Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to be a bit miffed to find out new coworker is earning more?

84 replies

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been the sole EA at a company for a few years - we’ve hired a new EA, I’ve been heavily involved in the hiring process. She will be supporting less senior people (I am not hierarchical at all but just for info), but I’ve just noticed her starting salary is £12k more than me - I can’t help feel a little undervalued by this especially considering I got my annual feedback at the end of last year and it was glowing.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 11:48

@chopc I totally appreciate that for sure but that’s not the case here. We’re both ‘senior’ EAs with pretty identical experience and my workload is definitely more significant, in fact the idea was I would hand over some of my work to her on a regular basis when I have too much on.

@Winniemarysarah I guess without going into numbers directly, I am earning £23k more in this job full time than in my last job 🙈 it took me a long time to accept I was worth of this salary and generally have imposter syndrome in my career but my feedback at the end of last year solidified my ‘worth’ so I felt confident on that. So considering I am on a good salary as it is, is it right to say I’m unhappy just because someone in the same job is earning more? It’s really hard to know - but I do have a pit in my stomach and it has certainly immediately demotivated me and made me want to switch off for the day (it’s a remote job).

OP posts:
Sonex · 07/01/2022 11:46

I think this one is easy. Immediate meeting. It has come to my attention. Please can I have my salary matched otherwise I believe my position here will be untenable.

Then either they up your salary and you get a nice big raise or you know they don't value you at all and you end up on that salary anyway at a new company now that you know what going market rate is.

This exact same thing happened to my friend who was asked to hire someone to work for her on a salary of 10K more. They matched it and gave her more, as she was senior, and back-dated it.

Aubriella · 07/01/2022 11:42

@AliceET88 the best thing is to talk about salaries with trusted colleagues.

Employers HATE that but it's in employees' favour.

AliceET88 · 07/01/2022 11:41

This happened to me, except with an existing colleague. I found out via various inboxes i manage, not officially, that they were going to go from being on the same salary as me to £15k more. To say I had an emotional response was an understatement. I felt physically sick which sounds dramatic but when you think you are working your butt off and doing really well and see someone else being rewarded (potentially for not contributing enough) it hurts so bad. So I pretty much immediately booked a meeting to discuss, rightly or wrongly seeing as i shouldn't have known the info. I cried, yep, cried in the meeting.. but i got my salary matched. Annoyingly we are now going through the process of hiring another EA (which i have been managing) and it concerns me they will end up earning more than me, even though i have set the salary to match. Urgh i hate it all. The longer I spend working the more I realise how little thee amounts of money mean to the company and how little of a sh*t they give about you potentially feeling hard done by either. As someone said above, try to remove all personal emotional attachment to it and try to see it as a business transaction.

caringcarer · 07/01/2022 11:38

Make appointment to see your boss and tell boss you are very disappointed that new worker is valued higher than you. Does she have higher qualifications than you? If not demand equivalent pay. If boss refuses hand in notice.

MaryStuart · 07/01/2022 11:32

@AdviceNeeded367

Thats the thing with the current recruitment climate - staff shortages mean that candidates can negotiate terms, including inflated salaries.
The current recruitment climate is insane. So now your chance Op. Either negotiate internally. You legitimately saw her salary. You work for more senior stakeholders and have recently had glowing feedback, plus have internal experience. Use that. But I’d also put the feelers out externally. You now know what the market is paying. So don’t be afraid to also use that information to your advantage. Speak to agencies, put yourself as ‘open’ on LinkedIn, sign up for job sites. See what your worth and believe in yourself. Or silently fume. Up to you!
Winniemarysarah · 07/01/2022 11:31

Op, what do you think the ‘right’ motive would be to have to ask for a raise?

LuckyAmy1986 · 07/01/2022 11:30

This happened to me before. I was fuming! It took all my balls but I brought it up with my boss and said I would have to start looking elsewhere as obviously my salary wasn't the going market rate. He gave me a fantastic payrise and was very apologetic and embarrassed. This may be slightly different though as he had no hand in the recruitment of this person so don't think he would have known the discrepancies in our salaries.

chopc · 07/01/2022 11:28

There are four people at our workplace doing the same job. However I don't think we should receive the same salary. We all being different amounts of experience and skills and contribute differently to the workplace.

ChristmasHost21 · 07/01/2022 11:27

As someone who is desperaty trying to fill gaps in recruitment...let me tell you its a great market out there for candidates. A job at my place that 6 years ago paid 16k now pays 23k, and not only that but I am saying to candidates how many hours do you want to work? 40 34 30? You choose and pro rata wage from there!

What I am trying to say is go to your manager to negotiate a better deal for yourself or find something much better out there!!!

AdviceNeeded367 · 07/01/2022 11:24

Thats the thing with the current recruitment climate - staff shortages mean that candidates can negotiate terms, including inflated salaries.

WhatDidISayAlan · 07/01/2022 11:23

That’s a huge difference. If there’s no difference in workload (which is really what matters rather than the seniority of who you are supporting), then there’s no reason why she should be on £40k, for example, and you’re only on £28k. I’d raise it at my next performance review.

Peppaismyrolemodel · 07/01/2022 11:22

@Aubriella

makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

Why do women short change themselves so much?

It’s not an emotional or moral decisiOn from the company’s POV. They will pay the smallest salary they can to the best candidate. So get another job offer. Go back to them and ask them to match. Be polite and clear. Don’t be apologetic- it’s a business decision not a star chart 🤷‍♀️
Aubriella · 07/01/2022 11:19

Right!!!!!! Every man I know wouldn’t even question kicking off they would be asking for that pay rise meeting before the day was out.

Exactly @UnderTheMoonlightWeDanced

Op, you are doing yourself a huge disservice if you don't fight for equal pay with new colleague.

I'm sure we can help you make the arguments if you like?

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 11:16

@converseandjeans I have access to all contracts so it’s not necessarily that they ‘allowed’ me see it, I just did. I do actually wonder if they were hoping I wouldn’t see it.

OP posts:
UnderTheMoonlightWeDanced · 07/01/2022 11:15

@Aubriella

makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

Why do women short change themselves so much?

Right!!!!!! Every man I know wouldn’t even question kicking off they would be asking for that pay rise meeting before the day was out.
converseandjeans · 07/01/2022 11:12

It sounds like they have allowed you to see the paperwork & you're right to question why your salary is lower. I can't see how they can refuse you a pay rise?

notapizzaeater · 07/01/2022 11:09

£12k is a huge amount extra - I'd be rattling a few cages.

Totalwasteofpaper · 07/01/2022 11:08

12K is SIGNIFICANT on your base.

I think you have three options

  1. make a case
  2. go to market get a job offer and ask them to counter
  3. go to market get a job offer, take it and never look back! Grin

i generally go for option 3

NoSquirrels · 07/01/2022 11:07

it’s actually a really very good salary for the job and I wouldn’t have even thought have asking for a raise before her hiring so that makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

But now you’ve got a benchmark salary to compare against.

Either her skills (& therefore yours too) are in demand at this higher salary or they’re not (& she would be paid the same as you).

Either she was paid a matching salary in her previous company or she has negotiated a raise.

Both mean you should make your case.

TorringtonDean · 07/01/2022 11:06

Yes, I agree more likely to be turned down because male bosses think we don’t need the money. We do, of course!! I was always the main family breadwinner and I believe my family lost out because I was female.

EBearhug · 07/01/2022 11:03

But apparently the experts say one main reason for the gender pay gap is that women don’t ask for more. It’s probably because we are conditioned to believe we are not worth it.

Women are also more likely to be turned down when we do ask for it, so we can't win either way...

TorringtonDean · 07/01/2022 10:59

It sounds like you are worth more and you work for more senior people. If they found the money for her then they could find the money for you. But I do sympathise because if I was you I would find it very hard to have the confidence to argue my case to my boss. I have even tried this before myself when I thought I had very good grounds. I was turned down flat because there was “no budget” and then hated myself because I left in tears. I then made up my mind to find a better paid job elsewhere - which I did but it took a year to find it.

But apparently the experts say one main reason for the gender pay gap is that women don’t ask for more. It’s probably because we are conditioned to believe we are not worth it.

Aubriella · 07/01/2022 10:56

makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

Why do women short change themselves so much?

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 10:51

@TorringtonDean yes I’ve seen her signed contract.

Thanks all for your input, I’m not very good at being assertive or advocating for myself so I wanted to gauge whether I was overreacting. the reality is though, I’m not actually unhappy with my salary - it’s actually a really very good salary for the job and I wouldn’t have even thought have asking for a raise before her hiring so that makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

OP posts: