Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
WheresTheLambSauce · 07/01/2022 21:36

Slimming world worked great for me... Until it didn't. I'm definitely an emotional eater, which was fine when I loaded my plate with vegetables, but definitely backfired when I mental health spiraled and I would eat massive bowls of pasta "because its all free food anyway, so who cares"? Not to mention when the SW rep grilled me about my subsequent weight gain in front of the entire group during said mental health spiral, causing me to have a (literal) anxiety attack. Ah, memories Hmm

Looking back now, I think it was really unhealthy for them to celebrate (and surreptitiously encourage) people losing 4+ pounds a week. The bigger the drop on the scales, the better. Even if that meant people's weight fluctuating week by week, rather than a consistent and steady drop. I remember feeling discouraged and guilty if I post "just" one pound.

I feel that weight struggles can be so tied with your mental health that anyone trying to make healthy changes should be able to work through the process individually, with a professional, but I doubt that will be a reality anytime soon.

danadas · 07/01/2022 21:27

Slimming World worked for me to a point but for people like me with a huge amount to lose it did nothing to help with portion control or developing new unhealthy relationships with food. I often thinks it probably works well for people who have been at a healthy weight before or need a bit of steer to lose a few stone but not for people with lifelong weight issues.

Calorie counting based on TDEE has been life changing for me. I have a huge appetite and adjusted calories to reflect my actual size means a slow steady but a lifestyle that I can maintain. I may not be losing a stone in two/three weeks like SW but I hope to have finally cracked the loss.

tectonicplates · 07/01/2022 21:25

They can claim all they like that syns stand for "synergy", but come on, it's obviously designed to sound like sins, i.e. bad things. Surely nobody is fooled by this ridiculous claim.

Freelady · 07/01/2022 21:24

I lost a lot if weight on it. I really dont understand how you can eat so much rice etc or how those snack pot drinks at 240 cals are all unlimited. I mean how can a 240 cal snack,( plenty lower than that) be unlimited??
I have kept of a good proprotion of the weight. I am 5 ft and was 9 stone 3 .. I went down too low on sw to... 7 4.. i now seem to be maintaining at about 8 stone 4 years on.
I really did not like the lìghr yogurts full of rubbish. Nor the low fats. However as I dont eat meat, i chosw sw as couldnt do keto etc !

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 07/01/2022 21:14

It’s basically calorie counting by a different name, but packaged into a nice little bundle with pretty badges and peer pressure.

You can loose weight on it, but if you really look at it it’s not healthy, it’s a very profitable business - the group I attended pushed the bars and meals which were full of crap. That’s why people tend to pile the weight back on, and it suits the business model well as they get returning customers.

JammyRedRooo · 07/01/2022 21:05

I'm on it at the moment, trying to lose the baby weight. It's worked well so far, I'm 16lb down and only have a few more to go until I reach my pre pregnancy weight. I'm not too worried about keeping it off tbh, my goal weight is where I've always hovered around without too much effort but pregnancy made me RAVENOUS.

However I know my body and I know that for me personally, lots of 'free' white carbs like pasta and rice isn't ideal so I wouldn't load up on those deliberately even though its 'on plan'. I try to stick to the main principles of lots of veggies and lean protein.

I enjoy it though. My group is lovely and not at all cult like, and I like the accountability factor. We have had some really tasty meals and our cupboards/fridge are full of lovely fresh ingredients rather than packed with junk.

I have noticed in group though that the plan doesn't really take into account that the more weight you lose, the harder it becomes. So you can get so far while still eating plenty of pasta/rice/potatoes when you have a lot of excess weight but that's not going to fly once you are already at a health weight. That's when low carb comes in I think, at least for me...

Anyway I'm rambling, but I do think YABU as it works to a certain extent but isn't a magic plan you can follow blindly, you need a bit of awareness of how weight loss really works and your own body as well.

StEval · 07/01/2022 20:52

@tabulahrasa

“They came up because all the women on SW kept going on about them. The irony being -Im slim and not on a diet !”

I lost track of how many times they were mentioned reading through this thread - and they come up in every thread like this.

It’s just weird, I kind of assume at this point tbh that no-one actually likes avocado, everyone is just eating it because they think it’s “healthy”, so they get angry when they have to weigh it out because it’s pretty high in fat and calories. that’s my conclusion anyway Grin

I’m not serious, but it does confuse me how often people mention it when talking about slimming world - I wasn’t willingly eating it before slimming world either.

I love avocado on toast, salt and pepper Smile Ive never weighed my food
Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 20:48

I bloody love avocado!

OP posts:
tabulahrasa · 07/01/2022 20:43

“They came up because all the women on SW kept going on about them.
The irony being -Im slim and not on a diet !”

I lost track of how many times they were mentioned reading through this thread - and they come up in every thread like this.

It’s just weird, I kind of assume at this point tbh that no-one actually likes avocado, everyone is just eating it because they think it’s “healthy”, so they get angry when they have to weigh it out because it’s pretty high in fat and calories. that’s my conclusion anyway Grin

I’m not serious, but it does confuse me how often people mention it when talking about slimming world - I wasn’t willingly eating it before slimming world either.

HelloBunny · 07/01/2022 20:42

Same here, Amy2021. I find the basic principle of SW, as an eating plan, to be sound. I don’t do the strict measuring, or buy any of the supermarket things (that I don’t like). I’ve realised now, that I’m older, that I won’t be able to eat whatever the hell anymore... SW is helpful to me right now, hopefully I can take what I need from it, and not attend the classes in future.

StEval · 07/01/2022 20:35

And avacadoes btw, are not in any way demonised (no idea why they keep coming up because they’re not even nice)

They came up because all the women on SW kept going on about them.
The irony being -Im slim and not on a diet !

PeacheyPeach · 07/01/2022 20:31

I've followed the SW plan many times over the years and have always lost weight. I do put the weight back on because I can't be bothered thinking about food/ counting suns/ working out if I've had my healthy extras, I end up getting sick of not being able to order a takeaway without counting it into my weekly food plan!!
But I'm the same whatever diet plan I follow 😅
I actually think I need to have cognitive therapy when it comes to my eating habits as I'm very famine or feast and I really get on my own nerves!!

CockneySpanner · 07/01/2022 20:31

IMO none of them work long term for the majority. I’m late 40s and never used to diet, always stayed a size 12-14 regardless (yeah I know, huge by MN standards 😂), but after I lost my mum (at 41) I was put on sertraline and went up to a size 18. It was after this weight gain that I first tried these diet clubs / plans and I swear all they have done has made my head spin with rules and terminology - syns, points, free food, on plan, low carb, mindful eating, fasting blah. I even tried rebelfit and while they seem to actually care about why people gain weight, I still felt like I was on a plan. These diets work for some for sure but many of them don’t address the reasons why we overeat in the first place. I thought the medication made me gain weight (maybe it did) but I’ve been off it for 3 years now and still no real loss (16-18). I’m not on any plans now and even though I’ve not lost; I’ve not gained, but most of all, it’s so freeing.

TheChosenTwo · 07/01/2022 20:29

I had this very conversation with someone today.
I’ve never joined so I don’t really know anything about it but from what I’ve heard they don’t actually teach you to reduce the amount you eat, they push overly processed food and you pay for someone to tell you that you can eat as much pasta as you like - it’s a cult!!
The minute you stop eating like it the weight will inevitably go back on because you haven’t learnt to train your body into eating ‘properly’.

amy2021 · 07/01/2022 20:26

It encourages members to cook from scratch, massively up their fruit and veg intake and stop having all the crisps and chocolate and biscuits they were having before. They can still have some but in moderation. You don't have to follow the plan blindly to lose weight. If I followed it to the letter I could lose 2-3 lbs a week, I choose to generally eat healthy but also not beat myself up if life gets in the way. I know a McDonald's is not going to throw me off if I track the calories and keep it to under 500 kcal for lunch for example. It's not rocket science but unfortunately too many members stop everything once they've lost the weight, like it's a prize or something.

I've fallen into this trap previously but have now started portion control especially with carbs, having the recommended portion size on the packet and eating from smaller plates. I'm also roughly tracking calories at the same time, keeping meals to 400, 600, 600 and having a couple of low calorie snacks in between.

Courcheval · 07/01/2022 20:25

A neighbour of my DM's lost about 12 stone with SW years ago. I think she was one of the Slimmer of the year winners.

Within 3 years she'd put all the weight back on and more besides.

I was going to give intermittent fasting a go, does anyone know much about it?

Dibble135 · 07/01/2022 20:22

I joined in 2015, lost 2 stone in 6 months and have kept it off ever since.

Got me cooking things like spaghetti Bolognese and curries from scratch instead of using jars like I used to, which is cheaper and tastes better.

I have not paid to attend since I got to target in 2015.

slashlover · 07/01/2022 20:12

You’re right. Any plan telling you that you can eat as many spuds and pasta as you like is destined to fail. I suppose that’s how it’s still such a money maker.

Why do people keep spouting this when it's been refuted by many people who actually know about the plan?

tabulahrasa · 07/01/2022 20:05

Slimming world has the same longterm stats as any other way of losing weight, because there isn’t some magical way of losing weight and keeping it off that works for everyone.

I find it the most sustainable thing I’ve tried, because if you actually like cooking and want to cook from scratch things like calorie counting are a huge pain in the arse.

And avacadoes btw, are not in any way demonised (no idea why they keep coming up because they’re not even nice) it’s a low fat eating plan, they’re high in fat, so if you’re going to eat them then it needs to be in controlled portions - you are in fact encouraged to add things like that back in once you’re trying to maintain. Foods that are in fact healthy are unlikely to trigger the habits you’ve spent ages changing but too high in either fat or sugar to not be controlled.

BoPeeple · 07/01/2022 20:02

SW gives me proper rage. All it does is encourage yo-yo dieting, which buggers up your metabolism and attitude to food FOREVER.

I had a friend who would always make sure she had a poo before ‘weighing in’ so she’d weigh a pound less.

If that doesn’t tell you it’s awful then I don’t know what will.

JustLyra · 07/01/2022 20:01

It's like any diet - it only works long term if you are in the right head space to make proper changes to how you eat. If you go boom and bust with it then your weight will do the same. SW is no different to any other company that profits from weight loss.

6 years ago I was 10 stone heavier than I am now. I've maintained my weight for 2 years now, despite lockdown.

It's not the first time I've done SW, but it's the first time I've done it in a way that wasn't looking for cheats. Where I didn't want to have unlimited pasta or whatever. When I was actually in a place where I could learn what works for me and what doesn't.

A lot also depends on your group leader as well. If they have a bad attitude to it then it really negatively impacts the whole group. Whereas a good leader who has the time to look at your diaries and help find what works for you and what doesn't is great.

Fraternaltwin · 07/01/2022 20:01

@samwitwicky

I joined last night. Had my first meeting. Even while sitting in group I had this sinking feeling of 'this isn't going to work'.

I've had that feeling all day and now I'm thinking of leaving.

I don't know what to do

You’re right. Any plan telling you that you can eat as many spuds and pasta as you like is destined to fail. I suppose that’s how it’s still such a money maker.
ivykaty44 · 07/01/2022 19:58

JurgensCakeBabyJesus i have an aunt who has never stopped going after getting to goal weight, she's never paid a penny for around 6/7 years - goes and gets weighed every week with her mates

I think the actual getting weighed is a big factor in the weight loss and retaining the weight. Stop going and not get weighed and that s when things can not stay on track

slashlover · 07/01/2022 19:56

Of course not, but diets (IME) usually only change when a food changes and has something added/removed. Sweetener (I don’t have it anyway as it’s bloody awful and I get migraines from it) hasn’t changed, so why have SW changed it in their plan?

Because people were trying to game the system and make cakes etc. with loads of it.

RhinestoneCowgirl · 07/01/2022 19:56

My SiL lost three stone before her wedding with SW, put it all back on.

I am suspicious of a programme that refers to 'syns', and also has it's own brand of snack bars.

I eat a diet full of fruit and veg and proper food, but probably more important, have a genetic inheritance that tends to run to tall and lanky...

Swipe left for the next trending thread