in a monastery wearing sackcloth and ashes. Grim and not at all aspirational.

Nopeihavenoidea · 09/01/2022 17:55

I was a teenage in the 80s - definitely WC so I am struggling to love those baggy sack dresses. No longer have the figure for body con either.

Made worse by going back to work after a break and while I have money I don’t want to spend it on things that make me look awful!

Have bought things from Massimmo Dutti, Brora and All Saints recently but struggling to find nice work clothes for an office that look professional and are natural fabrics.

HaveringWavering · 09/01/2022 17:55

@mathanxiety

It means WTF.
Shit. I ask that question when I like the style and want to buy something similar. I had no idea it could be misconstrued as an insult!