Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to be a bit miffed to find out new coworker is earning more?

84 replies

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been the sole EA at a company for a few years - we’ve hired a new EA, I’ve been heavily involved in the hiring process. She will be supporting less senior people (I am not hierarchical at all but just for info), but I’ve just noticed her starting salary is £12k more than me - I can’t help feel a little undervalued by this especially considering I got my annual feedback at the end of last year and it was glowing.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Hotyogahotchoc · 07/01/2022 13:38

It's understandable you'd be miffed but you ripped often negotiate their own salaries when they start a job so it's not technically wrong. If she was on more in her last job she may have asked for more when she was offered the job.

NewPapaGuinea · 07/01/2022 13:37

It does baffle me how companies are so reluctant to pay “market rate” for existing staff, yet are happy to recruit at that rate. This encourages staff to leave for that payrise and the company ends up paying more to replace them (whilst losing an experienced employee and incurring additional inboarding/training costs).

Sparklybanana · 07/01/2022 13:35

I found out that a colleague with less experience and fewer qualifications than me was hired under a significantly better wage. I raised it and they said that her previous job was better paid so they couldn't offer her less. I stood my ground and said they weren't being fair. I eventually got almost as much. I have the last laugh though. I left and 4 years later my salary is almost double. I'm still left with a lingering bitterness about that whole company because of a number of episodes
Like that. They also tried to make me redundant because I had less project work than the other staff. I had less project work because I had just returned from maternity leave - of course I had nothing! Dicks. Don't let people walk over you op. They are paying your colleague that much because they think your job is worth that much. They are paying you so little because you've not complained. Don't feel the need to be loyal - they are not being loyal to you otherwise they would have evened up the difference straight away.

Blahblahblah40 · 07/01/2022 13:31

[quote Randomname85]@TorringtonDean yes I’ve seen her signed contract.

Thanks all for your input, I’m not very good at being assertive or advocating for myself so I wanted to gauge whether I was overreacting. the reality is though, I’m not actually unhappy with my salary - it’s actually a really very good salary for the job and I wouldn’t have even thought have asking for a raise before her hiring so that makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.[/quote]
Same role + same responsibilities = same pay. If they could afford £12k for her then they can for you. If 12 was their maximum then they should have offered her £6k and given you a bump up to the same.

Itsmemaggie · 07/01/2022 13:26

@Aubriella

makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.

Why do women short change themselves so much?

I know it’s so frustrating. The motive is that you are now underpaid and deserve to be paid at the going rate. The motive for your company in under paying you is so that the bosses can put more money in their own pocket. Would you voluntarily give them £12k a year?
BobLemon · 07/01/2022 13:11

TWELVE?!?!

I’d be mortified if two team members doing the same role had such a gap.

My own (male) manager often mentions that women are “too agreeable” when it comes to salary. Stop being agreeable!

HelloNope · 07/01/2022 13:04

OP. If you don't ask you don't get!

alienalan · 07/01/2022 12:52

OP, if you leave, they will need to
Re-hire at a higher salary. Thats the market now.

They will expecting you to ask the question.

Its a simple case of don't ask, don't get.

alienalan · 07/01/2022 12:48

EA salaries have shot up considerably this past year

You need to ask for the same pay. Or get that cv done and start looking. The time is now

Isonthecase · 07/01/2022 12:46

I think you need to ask for a formal review of pay from your manager, chances are they know and are advocating for you or don't know and would if they did if they're a decent person anyway. You don't need to say how you know if you've just been a bit nosey to find out.

MiniCooperLover · 07/01/2022 12:36

Realistically OP now that you know you can't put this knowledge away. It'll eat at you over time and you'll get cross at times seeing the other EA maybe not be as busy knowing they're paid far more. The time is now to talk to someone, explain you have noticed the discrepancy, you are disappointed at the difference, are they aware etc and you are making it easy for them to either say oh god no I didn't realise or oh bugger. But if you do nothing you'll lose the moment

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 07/01/2022 12:33

Mrs hr's are advertising a position similar to hers ATM.
The salary range offered is between £4000-£12000 more than she takes home.😂😳
The company have been under paying for yrs, she has noticed this and received a substantial rise after threatening to leave

itwasntaparty · 07/01/2022 12:27

Go to market, get an offer, table it with current employer. If they don't match or better it take new job.

I saw a stat once that said if you don't move every two years or so you can lose something like 90k over the course of your career assuming in a professional / well paid role.

I've just moved after 16 years and got a 36k increase. I was underpaid in the previous role but they were never going to bring me up to market rate. Mat leave and part time for five years really fucked up my remuneration.

2boysDad · 07/01/2022 12:22

Are we all missing this part of the original post: " She will be supporting less senior people"

Don't ask for an equal salary, ask for one higher. You're job is more important, you should be paid more not the same.

IE: Ask for an £18k increase, not £12k.

If you ask for parity you have nowhere to go if they start to negotiate. If you start high then you could always reduce your request back to parity as a compromise.

If they refuse don't hand in your notice straight away, that's idiotic, you have to play the game. Be polite, keep you nose clean but then put all your efforts into getting a better paid job.

Good luck.

HoppingPavlova · 07/01/2022 12:22

GnomeDePlume Yep, and the absolute crime is I can’t give an existing person an increase to current market rate. They have to leave because I’m ‘not allowed’ to do that, but I can hire a new person at current market rate. It makes zero sense and realistically loses the company money in the hire/training process alone (don’t even go there with loss of experience), but I have zero control over this.

GnomeDePlume · 07/01/2022 12:16

@HoppingPavlova this is very true. I was offered a salary £20k above my previous salary for essentially the same job and knew that my previous manager would simply not be able to even approximately match it. It wasnt that she didnt think I was worth it but 'the rules' meant she would have too many hoops to jump through to be able to put a significant raise in place within the 24 hours I needed.

They are now stuck trying to replace me and having to offer only a few £k more than I was on because 'the rules' dont allow for significant increase on what the predecessor was paid.

FinallyHere · 07/01/2022 12:14

This is entirely standard.

Your options are to negotiate a raise and/or get a new job elsewhere.

If you stay, the implication is that you are happy enough of can't get another job.

If you use the salary of your new colleague as the sole, or even main reason to negotiate a raise, you are starting from a position of weakness. Much more powerful is to get a better job then give them a chance to match the salary you have been offered. Or at least point out that average salaries in the market are and you really don't want them to incur all the costs of recruiting and need to offer a higher salary to attract the best.

You do, of course, need to follow through snd resign if they don't at least match the new salary. If you are not ready to do that, better to resign yourself to know that you don't have it in you to negotiate a higher salary. Not everyone does. It's not just or even mainly about your worth, it's about the market.

Good luck.

Soaringhigh · 07/01/2022 12:10

[quote Randomname85]@chopc I totally appreciate that for sure but that’s not the case here. We’re both ‘senior’ EAs with pretty identical experience and my workload is definitely more significant, in fact the idea was I would hand over some of my work to her on a regular basis when I have too much on.

@Winniemarysarah I guess without going into numbers directly, I am earning £23k more in this job full time than in my last job 🙈 it took me a long time to accept I was worth of this salary and generally have imposter syndrome in my career but my feedback at the end of last year solidified my ‘worth’ so I felt confident on that. So considering I am on a good salary as it is, is it right to say I’m unhappy just because someone in the same job is earning more? It’s really hard to know - but I do have a pit in my stomach and it has certainly immediately demotivated me and made me want to switch off for the day (it’s a remote job).[/quote]
You’re talking yourself out of it already.
I think you should discuss this with your manager as it will slowly eat you up.
I have done this twice in the same role. The first time, I’ve found out my direct report was earning £20k more than I was and then also found out I was the least paid on the management team (80% men). My salary was very good but I felt cheated.
I tackled it by booking a meeting with my boss and also preparing a pack with all my achievement s and feedback from colleagues. I negotiated increases tied to certain milestones or goals and the timeline too. I now earn twice as much in the same role. It took about 12 months.
Point is, you need to set this right as it could also affect your future earnings .

UnderTheMoonlightWeDanced · 07/01/2022 12:05

You can do this!!! What’s the worst that can happen they say no? Then you can say “of course I understand (whatever their reasons are) and as I’m sure you can understand I will start making decisions for my career and salary to progress”
A friend of mine asked for a pay rise and to continue working from home - they said no to both within 2 weeks he got an offer and accepted for 10k more and WFH in contract. He saw them then advertising his job at his requested pay rise…. They were just being cheeky getting him for less as he had been there 10 years and he knows they wanted to keep him as his last 121 had been really positive.

Ohpulltheotherone · 07/01/2022 12:03

A job is worth what it’s worth. Your company say that the EA position is worth X (your salary + £12k).
So therefore you should be in that ballpoint. A couple of grand would be understandable because of the market changes but £12k??? No.

They are underpaying you based on what they are actually prepared to pay another EA.

Unless she has significant other experience or qualifications which make her a niche hire or specialist then there is no other explanation for why it would be such a massive % increase over the existing role value.

sbhydrogen · 07/01/2022 12:02

Doesn't matter if you earn £23k more in this job than your last, you're being fucked over. Bring it up with your manager. The worst outcome is that they say no, or say you can have a maximum of a 10% rise which would still be lower than their income. Fight for your pay.

I would also recommend getting an offer from elsewhere and going back to your company. It's amazing what can happen when you threaten them with leaving...

HoppingPavlova · 07/01/2022 12:01

Simply, and stupidly, you likely need to move companies and negotiate better as a new hire.

I’m a hiring manager and have this issue as company policy. I can give an existing staff member a maximum increase of x% ( it’s piss poor), and that’s with jumping through all sorts of hoops, but I can negotiate a current competitive market rate with a new hire. It’s obvious madness. I don’t make the rules though and can’t change them so it is what it is. I have great, experienced staff on less than I have inexperienced new hires because of current market shortages. It kills me and it’s unfair. I’m transparent and while I don’t disclose package $, I tell my experienced, skilled staff to leave and negotiate at another company as a new hire if $ are important to them as they are in a shit position and I’m helpless to do anything.

sbhydrogen · 07/01/2022 11:59

I’m not very good at being assertive or advocating for myself
Time to change that behaviour!

chopc · 07/01/2022 11:51

@Randomname85 then absolutely state your case and get your pay rise 💪🏽

GunsNShips · 07/01/2022 11:48

@Totalwasteofpaper

12K is SIGNIFICANT on your base.

I think you have three options

  1. make a case
  2. go to market get a job offer and ask them to counter
  3. go to market get a job offer, take it and never look back! Grin

i generally go for option 3

I’d go for 1) then 3) probably afterwards (depending on how much I enjoyed the job the rest of the time).