Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Middle Class Ugly Clothing part two

463 replies

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 22:39

Original thread here.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4446999-To-think-so-many-middle-class-clothes-are-ugly?pg=40

I admit I am hardly a style guru. But when I joined Mumsnet people talked about lots of companies I had never heard of like Toast. So I followed links of clothes posted and looked at the websites mentioned. And was shocked at how ugly so much of the clothing was.
Shapeless grey dresses. Black loose trousers teamed with black tunics which make the model look like she is a member of a cult. Shapeless brown t-shirts.
They are just so ugly. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
mathanxiety · 08/01/2022 02:52

Apologies if you didn't actually use the word fugly, but your general tone was very disparaging and your thread is called "Ugly Clothing" "Ugly" of course as determined by you.

A lot of other people agreed with the OP, @KimikosNightmare.

If you're making an argument for respecting other people's taste, then you have to allow use of the word Ugly by people who think some clothes are ugly.

RobertaFirmino · 08/01/2022 02:52

What you should be alarmed by, is why they have been making impractical clothing for girls and women, with cut outs all over, to reveal sex organs

Really? Clothes for women that 'reveal sex organs'? Where on earth are you shopping?

SquirrelG · 08/01/2022 02:24

I think the rumblings about modest dressing are a bit exaggerated. The last couple of years of Amish and prairie dresses remind me of the sort of hippy, dippy, long skirts, demure little cheese cloth blouses, and droopy Indian dresses and skirts I wore as a teenager late 70s/ early 80s, mixed in with Laura Ashley milkmaid/ Tess of the Durbervilles, followed on by Monsoon.

I was just about to say this (and I don't recall anyone wearing cheesecloth tops tied at the midriff either).

When I was in high school one minute we were rolling over the tops of our skirts to make them shorter, the next we were wearing our skirts mid-calf length. It hardly meant we had suddenly become "modest", it's just fashion.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 02:22

@KimikosNightmare well my SIL is on an unpaid internship now and was on UC for ages (during the pandemic) so would not have a big budget.my MIL doesn't earn much either but bought her home in 1997 so its easier for her to budget. some people on another thread told me that spending £35 to £40 on a dress is extortionate and absolutely the preserve of the middle class and women on lower incomes would not do that etc etc. I said that I buy all my clothes on sale but someone also told me that she would never go into an expensive shop but would prefer to buy her clothes from supermarket. my MIL and SIL are very thrifty, never had credit card debt but they don't buy their clothes from the cheapest place they can find. They also own fewer clothes. My MIL buys cheap t shirts from ASDA but she wouldn't think £35 is too much to spend on a dress; she used to like this brand called East and also Gudrun Sjoden, and my SIL also likes this brand called IRIS (which has a shop in hampstead); and they only buy on sale. It might seem strange to someone who isn't in their circle; why they buy moderately priced clothes when they can just get a dress or t shirt from ASDA (and they probably would if they found a suitable one); but my SIL once told me ''modest clothing costs more as there is more material' and they also need special clothes for shabbat etc. Its not just them (I actually think my MIL and SIL are relatively casual dressers compared to others), we just met up with my DH's secondary school friend for dinner and he is far from rich (lives with his grandma in a 1 bed flat while retraining) but he wore a suit to meet us at a falafel bar. He wears a suit wherever he goes, it must be more expensive than wearing t shirt and jeans. But poor religious Jewish people just accept the cost, i suppose, and cut back in other ways.

my SIL and MIL actually don't like work clothes as they don't work in a traditional office. they like kinda hippie flowing modest clothing..

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 02:11

@PattyPan

My wedding dress is similar to this one www.wed2b.com/dollie but the lace covers the shoulders and goes up so it’s more of a boat neckline. Modest but not full length, at 5’3 I don’t really suit maxi dresses Grin
That is a beautiful dress.
KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 02:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 02:07

This is some one's Pinterest of 1970s boho. Lots of long dresses and long sleeves. They were not described as "modest" in the 1970s.

The first 2 pictures and then some later ones are of Charlotte Martin who had been a girlfriend of Eric Clapton but when this was shot was with Jimmy Page.

Her dresses and pictures are beautiful.

www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/183732859768105916/

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 02:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 02:00

[quote onlychildhamster]@KimikosNightmare you probably had a bigger budget than me in my uni days. In my uni days, I wouldn't spend more than £15 on a dress. My budget is now 2.5-3 X that and it is much easier. When I first met my MIL and SIL, they had a bigger budget than me and still struggled; it's lots easier now. My MIL is the most strict and wears long sleeved t shirts and long ankle length skirts cos I think it's that hard to find dresses that fulfil her strict standards (and she doesn't like black, only wears natural colours). I know a lot of orthodox Jewish women had such a problem that a lot of Jewish shops sell an item known as a 'shell'- t-shirt worn under a dress. For formal wear, its still hard, I spent hours perusing pages for evening dresses with sleeves that appeal to me. I have one from Debenhams that I bought for SIL's wedding, it took me a few months to find it. My MIL told me her really religious mates go to a tailor to get sleeves added etc that is a pretty expensive option! But if you watched unorthodox on Netflix or shtisel, you will have an idea- my MIL follows many of the same standards on dressing (though she doesn't cover her hair in the house and she wears trousers when exercising).[/quote]
That's really interesting.

I didn't have huge budget at university. I could afford Wallis at a pinch but I've honestly never had a problem finding long sleeved clothes - whether dresses, shirts, blouses or t- shirts. I hated my hairy arms so preferred sleeves ( the penny finally dropped at age 30 that you can remove arm hair)

When I first started working in 1981 I had long sleeved work dresses from Wallis. I fondly remember a black and white spotted one with pleats and a pussy cat bow which is very similar to dresses Allessandra Rich now charges £1000s for her.

Your sister- in- law would probably have had the budget for Jaeger or Austin Reed? I had long sleeved tailored work dresses from them and Laura Ashley. They probably wouldn't have met the ankle length requirement for your mil.

So far as "modest" Racing Green used to have a very Toast vibe in the 1990s. The current iteration of Racing Green bears no resemblance to it. I had a lovely button through, full skirted, almost ankle length soft dark indigo denim dress from them. It was pure Toast.

The "no black" ankle length skirt would be difficult. Black and ankle length wouldn't be difficult- I had several Victorian riding habit skirts in but any other colour wouldn't have been mainstream.

unwicked · 08/01/2022 01:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

unwicked · 08/01/2022 01:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

PattyPan · 08/01/2022 01:44

My wedding dress is similar to this one www.wed2b.com/dollie but the lace covers the shoulders and goes up so it’s more of a boat neckline. Modest but not full length, at 5’3 I don’t really suit maxi dresses Grin

PattyPan · 08/01/2022 01:39

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@PattyPan I think on an individual basis there is nothing wrong with dressing modestly. I think on a society level if this is expected of women then that is wrong.[/quote]
I haven’t noticed that happening personally. Particularly fast fashion places like PLT, Boohoo, Missguided etc are still providing plenty of revealing clothing for those who want that, there are just more accessible alternatives now I think. The only thing I suppose is possibly skinny jeans being ‘out’ in favour of baggier ones but I haven’t seen that linked to modesty.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 01:28

@onlychildhamster yes you are right. No sleeves, but still pretty modest really.

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 01:25

@RoyalFamilyFan
www.wed2b.com/rosalee
Always thought this was the popular look..plenty do have see through mesh sleeves which aren't really sleeves in my book...

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 01:18

@KimikosNightmare you probably had a bigger budget than me in my uni days. In my uni days, I wouldn't spend more than £15 on a dress. My budget is now 2.5-3 X that and it is much easier. When I first met my MIL and SIL, they had a bigger budget than me and still struggled; it's lots easier now. My MIL is the most strict and wears long sleeved t shirts and long ankle length skirts cos I think it's that hard to find dresses that fulfil her strict standards (and she doesn't like black, only wears natural colours). I know a lot of orthodox Jewish women had such a problem that a lot of Jewish shops sell an item known as a 'shell'- t-shirt worn under a dress. For formal wear, its still hard, I spent hours perusing pages for evening dresses with sleeves that appeal to me. I have one from Debenhams that I bought for SIL's wedding, it took me a few months to find it. My MIL told me her really religious mates go to a tailor to get sleeves added etc that is a pretty expensive option! But if you watched unorthodox on Netflix or shtisel, you will have an idea- my MIL follows many of the same standards on dressing (though she doesn't cover her hair in the house and she wears trousers when exercising).

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 01:13

[quote SpiderMoniker]I'd forgotten about Jigsaw as it closed down in our city last year, but still seems to be thriving in smaller market towns. I ended up buying this jacket in Lewes last month and it is THE loveliest jacket I've owned in years - I get asked about it a lot!

www.jigsaw-online.com/products/eden-eco-down-puffer-navy[/quote]
There's still one in my city. I hope it's thriving. It's not somewhere I shop very often - sort of forget it's there. Same with Whistles and LK Bennnet but it would be a shame if it and Whistles and LKB disappeared off the high street.

Skullycup45 · 08/01/2022 01:12

I have to admit I've never noticed a huge issue with cleavage as a short person. I have short legs and a seemingly normal sized body (I can generally get away with regular tops and roll the sleeves up). I also don't have a large bust. Perhaps this is why. I also generally prefer a round or crew neck and always hated v necks.

I wonder if perhaps the shift towards shapeless and modest clothing is a reflection of women's changing attitudes to growing tired of being judged for their shape and appearance.

I have to admit with WFH since covid, I have embraced the jeans and jumper look in favour of dresses and heels.

SpiderMoniker · 08/01/2022 01:06

I'd forgotten about Jigsaw as it closed down in our city last year, but still seems to be thriving in smaller market towns. I ended up buying this jacket in Lewes last month and it is THE loveliest jacket I've owned in years - I get asked about it a lot!

www.jigsaw-online.com/products/eden-eco-down-puffer-navy

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 01:02

OP

People talk about how women these days are not frumpy like older women used to be in the past. I laugh at that because my 90 year old gran would have rejected this dress as too frumpy

Posted by you on the other thread.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 00:59

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@KimikosNightmare stop lying. Seriously you are out of order. I have never said any clothing was only for grannies. I would never use ageism like that. Never. I am quite angry now at your repeated lying about me.[/quote]
You started a thread to call out other women's clothes as ugly.

KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 00:57

@RoyalFamilyFan

There was a time when it was hard to buy dresses with more than cap sleeves from mainstream shops. I know because I bought the ones that did have sleeves. Wedding dresses though have always tended to be more modest except for a few years in the 1960s. But weddings have generally promoted a more virginal bride or more latterly a princess look.
When was that? I can't think of any time in my adult lifetime that was the case. And as I stopped wearing jeans and trousers in 1990 dresses were my go to.
RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 00:57

@KimikosNightmare stop lying. Seriously you are out of order. I have never said any clothing was only for grannies. I would never use ageism like that. Never. I am quite angry now at your repeated lying about me.

OP posts:
KimikosNightmare · 08/01/2022 00:55

[quote RoyalFamilyFan]@KimikosNightmare I never once used the word fugly or said any clothes were for grannies.
Neither of those are things I would ever say.
For some reason you have decided I am someone you are going to insult and be nasty to. I know that says far more about you than me.[/quote]
We shall have to agree to disagree on your tone. You were extremely disparaging about styles you didn't like. I wasn't the only poster who called you out on it.

Apologies if you didn't actually use the word fugly, but your general tone was very disparaging and your thread is called "Ugly Clothing" "Ugly" of course as determined by you.

RoyalFamilyFan · 08/01/2022 00:55

There was a time when it was hard to buy dresses with more than cap sleeves from mainstream shops. I know because I bought the ones that did have sleeves.
Wedding dresses though have always tended to be more modest except for a few years in the 1960s. But weddings have generally promoted a more virginal bride or more latterly a princess look.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread