Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
tabulahrasa · 08/01/2022 05:13

“It's because Slimming World is the worst one for claiming it's not actually a diet, it's just a lifestyle change and general healthy eating, therefore it's not a diet like all those other groups like WW.”

They all claim that...I’ve tried many ways of losing weight, that’s how they all try and sell themselves.

ivykaty44 · 08/01/2022 04:54

Babyg1995
You only put the weight back on if you go back to eating rubbish and over eating again confused
If we could do that we wouldn't need slimming world to start with.

But surely SW is there giving you the information on the life style change, if you revert back and don’t continue to attend, you can’t blame A duet group for those actions, it’s free to keep attending whilst within your goal weight

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 08/01/2022 00:51

@tectonicplates

They can claim all they like that syns stand for "synergy", but come on, it's obviously designed to sound like sins, i.e. bad things. Surely nobody is fooled by this ridiculous claim.
It's the other way round. It used to be 'sins' back in the early 90s - as a sort of jocular reference to limiting the amount of 'bad' stuff you ate. Then WeightWatchers started advertising themselves as 'the diet where no food's a sin' and SW changed it to 'syn' - supposedly short for 'synergy'.

It's all pretty nonsensical as spending 'syns' on SW is no different from using 'points' on WW on things that are high in sugar and fat. It's common sense that you can't eat much of those foods (particularly sugary ones) if you want to lose weight.

My personal experience is that it's better to cut them out altogether, apart from as a very occasional treat - losing the habit is the best long-term approach and if you cut added sugar from your diet, you get more satisfaction from naturally occurring sugars in foods with better nutritional value; i.e. fruit and veg.

BigFatLiar · 07/01/2022 23:43

It's because Slimming World is the worst one for claiming it's not actually a diet,C, therefore it's not a diet like all those other groups like WW.

I think the key to it is "it's just a lifestyle change and general healthy eating" If you don't accept the idea that you're going to have to change your eating habits permanently it won't work.

This isn't unique to SW, it goes for any diet. They only work while you do them.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 07/01/2022 23:32

@Andtheyalllookjustthesame

If it worked skimming world would go bust, wouldn't it? Horrible business model to permanently solve your clients issues.
Exactly.
tectonicplates · 07/01/2022 23:29

Several people have asked why Slimming World is being singled out when there so many other diets out there that are equally as bad. It's because Slimming World is the worst one for claiming it's not actually a diet, it's just a lifestyle change and general healthy eating, therefore it's not a diet like all those other groups like WW. I've heard so many SW people claiming it's different, not like all those other ones out there, so it often takes people a bit longer to realise that no, actually it is a diet.

mumda · 07/01/2022 23:21

@Babyg1995

You only put the weight back on if you go back to eating rubbish and over eating again Confused
If we could do that we wouldn't need slimming world to start with.
Andtheyalllookjustthesame · 07/01/2022 23:20

If it worked skimming world would go bust, wouldn't it? Horrible business model to permanently solve your clients issues.

Babyg1995 · 07/01/2022 23:17

You only put the weight back on if you go back to eating rubbish and over eating again Confused

FrownedUpon · 07/01/2022 23:15

SW promotes an unhealthy attitude to food & can be psychologically damaging for some. A lot of people require therapeutic input to understand and manage their relationship with food. SW ignores this, while happily taking money off some very vulnerable people.

Ragwort · 07/01/2022 23:04

All diets work ... when you stick to them ... I've been on every 'diet' going and lost loads of weight over the years .... but I know I am greedy, I love food and I eat too much.

SW did work for me and, because I am used to cooking from scratch I never added artificial sweeteners, ate muller light yogurts etc ... some of the comments on here are from people who haven't recently been to a SW meeting, you are not encouraged 'to eat as much as you want'.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 07/01/2022 22:50

Of course it only works if you stay on it- how do you think they make money? They don’t make money by people losing weight and staying thin.

addictedtotheflats · 07/01/2022 22:45

I lost 2 stone, continued to go to group for 3 years and kept it off. As soon as I stopped going its gone back on plus another stone overa few years, so very gradual. overall I dont think it gives you a good relationship with food and my portion sizes are huge now because of this. Ive just started a calorie deficit and using the nutracheck app and im finding it great.

Yummayumma · 07/01/2022 22:44

At the end of the day any diet that says 2 litres of Diet Coke is better for you than an avocado is not a healthy eating plan.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/01/2022 22:43

I’ve missed my group over Christmas and looking forward to going to see my friends tomorrow. I know so many people now locally I’d have never met but for group. Great mix of people, all ages. We have fun, lots of food chat and sharing recipes etc. Group Consultant is very sensible re plan. They do vary a lot.
Slimmingworld podcast is well worth a listen to (it’s free no need to be a member)

Dixiechickonhols · 07/01/2022 22:33

Works for me I lost 5 stone in 8 months from a size 18/20 to a 10/12 in my mid 40s and have maintained healthy bmi since. Gets slated on mumsnet but very positive for me. Encourages lots of lean protein, 1/3 plate minimum vegetables each meal. Emphasis on cooking from scratch.
Muller lights and processed stuff are not compulsory I don’t eat them. Massive bowls of pasta are not sw. As with anything you have to be sensible and mindful of portion sizes, eating until satisfied not overeating. You can have avocado, nuts etc just in sensible amounts.
Group support which has been massive plus to me. I see my friends, we go on walks together.
I eat lots of eggs, oats, homemade soup, fruit and veg. It’s very sustainable and family friendly. Lifestyle not a quick fix. I do some SlimmingWorld recipes also slimming eats, slimming foodie and pinch of nom.
Today I’ve had porridge and berries for breakfast, homemade mushroom soup for lunch, skyr yoghurt as a snack, homemade chilli baked potato & salad for dinner and mini bag of choc buttons and strawberries. I’m not hungry and feel well eating this way.

HelloBunny · 07/01/2022 22:30

I did have an eating disorder when I was younger. All I want now, is not to be skinny but to be not fat. To just eat sensibly. Yes, in order to lose weight, you do have to go to bed a little hungry rather than a bit full. SW can be about making lighter choices.

The one thing I don’t like about though, is that essentially it is an MLM. I’m being targeted by the SW Consultant to sign up myself, as one. I’ve no interest, but noticed that you have to pay to do the course...

And, yes, I’m aware that I’m paying to do SW. So, they’re already getting my money!

LemonadePockets · 07/01/2022 22:29

I couldn’t stand the mantra of adding sweetener to everything.. I can’t stand the taste of it! And it’s definitely not healthy!

Youngstreet · 07/01/2022 22:22

@Bluebluemoon

Any diet works if you stick to it. Once you go back to your old eating habits it piles back on obvs. It doesn't matter what you eat - it comes down to calories in v calories out.

If I stick to 1000 calories a day il lose weight quickly - doesn't matter if it's 1000 calories of chocolate or 1000 calories of healthy stuff. Of course il feel much better if it's 1000 of healthy stuff but it will have pretty much the same result regardless.

This^^ But I get shot down for saying so.
Idontknowlondon · 07/01/2022 22:11

No weight loss works. Over 95% of people who lose weight will regain it within 5 years. It doesn't matter how they lost it.

tabulahrasa · 07/01/2022 22:08

@Waifwafer

I bloody love avocado!
Not convinced Grin

My theory that no-one really likes it is based purely on the amount of times people mention it has to be counted.

But no-one ever gets irate about cheese or say Brazil nuts having to be counted even though they’ve got things in that are also good for you, they’ll just go, oh I like them, I’ll count it. But avocados? Nope

Campervan69 · 07/01/2022 21:52

It's the most tedious meeting ever. I've never managed to lose with SW as I can't bear to stay for the meetings. And I think that's all that keeps you on track. But I don't have the time to waste to go round the entire room finding out who.lost what.

Plus I am no good when told I can eat unlimited anything. As I do. It just makes me eat more.

JhsLs · 07/01/2022 21:48

It definitely works as long as you’re happy to give yourself an eating disorder in the process

minnimiss · 07/01/2022 21:47

YANBU It's a business! Designed to keep people coming back. Not to get people slim and send them on their merry way. It's very sad. A huge % of their customers end up bigger in the long run as the cycle of losing and regaining weight goes on and on. The few that lose weight and keep it off on this plan do it not with the crazy diet club but through discovering and maintaining a love of fitness.

42isthemeaning · 07/01/2022 21:44

They don't want you to lose the weight permanently. They want your repeat custom. They need a few amazing weight loss stories for the cover of their magazines, to keep the money rolling in. However I think the majority of people regain the weight (and sometimes more than they lost in the first place) I'm glad if it works for people but I'm pretty cynical about slimming clubs in general.