Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 12:47

@ivykaty44

MeredithGreyishblue

Where does SW say it address obsessive eating habits?

it may well promote "health eating habits - thats very different from promoting "addressing peoples obsessive eating habits"

It's in their marketing! They claim to have a whole system designed to help, called IMAGE. I wonder how many SW customers have heard of it, let alone been helped by it? Because it sounds like it's way above the average team leader's qualifications.

www.slimmingworld.co.uk/health/how-sw-works/behavioural-change.aspx

gunnersgold · 09/01/2022 12:44

It does work ! You can't go back to over eating when you reach goal though .. !!
I lost two stone last year and have kept it off by keeping my calories down and exercise up!

ivykaty44 · 09/01/2022 12:39

MeredithGreyishblue

Where does SW say it address obsessive eating habits?

it may well promote "health eating habits - thats very different from promoting "addressing peoples obsessive eating habits"

Notimeforaname · 09/01/2022 12:37

Worked*

Notimeforaname · 09/01/2022 12:37

Was the only thing that worled for my mum.

She started in 2012...is still at or below her target weight 10 years later. Only went to the meetings til she hit her target and has carried on eating that way since.

Guess it works for some,not for others.

DoctorSnortles · 09/01/2022 12:35

The problem I have with it is it works when you’re on it, but you can’t half-ass it as you can with some other diets. For example, if I’m calorie counting, I might have a 350 calorie lunch, then at four pm lose my shit and eat half a packet of biscuits. This is bad news but on SW it’s particularly catastrophic, because instead of my calorie controlled 350 lunch, I had a wildly uncontrolled, enormous bowl of pasta containing possibly 750 calories and THEN my biscuit consumption, after which I will tell myself I am back in the straight and narrow....which might mean a 850 calorie dinner, consisting mostly of (‘Free’)potatoes and (‘free’) baked beans, whereas in my calorie-controlled diet I might have a 400 calorie dinner. Yes, I’ve crammed half a packet of jammy dodgers into my mouth in both scenarios, but with SW there’s no reining things in.

You either do SW or you don’t. I have never gained weight so swiftly as I did when half-doing SW.

Lolacat1234 · 09/01/2022 12:27

It doesn't work long term because it's not sustainable. I managed it for about 2 months before I got fed up.

In my experience the easiest, safest way to lose weight is to focus on 1) being in a calorie deficit (burn more than you consume) 2) aim to get your macros right (which involves more than likely decreasing fat/carbs and increasing protein in your daily diet and 3) incorporating healthy consistent exercise into your daily routine, and making sure it's something you enjoy and want to commit to (for me it's dance workouts or walking workouts) and also to include some form of strength training whether it's with a fitness band or body weight exercises. The weight loss is slow but consistent doing it this way and more than likely to stay off long term.

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 12:15

@ivykaty44

However, it never addressed my obsessive eating habits

Does it say that on the tin?

It promotes it. No weighing or measuring. Repeated at every newbie session. For most over-eaters it's why they choose it. It encourages it. It's designed for people like me. It's not healthy. But it is a business model that keeps you paying out and disguisesitself as health focussed.
tabulahrasa · 09/01/2022 12:15

“However, it never addressed my obsessive eating habits. My compulsion to eat til I feel sick..”

Well no, nothing at that level of support would - I know someone with a diagnosed binge eating disorder - months of specialist mental health care didn’t resolve it.

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 12:11

@ivykaty44

Unlimited pasta my arse.

how can it be unlimited pasta if a third of your plate has to be vegetables? that surely limits your pasta to two thirds of a plate

Because you can eat the same again 30 mins later according to "the plan"
ivykaty44 · 09/01/2022 12:10

Unlimited pasta my arse.

how can it be unlimited pasta if a third of your plate has to be vegetables? that surely limits your pasta to two thirds of a plate

ivykaty44 · 09/01/2022 12:06

However, it never addressed my obsessive eating habits

Does it say that on the tin?

Luredbyapomegranate · 09/01/2022 12:05

Well, it’s part of the diet industry and that’s based on getting you to come back.

But you have to take the sensible bits from it, and make them your own.

Most of all you have to deal with the emotional issues around food

mumof2exhausted · 09/01/2022 11:47

It’s an an excellent business model as they get multiple return customers - if it actually worked then surely they wouldn’t?? My sister tried it and was baffled when the “leader” told her exercise was a bad idea. So very strange. Also theres so much focus on “low fat processed crap” - muller yogurts anyone ?

interferingma · 09/01/2022 11:45

SW does help people maintain when then come off the 'diet' part. At that point healthy things which might be regarded as calorific like the infamous avocado, and nuts and seeds, are reintroduced. It honestly isn't the fault of a diet plan if people choose to ignore the ongoing advice!
I speak as someone who lost around 3 stone through SW and three years later is largely still at target weight. I felt it gave me the tools to stay healthy. And I never resorted to weird bars or products. It just re-taught me portion control and that it was better to fill a plate with veg than loads of bread or pasta.

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 11:43

Allowing these people, mostly women trying earn some cash, to "consult" on health of others is a real worry.

How do I syn chia seeds? Erm, the same as ciabatta hun. Just look at the bread version

WTAF? And these people are revered as health experts. Rather than people struggling to earn a living in a shitty self employed scheme.

malificent7 · 09/01/2022 11:43

Slimming world does work. When you stop doing it it dosn't...not sure why this isn't blatantly obvious!
I don't do sw...i do calorie counting. It works...if i stop it won't work coz....der!

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 11:39

@itssarcasmjoan

SW and WW etc try to teach people about healthy eating and balance. Diets 'Fail' because people view them as diets not permanent changes to the way the eat and live.

Follow a plan and you will loose weight - stop and it piles back on.
It's not rocket science.

I would fundamentally disagree with that. SW doesn't try to teach that. It might headline that but what it encourages in a group setting is far from it. Their "consultants" are dangerous!

WW slightly better but not much.

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 11:34

Sigh. I lost 4st on SW. In around 9 months. The plan, in itself works. I was never hungry.

However, it never addressed my obsessive eating habits. My compulsion to eat til I feel sick. So, as soon as I step away from the hallowed plan, I'm eating all the butter instead of all the boiled eggs.

And the ridiculous nonsense of fake foods - pumping yourself full of 62 eggs whites and a ton weight of Candarel and calling it roulade is fucking awful. Eat one slice of real roulade and stop.

If you ever question it, the "consultants" (almost mlm-like huns) will tell you their overarching message is sensible eating, fruit & veg and stopping when you're full BUT they encourage all the cheats and fakes and face-filling during the meeting. (Which is as far from therapy as is earthly possible)

And exercise is apparently encouraged but never actually mentioned. They can't monetise it.

I remember my first "consultant" telling me if I wanted to, I could get up at 1am and eat a full chicken and 10 boiled potatoes as long as I took the fucking skin off.

How on earth is this shit promoting healthy attitudes to food? They need you to keep coming back or they don't make money.

tectonicplates · 09/01/2022 11:25

@Ivchangedmynameforthis

I have lost a stone here and there over the years. Put it straight back on with bells on. It worked when I needed to loose a stone quickly for my wedding but long term its not sustainable. I received a hand written envelope the other day with a card in it inviting me back. The consultant is a family friend and had seen my Xmas pictures and commented on them. Thankfully I have really thick skin and saw the funny side but really its a shocking way to advertise.
@Ivchangedmynameforthis What did she say on your Christmas pictures? Just a general Christmassy comment, or "I've seen your recent photos and wondered if you wanted to join Slimming World again"?
Morgan12 · 09/01/2022 11:16

I counted calories for 5 months straight. Never ate more than 1600 a day. Average was around 1400 a day though. I didn't lose anything.

I did SW for a week before Christmas and lost 5lbs.

Christ knows why but my body clearly responds to the plan.

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 11:06

@Ivchangedmynameforthis

I have lost a stone here and there over the years. Put it straight back on with bells on. It worked when I needed to loose a stone quickly for my wedding but long term its not sustainable. I received a hand written envelope the other day with a card in it inviting me back. The consultant is a family friend and had seen my Xmas pictures and commented on them. Thankfully I have really thick skin and saw the funny side but really its a shocking way to advertise.
How rude!
MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 11:06

ChicCroissant But you're overlooking why Sanada was unable to stay on SW long-term. Like all the other branded diets, SW is calorie reduction dressed up in fancy marketing and it's been scientifically proved that the body responds to a cycle of deprivation – which is what calorie reduction is – by having a hormonal response that raises hunger and craving cues. So it doesn't matter how successful you are and how much willpower you have, for the vast majority of customers, at some point SW will stop working for them as their body fights back.

SW's scientific/dietary advisors – assuming they have any – could tweak the programme to ensure optimal calorie increases at certain points to allow for the body's hormonal response, but why would they do that? If they did, everyone would succeed first time, keep the weight off forever and they'd go out of business! You say it's not a scam, I find it hard to see it as anything else.

Ivchangedmynameforthis · 09/01/2022 11:05

I have lost a stone here and there over the years. Put it straight back on with bells on. It worked when I needed to loose a stone quickly for my wedding but long term its not sustainable. I received a hand written envelope the other day with a card in it inviting me back. The consultant is a family friend and had seen my Xmas pictures and commented on them. Thankfully I have really thick skin and saw the funny side but really its a shocking way to advertise.

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 10:55

Fanciedchange It sounds like dieting has worked for you, and that's great, but for the vast majority it doesn't and SW is one of the worst offenders for creating a dieting programme that really isn't sustainable long-term, thus ensuring it has repeat customers year after year to stay in business. This TED talk by a neuroscientist backs up what HairyFanjoBanjo said about dieting messing with the body's set point. It's fascinating.

www.ted.com/talks/sandra_aamodt_why_dieting_doesn_t_usually_work?language=en