Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rear facing car seat placed front facing in DPs mum's car

135 replies

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 13:01

DD is 8 months old and uses the car seat which is group 0+ (I think that's the one anyway). It's a rear facing one and one that comes with the buggy when buying the travel system.

I don't drive so this hardly get used unless I take a cab to go somewhere which is rare. DD only really uses the car seat when her grandma (on her dad's side) picks her up for the day. Today her grandma picked her up and DP took DD downstairs in the buggy and put the car seat in the back the usual rear facing way.

I'm nosy so I always look out my window to see what's going on and because the car seat is quite bulky so sometimes it's a struggle for DP to strap her in. Anyway! I saw a few words were exchanged and DP turned DD's car seat around so she was front facing and they got ready to drive off. I called him straight away and said she can't be that way in that type of car seat and they need to change her round. I said the seat belt goes around the back of the seat, you can't just have it across her lap and that he basically hadn't strapped her in properly. He said alright then changed it back the correct way. I could see his mum had a lot to say about it (surprise surprise).

I just texted him reminding him to make sure DD is always as safe as possible and to please not do that again. He said they did it because she cries when facing the seat which made me think maybe they've done this before(?) I'm planning to speak to him when he comes back (nothing serious, more of a 'you can't do that in this type of car seat' chat) but was starting to think if I've got it wrong or if I'm being unreasonable?

I don't have a car or drive so again I don't know the law regarding these things. I did have a look on Google and Gov and it seems that to be front facing you need a different type of seat and DC has to be above a certain weight but I'm starting to doubt myself especially as his mum had something to say. So tell me MN, AIBU here or just being 'precious?'

If I am, what's the correct way when it comes to car seats?

OP posts:
bantuknots · 07/01/2022 21:15

Wow. Just wow.

So DP came back with DD whilst she was asleep. His mum was waiting downstairs so he went to say by to her. Before he left I said, 'so wait is that the first time you went to put her facing forward or have you done that before?' He said, 'it was the first time....no actually we might have done it once before.'

I said how dangerous that was, it wasn't allowed in that type of car seat and his mum could get a fine if she was ever stopped. He just looked at my blankly. I said, 'you can't even strap her in properly as the seatbelt needs to go across the back of the car seat.' He got defensive and said 'she was strapped in properly. I can't remember how but they made it work.' I said, 'it's literally not possible.' He said, 'it's fine because my sister was with her in the back anyway.'
I completely forgot his sister was also in the car sitting at the back. I couldn't see her from the window so apologies for that!
It's also not as if his sister could magically save DD if they ever got into an accident anyway.

Then I said 'are you even sorry?' He said 'er yeah i'm sorry' (with a completely mI'm not sorry at all' expression on his face). I told him to get out of my house and said that his mum isn't having DD again. He just sighed and left.

I started crying when he left (think the pregnancy hormones got the better of me) but I just couldn't believe how unsorry he was when we're talking about his daughter's safety here. I know he thinks I'm overreacting. Because mummy dearest has says it's fine then it must be. What a prick!

OP posts:
saraclara · 07/01/2022 20:46

[quote bantuknots]@saraclara that argument is invalid because if her grandm wanted to see her so badly, she could easily bought a mirror herself.
As I said, I don't drive nor do I have a car. I didn't even know these mirrors were a thing until people suggested them in the comments on here. DD's grandma also could have asked me to buy a mirror or say something about wanting to see her granddaughter whilst she's in the back.

DP could also sit with her at the back to stop her crying as she'll be seeing a familiar face but clearly he rather that he stretches out his legs in the front.

Fwiw, whenever DD is in a cab or any type of car, she loves it. Always fall asleep during the journey and enjoys looking outside the window. How can I do anything about her crying when no one's even told me she cries whilst in the car?[/quote]
I didn't even realise that those mirrors existed, when I first had to drive alone with my DGD.

I didn't pick up that OP's partner was in the car throughout the journey from the OP. If that was the case, then yes, of course he should have sat in the back with his DC if there was no mirror.

inheritancetrack · 07/01/2022 20:25

The mum probably wasn't aware of the safety of rear facing seats and just assumed it was put in wrong. DP should have been better informed and insisted on the correct usage.

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 20:18

@saraclara that argument is invalid because if her grandm wanted to see her so badly, she could easily bought a mirror herself.
As I said, I don't drive nor do I have a car. I didn't even know these mirrors were a thing until people suggested them in the comments on here. DD's grandma also could have asked me to buy a mirror or say something about wanting to see her granddaughter whilst she's in the back.

DP could also sit with her at the back to stop her crying as she'll be seeing a familiar face but clearly he rather that he stretches out his legs in the front.

Fwiw, whenever DD is in a cab or any type of car, she loves it. Always fall asleep during the journey and enjoys looking outside the window. How can I do anything about her crying when no one's even told me she cries whilst in the car?

OP posts:
saraclara · 07/01/2022 20:06

Did you provide your MIL with a mirror? I found it absolutely terrifying driving with my DGD in rear facing seat. Not being able to see that she was okay was so awfully worrying and counter intuitive, as I'd always been able to see my babies/toddlers when I drove then anywhere.

I'm not excusing MIL here if the seat could not be fitted properly as a ff seat, but if you don't provide her with a means to see your baby, your argument is going to be more difficult.

Lou98 · 07/01/2022 19:47

@G5000 @ffscovid while I don't personally agree with that poster having their baby FF at 8 months, any seat that isn't an isize can be FF from 9kg, my son was 9kg at 6 months so plenty of 8 month olds will be. Doesn't make it safe but there are appropriate seats for them which are legal

Lou98 · 07/01/2022 19:45

@Staryflight445

Yes it is op. A seat that swivels 360 would be an i size seat, and they have to be used rear facing until 15M. The other seats wouldn’t be appropriate until your baby is 9KG as a starter weight.

Not all swivel seats are isize - the ones that aren't can be FF from 9kg which plenty of 8 month olds are. My son was 9kg at 6 months.
I do agree with you that RF is safer and we'll be keeping my son RF as long as possible but it isn't true about all swivel seats being isize, my son's isn't

Staryflight445 · 07/01/2022 19:23

If your partner is this careless it wouldn’t surprise me if your child’s straps aren’t done tight enough either.
The amount of people who don’t do them up properly and post photos on social media really give me the cringe.
Rule of thumb is they’re on properly if you could tip the car seat upside down with them in it and your child doesn’t move.

Esssa · 07/01/2022 19:21

Joie do 3 spin options. From birth to 4ish years old. The 360 spin is FF from 9kgs. The 360 ispin is FF from 15 months. The spin safe turns but cannot be forward faced at all. They are all isofix seats so if you got the spin safe it should be impossible for them to FF her in it. I'm sure there are other brands that have something suitable but as I have the ispin I know about the Joie ones. Downside is the spin safe costs more but has extra safety testing.

G5000 · 07/01/2022 18:48

I'm really relaxed on the FF point and both of my kids were FF by 8m but in appropriate car seats.

Well sure, I'm old enough to remember my sister on the back seat in a moses basket, but I wouldn't call that appropriate.

DoTheyKnowItsLemonJuice · 07/01/2022 18:47

God, I just wouldn’t let his mum take the baby out.

I’m not even that much of a stickler with most things but this seems enormously, life-or-death negligent and neglectful of your DD’s safety, enough that I would consider it worth a massive family disagreement.

Thank goodness you were at the window OP!

ffscovid · 07/01/2022 18:44

@G5000

I'm really relaxed on the FF point and both of my kids were FF by 8m but in appropriate car seats.

There are car seats appropriate for an 8m old baby to FF? Which ones?

I'm assuming this poster probably had their DC many years ago. In the 90s, Britax seats were approved for ages 6 months plus that were not only FF, but didn't even have a harness (used adult seat belt like a HB booster!). See attached Argos catalogue image Confused
Rear facing car seat placed front facing in DPs mum's car
Footnote · 07/01/2022 18:43

@Luhou my tall 4.5 has never complained about rear facing and has plenty of room for her legs.

G5000 · 07/01/2022 18:38

I'm really relaxed on the FF point and both of my kids were FF by 8m but in appropriate car seats.

There are car seats appropriate for an 8m old baby to FF? Which ones?

bantuknots · 07/01/2022 18:36

@SingingWaffleDoggy

Apologies if you thought I was weighing in on the RF vs FF debate. I didn’t make myself clear that I wondered if it was him being influenced into making that decision and that if he were more clued up he may be more assertive regarding the safety of your child. He should of course know better seeing as you’ve used that car seat for 8 months but if someone he perceived as more knowledgeable told him it was fine I could see why he may give in if not realising the dangers. Although, the fact that the seatbelt didn’t secure the seat adequately should have been a giveaway!
@SingingWaffleDoggy no problem! I appreciated your previous comment even though I didn't @ you.

that I wondered if it was him being influenced into making that decision and that if he were more clued up he may be more assertive regarding the safety of your child.

This is exactly it. If he knew just how dangerous it is, he wouldn't of done it. He probably would have thought, 'I didn't know it could go this way' and that's about it. He wouldn't have done it if he knew what he was doing but at the same time that's just not a valid enough excuse for me. Once I speak to him he'll hopefully realise how serious it is. If he doesn't, there's clearly no helping him

OP posts:
bantuknots · 07/01/2022 18:32

Thanks for the video links and as I said previously, this isn't a rear facing vs front facing debate but thanks for everyone's input. My DD is already 9kg to the poster that mentioned the weight, so even if I wanted her to have a front facing one I'd buy her an appropriate one (I just said 360 as I've previously seen that one but not obviously looked at the requirements for it).

Also, as much as my DP listens to his mum. If I recommend his mum a car seat and I said she can still only face the seat, he'd listen to that. If his mum wanted to switch it round to face the front, he wouldn't do it based on the fact that I've asked him not too. He was still so stupid in this situation but he clearly thought his mum knew best for whatever reason

OP posts:
SingingWaffleDoggy · 07/01/2022 18:10

Apologies if you thought I was weighing in on the RF vs FF debate. I didn’t make myself clear that I wondered if it was him being influenced into making that decision and that if he were more clued up he may be more assertive regarding the safety of your child. He should of course know better seeing as you’ve used that car seat for 8 months but if someone he perceived as more knowledgeable told him it was fine I could see why he may give in if not realising the dangers. Although, the fact that the seatbelt didn’t secure the seat adequately should have been a giveaway!

CornishTiger · 07/01/2022 17:52

Can’t find a infant car seat installed incorrectly crash test but I can tell you they wouldn’t come off very well if they survived.

CornishTiger · 07/01/2022 17:48
CornishTiger · 07/01/2022 17:43

He’s treating your daughter as a potential crash test dummy. I can find you a video that’s shocking.

What I can tell you as someone who was a car seat expert is that when you have someone who has zero care like these two do them if you get a 360 seat they’ll just use it forward facing and turn it back to rear facing when you are in view. It’ll be there little secret from what you’ve said about them.

HardbackWriter · 07/01/2022 17:13

Obviously the safety of your baby is paramount and should be more than enough motivation for anyone, but it might also be worth pointing out that what they did was dangerous for everyone in the car. A car seat fitted this incorrectly (not really fitted at all) could easily come loose in a crash and then what you've done is put a heavy, unsecured projectile in the car. It could easily kill someone in the seat in front. It would actually be very dangerous to drive around with the seat 'strapped in' like even without the baby in it.

BoredZelda · 07/01/2022 17:10

Regardless of the choice of RF or FF, the seat should be installed as per the instructions.

CaveMum · 07/01/2022 17:09

Depending on which 360 seat you get it’s not as simple as “she’ll just turn it forward facing.” We had the Cybex Sirona and the seat would not face forward unless you stowed away the harness (forward facing used the car seat belt to secure the child) and pressed a release catch underneath the seat itself - it was a huge faff so not something she’d be able to every journey and convert back again so you don’t know she’s done it.

solbunny · 07/01/2022 17:08

@Skeumorph

He's so quick to go along with anything his mum says. She says jump and he says how high.

'If you won't prioritise our baby's safety over your mum's wishes, then it's best that the two things - your mum and our child - don't mix.'

This!
BlibBlabBlob · 07/01/2022 17:06

@bantuknots show your DP this video:

And that kid was properly strapped into a seat DESIGNED to be forward facing. And he was 10 months OLDER than your DD.

In a crash, even just a minor crash, your daughter would be dead if she is in an infant carrier that has been installed completely incorrectly. This is really, REALLY serious. If he thinks that risking his daughter's life is more important than disagreeing with his mother, you have a serious DP problem. I'm so sorry, I know this is a horrible situation and even if you were to go as far as LTB then you still couldn't guarantee your daughter's safety with this man and his mother. Sad