Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave isolation when I'm getting a blazing positive LFT (on Day 10)

59 replies

TeddySteady · 07/01/2022 14:48

I really don't understand why I'm still testing positive with such a strong line. I was only mildly ill and my symptoms cleared up days ago. I know the official advice is that you're free to go at the end of the 10-day period. And that if you get 2 negatives 24 hours apart on days 6 and 7 then you're also free to go on your way. But Whitty muddied the waters the other day when he suggested a LFT is a good indicator of infectiousness and you should keep isolating till you get a negative. And I've read that PCRs can pick up dead virus for up to 90 days but that a LFT detects infectious virus. Does anyone know what's what? So confused and I really don't want to mingle with people if there's a chance I'm still infectious....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MatildaTheCat · 08/01/2022 18:08

There are some well informed people on this thread so may I piggyback on with a query?

I’m day 12. Was pretty unwell for about 8 days. Very, very slight cough. Finally tested negative on day 10 and felt good to go.

Day 11 I developed a filthy cough and shortness of breath on exertion. I can go long periods without coughing but then cough a lot. Small amount of chest pain on coughing occasionally.

Is this a new illness caught from goodness knows where since I haven’t been anywhere? Or a new stage of covid albeit uninfectious?

NumberTheory · 08/01/2022 17:39

I do understand what you’re saying and I appreciate that some things in life are not black and white. However, what I’m trying to establish is whether a LFT test can show a positive result with ‘dead’ virus or whether a red line means you’re likely infectious. It seems hard to discover that info and there must be a yes or no answer.

Yes, LFTs can pick up “dead” viral particles and show positive after you’ve stopped being infectious. LFTs detect proteins on the surface of the virus. They can (but won’t necessarily) show up long after the virus has been neutralized and you are no longer infectious.

A lay explanation from MIT’s medial school is in this article.

Aozora13 · 08/01/2022 09:38

I was in the same position and agree it’s completely unclear. I have scoured the internet and still none the wiser about it. My parents were due to visit on day 11 when I was still testing positive. They decided they still wanted to come, and are still testing negative after a week so I’m taking that as a completely unscientific indication that I was no longer infectious. In the end I decided to stop testing and go with the guidelines.

TeddySteady · 08/01/2022 09:28

People like to understand rules in terms of categorising things as safe or unsafe, but there's no binary distinctions here. In the same way that there was no rational justification why 6 people were safe to meet together as lockdown eased but 7 people weren't allowed, but nevertheless that was the line that was drawn to get people to reduce the amount of household mixing. In the same way that standing 1.9m away from someone is really broadly similar in risk to standing 2.1m away.

I do understand what you’re saying and I appreciate that some things in life are not black and white. However, what I’m trying to establish is whether a LFT test can show a positive result with ‘dead’ virus or whether a red line means you’re likely infectious. It seems hard to discover that info and there must be a yes or no answer.

Also, I’m curious what the virus lingering on with a long-lasting positive result means. Does it mean you had a high viral load? Some people on here are talking about getting a positive result for several weeks. Could it be linked to long covid or anything like that?

I’m now on day 11 and still as positive as ever. I know I’m free to go but I do wonder what it means, given I had a mild symptoms and they disappeared days ago.

OP posts:
blackcurrantjam · 08/01/2022 09:22

[quote WreckTangled]@blackcurrantjam thank you that's really interesting. I wonder why government guidelines are saying that health and social care staff shouldn't return to work until a negative LFT Hmm [/quote]
You're welcome. I don't know. It's all a bit Hmm with the latest change from whitty. On one hand he said the lfts are good at infection control but failed to mention the 10 day thing alongside it plus he dodged the 90 day question which was annoying which had people not testing for 90days because of potential for positive results that were non infectious positives

Tbh I think if Omicron continues to be relatively mild, they're going to have to allow people out covid or not.

BuanoKubiamVej · 08/01/2022 08:31

People like to understand rules in terms of categorising things as safe or unsafe, but there's no binary distinctions here. In the same way that there was no rational justification why 6 people were safe to meet together as lockdown eased but 7 people weren't allowed, but nevertheless that was the line that was drawn to get people to reduce the amount of household mixing. In the same way that standing 1.9m away from someone is really broadly similar in risk to standing 2.1m away.

When you are infected with covid you will be at peak infectiousness about 5 days after infection and will then get gradually less infectious. The 10 days isn't a cutoff after which you are safe and before which you are an unacceptable risk. It's a line drawn as a sensible balance between reducing the risk to a reasonable level vs the harms that are done when normal activities aren't allowed.

You've completed your 10 days so no longer have to isolate. Given that you still have positive LFTs I would think it would be wise to be a little more rigorous about wearing your face mask when mixing with others, and not going to anything like a theatre or concert just yet, or visiting anyone vulnerable unless the harm done by you not visiting outweighs the relatively modest risk that you might still be a little bit infectious. Expecting people to fully isolate until they get a negative even if that takes a month is an unreasonable balance and is asking too much.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunonono · 08/01/2022 08:17

@shoofly

If there's any chance you're still infectious (as supposedly evidenced by a positive Lft) then why on earth would you Not still isolate?
Do you have to ask?
WreckTangled · 08/01/2022 07:57

@blackcurrantjam thank you that's really interesting. I wonder why government guidelines are saying that health and social care staff shouldn't return to work until a negative LFT Hmm

CheshireCats · 07/01/2022 22:21

@shoofly
Because some of us don't get sick pay, can't work from home/didn't get furlough (self employed) and don't earn any money for the whole isolation period. Because we still have to buy food and pay the bills. The fuel bills that are higher because we're in all the time isolating.
Ffs- some people have not got a clue how other people struggle.

blackcurrantjam · 07/01/2022 22:18

After day 10 sorry, ten full days

blackcurrantjam · 07/01/2022 22:18

[quote Porcupineintherough]@blackcurrantjam that's not true. In most people, esp asymptomatic or mildly ill, there is no live virus at day 10. In a small percentage of people there is, esp if they are seriously ill or unvaccinated (or both). If you are still running g a fever on day 10 fi you need to stay in quarantine.[/quote]
Yes probably although I think people are so unlikely to be infectious and quarantine so awful that if they're ok then at day 10 they're good to go

blackcurrantjam · 07/01/2022 22:14

@WreckTangled review: www.thelancet.com/journals/lanmic/article/PIIS2666-5247(20)30172-5/fulltext

wintersdreams · 07/01/2022 17:49

I tested positive on a LFT for 6 weeks after I had covid- I double checked with my GP and she said it was fine to leave isolation as long as I didn’t have a fever

LethargicActress · 07/01/2022 17:49

Follow the rules and get yourself out.

Orangebonbon · 07/01/2022 17:45

You can still be infectious and test positive for 90 days after covid.

NumberTheory · 07/01/2022 17:42

I’m coming up on 10 days and have wondered the same thing (have also been given a huge amount of “we made it up ourselves” advice from HCPs, which has been annoying (before anyone jumps to the NHS’s defense, I’m currently in the US).

What I’ve discovered from all my probing is that although there is still SARs virus in your system, scientists have not been able to culture replicating virus from patients past 10 days unless those patients have been severely ill (when it can be 20+ days). The most common definition of “severely ill” I’ve seen is that you require hospital treatment.

So you can still have virus in your system, but it can’t replicate so it doesn’t matter if you pass it on to others because it can’t make them sick.

However, I haven’t seen an explanation for why having a fever at day 10 requires you to wait longer, even if you haven’t been hospitalized. So I’m still reading.

Meggie2008 · 07/01/2022 17:41

My LFT was positive until day 13. I was paranoid and didn't go out, but thankfully it was negative on the Sunday so I could go back t the office on the Monday

TeddySteady · 07/01/2022 17:28

@housemaus

You should be fine!

The CDC says there's an increased, but still small, chance you could be potentially still infectious past 10 days if you had the illness quite severely or were severely immunocompromised (here).

Otherwise after 10 days from the first positive test (and you've had no fever for over 24 hours) you're all good regardless of the LFT.

The LFT detects the presence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA - they're reacting with specific molecules on the surface of the virus. In that sense, you getting a positive now isn't actually a 'false' positive - they tend to be reasonably accurate in that sense. You are likely to still have virus in your system, and it's showing that.

However, the amount of virus in your system (and some other stuff) affects whether or not you'd be able to infect someone else, and by day 10 you probably can't, hence why it's a 10 day isolation.

I assume the thinking behind the 6/7 day testing and early release is that if by then you're not harbouring enough virus to test positive you've not got enough to infect anyone either.

@housemaus Thank you, that is a helpful explanation.
OP posts:
housemaus · 07/01/2022 17:19

You should be fine!

The CDC says there's an increased, but still small, chance you could be potentially still infectious past 10 days if you had the illness quite severely or were severely immunocompromised (here).

Otherwise after 10 days from the first positive test (and you've had no fever for over 24 hours) you're all good regardless of the LFT.

The LFT detects the presence of SARS-CoV-2 RNA - they're reacting with specific molecules on the surface of the virus. In that sense, you getting a positive now isn't actually a 'false' positive - they tend to be reasonably accurate in that sense. You are likely to still have virus in your system, and it's showing that.

However, the amount of virus in your system (and some other stuff) affects whether or not you'd be able to infect someone else, and by day 10 you probably can't, hence why it's a 10 day isolation.

I assume the thinking behind the 6/7 day testing and early release is that if by then you're not harbouring enough virus to test positive you've not got enough to infect anyone either.

GoLittleRockstar · 07/01/2022 17:09

There will always be outliers who are infectious past ten days. It’s a guide not gospel.

noworklifebalance · 07/01/2022 17:06

@TeddySteady

As I thought, it really is as clear as mud! There doesn’t seem to be any clear consensus at all.
This
noworklifebalance · 07/01/2022 17:06

noworklifebalance
NHS advice to staff (caveat: I don’t work in the NHS) is:*
- not to test again even if positive on day 6
- to return to work after day 10 if symptom-free (except for cough that can persist)
- & no need to repeat the lateral flow on day 10

*was head scratching with a friend trying to figure this out whilst she waited for confirmation from her manager.

I work for the nhs and I was positive on day 6&7, I’ve been told from day 10 to test and can go back when I get a negative

Sounds like NHS Trusts are giving slightly differing advice.

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 17:06

@blackcurrantjam that's not true. In most people, esp asymptomatic or mildly ill, there is no live virus at day 10. In a small percentage of people there is, esp if they are seriously ill or unvaccinated (or both). If you are still running g a fever on day 10 fi you need to stay in quarantine.

TeddySteady · 07/01/2022 17:02

As I thought, it really is as clear as mud! There doesn’t seem to be any clear consensus at all.

OP posts:
WreckTangled · 07/01/2022 16:39

@blackcurrantjam

The ten day thing is because NO live virus was found after day 9 in study. Not infectious. Think about it. Viruses don't work like that?!
Have you got a link to that study please?