Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
HairyFanjoBanjo · 09/01/2022 09:49

I personally think Noom is as bad as the rest of them and is very expensive - the company are making an absolute fortune from people’s misery unfortunately.

CatkinToadflax · 09/01/2022 09:02

Personally I prefer NOOM. I’ve been doing it for a year and have lost 3.5 stone and am nearly back to my target weight. I’ve recommended NOOM to several friends and it’s working brilliantly for some but not at all for others. I know that to reach and maintain my target weight I will have to follow this plan forever, whether continuing my NOOM subscription or using My Fitness Pal to keep on track of what I’m eating. Of course when you stop following a diet/healthy eating plan/whatever you want to call it, the weight will go back on.

Personally I’m not keen on Slimming World or any group based programme because I am very shy and introverted and going to a group for a weigh in and applause is my idea of hell. I did it and hated it. But that’s just how I feel, and I acknowledge that it works well for others.

Pikaso · 09/01/2022 08:52

Not read full thread but YANBU. It’s a cult which preys on uninformed people (women normally). It does not encourage healthy eating. I joined once and as I’m not actually overweight (but heavier than I want to be) I didn’t have much to loose. I was 10st 9lbs (at 5ft 10). In the first week I lost 2lbs and when I stepped on their scales the woman gave me a sympathetic look and said “2lbs? Oh well, you might have a better week next week”. That’s when I realised their leaders don’t have a fucking clue either. It’s all about selling sugar filled shite and charging people £5 a week to step on a set of scales.
Absolute rubbish.

Unlimited pasta my arse.

Calories in vs calories out is the only way.

FanciedChange · 09/01/2022 08:48

@HairyFanjoBanjo yes agree with that 100%

HairyFanjoBanjo · 09/01/2022 08:43

@FanciedChange

I think we are possibly talking about different things here.

I’m not advocating weight gain or lack of exercise whatsoever. But eating and exercise being used as a stick to beat yourself with in an attempt to adhere to societies expectations of body shape or size (with the agenda for almost all proponents to cash in on mass self body hatred).

It sounds like you made a health based decision for your mind and body and your approach was sensible for you.

ivykaty44 · 09/01/2022 08:31
Go to block 5 if you want to get straight into the science, the first 4 blocks of the podcast are about who the professor is and how he got to where he was doing research.
FanciedChange · 09/01/2022 07:33

@HairyFanjoBanjo

Most people have a body size ‘set point’ or ‘range’. Traditional ‘diets’ just fuck that up, but forcing you into calorie deficit for as long as you can hack it. Once you start eating ‘normally’ again, you regain the weight and usually some more on top.

Psychologically, diets tell your brain there is a famine. So when you stop the ‘famine’ your body tries to regain ASAP and some in case of another famine (diet). It’s actually your body being smart and trying to help you.

We aren’t all meant to be stick thin our whole lives, but societal conditioning means we are all pushed to hate our bodies and aspire to be thin / thinner with whatever the fashionable body type is. This societal conditioning and consumerism makes diet companies a LOT of money.

It’s incredibly depressing.

@HairyFanjoBanjo I agree with parts of what you're saying but not all weightloss attempts are aesthetic only. I put on lots of weight due to medication and chronic pain (less exercise) and was very overweight for 3.5 years. At the beginning of 2021 I decided I had to diet and last year lost 2.5 stone. The vast majority of my pain has cleared and my IBS is virtually gone. The weight loss also meant I was able to exercise (it is hard to exercise intensively if you are obese) and this in turn has improved my conditions and mental health. Tbh, dieting has drastically improved my life and I never want to get that fat again.
HopefulRose · 08/01/2022 22:38

Slimming World is a cult and has built a business by peddling fake science.

ChicCroissant · 08/01/2022 22:37

@Sanada

Haven't RTFT but I joined Slimming World, lost 1.5 stone. I ended up leaving the group and tried doing it from home (because I hated group, always felt like I was the odd one out). Ended up getting annoyed with SW because I felt like all I could cook while following it was English food and "fakeaways" (I prefer to cook traditional Chinese dishes). It also irritated me that muller lights were 1/2 syn but a better quality yogurt was 2 syns for a similar amount when the calorie content was similar. As a result I ended up putting back on the weight and then some(I was heavier than when I started!).

I'm not the only one this has happened to, I know of at least 3 people who left Slimming world and ended up piling it back on and then some. SW is nothing more than a scam and I regret signing up to it.

So when you followed the SW plan you lost 1.5 stone (well done, that's great) and when you didn't follow the SW plan you gained weight.

It's fine to make the choice not to follow it any more as you did, but that doesn't make it a scam. It worked for you. The reason it isn't working for you now is because you are not following it!

itssarcasmjoan · 08/01/2022 21:12

SW and WW etc try to teach people about healthy eating and balance.
Diets 'Fail' because people view them as diets not permanent changes to the way the eat and live.

Follow a plan and you will loose weight - stop and it piles back on.
It's not rocket science.

ZiggZagg · 08/01/2022 19:30

@BIWI Grin

BIWI · 08/01/2022 19:17

[quote ZiggZagg]@BIWI I love LCBootcamp, my favourite bit is where we have to sacrifice our first born to join Wink or when we have to self flagellate if we do not lose any weightGrin[/quote]
Self flagellation even if you do lose weight @ZiggZagg. It's the only way.

BigFatLiar · 08/01/2022 18:32

These big name weight loss companies are only successful because they rely on members to fail - lose some weight, stop going to meeting and following the plans - and then come back again when you’ve got fed up of your subsequent weight gain / have a special event coming up and so on.

You can't blame them for your failure though. It's not someone else's fault if you go back to cakes, chocolate, pizza and wine.

ZiggZagg · 08/01/2022 18:17

@BIWI I love LCBootcamp, my favourite bit is where we have to sacrifice our first born to join Wink or when we have to self flagellate if we do not lose any weightGrin

Onlyhuman123 · 08/01/2022 16:59

@Startrooper

These big name weight loss companies are only successful because they rely on members to fail - lose some weight, stop going to meeting and following the plans - and then come back again when you’ve got fed up of your subsequent weight gain / have a special event coming up and so on.

Pretty much all weight loss plans fail to thoroughly cover the why’s of overeating and poor food choices. The initial buzz of weight loss wears off for many and they can’t/won’t maintain the plans, and these days it’s well known that carbs convert to sugar so why they still encourage regular consumption of pasta, rice, bread, potatoes etc as well as selling those sickly sweet substitute own-brand chocolate/cereal bars and crisps etc in their meetings is beyond me. All these carbs and sweet foods should be very occasional and certainly not consumed daily for long-term weight loss.

Cut the carbs and all processed foods, up your protein significantly, drink 2L water along with lots of vegetables and no more than 1-2 fruit daily, take up regular exercise, and address your psychological reasons for poor food choices or excessive intake and you are likely to have more success and more money in your pocket too.

Yes! This!!

I found this info after I joined Second Nature. Brilliant and insightful. Looks more towards the psychology of why we eat what we eat and how habits, sleep, water intake can have a huge impact. I've done SW and WW and whilst I kept the weight off for a long time, since hitting menopause the weight has piled on. For me, it's definitely the overload of carbs I've eaten...which SW encourage you to have too much of.

FinallyHere · 08/01/2022 14:31

It’s essentially an MLM.

I'm no afraid there is much truth in this view of SW as a MLM business.

Local leaders are not treated very well, can often not even break even unless or maybe until they have a team of leaders

DwangelaForever · 08/01/2022 14:26

Slimming world works and it's very maintainable as long as you keep up with the third of your plate as vegetables (speed food).

It's a low fat plan and anything high fat is synned. People complaining about avocados melt me. If you want to eat avocados go find a high fat diet that works for you. It's like going on keto and moaning you can't eat carbs.

It's really easy to follow and stick to and I hate the bad rep it gets!

only11monthstillxmas · 08/01/2022 14:23

I think SW is one of the healthier lifestyles out there

They don't say eat as much pasta as you like

They say fill a third of your plate with low density food like salad and veg then add the rest of your meal - eat till you are comfortably full

Any sensible person is going to realise that muller lights and hi fi bars are not nutritious filling or beneficial foods
But is it not about finding a balance ?
Do we not all want a wee treat now and then

I did it once - successfully -but couldn't stand the happy clapping brigade and having to take home a carrier bag full of crap from everyone's cupboard

I did like the accountability of the scales though , which there was an alternative

Thegiftthatkeepsongiving · 08/01/2022 14:12

SW is a step towards healthier eating for some people but that is on the basis you have a healthy attitude to food in the first place. I know someone who is with SW and while they are losing weight it doesn’t address their psychological issues with food (namely comfort eating and comfort drinking).

Grapewrath · 08/01/2022 13:59

Of course it doesn’t work, it wouldn’t be as profitable if it did.

Loudestcat14 · 08/01/2022 13:49

I haven't RTFT but the end of the day, SW is a business and to make money it needs to attract new customers – but more importantly it needs to retain existing ones. So, its plan works in the short-term – users often lose lots of weight in the first few months. But long-term it isn't sustainable and the weight creeps back on – ensuring SW has a lovely pool of repeat customers who sign up again and again in the hope of it working this time. SW isn't alone in this, WW is the same. It's quite ironic the diet industry is probably the only one that relies on failure to stay in profit!

tabulahrasa · 08/01/2022 13:48

@Waifwafer

For those that are saying this thread is missing the point and that anyone will put weight back on if you deviate from the plan:

The point I'm trying to make is that SW doesn't seem like a sustainable lifestyle choice, thus being almost impossible to stick to long term. Viewing foods as "syns", congratulating members who ha lost the most weight that week (even if it's actually 5lb in water weight or from a tummy bug rather than actual fat loss) and promoting low calorie but synthetically enhanced foods over calorie-dense nutritious food all points to this:

Short term, rapid weight loss, possibly a bad relationship with certain food groups and teaching members to celebrate the number on the scales, which might actually mean nothing.

Eating less, moving more and taking measurements seems much more sustainable long term... And it's free!

That’s your understanding of it though, but some of that is very inaccurate.

The promoting synthetically enhanced foods for instance, just doesn’t happen - Diet Coke isn’t ever particularly mentioned unless someone new questions whether they can drink it or if they should switch to water and the answer is always, you don’t have to count it because it’s got practically no calories in it, but obviously water is better for you, but it’s up to you what you drink.

Low fat yoghurt is just yoghurt! Only plain ones are in the free food lists, not flavoured ones...

What it does promote is lots of lean proteins, the more complex carbs, fruit and veg and controlling fats, sugar and things like alcohol...

You’re encouraged when you join and every week when you go, to look at your habits and why you do them, so you can make longterm changes, to use other members as your support system and to keep doing all that once you’re where you want to be and keep going for free - do some people still treat it like a quick fix? Yes of course, people don’t really like change IME.

It wont be the right way of losing weight for everyone - but eating less and moving more is very very simplistic and doesn’t take into account at all how people become overweight. I actually eat far more doing slimming world than I did before but it’s real food because my tendency is to skip meals, not eat until I’m very hungry and grab something small but very unhealthy, when I’ve tried calorie counting or WW I’ll happily be starving most of the time and use all my calories or points on very very unwise things.

Things like slimmer of the week are a bit... meh, but at least it’s trying to focus on a positive, I’ve been to weightloss places that made you stand up by yourself if you’d gained the most that week while they gave you a blooming lecture Hmm if I gain at slimming world it’s just a case of, ok... what’s your plan and target for this week?

Veeveeoxox · 08/01/2022 13:37

I had gastric sleeve surgery 3 months ago I've tried almost every diet but got into the yo yo diet mentality. I had CBT to prepare me for WLS , my calorie deficit is huge and some weeks I don't lose then I will lose 8lbs the week after then nothing. The weighing every week definitely isn't accurate for fat loss. Slimming world teaches nothing about portion control and the syns thing contributes to disordered eating, diet culture has made us all fatter!!!

Dixiechickonhols · 08/01/2022 13:33

Yes plan is minimum 1/3 plate each meal vegetables. You see people saying they are doing SlimmingWorld but don’t do this - Facebook and Instagram you see this a lot.
Got new pack today and it’s there in big letters.
It also doesn’t say stuff yourself on massive portions!

Dixiechickonhols · 08/01/2022 13:29

Lose weight however you want but I personally dislike people who have no idea of current SlimmingWorld plan criticising it for things it doesn’t say. It 100% doesn’t say diet pop is healthier than avocado. They very much encourage you using some syns in meals on things like avocado or nuts.
Yes you can lose weight on your own but people lose better with support - friend, PT, group like SlimmingWorld.
Like I say works for me. January 2019 I joined obese size 18/20 by Easter I was a 14 and June I was a healthy bmi. 3 years on i’m wearing a size 10 dress today.
I post on Instagram and don’t post weird stuff or massive portions. Just normal healthy eating. I’ve had overnight oats for breakfast (yoghurt not muller light!, 40g oats and fruit) I’ll have a salmon salad for lunch and Piri Piri chicken tonight with peppers and onions. Plus I can have a bit of chocolate if I fancy tonight. 10,000 steps. For me I feel well eating this way and it’s sustainable.

Over 2/3 of ladies my age are overweight. It’s not easy to lose weight on your own.
Target members are completely free, they are very happy for you to go weekly or occasionally up to you and you you get all membership perks like app.