Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this card is grim and not appropriate in a shop where children can see it?

262 replies

Glassisalwaysgreener · 07/01/2022 18:08

Just that really.

Went into Scribbler to get a birthday card DS10 was with me and saw this. I thought it was grim and shouldn’t be on view in a high street shop where children can see it.

www.scribbler.com/Cards/Birthday-Bum-Sex-BC1331/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 14:05

@MabelsApron

It’s a bit off to assume that people without kids don’t agree with you because they’re “me myself and I”. We have lives like you and they may include other people’s children, even. We’re perfectly capable of seeing things through other lenses, and of having empathy for issues that affect children. We just don’t agree that horror displays in shops, or cards in a store whose selling point is rude cards, is tantamount to the breaking of children’s innocence.

If anything I think it’s the other way around - parents are more emotive about things that might upset children, and tend to exaggerate their effect. There was a thread the other week where OP described an advert as including someone’s face being ripped off - turned out it was nothing of the sort.

I do agree that sexualisation as advertising is a problem (I’ve seen babygroes with Ladies Man on them and I think that’s awful) but Halloween displays and rude cards are part of life, and in this case the rude card was in a shop for rude cards. I think demanding that such things not exist (as I assumed you were, having complained to the shopkeeper re: the display) is a bit much.

Yes you can see through lenses and have empathy for children. It is entirely different when you become a parent and are suddenly responsible for your own child’s welfare 24/7 and love them more than you could possibly have imagined. You have protective instincts you never knew were there, there is no lense, just the reality of being responsible for their safety and welfare every single time you step out of the door and it is a dangerous and unsympathetic world out there (and indoors too - you’re never off duty really, not with small children). It is a very different perspective when you are an independent adult, you can walk away from distasteful or disturbing stuff and it will not impact you the way it would a child.
TequilaBlaze · 08/01/2022 13:49

OMG, I went into a restaurant where they were serving steak and wine. Don't they know my baby can't have steak and wine?! I'm going to make a complaint, if something isn't suitable for my child it shouldn't be available for consumption 🙄

betwixtlives · 08/01/2022 13:41

@dworky

People claiming 'parenting fail' are totally wrong. Unless Scribbler have a notice at the entrance stating "Not suitable for children", how would customers know? in fact, it would be very simple & inexpensive for them to implement but, of course, they won't because they don't want customers choosing to shop elsewhere. They want to stock adult stuff but refuse to take any responsibility for it. Stop making excuses for shitty, irresponsible retailers & demand they do better.
They literally do have a sign warning parents on the door. The one near me anyway
MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 13:34

Ironically Ann Summers is probably a shop contributing to the existence of children…

phoenixrosehere · 08/01/2022 13:20

I had the same situation happen in Anne Summers, they had d**os just out on display! My poor ds didn't know where to look! It sparked some very uncomfortable conversations at home.

These shops need to seriously have a think about the children. Disgusting.*

Sarcasm?

BiscuitLover3678 · 08/01/2022 13:16

I don’t get why it’s not entirely what you expected. As in you didn’t expect to do it or it wasn’t how you thought it should be? Bit dodgy. You wouldn’t say that about piv sex without looking a bit creepy.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 08/01/2022 13:16

YANBU at all OP!

I had the same situation happen in Anne Summers, they had d*os just out on display! My poor ds didn't know where to look! It sparked some very uncomfortable conversations at home.

These shops need to seriously have a think about the children. Disgusting.

Suzanne999 · 08/01/2022 13:08

Well that’s a store to avoid.

MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 13:05

It’s a bit off to assume that people without kids don’t agree with you because they’re “me myself and I”. We have lives like you and they may include other people’s children, even. We’re perfectly capable of seeing things through other lenses, and of having empathy for issues that affect children. We just don’t agree that horror displays in shops, or cards in a store whose selling point is rude cards, is tantamount to the breaking of children’s innocence.

If anything I think it’s the other way around - parents are more emotive about things that might upset children, and tend to exaggerate their effect. There was a thread the other week where OP described an advert as including someone’s face being ripped off - turned out it was nothing of the sort.

I do agree that sexualisation as advertising is a problem (I’ve seen babygroes with Ladies Man on them and I think that’s awful) but Halloween displays and rude cards are part of life, and in this case the rude card was in a shop for rude cards. I think demanding that such things not exist (as I assumed you were, having complained to the shopkeeper re: the display) is a bit much.

nalabae · 08/01/2022 12:54

Ew cringe

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 12:46

Also when I said about shopping in the 90’s I meant shoppy shops, not newsagents (which obviously had those awful lads mags, page 3 etc etc…)

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 12:40

[quote MabelsApron]@Mumtumtastic Expecting shops etc never to have anything which your toddler might deem scary so that she is protected and doesn’t have her innocence “broken” is… a bit much, surely? In my experience of toddlers, they’re capable of finding pretty much anything scary. My sister was scared of moustaches at that age.[/quote]
Not really the point I was trying to make. No a one off would be scary but of course kids are resilient, I meant the breaking of innocence in relation to wholesale sexualisation, and this effect is cumulative (although depending on how graphic the ‘one off’ was, could be enough). I feel like disgusting horror stuff in an otherwise neutral shop, like with overtly sexual products like this card or sex toys in Poundland, crosses a line as to what is acceptable in public spaces.

I’ve noticed an increase in disturbing merch in regular shops, and especially around Halloween year on year becoming more horror show frightening and yes this probably relates to becoming a parent myself, as before when it’s just you, yourself and I you can quite easily dismiss stuff like this. The point is it’s grim and desensitises us culturally as to what is acceptable in our public spaces - things everyone will see, young, old and everything in between (re: horror graphic gruesome or overt sexualisation).

Livpool · 08/01/2022 12:17

It isn't really my type of humour but unlike
a lot of PPs I just move on. Who cares if you find it 'grim' that is their USP and if you don't read a sign on the door advising that is on you.

Since when did 'I don't like it' equal rip up a card in Tesco this must be removed and no one else must like it either

LaBellina · 08/01/2022 12:17

Vile but it’s adult humor in a shop that’s known for it, you can’t censor everything because it might be inappropriate for children. At least parents can choose not to bring their DC in the shop, I find the amount of vile adult stuff that is too easily accessible on the internet a much bigger concern then this tasteless example of adult humor.

MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 12:16

@Mumtumtastic Nobody was there to have seen what you’re talking about but you said the shopkeeper had seen sales increase through using the display so I’m doubtful that it was truly grotesque if I’m honest. Probably unpleasant for a toddler but no, I don’t want to live in a world where anything that a toddler might find scary isn’t permitted.

I agree that sexualisation is an issue (though I’m a child of the 90s and remember seeing FHM, Zoo and Nuts in the shops so it’s not a new thing). But I think there’s a wider balance to be struck and I do worry that we’re under pressure to sanitise everything all the time.

I don’t know why it matters whether or not we have children, either!

LindaEllen · 08/01/2022 12:13

@Etinoxaurus

I ripped a rude card up in Tesco’s once 😬 Scribblers is different though.
Did you really? I hope you paid for it. How fucking ridiculous.
Youdoyoutoday · 08/01/2022 12:00

Lol!! People don't read signs!!

RoomOfRequirement · 08/01/2022 11:48

Oh Grow up some of you! What do you want, a huge security guard yelling not suitable for children and an alarm going off every time an under-18 goes near the doors?

There are signs. If you didn't read them, that's on you. Take some personal responsibility!

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 11:47

The point I was making was that in this regular looking card shop there was some extreme gruesome stuff, I’m not talking cutesy spooky - it was proper grim, Freddy Krueger style graphic. It wasn’t even Halloween where you can expect to see stuff like that about. It was a week before Christmas. It was casually placed next to all the sparkly Christmas stuff. Does that not sit wrong with anyone else??

Are those who say they don’t care maybe not have kids, or have teens and older who wouldn’t be phased? I don’t care what the lot of you say 2-3 year olds should not be subjected to horror film rubbish like that. It’s plain wrong. And if Mary Whitehouse was here and petitioned against it I would happily sign!

And where is the acceptable line as far as sexualisation goes in public spaces? The card the OP wanted to discuss was vile. So describing sex acts on cards is fine as long as there is a tiny warning on the shop front. How about visual depictions? And if that’s fine, well why not go the whole hog and have porno cards, as long as there’s a ‘funny’ message along side them to make them humorous right?

There is no acceptable boundary of common decency anymore. This isn’t great for anyone but is especially toxic for children.

ANameChangeAgain · 08/01/2022 11:43

I used to be angry at seeing page 3 at child eye level or on counter tops in newsagents as these are "family" shops. The place for them (if there was one) was top shelf. I wouldn't buy or appreciate a card like the one in the op, but equally I wouldn't be offended by it in a shop specifically for these types of cards.
Does anyone remember Vickerstaffs? We used to go in there for a giggle in our early teens.

Theblacksheepandme · 08/01/2022 11:42

Down with that sort of thing.

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 08/01/2022 11:34

This card will have me laughing all day! Thanks!

MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 11:12

@Mumtumtastic Expecting shops etc never to have anything which your toddler might deem scary so that she is protected and doesn’t have her innocence “broken” is… a bit much, surely? In my experience of toddlers, they’re capable of finding pretty much anything scary. My sister was scared of moustaches at that age.

melj1213 · 08/01/2022 11:06

[quote saraclara]@melj1213 seriously, you think the average person walking up to that shop will see that sign? Really? You notice small black and white signs right at the bottom of a big storefront window when you're focusing on the heading towards and through the doorway?

If you didn’t see this then that’s your fault not the shop’s fault.

The shop has deliberately put it where customers are unlikely to see it. It's not the customers' fault if they miss it.[/quote]
You asked where the sign was, I pointed it out 🤷‍♀️

I work in a supermarket on the customer service desk - I once had a guy standing at a totally different desk who had a temper tantrum when I told him he was in the wrong place and he said "you should have a sign" .... when I pointed out the lit up 4ft high, unmissable "Customer Service Desk" sign that was literally behind my head he just huffed and said "I didn't read it". So it doesn't matter where you put signage, some people won't read it anyway.

The store is not legally obliged to provide a warning sign, they do so as a courtesy so they can put it wherever they like ... if you wander I to shops without knowing what they sell and looking at the signs in the window then that's on you.

pengu · 08/01/2022 10:41

Loved more magazine