Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
Morgan12 · 09/01/2022 16:49

But it's calorie controlled. And that's the point of the diet.

Beef - 150 cals
Rice - 198 cals
Chips made with potato in airfryer - 150
Sauce - 100
598 calories for a very satisfying dinner.
Also add onions and mushrooms to sauce.

BusterGonad · 09/01/2022 16:47

Of course it doesn't work if you think eating a casserole dish full of pasta is going to lose you weight! You do need to engage your brain too. Slimming world actually encourages you to cook proper meals, using fresh veg, beans, lentils etc. It also encourages you to eat more fruit. The basics of it is to eat free (healthy) foods, cut right back on bread etc, eat a moderate amount of pasta, rice etc. By free pasta they mean a sensible amount for yourself. So if you're 20 stone that would be quite a large portion, if you're 10 stone then not so much. The weight loss happens because you almost stop eating crap like crisps and biscuits but you can have about 300 calories of your desired food per day. Of course you will go right back to square one if you stuff your face again once not following the healthy eating guidelines. At some point you do need to take responsibility for yourself.

00100001 · 09/01/2022 16:46

[quote MeredithGreyishblue]@00100001 it sounds like you've been assimilated by the borg.

SW use these insta influencers, both directly and indirectly with products they endorse by featuring in their mags - like JD Seasonings for example. It might not be "plan" but because there's absolutely no control over what consultants come out with and agree with in "therapy" it's endorsed.

And one third "speed" is a third if its with 80g of pasta or 2kg of pasta. Its not a magic getout. Even if it is called speed. Its still unregulated, unqualified part time sales people advising people on their health.

And I beg to differ on not pushing SW food. They do. If only by offering people the easy route so they'll stay members. Consultants are drive by membership sales.[/quote]
Yes but no-one is eating 2kg of pasta at a meal are they? Confused

The plan is fine. It says to eat lots of veg, lean meats, fruits, some carbohydrates, some fats, calcium etc.

It literally is the eat well plate....

Yes, they offer their weird cereal bars...but noone is forced to buy them.

Also noone needs to have artificial sweeteners or even use spray oil etc and they can still be "on plan".

And yes, the consultants are sometimes guilty of not following the plan...

But it doesn't mean the plan doesn't work!

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 16:45

00100001 I'm glad to hear it's not part of the plan, but it raises the question of how the plan is being explained to SW followers so they can interpret it so woefully and unhealthily! I mean, the person who posted it used all the SW hashtags including – oh the irony – #foodoptimising!

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 16:36

@00100001 it sounds like you've been assimilated by the borg.

SW use these insta influencers, both directly and indirectly with products they endorse by featuring in their mags - like JD Seasonings for example. It might not be "plan" but because there's absolutely no control over what consultants come out with and agree with in "therapy" it's endorsed.

And one third "speed" is a third if its with 80g of pasta or 2kg of pasta. Its not a magic getout. Even if it is called speed. Its still unregulated, unqualified part time sales people advising people on their health.

And I beg to differ on not pushing SW food. They do. If only by offering people the easy route so they'll stay members. Consultants are drive by membership sales.

00100001 · 09/01/2022 16:33

I think it's unfair to say the plan "doesn't work" when actually it does. Like any weight loss programme, it depends on people actually following it, not interpreting it as they see fit, and also not committing to a lifestyle change for life.

SW et al all say they're "not diets" but a change in lifestyle etc.

The same could be said for all these 'just count calories' a d eat what you want. It works, IF you continue to count calories, however if you stop counting cals and things like an extra biscuit, or another slice of cake etc creep in, you'll out in weight again.

cushioncovers · 09/01/2022 16:33

When I did sw I was eating a lot of the free food but not loosing any weight. When I entered my food intake into a calorie counter it turns out I was eating 2800 calories a day roughly. So when I discussed this with the sw consultant she said to cut out some of the free food. Which is fine but I only joined sw because I thought I could eat loads of the free food mentioned. If I had to portion control then what was the point of paying to do sw🤷🏻‍♀️. Calorie counting and being in a deficit is the only way to lose weight.

00100001 · 09/01/2022 16:24

@Frankola

Slimming World is a commercial business. Its designed to suck you in and keep you there as long as possible. I've known so many people yo yo on Slimming World. Its terribly unhealthy.

The fact they have their own food products that they encourage you to buy rather than fruit and veg says it all really.

My friend was once sat with a huge tub of pasta which she gleefully told me was a "free" food and she could eat as much as she wanted. Unbelievable.

I think you've been misinformed...

...They do encourage you to buy fresh fruit and veg... They promote their foods as a convenience that you have to add veg to...it even says it on the bloody packet.

And your friend wasn't following the plan by eating a huge tub of pasta... Unless of course, that same tub was 1/3 speed food and she was listening to her appetite...?

00100001 · 09/01/2022 16:21

@MrsTrumpton

WineGetsMeThroughIt I just looked up that hashtag. One of the first plates is beef and mushroom curry Mayflower curry – so, a shop-bought sauce laden with hidden sugar – with rice AND chips! On what planet can that be healthy??!!!
It isn't.

But isn't following plan either....

WingingItSince1973 · 09/01/2022 16:18

One of my close friends has been doing sw on and off for about 20 years. She's looses lots if weight but then put it back on again. Her meals used to be weird and if she saved her syns or whatever it was she would eat a packet of ham or something else random. I used the NutraCheck app and fitness pro. Both are good way of counting calories, keeping track of sugar and fat intake. The fitness pro is bluetoothed to my watch so can track steps done and calories used. I find a basic healthy eating, no junk, calorie controlled diet better than sw or ww. But then we are all different x

Frankola · 09/01/2022 16:14

Slimming World is a commercial business. Its designed to suck you in and keep you there as long as possible. I've known so many people yo yo on Slimming World. Its terribly unhealthy.

The fact they have their own food products that they encourage you to buy rather than fruit and veg says it all really.

My friend was once sat with a huge tub of pasta which she gleefully told me was a "free" food and she could eat as much as she wanted. Unbelievable.

BigFatLiar · 09/01/2022 15:56

@Sackofnickles

I followed a chap on SM for a while who lost 16.5 stone on SW, only to put it all back on.
While still on the plan or after he stopped?
Ivchangedmynameforthis · 09/01/2022 15:48

@tectonicplates just general comments nothing about weight. They were not the most flattering pics though and I have defo put weight on. I assume these cards went to lots of people but the fact she had seen my unflattering pics made it personal. Like I said I'm not offended. My DH and I found it quite hilarious.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 09/01/2022 15:27

I was 10st 9lbs (at 5ft 10). In the first week I lost 2lbs and when I stepped on their scales the woman gave me a sympathetic look and said “2lbs?

That's awful. When you are a healthy BMI but wanting to get to your personal ideal weight, 2lb is an excellent loss in a week. You generally only get losses of more than that if you are starting from a point of being overweight.

MeredithGreyishblue · 09/01/2022 15:16

@ivykaty44

MeredithGreyishblue

Where does SW say it address obsessive eating habits?

it may well promote "health eating habits - thats very different from promoting "addressing peoples obsessive eating habits"

Surely most people are over eating. That's how you get fat! By eating the whole bar of chocolate and not one chunk. It encourages this behaviour. It's how it makes money. It's the whole thing - how it differentiated itself from WW all those years ago. When arguably WW was looking at nutrition in its weights and food categories and portions.

SW never addresses that. It might tell you it's going to but the groups themselves are all people being given a round of applause for swapping 6 bags of crisps for 12 boiled eggs. Or drinking their own body weight in aspartame. There's no nutritional education and they certainly don't encourage exercise.

The therapy bit purports to look at behaviours but in reality when a consultant (who don't have to meet any particular requirements other than a willingness to risk money investing in a franchise) leads a group they are clueless and they don't alienate any members by being honest because they want them to come back. So they agree to people creating franken-foods to suit their gluttony and love of a meat pie. Let's look at how to make an aspartame roulade that you can eat ALL of rather than addressing how to manage only eating one slice of real food.

And people look up to these entirely unqualified "health professionals" that take their cash every week. And they listen to the nonsense.

I consider myself a fairly intelligent human and even I went along with it for a few months until I started to actually think about it. Because you WILL lose weight. So you conveniently don't look too hard.

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 15:15

WineGetsMeThroughIt I just looked up that hashtag. One of the first plates is beef and mushroom curry Mayflower curry – so, a shop-bought sauce laden with hidden sugar – with rice AND chips! On what planet can that be healthy??!!!

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 15:11

My mistake, there are a few more eating disorders that are medically recognised, including Orthorexia. BEAT lists them here. My point stands though – the majority of dieters don't have eating disorders but suffer with ingrained disordered eating patterns like yo-yo dieting. They're not discouraged from joining SW, but probably should be.

WineGetsMeThroughIt · 09/01/2022 15:08

Just search #SWUK on Instagram and you can clearly see the crap women on slimming world are eating and why it doesn't work long term. I'm actually baffled that anyone can lose weight in the stuff they're eating. The carbs And sugar must be causing immense cravings and energy drops

MrsTrumpton · 09/01/2022 15:01

@tabulahrasa

www.slimmingworld.co.uk/faqs/before-you-join/eating-disorder-advice

I have an eating disorder. Can I still join Slimming World?

We feel that joining a Slimming World group or our Online service may not be the best solution for your weight management at present.
Although we’d love to be able to help, eating disorders aren’t our area of expertise. We believe that for your long-term health and safety you would be best supported by trained professionals in this field. We’d encourage you to speak to your doctor or practice nurse regarding your weight concerns. They should be able to give appropriate guidance and possibly a referral to a specialist in this area.

There are three medically recognised eating disorders in the UK – bulimia, anorexia and binge eating. The vast majority of dieters – including most commenting against SW on this thread – will not have been diagnosed those BUT may well have disordered eating patterns including a long history of yo-yo dieting. You'll note Slimming World doesn't encourage those sufferers to go to their doctor though, because they are dream customers, coming back time and time again to lose weight and paying for the misery of it.
ivykaty44 · 09/01/2022 14:50

MrsTrumpton. thank you, its certainly suggesting the tackling of self sabotage & ingrained patterns of eating - which would cover the binge eating.

it seems a lot to be promising within a group meeting, and obviously failing in cases

tabulahrasa · 09/01/2022 14:35

www.slimmingworld.co.uk/faqs/before-you-join/eating-disorder-advice

I have an eating disorder. Can I still join Slimming World?

We feel that joining a Slimming World group or our Online service may not be the best solution for your weight management at present.
Although we’d love to be able to help, eating disorders aren’t our area of expertise. We believe that for your long-term health and safety you would be best supported by trained professionals in this field. We’d encourage you to speak to your doctor or practice nurse regarding your weight concerns. They should be able to give appropriate guidance and possibly a referral to a specialist in this area.

MrsBerthaRochester · 09/01/2022 13:34

Yanbu. I have had a couple of friends who done it and became obsessed. Its almost cult like. One was a slimmer of the year after losing 9 stone. Yep she put it all back on. She rejoins loses a couple of stone,puts it back on and the cycle repeats. Its a huge con.

WineGetsMeThroughIt · 09/01/2022 13:20

I see a load of SW accounts on Instagram, and the food that people post looks disgusting. Crap junk food. Spaghetti hoops for breakfast, crisps, loads of weird skinny syrups, low cal whip bars. Just eat real food and calorie count!

what that diet must be doing to peoples insides grosses me out

Sackofnickles · 09/01/2022 13:20

I followed a chap on SM for a while who lost 16.5 stone on SW, only to put it all back on.

Floogal · 09/01/2022 13:17

Sooo expensive and many of the people buying it don't seem to be losing weight. Losing lots of pounds but not the pounds they want to lose