Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 07/01/2022 19:55

BarbaraofSeville. sums it up in a very sensible nut shell

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 07/01/2022 19:49

It's a business if it worked people wouldn't need to go back and they wouldn't make more money

Andoffwego · 07/01/2022 19:48

It’s great at eating a lot of weight off quickly. But it’s terrible long term and doesn’t encourage the sort of attitude to food and eating that could sustain weight loss long term: it doesn’t retrain you to eat smaller portions, it doesn’t encourage eating healthy fats, and it encourages a huge amount of carb consumption. Also lots of shit in there such as processed meals and sweeteners. The only good, sensible bits of the plan are filling one third of your plate with fruit and veg, and I think the healthy extras force you to make sensible choices (e.g. if I want toast for breakfast, it’s not a good idea to have a sandwich for lunch/if I want cheese on my jacket potato, I’d better not have any on my spaghetti bolognaise later).

Hankunamatata · 07/01/2022 19:48

It's actually the only diet plan iv manages to maintain over the years after trying them all. Sensible meals, not cutting out food groups. If you read the whole pack theres loads about mindful eating and eating until you are full.

MiniPumpkin · 07/01/2022 19:45

Oh also will never return as you are forced to attend the first group despite if you are a returning member. So you’ve done it before but they make you sit and listen to all the chat for at least an hour which is a waste of precious time

ChrissyPlummer · 07/01/2022 19:45

@slashlover

And didn’t they once do an about-turn on Porky Lites? Used to be free, but now not, even though the make up of them hasn’t changed. Ridiculous.

They did the same with sweetener, used to be free but now has a syn value. Unless you think no diet every changes?

Of course not, but diets (IME) usually only change when a food changes and has something added/removed. Sweetener (I don’t have it anyway as it’s bloody awful and I get migraines from it) hasn’t changed, so why have SW changed it in their plan?

I lost over 3 stone a few years ago with a PT, who is also a qualified nutritionist. If I went back now, he wouldn’t suddenly tell me to eat those new 100 cal Mars Bars, because his take is that if I want chocolate then eat some and keep to his plan the rest of the day/week. He believed having small amounts each day wasn’t a good idea. If I was struggling and said “I really want a KFC”, he’d suggest I get some wings and wedges from the hot counter in Asda, for example. He described the yoghurts and cake bars as “monster foods” - having a lot of calories for little to no nutritional benefit.

PurpleFlower1983 · 07/01/2022 19:45

I’ve had success with SW over the last year, I joined because I was pregnant and weighed far too much but wanted an approved diet. It worked and over the whole pregnancy I lost 5lbs and gave birth to a healthy 8lb boy. Another stone came off within 2 weeks. I’ve kept it up and the weight is steadily coming off but I’m under no illusion about pasta, potatoes, rice etc. I spent far too many years on My Fitness Pal to know that if I ate all I wanted, or even every day I wouldn’t lose. For me now it’s more about the group incentive and I do think it’s a healthy eating plan.

MiniPumpkin · 07/01/2022 19:43

Yanbu. Done sw a few times, weight falls off when you do it properly. Personally I will only do it if feeling I want a bit of weight off on a hurry, it’s certainly not long term as it goes back on for me

mumofEandE · 07/01/2022 19:42

I have lost 3 stone on WW and put it back on - got to size 10
I have lost 3 stone on SW and put it back on - got to size 10

They are businesses - and I am simply greedy!

BarbaraofSeville · 07/01/2022 19:40

Well no, because you're supposed to eat until you're not hungry. This would be a much smaller amount of food for a 5'4 female compared to a 6'1 male.

If you follow the plan and eat the required proportion of fruit and vegetables, the calorie density of the food is sufficiently low that you're in calorie deficit so lose weight.

BoredZelda · 07/01/2022 19:34

My TDEE as an obese 5ft 4 female will be drastically different to an overweight 6ft1 male, for example.

I assume, like other systems, you’ll be given a different number of points to work within.

StEval · 07/01/2022 19:31

It creates an attitude of good and bad foods which isn't based in nutritional evidence. Eg white pasta (free=good) and avocado (syn=bad). I have a history of eating disorders and find SW immensely triggering for this very reason, no food should have an inherent value judgement placed on it.

I once ate avocado in an office of women all doing SW.
You would imagine I was tucking into a kitten by their reactions Grin
They all did SW so that they could drink prosecco all weekend, the wierd thing was they would all post pics with glass in hand and the others would post really PA comments about empty calories even though they did the same.

JealousOfDDsOodie · 07/01/2022 19:30

I remember people having a discussion in a group I went to once about having rice pudding made with diet cream soda and a muller light - as a breakfast! In what world is that a healthy choice?!

Postdatedpandemic · 07/01/2022 19:27

If you go on a diet just to lose weight you will probably fail.

If you adjust your lifestyle (including your diet) to become healthier you will probably lose some weight as a by-product.

Staryflight445 · 07/01/2022 19:26

You’ve got people eating the weirdest rankest stuff as well as substitutes for ‘bad’ foods.
It’s really not great is it.

Staryflight445 · 07/01/2022 19:25

It works short term but it isn’t sustainable, it’s sad that people constantly go back to it, it’s like this hasn’t clicked for them yet.

HelloBunny · 07/01/2022 19:21

I joined to lose the baby weight, and get back to my usual size. Not to get “skinny” like the diets of my youth (fags‘n’vodka). I’m 45 now.

At th first class the woman
behind me said “you don’t need to lose weight”. I said I’d had a baby. She said “Yes. Nip it in the bud now. Otherwise, it’s a slippery slope...”

What I noticed is that most members are post-menopausal women, who have been members on and off for years. It’s not their first time at the SW rodeo.

What I found helpful was to loosely work within the SW framework. Not o it to the letter. Which my yo-yo dieter mother is doing, with gusto. She always puts the weight back on...

Changemaname1 · 07/01/2022 19:13

It’s like you say OP it’s just a calorie deficit diet. It encourages people to cook from scratch a bit more though and think about what they are eating which I think is good for people who previously have eaten a lot of processed food etc

I was on a slimming world recipe group just to try get some new meal ideas and what struck me though was people seeming to think it was some magic formula like asking questions like if they’d still lose weight if they didn’t eat the allotted amount of veg with a meal or if they would still lose weight if they ate less than their allowed amount of syns for the day Confused so maybe some of the people that do it once that strict guidance is gone they don’t have a clue and just over eat again 🤷🏻‍♀️

Catcrazy83 · 07/01/2022 19:13

Years ago since I tried it so may have changed, but never worked for me. I need portion control, not being told I can eat as many potatoes as I want 🐷

HairyFanjoBanjo · 07/01/2022 19:04

Most people have a body size ‘set point’ or ‘range’. Traditional ‘diets’ just fuck that up, but forcing you into calorie deficit for as long as you can hack it. Once you start eating ‘normally’ again, you regain the weight and usually some more on top.

Psychologically, diets tell your brain there is a famine. So when you stop the ‘famine’ your body tries to regain ASAP and some in case of another famine (diet). It’s actually your body being smart and trying to help you.

We aren’t all meant to be stick thin our whole lives, but societal conditioning means we are all pushed to hate our bodies and aspire to be thin / thinner with whatever the fashionable body type is. This societal conditioning and consumerism makes diet companies a LOT of money.

It’s incredibly depressing.

ExcuseeeeMe · 07/01/2022 19:04

I only know of one person who has kept the weight off for years doing slimming world. She clearly has an eating disorder and signed up her daughter as soon as she was old enough to attend too. When we go out for a meal she talks about syns etc non stop. Constantly trying to convert others to her way of eating it’s like a cult.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 07/01/2022 19:02

YANBU. I lost 3 stone with slimming world. Then plateaued and couldn't lose any more. Then I felt shit and lost interest and put it back on. Slowly. The leaders aren't interested once you stop being 'star of the week'

ginsparkles · 07/01/2022 19:00

It can work. I lost several stone on SW and kept it over for well over a year. I put a small amount back on after I broke my spine and wasn't able to be as active.

The basics of cooking for myself rather than pre prepped food, having a third of my plate filled with vegetables and allowing myself some "treats" each day, have stayed with me. Whilst I am not at my lowest target weight, I am nowhere near my heaviest.

For me it worked. I still use the principles and recipes to help me maintain a balance. And have gone back to those basics to help me loose of the extra lbs lockdown has given me.

PatchworkElmer · 07/01/2022 19:00

Slimming world is awful.

The point is that your diet should be sustainable. Places like SW introduce a new ‘system’, but it’s not sustainable in the long term- so people lose weight, are delighted it works- and then fall off the wagon. When people fall off the wagon, they’re told it’s because they stopped following the plan- the blame is placed on them, and they ultimately sink more money into SW to lose weight again.

It’s a great business model to have a diet that’s not sustainable so that people are highly likely to gain and come back again and again… repeat business!

JaceLancs · 07/01/2022 18:58

I lost a lot of weight on SW without ever eating a muller light or a hi fi bar
I don’t eat pasta anyway as am gluten free and most of the substitutes or awful
The main thing that helped me was meal planning and documenting what I ate which you can do just as easily on my fitness pal
I also benefitted from the accountability and support of other group members - some of whom are now good friends
The only reason I gained some (not all) of the weight was lockdown blues upped my drinking and I stopped doing SW group whilst they were online only
I’m currently trying to lose weight again with a combination of things including only drinking at weekends - more exercise and low fat, low sugar, low carb general healthy eating
I cook most things from scratch due to allergies

Swipe left for the next trending thread