Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this card is grim and not appropriate in a shop where children can see it?

262 replies

Glassisalwaysgreener · 07/01/2022 18:08

Just that really.

Went into Scribbler to get a birthday card DS10 was with me and saw this. I thought it was grim and shouldn’t be on view in a high street shop where children can see it.

www.scribbler.com/Cards/Birthday-Bum-Sex-BC1331/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 19:03

@Mumtumtastic This shouldn’t need clarifying, but suggesting that a shopkeeper shouldn’t remove a display that’s making her money because of your toddler not liking it is entirely different from supporting child exploitation and gun violence. Your conflation of the two is offensive, and trivialises those very serious issues. I genuinely am shocked you can’t see that.

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 18:40

In fairness I have digressed off the main topic of the thread, I am not comparing murder to a card that is ridiculous and not what I said. I originally said about the horror display because it too was in an innocuous card shop and was very out of place amoungst the Christmas and KIDS toys right next to it.

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 18:35

[quote MabelsApron]@Mumtumtastic Comparing a rude card to child sexual exploitation and gun violence is so far beyond offensive that I’m almost staggered that I have to actually point it out.[/quote]
Why? You’re saying it makes money so what’s the problem right?
This is the ultimate conclusion to this kind of reasoning.

Porn is offensive (and imo, inherently wrong and damaging) but very popular and very profitable. So were the other areas I mentioned, this is a well known fact. You are offended by these facts. And to be honest I’m glad you are as these things are wrong, people should get offended and angry about them as they are part of society but it is doing a lot of harm.

XenoBitch · 08/01/2022 18:30

@Mumtumtastic if your toddler is scared of a display then the simply and sensible thing to do is to not go in that shop with your child. The shop owner owes you nothing at all. Their profit (and therefore livelihood) does come above your feelings (and was your toddler actually scared, or are you just pearl clutching and creating a non-issue?).

And comparing a card to children being murdered is such a huge reach, I bet you pulled your shoulder out.

XenoBitch · 08/01/2022 18:25

Well, this thread took a strange turn. It has gone from funny adult cards to murdered children in 10 pages.

MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 18:25

@Mumtumtastic Comparing a rude card to child sexual exploitation and gun violence is so far beyond offensive that I’m almost staggered that I have to actually point it out.

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 18:18

@MabelsApron

To be fair, if the owner sees sales increase because of her display, why should she remove it because of one specific toddler finding it scary? If it’s increasing traffic and sales then I struggle to believe that it’s as awful and off-putting as you suggest.
Ah sorry, I didn’t realise the benchmark for whether something is good is whether it makes nice profit. Thanks for enlightening me, I understand now.

By the same reckoning she should probably stock porn cards in her shop then, I’m sure they’d sell well.

The whole porn industry has multi million $ net worth, must be a great business to be in, sexual exploitation of children brings in a good buck too I understand. Gun shop owners in the US I’ve heard do very well for thenselves, sales through the roof. Never mind about the murdered kids, as long as the money machine keeps a grinding away, all is well.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 08/01/2022 18:08

[quote phoenixrosehere]@OmgIThinkILikeYou

I was hoping it was sarcasm, but you never know on MN. Made me chuckle….

I wonder where for some of these people personal responsibility begins and ends.[/quote]
Haha I'm glad it did, I had a chuckle whilst typing it out Grin

I think if you take a child into an inappropriate shop by mistake, you just walk out once you realise and have a laugh about it with friends later. I do have a child but I don't expect the world to accommodate him.

Sportslady44 · 08/01/2022 16:53

never heard of it but it dosent suprise me.

everything does downhill and gets worse..

MabelsApron · 08/01/2022 16:52

To be fair, if the owner sees sales increase because of her display, why should she remove it because of one specific toddler finding it scary? If it’s increasing traffic and sales then I struggle to believe that it’s as awful and off-putting as you suggest.

EllaVaNight · 08/01/2022 16:36

Do mumsnet posters get paid every time they use the word grim? Or vile for that matter!

EllaVaNight · 08/01/2022 16:35

I ripped a rude card up in Tesco’s once 😬 and youre proud of this/think you're hard/hilarious because....? I can feel the second hand embarrassment.

slashlover · 08/01/2022 15:24

This could not be further from what I’m talking about, natural world stuff is different (and I personally like bugs and encourage our DC to enjoy/ explore them) I’m talking about objects that are deliberately designed to be gruesome put out by adults (in this case the manageress) who couldn’t care less if it scared little kids because it makes good money. There was a life sized zombie hand sticking out of the ground with blood and skin peeling off, just nasty nasty. It makes me sad if this is viewed as normal.

Were your kids scared or did you actually see any scared kids?

Beetlejuice came out when my sister was 4 and we probably rented the video when she was 6, much was made about how she should never see it as it would traumatise her. She ended up getting up early to watch it and absolutely loved it, it's still one of her favourite films.

fitsandgiggles · 08/01/2022 15:19

I want to know what happened with this card that got ripped up!

KiloWhat · 08/01/2022 15:09

Don't take a kid in there. They usually have signs up.

phoenixrosehere · 08/01/2022 15:07

@OmgIThinkILikeYou

I was hoping it was sarcasm, but you never know on MN. Made me chuckle….

I wonder where for some of these people personal responsibility begins and ends.

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 15:01

@slashlover

Yes you can see through lenses and have empathy for children. It is entirely different when you become a parent and are suddenly responsible for your own child’s welfare 24/7 and love them more than you could possibly have imagined. You have protective instincts you never knew were there, there is no lense, just the reality of being responsible for their safety and welfare every single time you step out of the door and it is a dangerous and unsympathetic world out there (and indoors too - you’re never off duty really, not with small children). It is a very different perspective when you are an independent adult, you can walk away from distasteful or disturbing stuff and it will not impact you the way it would a child.

The number of times I have seen a kid interact with a 'scary' thing with interest until a parent freaks out and drags the child away which causes the child to be upset. For example, children and not born with a fear of spiders/bugs/snakes until a parent instils that into them.

This could not be further from what I’m talking about, natural world stuff is different (and I personally like bugs and encourage our DC to enjoy/ explore them) I’m talking about objects that are deliberately designed to be gruesome put out by adults (in this case the manageress) who couldn’t care less if it scared little kids because it makes good money. There was a life sized zombie hand sticking out of the ground with blood and skin peeling off, just nasty nasty. It makes me sad if this is viewed as normal.
OmgIThinkILikeYou · 08/01/2022 14:54

I even blocked out the dildo to be extra pearl clutching. Sometimes I mistake my idiocy for genius hahaha

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 08/01/2022 14:52

@phoenixrosehere

I had the same situation happen in Anne Summers, they had d**os just out on display! My poor ds didn't know where to look! It sparked some very uncomfortable conversations at home.

These shops need to seriously have a think about the children. Disgusting.*

Sarcasm?

I was really hoping it would be obvious 🤣
Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 14:43

@TequilaBlaze

OMG, I went into a restaurant where they were serving steak and wine. Don't they know my baby can't have steak and wine?! I'm going to make a complaint, if something isn't suitable for my child it shouldn't be available for consumption 🙄
You know what TequilaBlaze, I don’t want to see that shite either! And know I’m not alone in this in RL
phoenixrosehere · 08/01/2022 14:33

*It’s a bit off to assume that people without kids don’t agree with you because they’re “me myself and I”. We have lives like you and they may include other people’s children, even. We’re perfectly capable of seeing things through other lenses, and of having empathy for issues that affect children. We just don’t agree that horror displays in shops, or cards in a store whose selling point is rude cards, is tantamount to the breaking of children’s innocence.

If anything I think it’s the other way around - parents are more emotive about things that might upset children, and tend to exaggerate their effect. There was a thread the other week where OP described an advert as including someone’s face being ripped off - turned out it was nothing of the sort.*

I agree with you. I have children and have been to Scribbler several times. The ones I’ve gone to off Oxford Street in London and near Westgate in Oxford have a sign on the window and has been said by many of us who have worked in retail, people fail to read. If people don’t want their children exposed to said card or cards, it is easy to simply not go in there.

Becoming a parent has made me more sensitive to some things but it has also shown me how ridiculous other parents get over minor things that are easily solved.

Mumtumtastic · 08/01/2022 14:21

If I’d taken a picture I would happily have shared what that awful display looked like as it was grossly graphic gruesome, as it was I was happy to leave and yes I have no problem asking the manager to challenge what the purpose of it was, as it was entirely out of keeping with the rest of the shop cards, birthday decorations and Christmas display which was actually geared up for children with soft toys, baby toys and little kid puzzles etc.

My mothers neighbour hung a life sized rotting human corpse from his tree in the front garden at Halloween. Scared the neighbourhood kids and gave my niece nightmares. Everyone I know hated it but I’ll assume within the weird MN microclimate that people won’t see a problem with that either

Tlittle · 08/01/2022 14:19

I remember as a kid my dad reading the sun with good ol' page three.I also went In their room and found some Viz magazines.
Remember walking down great Yarmouth seafront and seeing some dodgy postcards.Martyns shop has always had dildos in next to all the other stuff though it does have a sign.None of it affected me or made me a deranged pervert lol

slashlover · 08/01/2022 14:15

Yes you can see through lenses and have empathy for children. It is entirely different when you become a parent and are suddenly responsible for your own child’s welfare 24/7 and love them more than you could possibly have imagined. You have protective instincts you never knew were there, there is no lense, just the reality of being responsible for their safety and welfare every single time you step out of the door and it is a dangerous and unsympathetic world out there (and indoors too - you’re never off duty really, not with small children). It is a very different perspective when you are an independent adult, you can walk away from distasteful or disturbing stuff and it will not impact you the way it would a child.

The number of times I have seen a kid interact with a 'scary' thing with interest until a parent freaks out and drags the child away which causes the child to be upset. For example, children and not born with a fear of spiders/bugs/snakes until a parent instils that into them.

RoomOfRequirement · 08/01/2022 14:09

This turned into a non-parents are selfish and couldn't POSSIBLY understand later than I expected 🙄