Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop BF to TTC?

85 replies

cheezandbeanz · 07/01/2022 18:13

I'm in a real pickle here.

My baby has just turned one and still feeding from me a lot. I have always fed on demand and am still doing so. I am his comfort, his milk source, and safe to say he loves a boob. He feeds round the clock, and is starting to eat more solids but I'd say is still taking 70% of his calories through my breast milk.

My periods haven't returned, but I am really keen to TTC #2. We don't have age on our side (I'm just turned 35), it may take a while to conceive (though it didn't first time around luckily) and I really would like our babies close together.

I don't know whether it would be awful to stop breastfeeding my son in order to TTC his sibling or whether I just wait and he may self wean? I just can't see it happening any time soon. I've had no hint of a period as yet :-(

It feels I'm doing my son a disservice by taking his boobs away when he isn't ready. But I know a year is a great amount of time and he's had a brilliant start.

I'm just really torn!

Any experience/advice welcome!

OP posts:
5keletor · 07/01/2022 21:46

I became pregnant while still breastfeeding and not trying (it was a happy accident, we had initially planned for a bigger age gap), my period hadn't returned and baby was still feeding a lot (we have a very small gap!). Maybe my period would have come soon had I not been pregnant, to be honest I didn't think it was at all likely, but it is possible while breastfeeding. I continued to feed my now toddler throughout pregnancy and for a few months after baby arrived, until he decided to stop.

UndertheCedartree · 07/01/2022 21:43

I mean obviously it is a great achievement but the WHO recommend breast feeding for at least 2 years so personally, I feel it is a little early. Looking back it would have definitely felt very premature for me to take the breast away from my DC at that age. It is a wonderful resource for an upset toddler! However, ultimately it is your choice. I think my periods came back when my DC were between 18 months - 2 years - I was still breastfeeding.

pompomsgalore · 07/01/2022 21:38

OP I would work on the 10pm side of things. That's when you won't be at your tiredest and most vulnerable to giving in to feeding.

Have you tried white noise? Download an app and when he wakes at 10 try a quick cuddle so he knows you've attended to him. But tell him it's nighttime and he goes in his cot now. Pat Pat Pat on his back like a mad woman and blare out the white noise. That's what worked for us and might be crap for you but hopefully you'll find it works somehow.

If you feel bad about the crying remember you are just teaching him about how nighttime's are. You aren't leaving him cry you are going to him but guiding him about the nighttime etiquette. Be consistent.

Opus17 · 07/01/2022 21:10

You don't have to stop completely. I'm still feeding my 18 month old and my period returned when he was 14 months as he had stopped a few feeds during the day ( we were down to two).

All you need to do is cut out some feeds. You could start by cutting out one at a time so it's not too much for him. And hopefully this'll kick start your period again

BogRollBOGOF · 07/01/2022 21:01

I didn't have periods until 2m after my final feed with both babies.

DS1 was down to a morning/ bedtime feed at 13m when I stopped for TTC.

DS2 was more motivated by milk (and solids) but at 18m for my sanity I went cold turkey on night feeds and at 20m had had enough all together. I'd BFed in every year from 2010 to 2015 by that point and wanted a break from pregnancy/ lactating. I actually had milk for a good while after stopping with them both too.

DS2 was worth stopping for!

89redballoons · 07/01/2022 20:58

For me, my periods only came back when I stopped breastfeeding completely. I was down to one feed per day and still nothing.

Then when DS was 16 months, we weaned completely. I got my first period since his birth a week later, had 2 more cycles and then conceived the cycle after that.

So it's different for everyone and my experience doesn't seem to be exactly the norm, but it does happen.

As for weaning, I found it fairly easy as by 15/16 months my DS had pretty good verbal understanding, but again everyone is different. Basically I gradually replaced feeds with either a drink of water or cow's milk, and/or a cuddle or a plat, depending on if I thought he was asking because of hunger or thirst or boredom or the need for closeness. I'd just say, no milk now, we'll have milk in the morning.

Then when the morning feed was the only one left and had been for a week or so I got up as soon as DS woke, brought him downstairs and promptly got breakfast ready and played with him instead of feeding. It was really less painful for either of us than I'd been expecting.

milkieway · 07/01/2022 20:55

You don't have to stop breastfeeding you could just try reducing some feeds and see how you go, most women their periods return to normal 9-18 months post partum irregardless of how much the baby feeds so you're feeding

www.llli.org/breastfeeding-info/fertility/

Hyppogriff · 07/01/2022 20:51

Just phase it out one feed at a time and dial up the food and sippy milk - he doesn’t need bf anymore (I am not an anti BF I BF both of mine and I get it ! )
WHO guidelines are written with the developing world in mind where water and other food sources are is not reliable

M1RR0R · 07/01/2022 20:45

My periods came back at 14 months even with feeding round the clock. Maybe give it a couple more months?
You sound like you love breastfeeding, I do too, I love the connection. 35 isn’t ‘old’ & your periods will come back soon (I don’t know of any that have stopped for years!)

JustWonderingIfYou · 07/01/2022 20:40

Night weaning should give you back your periods

BingBongBoo86 · 07/01/2022 20:38

My periods came back at 14 months pp, I was still breastfeeding A LOT, day and night. I totally get being emotionally attached to BF, it’s been such a great experience.

Now pregnant, at 36 years old and still breastfeeding DD1.

I would wait a bit longer to see if your periods come back and then track ovulation. There’s a great Facebook site with called ‘Breastfeeding older babies and beyond’, there’s lots of advice to be had, I highly recommend it. Good luck!

yoyo1234 · 07/01/2022 20:38

I think lots of people become pregnant when breastfeeding and I think I would personally keep it up until he wanted to stop (and it's clear you enjoy your time feeding himSmile). WHO I think recommends 2 years (now slightly more I think- just check online!).

superhappymagicforest · 07/01/2022 20:29

I had to wean completely for my periods to come back. DS was 27 months and I’d tried everything including cutting down to one feed. My periods came back two months later and I got pregnant the month after. It was a really really tough decision and I feel so guilty that I’m still feeding his sister at 3.5. Personally I’d maybe leave it a bit longer as one is so tiny and there’s still a good chance your periods will come back without weaning soon - I think I was quite unusual. Good luck with whatever you decide xxx

pollyparrot45 · 07/01/2022 20:27

I'm breastfeeding & pregnant with a second.

You could reduce feeds if you want but it won't necessarily make your periods resume even if you stop.

It's quite rare to still not have your period but it won't be forever.

DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes · 07/01/2022 20:25

I got pregnant with DD2 whilst still breastfeeding but I had cut it down over a period of about four or five months and got my period back. At one DD1 was like your son sounds, so I started to cut it back to get my menstrual cycle going again. I still fed on demand at night but cut it out apart from before naps in the day. In reality this meant her Dad dealing with her more than me to start with… we started it over a holiday period and I spent the first few days just “disappeared” a lot so that she had no choice to get back and eat food instead. It worked, period came back around six weeks later.

Darkstar4855 · 07/01/2022 20:22

My period came back at 10m when I went back to work three days a week and was going long periods of the day without feeding. I was still feeding 3-4x at night and fed until he was 2.5.

If you want to carry on night feeding then why not try reducing daytime feeds instead? It’s actually easier because there’s more to distract them in the day and it’s simpler to give an alternative. You could try expressed breast milk or formula in a sippy cup during the day and have plenty of fun distractions on hand (let’s look at this book together, let’s go to the park). They still get that closeness and comfort at night when they most need it.

FortniteBoysMum · 07/01/2022 20:14

You say feeds are making up around 70% of his intake. If you cut the feeds he will up the solids to make up the difference.

Slimemonster · 07/01/2022 20:07

I'd continue to feed personally.
I eventually fell pregnant when dd was 2y2m then fed through pregnancy and then tandem fed too - such an experience!
Xxx

LuckyWithMyLot · 07/01/2022 19:57

I BF on demand and DS wants to feed round the clock, all times day and night!
Despite this, periods came back at 18 months and then we started TTC. I had a short luteal phase (initially 7 or 8 days) but this naturally lengthened each month by a day. Fell pregnant on my 5th cycle. Oh and DS still feeds 4 or 5 times in 24 hours.

I did read it can help to eat plenty so you're not in a calorie deficit and to try and have one long period in 24 hours when you don't feed. For us, this was 7pm to 5am.

lochmaree · 07/01/2022 19:51

also in reply to pp, I am also cosleeping with my first. we intend on setting up another bedroom with double floor bed so that we have the flexibility to change things/him to sleep on his own or with his dad, but right now I have no desire to.

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 19:51

He’s probably small because he’s filling up on milk and not taking enough solids.

lochmaree · 07/01/2022 19:49

my periods came back at 12/13m pp while breastfeeding, I didnt stop bc but we weren't ttc at that point, but then did from I think about September (~20m pp) and that worked. currently 15 weeks pregnant and bf my 2 yo.

Emma Pickett on Instagram has some useful advice on weaning, the bf relationship for both of you, pregnancy and bf, etc. lots of really useful info.

thebigpurpleone · 07/01/2022 19:44

I personally cannot think of anything worse but we are all different.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 07/01/2022 19:34

Honestly it just sounds so difficult to be pregnant and Co sleeping with the first

Everyone is different but for me, even with bad morning sickness, it was not. It’s not a “definitely have to stop”. OP should play it by ear

Esssa · 07/01/2022 19:31

You could temporarily (or permanently) night wean as these are the feeds to drop to more likely kick start your cycle. 12 months is the minimum age to drop breast milk or formula but it is recommended to feed to 2 years or longer if desired. I'm about to hit this issue soon but not from a cycle angle. That returned at 6 months. My issue is whether I want to risk drying up before she's ready to wean and whether I'll want to feed while pregnant. Also have the co-sleeping to sort as I'm not sure I fancy trying to keep a newborn and a toddler safe in bed with me. Good luck. It's a difficult decision to make.