Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to be upset about my husbands attitude?

261 replies

emmysworld · 07/01/2022 12:10

Morning everyone.

I'd like to know if I'm being unreasonable please.

I recently came into a very large amount of money, and I wanted to use a little bit of it to treat my husband and toddler to a family holiday soon.

I have discussed it with my husband many times and have said I'd really love to go to the Maldives (or somewhere similar) I went many times as a child and I think my toddler would absolutely love the open space, water and exploring.

I asked my husband this morning "if it's okay I think I'm going to go ahead and book the Maldives" already feeling like I'm treading on egg shells as I always do...and he turned around to me and said he has a problem with it and it's not okay but it's my money. He said the flight will be a nightmare with a toddler (I've flown alone with our toddler many times) and I think he's just being really ungrateful and spiteful because I'm paying for something for us.

I feel like I shouldn't even have to ask for permission to book a holiday (providing all is okay with his work etc)

I've also offered to buy our family car as we don't have one at the moment, as it's my money I'd like to buy a 4x4 but again he's being nasty About it and saying he would feel embarrassed driving it and it's a sh*t car...rather than being grateful for the fact we will have a car to get us from A-B without the need to hire one anymore.

I just feel like I can't win. Im trying to do nice things for us and I feel like his attitude is a slap in the face.. I may as well put the money towards a divorce at this rate. He's made me cry so many times.

Thanks.

OP posts:
EerieSilence · 07/01/2022 17:44

Use the money for divorce and start of a new life.
Don't bother with anything else. Focus on you and your son.
He's a major twat.

tommyhoundmum · 07/01/2022 17:43

Sounds to me like he'd like you just to give him half and he can do as he chooses.

He's a sour man and this won't improve. Leave him when you are ready.

Good luck

Bluebluemoon · 07/01/2022 17:43

Not rtft but just from your OP I would guess:

He's jealous and threatened by the fact you have some money of your own and are making choices on your own as he is an abusive, controlling bully. He can't obviously tell you he's jealous and pissed off that you've inherited money though - coz that would make him sound like the abusive man child he is - so instead he's criticising and insulting the holiday/car that you want and inventing reasons why they are crap choices.

He sounds like a complete arse.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 07/01/2022 17:40

@emmysworld

Maybe I'm just being naïve and trying to kid myself into thinking this awful marriage will ever work. We've gone down the route of divorce before and I said I'd come back if we had counselling and things changed, and of course they haven't.

He sleeps on the sofa, drinks a huge amount of alcohol and is just generally so miserable. Every thing I suggest or say to him has a negative response which is where the walking on eggshells comes in..."would you like to come for a family walk?" And his response is "I don't like walking"

Would you like to go to the cinema "I don't like the cinema"

These are his general responses to everything

He's not a great dad.

Great dads don't model this behaviour to their children.

Great dads don't treat their wives like lesser beings, knock their accomplishments (your business), and snipe at them for daring to have money themselves.

He's not a great dad. He's not a great husband. he's not a great person. he's just paid well ...

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 07/01/2022 17:39

Id set aside the money and ear mark it for a holiday to the Maldives when your toddlers a bit older and you'll both enjoy it more......he sounds like a Complete bellend tho. And you sound like youre in a good position to finally get rid of him.

MerryMarigold · 07/01/2022 17:38

Ok, sorry. I RTFT of OP's replies and he sounds like a nasty piece of work. OP, you don't need him financially, not sure why you are doing this to yourself.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 07/01/2022 17:37

@emmysworld

I've asked him which car he'd like and where he'd like to go on holiday etc, I haven't left him out of any decisions. He hides all his finances from me. I don't know anything about his finances as we don't share bank accounts etc. all I know is he earns an extremely large amount of money and doesn't like the fact I now also have money.

Everything I've done in the past finance wise (with my own personal money) he's always had a problem with. Like me having my hair done or buying myself an exercise bike to lose weight post pregnancy

Such a concerning post.

You now have the potential means to get good legal advice and leave him, and force him to support his child elsewhere. And give you a fair cut of moneys in his secret accounts.

Frankly, I'd do it based on what you've said. He's financially controlling (which is abuse) and it's only going to get worse.

Don't waste your money on holidays and cars for him. Use it to get out of an abusive marriage and set yourself up with your child.

Notahandmaid · 07/01/2022 17:34

From the sound of it, the OP has tried to get her DH interested in how to to spend the money and he isn't interested in any suggestions. He isn't interested in anything much at all and doesn't like the fact that it's changed the power dynamic in the relationship.

And, as I posted above, I wouldn't presume that money left to my DP was automatically our money and vice versa.

MerryMarigold · 07/01/2022 17:31

@WorraLiberty

Do you think it's because you decided on the Maldives and you decided on that particular car?

If it's to be a family holiday and a family car, perhaps he feels as though he should be included in the choosing?

This.

I would refuse to drive a 4 x 4 as well! I don't consider it to be dh's money or mine. If I inherited, it would the family's money and we would decide. I may get slightly more say but I think dh would allow me that if it had come from, say my parent dying, and I was willing to discuss things.

Migrainesbythedozen · 07/01/2022 17:28

@CowMarshland

Why is it just your money when your in a partnership with your dh? Wouldn’t it be better if there was a discussion about how “we” spend the money?
@CowMarshland Please RTFT OP is in an emotionally abusive relationship and her husband doesn't even allow her to know how much he earns or what his bank accounts are.
CowMarshland · 07/01/2022 17:26

Why is it just your money when your in a partnership with your dh? Wouldn’t it be better if there was a discussion about how “we” spend the money?

SweetBabyCheeses99 · 07/01/2022 17:25

He sounds like a dick. Take your toddler to the Maldives, buy the car for yourself. Then divorce him - but not before doing some good detective work on his finances. See how he enjoys being alone.

Whatayear81 · 07/01/2022 17:23

* Did you not read where her husband makes them keep all their finances separate *

Which rather works in the OP’s favour now that she’s come in to a very large inheritance!

Notahandmaid · 07/01/2022 17:20

Hi OP
I'm so sorry to hear you're in this situation. And I'm appalled at what he said to you after you'd lost your dad. At a time in your life when you needed him to be supportive, he was unkind and unpleasant to you.

I'm also appalled at some of the less than sympathetic answers on here (e.g. one saying you're not compatible with your DH - that's a 'it takes two to tango' argument when it's hard to be compatible with someone who is emotionally abusive!).

If my DP came into some money that was left specifically to him, I would not presume that he would spend it on things for us. I would hope he would but would not automatically assume that I would be entitled to decide how it was spend. Similarly, if I was left some money - and the person who left it to me specified that it was going to me and not to both of us - I would discuss how to spend it with DP but wouldn't expect him to presume that it would be shared either. I don't think that's strange at all.

I agree with others who have suggested sitting down to talk to him but then it does sound as if he has issues and you would be better off out of it (sorry).

Unsure33 · 07/01/2022 17:19

Why should he keep all his money but you offer to share yours . If you are married that’s not right at all . What is he hiding from you ?

If you were to get divorced he will try and hide everything I bet .

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 07/01/2022 17:19

@EatDrinkEatDrink

Just read your posts, keep the money and get a divorce!! He sounds like an arse, this isn't a marriage. Buy yourself a lovely home away from this man.
Ah, didn't see the follow up post!
JesusInTheCabbageVan · 07/01/2022 17:18

@EatDrinkEatDrink

You say "I" came into s bit of money, not "we" surely if you are married it's not you "treating" them? I don't understand how people on here are married yet you still have mine and yours. If either of me or my husband came into money I'd say "we". Must just be a different way of thinking about it. If we go on holiday we decide together and the same with a car, chose together even if it's mainly one of us driving it. You clearly don't follow this approach. I'd find it weird if my husband made a song and dance about treating me to a holiday and car that he'd chosen (that I didn't actually want) and then want me to be congratulatory towards him, we just don't live like this.
Yeah, it doesn't work that way in abusive/toxic relationships, which this is. But good to know you're doing great, I'm sure the OP feels better now Star
EatDrinkEatDrink · 07/01/2022 17:13

Just read your posts, keep the money and get a divorce!! He sounds like an arse, this isn't a marriage. Buy yourself a lovely home away from this man.

Somethingsnappy · 07/01/2022 17:11

Good luck op. You can choose to be happy. And you can choose to surround yourself with only people who make you happy. Why choose to be miserable just because it's become a habit? You have the means to lose your husband and be happy. Do it. Often, taking the most difficult step creates the best results. Deep breath! x

Migrainesbythedozen · 07/01/2022 17:09

@EatDrinkEatDrink

You say "I" came into s bit of money, not "we" surely if you are married it's not you "treating" them? I don't understand how people on here are married yet you still have mine and yours. If either of me or my husband came into money I'd say "we". Must just be a different way of thinking about it. If we go on holiday we decide together and the same with a car, chose together even if it's mainly one of us driving it. You clearly don't follow this approach. I'd find it weird if my husband made a song and dance about treating me to a holiday and car that he'd chosen (that I didn't actually want) and then want me to be congratulatory towards him, we just don't live like this.
@EatDrinkEatDrink Did you not read where her husband makes them keep all their finances separate and doesn't even know what he earns or anything about his money or bank accounts? She said 'I' because her husband has made sure that she sees only her money as hers, and his is his.
EatDrinkEatDrink · 07/01/2022 17:04

You say "I" came into s bit of money, not "we" surely if you are married it's not you "treating" them? I don't understand how people on here are married yet you still have mine and yours. If either of me or my husband came into money I'd say "we". Must just be a different way of thinking about it. If we go on holiday we decide together and the same with a car, chose together even if it's mainly one of us driving it. You clearly don't follow this approach. I'd find it weird if my husband made a song and dance about treating me to a holiday and car that he'd chosen (that I didn't actually want) and then want me to be congratulatory towards him, we just don't live like this.

MrsDrDear · 07/01/2022 17:04

He said to me the other day he doesn't give a F about my dad as look how I turned out.

When my dad first died he also said to me "oh well now you have one less person to call

I wouldn't divorce him.

I'd kill the bastard.

Closetbeanmuncher · 07/01/2022 16:58

Have you never thought of the reasons he hides the finances from you? Your inheritance has popped his little bubble of superiority and he's pissed.

Honestly though OP the marriage sounds miserable. I used to be with one of these joy sucking rainclouds of misery. Nothing you do will ever be good enough/right, trust me.

Whatayear81 · 07/01/2022 16:32

* I have offered to pay hundreds of thousands towards it, buy the furniture and also pay for our toddlers nursery fees*

You offered.
Did he accept?

prettyteapotsplease · 07/01/2022 16:31

It sounds like you're already a broken family - you just have the misfortune to still live under the same roof. Could life really be much worse if you were to part? It doesn't seem like you make each other happy and walking on eggshells really shouldn't be a part of everyday life.