Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave isolation when I'm getting a blazing positive LFT (on Day 10)

59 replies

TeddySteady · 07/01/2022 14:48

I really don't understand why I'm still testing positive with such a strong line. I was only mildly ill and my symptoms cleared up days ago. I know the official advice is that you're free to go at the end of the 10-day period. And that if you get 2 negatives 24 hours apart on days 6 and 7 then you're also free to go on your way. But Whitty muddied the waters the other day when he suggested a LFT is a good indicator of infectiousness and you should keep isolating till you get a negative. And I've read that PCRs can pick up dead virus for up to 90 days but that a LFT detects infectious virus. Does anyone know what's what? So confused and I really don't want to mingle with people if there's a chance I'm still infectious....

OP posts:
HamCob · 07/01/2022 16:36

DH was contacted by test & trace several times during his isolation. He still felt rubbish on Day 8 and asked the T&T staff if he should still continue to isolate past the 10 days if he felt unwell. They told him that as long as he didn't have a fever/temp he shouldn't be infectious.

blackcurrantjam · 07/01/2022 16:34

The ten day thing is because NO live virus was found after day 9 in study. Not infectious. Think about it. Viruses don't work like that?!

WorraLiberty · 07/01/2022 16:32

Honestly OP, I could have written this.

I'm in exactly the same position. My isolation was up yesterday and my LFT went straight to bright red today.

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 16:29

OP symptoms are a better sign of infectiousness on day 10 than lateral flow tests. So if you are running a fever or vomiting, or feel terrible then go back to bed (coughing and loss of smell/taste can last for weeks so you can ignore those).

When I first had COVID in March_April 2020, day 10 -14 were the worst. I'm sure I was infectious then.

Choccyp1g · 07/01/2022 16:29

I actually felt fine on day 6, the very day the announced the "2 negative tests rule", but came up with a very strong positive. Faint positive the next day, didn't bother testing again, and stayed home till day 11.

Choccyp1g · 07/01/2022 16:26

@Clueless2000

It really concerns me that there is so much confusion about this. Can the government communicate anything clearly, FFS.

@Choccyp1g so are you saying that you think people cannot stop isolating until they test negative - even if that’s beyond 10 days? Because I’m certain that is not the case. I’m not having a go, by the way, just trying to work out what you mean.

What I was trying to say is that we don't really know.
Ideally we'd have a test that shows whether you are infectious. Then it would be simple: if you are too ill too work, stay at home.
While you are infectious, isolate. Otherwise, general social distancing, masks etc. for everyone.

The problem at the moment is that people are infectious before they feel unwell, and even if they test regularly, they may be infectious before it shows up as positive.

Similarly, you may be infectious after you feel better, and may or may not continue to test positive.

Momof2boys1girl · 07/01/2022 16:21

@noworklifebalance

NHS advice to staff (caveat: I don’t work in the NHS*) is:
  • not to test again even if positive on day 6
  • to return to work after day 10 if symptom-free (except for cough that can persist)
  • & no need to repeat the lateral flow on day 10

*was head scratching with a friend trying to figure this out whilst she waited for confirmation from her manager.

I work for the nhs and I was positive on day 6&7, I’ve been told from day 10 to test and can go back when I get a negative
GullyGawk · 07/01/2022 16:18

Where I live it was 10 daya isolation at first, now it’s 7 days but they are thinking of changing it to 5. Unless you still feel unwell of course, then you stay at home just like with everything else. It’s weird the rules aren’t the same, it’s the same virus.

Clueless2000 · 07/01/2022 16:17

It really concerns me that there is so much confusion about this. Can the government communicate anything clearly, FFS.

@Choccyp1g so are you saying that you think people cannot stop isolating until they test negative - even if that’s beyond 10 days? Because I’m certain that is not the case. I’m not having a go, by the way, just trying to work out what you mean.

ExcuseeeeMe · 07/01/2022 16:17

@shoofly

If there's any chance you're still infectious (as supposedly evidenced by a positive Lft) then why on earth would you Not still isolate?
Because lots of people don’t have the privilege to work from home maybe .
Choccyp1g · 07/01/2022 16:15

Or did they catch it from asymptomatic cases, which means they should use PPE in the NON-Covid wards, and not bother in the COVID positive areas.

Choccyp1g · 07/01/2022 16:14

Clueless2000 Fri 07-Jan-22 15:59:17
Yes what Chris Whitty said was confusing but to be fair, I don’t think he finished his sentence.
Positive test does not necessarily = infectious. After 10 days you will not be infectious anymore even if you’re still testing positive.

If it was as simple as this, so many doctors and nurses would not have caught it from COVID patients in hospital, as it usually takes more than 10 days from infection to hospitalisation.

CovidForChristmas · 07/01/2022 16:07

You only have to continue to isolate after 10 days if you have a temperature.
Otherwise you are free from day 11 regardless.

TrophyWinner · 07/01/2022 16:06

This is only the case for PCR not LFT.

No it wasn't. I was involved in the set up of school testing, always LFT, and instructed not to test myself as I'd been ill less than 90 days previously

WreckTangled · 07/01/2022 16:04

@noworklifebalance

NHS advice to staff (caveat: I don’t work in the NHS*) is:
  • not to test again even if positive on day 6
  • to return to work after day 10 if symptom-free (except for cough that can persist)
  • & no need to repeat the lateral flow on day 10

*was head scratching with a friend trying to figure this out whilst she waited for confirmation from her manager.

This isn't the advice in my trust or on the government website (for health and social care staff).

It clearly states you can return to work if you have two consecutive negative LFT's 24 hours apart starting from day six. You cannot return to work after ten days unless you have a single negative lft result.

Also it's after ten days of isolation, not day 10 of isolation and day 1 is the day after symptoms/positive test (whichever is first) Confused no wonder we're all so confused.

Pedalpushers · 07/01/2022 16:03

Oh I also meant to say you are still infectious but at nowhere near the same level, unless you are really getting up in someone's grill you won't pass it on.

Pedalpushers · 07/01/2022 16:01

@TrophyWinner

When I had covid, a year ago, I was told not to test for 90 days and the result would likely be positive. Yes you can go out now if you are well.
This is only the case for PCR not LFT.

You are almost certainly still infectious. The reason why it isn't the official government advice is because it's more confusing and difficult for people and businesses to work around when the vast majority of people will no longer be infectious after the 10 day isolation.

Clueless2000 · 07/01/2022 16:00

Bugger sorry- that should say “but if you get two negatives from day 6 onwards you are highly unlikely to STILL be infectious”

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 16:00

@Clueless2000 said what I was trying to but much better!

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 15:59

One of my friends (healthcare worker) took over a month to test negative on LFTs after she had covid. She definitely couldn't have isolated for that time!

I think my understanding is that you're only infectious at the start of the infection (like with many other bugs). Leaving isolation early based on a negative LFT is just if you happen to be among the lucky ones whose infection levels drop off really quickly so there's no point waiting until day 10. And that for most people, even if you're still showing positive on an LFT after day 10, you're far enough past the point where you're infectious that it's OK to head out.

noworklifebalance · 07/01/2022 15:59

NHS advice to staff (caveat: I don’t work in the NHS*) is:

  • not to test again even if positive on day 6
  • to return to work after day 10 if symptom-free (except for cough that can persist)
  • & no need to repeat the lateral flow on day 10

*was head scratching with a friend trying to figure this out whilst she waited for confirmation from her manager.

Clueless2000 · 07/01/2022 15:59

Yes what Chris Whitty said was confusing but to be fair, I don’t think he finished his sentence.

Positive test does not necessarily = infectious. After 10 days you will not be infectious anymore even if you’re still testing positive. BUT if you get 2 negatives from day 6 onwards, you are highly unlikely to not be infectious so can stop isolating. Equally, if you get 2 positives from day 6 onwards you MIGHT not be infectious anymore but there’s no clear way of telling so that’s why you wait till the full 10 days if your LFTs are still positive before then, as by day 10 you’re definitely safe.

wishful2012 · 07/01/2022 15:54

Am coming up on 10 days so am wondering this too. The fact the you just need a lft now instead of a pcr doesn’t this mean it should be negative before you leave isolation. Am lost

Brightwell12 · 07/01/2022 15:53

I'm in the same postion, going back to work on Monday but told to test daily. (nhs)

HermioneWeasley · 07/01/2022 15:50

There is no requirement for a clear test after the 10 days are complete and if you don’t have a temperature

Swipe left for the next trending thread