Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rear facing car seat placed front facing in DPs mum's car

135 replies

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 13:01

DD is 8 months old and uses the car seat which is group 0+ (I think that's the one anyway). It's a rear facing one and one that comes with the buggy when buying the travel system.

I don't drive so this hardly get used unless I take a cab to go somewhere which is rare. DD only really uses the car seat when her grandma (on her dad's side) picks her up for the day. Today her grandma picked her up and DP took DD downstairs in the buggy and put the car seat in the back the usual rear facing way.

I'm nosy so I always look out my window to see what's going on and because the car seat is quite bulky so sometimes it's a struggle for DP to strap her in. Anyway! I saw a few words were exchanged and DP turned DD's car seat around so she was front facing and they got ready to drive off. I called him straight away and said she can't be that way in that type of car seat and they need to change her round. I said the seat belt goes around the back of the seat, you can't just have it across her lap and that he basically hadn't strapped her in properly. He said alright then changed it back the correct way. I could see his mum had a lot to say about it (surprise surprise).

I just texted him reminding him to make sure DD is always as safe as possible and to please not do that again. He said they did it because she cries when facing the seat which made me think maybe they've done this before(?) I'm planning to speak to him when he comes back (nothing serious, more of a 'you can't do that in this type of car seat' chat) but was starting to think if I've got it wrong or if I'm being unreasonable?

I don't have a car or drive so again I don't know the law regarding these things. I did have a look on Google and Gov and it seems that to be front facing you need a different type of seat and DC has to be above a certain weight but I'm starting to doubt myself especially as his mum had something to say. So tell me MN, AIBU here or just being 'precious?'

If I am, what's the correct way when it comes to car seats?

OP posts:
NotVictorianHonestly · 07/01/2022 15:46

But if you tell her to get a 360 car seat she'll just use it to have her rear facing, which is bloody dangerous at her age. I'm sorry to be blunt, but the chance of her surviving an is reduced by front facing.

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 15:43

@girlmom21 exactly, that's my point. Imagine they had an accident and DD was worse off because they'd purposely turned her car seat around. Saying, 'I didn't know' isn't going t cut it. And thank you, I knew because it's my job to know. I don't have a car, I don't drive and yet I still knew. It's pathetic really

OP posts:
bantuknots · 07/01/2022 15:41

@Skeumorph

That's absolutely appalling.

It's not enough to say they/he 'didn't know'. He did know: you've been using that seat 8 months, he knows how it fits in, he knows how the seat works.

What happened was he went to fit the seat correctly and his mum overruled him in order to have things the way she prefers.

The fact that he was ok with seeing his tiny daughter driven away with a seat belt over her lap would be it - trust gone.

No more out of your sight and in MIL's care alas. She can't be trusted.

Thank you! @Skeumorph you've put all of my thoughts into one post.

That's exactly it. He placed her down the correct way, his mum says a few words and now she's facing the front? What the actual hell. That's not okay at all.

The fact that he was ok with seeing his tiny daughter driven away with a seat belt over her lap would be it - trust gone.

This is exactly what my mum said! Both of the adults were strapped in safely but our little baby is the only one not strapped in properly? Disgusting.

I think I'll look for a new car seat that DPs mum can buy for her car. Probably a 360 one and one DD can use for a few years and will say that until his mum has bought that, she won't be picking up DD. I don't like her as it is but to put her one and only grandchild in a position where she's unsafe, it's a joke

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 07/01/2022 15:40

What a pair of idiots. Thank goodness nothing happened so far!

NotVictorianHonestly · 07/01/2022 15:21

They should be kept rear facing as long as possible and there's no way on earth I'd let my child front face before two at the very earliest. Even then I intend to keep them RF until 4 if at all possible.

Can you imagine if you knowingly let them forward face and then they were seriously injured or killed when they would have been much more likely to survive rear facing? Horrendous.

You can get mirrors to hang on the rear seat by the way that help baby to look around and reduce tears.

girlmom21 · 07/01/2022 15:15

@bantuknots

This is her partner and MIL purposefully and knowing incorrectly installing a baby carrier in a way so dangerous that the slightest bump could have been lethal.

I don't actually think my partner knew how dangerous it is but it's seemed that they've done this before so I don't actually care!
That's also not how the car seat is meant to be used, it's honestly common sense. Very annoyed at the both of them and they should have known better

It doesn't matter if he claims he doesn't know how dangerous it was. He's a parent. It's his job to know. You knew.
Skeumorph · 07/01/2022 15:14

That's absolutely appalling.

It's not enough to say they/he 'didn't know'. He did know: you've been using that seat 8 months, he knows how it fits in, he knows how the seat works.

What happened was he went to fit the seat correctly and his mum overruled him in order to have things the way she prefers.

The fact that he was ok with seeing his tiny daughter driven away with a seat belt over her lap would be it - trust gone.

No more out of your sight and in MIL's care alas. She can't be trusted.

CaveMum · 07/01/2022 15:10

Totally unacceptable. If MIL has problems getting her in/out of the seat you (or she !) can but seats that rotate to face the door to get in and out and then turn back to rear face and later to forward face.

My two were in Cybex Sirona seats that do this from about 10 months, rear facing till about 3 and then turned to forward face for about another year. They’re not cheap seats by any stretch but you do get several years use out of them.

colourfulpuddles · 07/01/2022 15:08

I wouldn’t allow them to take her again.

It’s 5 times safer for children up to 4 years of age to rear face.

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 15:07

This is her partner and MIL purposefully and knowing incorrectly installing a baby carrier in a way so dangerous that the slightest bump could have been lethal.

I don't actually think my partner knew how dangerous it is but it's seemed that they've done this before so I don't actually care!
That's also not how the car seat is meant to be used, it's honestly common sense. Very annoyed at the both of them and they should have known better

OP posts:
bantuknots · 07/01/2022 15:05

@APineForestInWinter

This is very worrying. Most people are extra-cautious with other peoples babies. If she's being blasé about a clear safety issue like this, what else? The main issue is that she thinks she knows better than the law, she doesn't seem to respect your role as parents, and your husband seems to prefer to keep her happy than keep his child safe. Even if it's wasn't the law, or the seat was designed for both rear and forward facing, she should follow your preferences and decisions. But she has chosen to break the law and use the seat in a manner that it wasn't designed for. If a paid babysitter did this you'd sack them.
Yes this is it. I suspect DP has also done this just to shut his mum up and let her see DD whenever she turns around. However when doing this he's literally put his own child in danger. Everyone in the car will be strapped in properly yet my poor baby would only have a seatbelt over her legs and that's it? So unacceptable
OP posts:
bantuknots · 07/01/2022 15:02

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I am not sure if I'm getting the wrong end of the stick or everyone else is bit the way I'm reading it, this isnt a forward facing van rear facing seat debate...

My understanding is your seat is a rear facing seat only not an adaptable or swivel seat. And so they're effectively just using it backwards in a way that it's not designed to be used and therefore even if you believe forward facing seats are ok, in this case it's still not safe as it's not designed for this purpose.

I'd be absolutely fuming that your husband thought this was ok

@DrinkFeckArseBrick yes this is exactly it.

Tbf I didn't even know people had rear facing/front facing debates so that's definitely not what I wanted to start. It's the fact that this is a rear facing car seat ONLY and they've purposely used it incorrectly. It's so dangerous and so ridiculous that they'd do this

OP posts:
LakeShoreD · 07/01/2022 14:09

I am not sure if I'm getting the wrong end of the stick or everyone else is bit the way I'm reading it, this isnt a forward facing van rear facing seat debate...
Exactly this. We are not talking about a correctly installed convertible seat that OP’s baby was a bit too young to go forward facing in. This is her partner and MIL purposefully and knowing incorrectly installing a baby carrier in a way so dangerous that the slightest bump could have been lethal. What age you would turn a child forward, in a correctly installed seat, is totally irrelevant to what happened here.

APineForestInWinter · 07/01/2022 14:04

This is very worrying. Most people are extra-cautious with other peoples babies. If she's being blasé about a clear safety issue like this, what else?
The main issue is that she thinks she knows better than the law, she doesn't seem to respect your role as parents, and your husband seems to prefer to keep her happy than keep his child safe.
Even if it's wasn't the law, or the seat was designed for both rear and forward facing, she should follow your preferences and decisions. But she has chosen to break the law and use the seat in a manner that it wasn't designed for. If a paid babysitter did this you'd sack them.

liveforsummer · 07/01/2022 14:04

@Staryflight445 not in the front in an infant carrier FACING the front in an infant carrier (on the back seat)

liveforsummer · 07/01/2022 14:03

Rear facing is technically safer than FF for everyone, not just up to age 6, but in reality its not practically possible and the rate of accidents in the UK is low so you are reducing a risk that is very very small to begin with.

I've always wondered why they don't just stick the back seats in the other way around these days. Surely that's an option

Staryflight445 · 07/01/2022 14:02

Is she in the front in an infant carrier op? Has she even turned the air bag off? Incredibly dangerous if she hasn’t.
An air bag blow can kill an under 16.
Plus not to mention the dangers of not using an infant carrier correctly.
Your mil is the driver and is legally obliged to be following the law. If she cannot do this she shouldn’t be driving your child around.

liveforsummer · 07/01/2022 14:01

@Staryflight445

It’s dangerous and illegal. You cannot legally FF until 15months.
You can. In the old style car seats that ff at 9kg. Plenty 8 month olds are 9kg. Not best or safe practice but at least what the seats are designed for.
DeepaBeesKit · 07/01/2022 14:01

Despite the minimum legal age I believe it’s safer to rear face until the age of 6

This kind of comment is annoying because the RF seats that will fit all but the shortest torso 6 year olds are huge and just don't fit in the compact cars we often drive in the UK unless you only have one child & no front passenger and can get the passenger seat very far forward.

Rear facing is technically safer than FF for everyone, not just up to age 6, but in reality its not practically possible and the rate of accidents in the UK is low so you are reducing a risk that is very very small to begin with.

liveforsummer · 07/01/2022 14:00

Agree with @DrinkFeckArseBrick this is far beyond the ff rf thing. Those arguments are irrelevant when it's an infant carrier. That should ever be ff no matter the age or weight of the child. It's in no way designed to be. Had they put a sturdy 8 month old in a seat designed for 9kg ff it would have been bad but what they did is awful

girlmom21 · 07/01/2022 13:57

@ZoBo123 they can go in the front but it's nowhere near as safe

Nanny0gg · 07/01/2022 13:55

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

I am not sure if I'm getting the wrong end of the stick or everyone else is bit the way I'm reading it, this isnt a forward facing van rear facing seat debate...

My understanding is your seat is a rear facing seat only not an adaptable or swivel seat. And so they're effectively just using it backwards in a way that it's not designed to be used and therefore even if you believe forward facing seats are ok, in this case it's still not safe as it's not designed for this purpose.

I'd be absolutely fuming that your husband thought this was ok

I think you're reading it right.

Rear facing car seat being used incorrectly.

Therefore extremely dangerous in an accident.

Staryflight445 · 07/01/2022 13:42

It’s dangerous and illegal.
You cannot legally FF until 15months.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 07/01/2022 13:42

I am not sure if I'm getting the wrong end of the stick or everyone else is bit the way I'm reading it, this isnt a forward facing van rear facing seat debate...

My understanding is your seat is a rear facing seat only not an adaptable or swivel seat. And so they're effectively just using it backwards in a way that it's not designed to be used and therefore even if you believe forward facing seats are ok, in this case it's still not safe as it's not designed for this purpose.

I'd be absolutely fuming that your husband thought this was ok

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 13:37

@MadeForThis

They could have killed her. Even a small crash with the belt across the babies stomach could be fatal.

It sounds like they have did this before. Do you trust them not to do it again?

I'm asking myself the same thing. DP will understand when I speak to him but if he insinuates I'm overreacting or anything of the sort, I'll say his mum can only visit DD at our house. I think I'll have a chat with my mum and see what she says
OP posts: