Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that slimming world doesn't work?

358 replies

Waifwafer · 07/01/2022 16:43

Many of my friends (including myself) have joined Slimming World over the years. There is a trend - they all lost quite a substantial amount of weight over a relatively short period of time. Kept it off for no more than six months, then ended up putting it all back on... Sometimes more.

Looking at the plan, it doesn't look like a sustainable, long term lifestyle and it doesn't even seem like a healthy way to lose weight. Viewing treats as "syns" seems dangerous. Encouraging in group for members to eat unlimited pasta is ludicrous. It's essentially a calorie deficit just like every other method of losing weight, but encourages members to view food in a negative way.

Also, the whole experience is based on the number on the scales, which may fluctuate week-on-week and not actually be anything to do with fat loss.

AIBU to think that Slimming World is all a big con and doesn't work on a long term basis?

OP posts:
GirlInACountrySong · 07/01/2022 18:56

why just single out slimming world? that stupid macro counting thing,weightwatchers,shakes....all as bad

what about BIWI's LC bootcamps?

TolkiensFallow · 07/01/2022 18:54

Slimming world is a diet. If you do the diet you will lose weight. It does also teach you a little about the need for fibre and a healthy sized dairy portion.

With any diet, if you stop dieting and binge on unhealthy food, you will gain the weight again. It’s not he diets fault. You can eat a little more once you are trying to maintain rather than lose weight but if you revert to pigging out you will gain.

I can’t really see that’s the specific diets fault.

Chely · 07/01/2022 18:49

All these type of plans are the same. Get you in and reliant on them so you keep paying year after year.
I was on ww a few years back, so many users got to goal and would leave only to return having gained weight again. I lost a lot of weight but it made me a bit obsessive over food, I will not be returning to it to lose current excess fat after having baby.

WhiteJellycat · 07/01/2022 18:49

I think saying "it's not a diet" doesn't help the mindset either. Ok so it's a long term lifestyle change so not a diet in that sence but... you shouldn't be in the mindset that you can eat whatever you want. Because in reality you cant. You can whatever you want IN MODERATION. The plan works, but the high level message doest reflect the plan which is 1/3 super low GI with every meal eaten first on the plate the rest low GI and high gi in strict moderation. That's SW in a nutshell

NerrSnerr · 07/01/2022 18:49

I think when people say it doesn't work, they don't mean that if you stick to Slimming World (or weight watchers, noom, Cambridge etc) you won't lose weight, what they mean is that the vast majority people who do these diets will ultimately end up heavier than when they started. That's the reality. Of course there are some success stories and some people do lose weight and keep it off forever but the diet industry rely on the others who pump money into them year after year.

Tania64 · 07/01/2022 18:43

The general plan is quite good but certain things don't make sense such as the SP plan. The reps are not very knowledgeable and success is only measured by what the scales at the meetings say. If you are losing body fat and inches but not actual weight you are deemed a failure so it can knock your confidence. Half of the meetings is spent trying to sell you hi fi bars and cookbooks.

vixeyann · 07/01/2022 18:43

I lost the last bit of baby weight when I went a few years ago but I found the meetings a miserable experience and was just paying a fiver to get weighed. Having to go round the room and say whether you had put on or lost and the ridiculous incentives where they rewarded the biggest loser of the evening. If you only had a few pounds to lose then this was never going to be you. I found it hard to take it seriously as a long term option when the group leader's weight went up and down all the time and she went to another group to keep on track!

JudgeRindersMinder · 07/01/2022 18:41

@melmos

Not the point of this thread but I think the emotion in the responses highlight what a complex issue our relationship with food and weight is both personally and as a society.
Absolutely!
rrhuth · 07/01/2022 18:39

I don't see the issue with it, surely any eating plan that encourages eating lots of fruit/veg, ordinary food and limited sweet/fatty stuff is fine?

I am dubious about dieting full stop but switching to longer term healthy eating is a good move. I don't see what is particularly unhealthy about SW.

The reason people put weight on afterwards is presumably because they revert to their pre-diet eating habits.

TwinkleToesStrikesAgain · 07/01/2022 18:33

I did sw for a while. I stopped going when it was obvious that the leader was putting on weight faster than the rest of us. If she couldn't make it work long term for her, what hope for me?

Newmummytoakitten · 07/01/2022 18:30

@PurpleSky300 the terminology is awful... I hate the groups.... watch the peter kay sketch about it...hilarious... but I have been able to look past it and just use my own words....

I eat crap (syns) and do exercise (body magic) Grin

Sittingonabench · 07/01/2022 18:27

While it didn’t work for me I do disagree. It works - in that people lose weight, it encourages a more balanced approach to food types and so the general person will eat more veg/fruit and drink more water. These are all great things and most people even when they stop carry these things with them. But it is only a structure and it is limited. It will not fix your relationship with food and you need to find your own balance. I know people who have done this but it is hard. I could t work within the framework as a holiday or festive period would throw me off completely but that is down to me not SW

00100001 · 07/01/2022 18:26

People are idiots and don't follow the plan properly and so think it doesn't work.

When in fact it dies work.

It isn't "unlimited pasta" as in, you can't eat 3kg of pasta a day. It's unlimited pasta alongside 1/3 speed on your plate AND listening to your appetite.

bigbluebus · 07/01/2022 18:25

Not only does Slimming World not work - diets don't work. If you're on Facebook look up Rebelfit. I heard about in on Mumsnet so I'm surprised it's not been mentioned. He explains why it doesn't work - and he doesn't mince his words so if you're easily offended maybe don't look!

slashlover · 07/01/2022 18:23

And didn’t they once do an about-turn on Porky Lites? Used to be free, but now not, even though the make up of them hasn’t changed. Ridiculous.

They did the same with sweetener, used to be free but now has a syn value. Unless you think no diet every changes?

slashlover · 07/01/2022 18:19

Ultimately the bosses at slimming world are happy with the model, that most people lose a couple of stone, stop doing it so put on more, remember they lost on slimming world before so join again and the cycle continues forever. This keeps them rich.

There are several people in my group who have stayed at target for 4-7 years. The trick is that they still go to group at least once a month, which is free.

Everyone talks about unlimited pasta but the plan does state a wide variety of foods and 1/3 of the plate of pasta should be veg. Some people will try to cheat any system, I remember my friend doing calorie counting 10 years ago and skipping breakfast so she could have chocolate at night.

DuggeeHugPlease · 07/01/2022 18:18

I found it worked for me, lost 2 stone and stayed at target for about a year - going to weekly weigh ins. I stopped going when groups closed for covid and never went back - but crucially I haven't put the weight back on either.

I don't follow the plan any more but I'm much more aware of what I'm eating and have developed good habits of plating up a third of my plate with vegetables before putting anything else on and I also cut out snacks which has stuck with me.

I like big portions so it appealed to me, it just means I'm eating big portions of lower calorie food and staying full in between meals.

It's not perfect and if you look for loop holes and cheats then it won't be the healthiest but the principles are good.

samwitwicky · 07/01/2022 18:17

Update: I've cancelled my membership.

Thank you @Waifwafer for the post, it helped me realise that SW really isn't for me and just confirmed everything I was thinking in group yesterday.

Postdatedpandemic · 07/01/2022 18:14

My everyday diet (as in food consumed) sounds just like @slashlover 's SW diet.
Easy, filling and sustainable (for the person and the planet)

As part of my job I have to encourage people to follow the dieticians advice. The ones who succeed are the ones who learn to like vegetables.

melmos · 07/01/2022 18:11

Throw at us Blush

melmos · 07/01/2022 18:10

Posted too soon but I think a lot of this would be alleviated if we had less snobbery around it, most of us just trying our best while trying to deal with what our lives through at us

Fuckaduck21 · 07/01/2022 18:09

I followed SW for 9 months (never went to a group because it really isn't my kind if thing), researched the plan and took some elements from it, and lost 6 stone. I've kept it off for around 2 years so far. Its bloody hard keeping the weight off, harder than losing it!! I think it worked for me because I actually think about what I'm eating before I eat it.
I have found an amazing website called slimming eats and I meal plan off that.

WhiteJellycat · 07/01/2022 18:08

Not sure about now as not been for years, but it was based on low GI. So if your plate is one third super free ( ie GI close to zero food) then in theory the rest could be pasta BUT you have to eat a whole little gem to counteract a butt ton of pasta. But I'm.not sure that is how people do it for every meal ( is 1/3 salad with bolognese, 1/3 broccoli or cabbage with a roast, 1/3 low sugar fruit with breakfast).

In reality I think people think the free food was fill your boots, not bulking out with negligible low gi food.

Because the words GI and calories is never mentioned so how can most people keep it up?

In theory you cant eat two jacket potatoes IF you eat 4 little gems first.

melmos · 07/01/2022 18:04

Not the point of this thread but I think the emotion in the responses highlight what a complex issue our relationship with food and weight is both personally and as a society.

Lipsandlashes · 07/01/2022 18:04

I think Slimming World is absolutely awful, for the reasons you have given. It’s like a cult to members though. Also I’ve got PCOS so if I ate unlimited pasta I’d be the size of a house!