Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
gwenneh · 07/01/2022 17:22

It works, as long as you do it exactly as described.
It stops working when you step outside of the rules.
It's a diet.

It's not designed to be a sustainable lifestyle choice, because there's no market for creating non-repeat customers. They WANT you to lose weight temporarily and remember that when you put weight back on and look for the next solution.

It'll "work" in the sense of you'll keep weight off if you find it a permanently sustainable way of eating. It's not designed to be that, so it's not surprising most people don't keep the weight off.

BoredZelda · 07/01/2022 17:21

Had a jacket spud and beans, I pointed out there was less calories in the veggie lasagne which she wanted (calories all on the menu) but she was having none of it!

It’s not just about calories.

Chloemol · 07/01/2022 17:21

Did it years ago, kept the weight off for quite a while but it’s gone back on, simply as I am eating dar to much crap

It’s no different to WW, Cambridge diet, or any of the others
As soon as you stop following any of them you start to put weight on

Simply put you need to put in less calories than you use, and exercise

JudgeRindersMinder · 07/01/2022 17:21

@slashlover

This. It's not sustainable and encourages hideous processed food and loads of sugar.

This is my food for today (I'm veggie)

Breakfast - Omelette made with two eggs and lots of veg - onions, peppers, tomatoes, etc.

Lunch - Homemade soup with veg and random beans/chickpeas and two slices of wholemeal bread

Dinner - Homemade chilli and rice

Snack - cherry tomatoes and houmous and veg sticks.

I'll have a glass of wine tonight from my syns.

How is this processed food and sugar?

It’s far from processed food and sugar, but it’s also VERY light on protein, which is what keeps you feeling full, not fruit & veg
BoredZelda · 07/01/2022 17:20

Any person will put back weight on after dieting if they revert back to old habits.

I’ve been following one of these plans similar to SW, and have lost weight slowly and have changed my eating habits. If people have another way that works for them, they should use that.

I had a consultation with a dietitian and she gave me a meal plan, followed it to the letter and lost the same amount of weight. But, it was full of foods that I don’t enjoy and meant having a completely different diet than I had previously. I gave it up because it was too rigorous, I was always hungry, and I couldn’t eat any of the meals I enjoy. Not sustainable for me in the long term.

JudgeRindersMinder · 07/01/2022 17:20

And don’t get me started on not mashing a banana! Ffs

slashlover · 07/01/2022 17:20

This. It's not sustainable and encourages hideous processed food and loads of sugar.

This is my food for today (I'm veggie)

Breakfast - Omelette made with two eggs and lots of veg - onions, peppers, tomatoes, etc.

Lunch - Homemade soup with veg and random beans/chickpeas and two slices of wholemeal bread

Dinner - Homemade chilli and rice

Snack - cherry tomatoes and houmous and veg sticks.

I'll have a glass of wine tonight from my syns.

How is this processed food and sugar?

Steelesauce · 07/01/2022 17:19

My mum is back on slimming world too. She drove me crackers today when we went out to eat. Had a jacket spud and beans, I pointed out there was less calories in the veggie lasagne which she wanted (calories all on the menu) but she was having none of it!

JudgeRindersMinder · 07/01/2022 17:18

They do absolutely nothing to address WHY you are overweight in the first place. Their “consultants” only know about the SW plan, and if you ask a question that’s slightly off piste they have no idea.

I say this as a former SW branch “woman of the year” who put back on all 5 plus stone I’d lost amd 4 years later has had a sleeve gastrectomy due to my food addiction.
If you have food issues, all you hear is “as much as you want” and that’s what you do.

Absolutely nothing healthy about it.

I had a very good gym habit at the time I did SW, good mix of cardio and resistance training, and one week when I didn’t have a great loss -note, not NO loss, and the class leader told me to lay off the gym for a week.
Have you ever heard anything so ridiculous in your life?

If you need to lose up to say 2 stones then yes maybe it’s for you, but if you have more than that to lose, you need to have a hard look at WHY you’re so overweight, and SW or WW aren’t going to help you with that.

Gastric sleeve is by no means an easy way out or a cheat, but it’s what I needed

zigzag56445 · 07/01/2022 17:16

Slimming world is a plan that works if you follow it.
But...
Its a bunch of convoluted rules that keeps you from the principle that you need a calorie deficit to loose weight.
If you educate yourself about good nutritious food and don't demonise treats you can get a healthy balance.
The fitness chef on Instagram has some good stuff that helps drive this home.

SirChenjins · 07/01/2022 17:16

@tricksyt

My friend has been doing it on and off for years, and she posts photos on Instagram of her meals, that often consist of a big pile of pasta, with low fat cheese and low fat sausages. Confused

She loses 3 stone and then puts it all back on within 6 months.

Funnily enough, I have friends who do other non-SW plans, lose weight, stop doing the plans, and put the weight back on again.

It’s like someone out there has promised that weight will stay off even if you revert back to your old eating habits - but only if you don’t do SW.

SnowyBerries · 07/01/2022 17:16

I think it works and you can eat very well and healthily on it, but if you stop doing it the weight goes back on as with any eating plan.

Steelesauce · 07/01/2022 17:16

My mum lost 7st on slimming world, I lost 3.5. Both of us regained some of that weight but it was due to us eating crap again.

I use slimming world principles now (lots of fruit and veg etc.) But use my fitness pal. It means I can have a life, I can go out to eat and not just have a jacket potato and beans because its 'safe'. I hate keto etc. As it is much more restrictive and I wasn't eating veg when I was on them due to the carbs!! Who gets fat eating broccoli 🤣

Arethechildreninbedyet · 07/01/2022 17:14

I’ve found slimming world is what it is.

Bollocks to it being a lifestyle - it’s a diet and a faddy one at that.

If you need to lose weight quickly it will work but it is not a long term sustainable options. I read an article online where over 75% of the members they spoke to put the weight back on within 2 years I’ll try and find it.

emmathedilemma · 07/01/2022 17:14

I’ve never understood how anyone looses weight on SW! I don’t have that portion control to be able to eat unlimited amounts of foods. I lost 4 stone on Weight watchers and whilst it was a faff having to weigh everything, and I’ll admit I’ve put some of the weight back on, I still keep the habit of weighing portions of carbs.

Stiltonlover · 07/01/2022 17:14

I don't get what people expect from a diet plan then.
You do the diet, you lose the weight = the diet works.
Great.
You then aren't trying to lose weight anymore, so you change your eating habits to....xyz
You put on weight again
And...blame the diet?

tricksyt · 07/01/2022 17:13

My friend has been doing it on and off for years, and she posts photos on Instagram of her meals, that often consist of a big pile of pasta, with low fat cheese and low fat sausages. Confused

She loses 3 stone and then puts it all back on within 6 months.

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 17:12

www.instagram.com/reel/CYW_BM2JHNr/?utm_medium=copy_link

This pretty much sums up my thought process on the whole "scales" side of SW

OP posts:
AllKnowingGerbil · 07/01/2022 17:12

It's a very effective way of losing weight. Keeping it off is up to you I'm afraid.

SirChenjins · 07/01/2022 17:10

This. It's not sustainable and encourages hideous processed food and loads of sugar.

No, it really doesn’t - not if you follow it properly.

It works well if you have a lot of weight to lose, but as soon as you stop it'll all go back on.

Wrong again. I had 1.5 stones to lose. All lost, and stayed off. You’re right on the latter though - just like every single other plan you’ll put weight on when you stop it.

It's really not a healthy way of eating.

Yes it is - if you follow it properly.

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 17:10

And it isn't just 'unlimited pasta' or wall to wall Muller Lights

The name "Free Food" contradicts this, then. Perhaps they should name it something else?

OP posts:
Prinnny · 07/01/2022 17:09

SW only works if you’re fat with lots of weight to lose and have terrible eating habits.

They instil bad habits though, like the cooked fruit is sinful but endless pasta is fine!

SirChenjins · 07/01/2022 17:07

Oops - quoted the wrong post!

Onehotmessiah · 07/01/2022 17:07

It works for people who stick to it (like any diet, plan, lifestyle whatever you want to call it) people who lose 3 stone and then go back to what they were eating before WILL put it back on. I’d say that’s quite obvious. If you can’t adapt your life to that plan, it’s not sustainable (as you said) and so it’s not the plan for you!

SirChenjins · 07/01/2022 17:07

@BarbaraofSeville

Don't they have lots of processed suff and snacks

They're allowed but not compulsory.

You're supposed to make your meals from veg, salad, lean meat, fish, eggs, fruit, pulses, rice, have small amounts of dairy and wholemeal bread and then a very limited amount of obvious junk like crisps, cakes, alcohol, white bread etc.

And what happens when you stop doing Rebelfit and exercising every day of the week, and revert back to your old eating patterns?

That’s right - you put on weight.