Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to be a bit miffed to find out new coworker is earning more?

84 replies

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been the sole EA at a company for a few years - we’ve hired a new EA, I’ve been heavily involved in the hiring process. She will be supporting less senior people (I am not hierarchical at all but just for info), but I’ve just noticed her starting salary is £12k more than me - I can’t help feel a little undervalued by this especially considering I got my annual feedback at the end of last year and it was glowing.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PearlclutchersInc · 07/01/2022 15:36

She might be supporting less senior people but will she picking up work that you don't or that you don't have the skill set so effectively its not the same job?

This is what happens where I work so hardly anyone can do the "why is she paid more than me" thing.

Ginger1982 · 07/01/2022 15:32

I worked somewhere for 8 years where the men doing the same job as me earned more. 3 times I tried to raise it with my boss and he fobbed me off every time. So I quit.

When was your last raise?

MaybeHeIsMyCat · 07/01/2022 15:24

@AryaStarkWolf my boss luckily is very used to my "er excuse me, this isn't fair, sort it?"
I don't earn a lot at all though! But we are all paid the same except for commission so it's very transparent

GodspeedJune · 07/01/2022 15:16

Yanbu to be miffed, but now, please take PPs advice and do something about it.

Sadly often the best way to get a pay rise is to go elsewhere. If you like working there, give them the chance to put it right, but be ready to look elsewhere too.

rookiemere · 07/01/2022 15:12

This happened to me about 20 years ago when I was involved in the interview process of a male who would be doing the same role as me, salary came up in the discussion and it turned out he was being offered £10k more than me. I still kick myself for having said nothing, even if they hadn't offered me any more it's hugely crass to involve someone in the recruitment process if they're getting paid less in the same role as the new hire.
You have to speak to your boss. Ask them about the salary discrepancy, particularly as the new hire isn't taking on the senior managers and you are.
Be very dispassionate about it , ask open questions " I happened to see that salary is £13k more than mine, but I'll be responsible for the more senior executives, so that doesn't seem right. Why is the salary so much higher? " and be prepared for awkward silences which you must not fill up. Let them squirm and feel it - you definitely deserve more if this is the market cost for a new hire.

ninnynonny · 07/01/2022 15:12

Can't you just raise it as a grievance? I found out my (male ) colleague, who has been in the job two years less than me, was earning more than me for doing the same job and kicked off ! I'm still waiting for the result of the 'investigation' as they are trying very hard to prove he does different tings (he doesn't) but if I don't get a raise and back pay, I am going straight to my union. There are laws about this!

SameToo · 07/01/2022 15:07

I’m higher paid than my colleague. Technically I have more experience and more skills, but I also came from a higher paying job than she did and negotiated a higher wage in the interview. Conversely, she came from a lower paying job and was happy with the lower salary the offered her. Not sure how she feels now that she knows we’re paid differently but my advice is always go ask for more 🤷‍♀️

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/01/2022 15:04

worth not work

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/01/2022 15:04

Motivation for asking for a raise
(read this out loud until you believe it)

I am a good employee
I do my job well
My company has indicated that an equivalent job is work £12K more than I am getting
Therefore my job is worth at least £12K more
Therefore am going to ask for at least £12K more

I work in the City and trust me people would have been knocking on the Manager's door within minutes. If you don't tell them then they will assume you are happy with the inequality. They won't be surprised you ask.

AryaStarkWolf · 07/01/2022 15:04

rock the boat*

AryaStarkWolf · 07/01/2022 15:03

Yep. See also mouthy/gobby/opinionated
To me I would just see the salary difference as unfair and I'm quiteblack and white in what I see as not fair so I would be "well, why?"
It's straightforward to me that it's "wrong"

More women need to think like this, it's so much down to how we're raised in society as girls and into womanhood. That we can't rock the bought or be greedy and we have to nice and compliant etc etc etc Bleh

MaybeHeIsMyCat · 07/01/2022 14:57

@AryaStarkWolf

but then I have been described as.. sassy

I hate that, if you were male you'd just be a male being male

Yep. See also mouthy/gobby/opinionated To me I would just see the salary difference as unfair and I'm quite black and white in what I see as not fair so I would be "well, why?" It's straightforward to me that it's "wrong"
TitsInAbsentia · 07/01/2022 14:56

Get your hands on a couple of salary surveys that are relevant to your area (not sure where you are located) and see where you fit in. Use that as part of your discussion. Also be careful to not disclose you know how much she is on - just because you have access to the info doesn't mean you should look at the info etc - don't want them to think you can't be trusted. Just perhaps say there is the implication she has started on a salary significantly more than yours.

Leave your imposter syndrome in the bin! As someone who has worked as a sole EA before you carry the place most of the time, you ARE important!

AryaStarkWolf · 07/01/2022 14:47

but then I have been described as.. sassy

I hate that, if you were male you'd just be a male being male

MaybeHeIsMyCat · 07/01/2022 14:44

@NellieWellietheEllie

A white man would think: "This is good news for me as it means I have the opportunity to get a 12k rise. I'll find my manager now and demand a meeting about it and then spend 45 minutes talking about how underpaid I am and how much I deserve this in tones of outrage"
That would be me except I'm female Blush I'm more likely to go "why is she paid more? Match it, or here is my notice" but then I have been described as.. sassy
HaveringWavering · 07/01/2022 14:41

@Randomname85

So I’ve sent a note to the person in HR who is sort of an equal to my manager, I have a good relationship with her and she completed the hire so I want to talk to her about it first to see if there is (what it could be I can’t imagine) and explanation I haven’t yet thought of. Will see how that goes and then go from there! Thank you all so much for this brilliant advice and ‘head wobbling’ - it’s really helped me put it in perspective.
Brilliant. Well done and good luck.
AryaStarkWolf · 07/01/2022 14:34

[quote Randomname85]@TorringtonDean yes I’ve seen her signed contract.

Thanks all for your input, I’m not very good at being assertive or advocating for myself so I wanted to gauge whether I was overreacting. the reality is though, I’m not actually unhappy with my salary - it’s actually a really very good salary for the job and I wouldn’t have even thought have asking for a raise before her hiring so that makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.[/quote]
Of course your motives are right, why should you, who's been there longer and doing the same job be paid less than someone else?!

Newmumatlast · 07/01/2022 14:32

[quote Randomname85]@chopc I totally appreciate that for sure but that’s not the case here. We’re both ‘senior’ EAs with pretty identical experience and my workload is definitely more significant, in fact the idea was I would hand over some of my work to her on a regular basis when I have too much on.

@Winniemarysarah I guess without going into numbers directly, I am earning £23k more in this job full time than in my last job 🙈 it took me a long time to accept I was worth of this salary and generally have imposter syndrome in my career but my feedback at the end of last year solidified my ‘worth’ so I felt confident on that. So considering I am on a good salary as it is, is it right to say I’m unhappy just because someone in the same job is earning more? It’s really hard to know - but I do have a pit in my stomach and it has certainly immediately demotivated me and made me want to switch off for the day (it’s a remote job).[/quote]
Yes, it is. Why even question if it's right to say you're unhappy. You have found out you're deemed less valuable in a monetary sense and would like to be valued the same

Randomname85 · 07/01/2022 14:28

So I’ve sent a note to the person in HR who is sort of an equal to my manager, I have a good relationship with her and she completed the hire so I want to talk to her about it first to see if there is (what it could be I can’t imagine) and explanation I haven’t yet thought of. Will see how that goes and then go from there! Thank you all so much for this brilliant advice and ‘head wobbling’ - it’s really helped me put it in perspective.

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 07/01/2022 14:20

@NellieWellietheEllie

A white man would think: "This is good news for me as it means I have the opportunity to get a 12k rise. I'll find my manager now and demand a meeting about it and then spend 45 minutes talking about how underpaid I am and how much I deserve this in tones of outrage"
🤣🤣🤣 A person would think.
NellieWellietheEllie · 07/01/2022 14:17

A white man would think: "This is good news for me as it means I have the opportunity to get a 12k rise. I'll find my manager now and demand a meeting about it and then spend 45 minutes talking about how underpaid I am and how much I deserve this in tones of outrage"

Lolabray · 07/01/2022 14:10

Absolutely not being unreasonable. I’d be looking for something else or complaining!

nosyupnorth · 07/01/2022 14:04

Raise it with whoever is in charge of your pay (and don't wait until your next official review unless it's very soon -- that could mean months of missing out on higher pay!) - my department brought a new person in last year and several others in the team were given a 'market adjustment' pay rise in recognition of the fact that the rate the new person was on would also be the rate to replace them if they left because they felt underpaid.

Beer2bed · 07/01/2022 13:44

I found out a colleague with a lesser role and less responsibility was on 10k more than me a couple of years ok. I arranged a meeting with the boss, asked if they thought my value and worth to the company was so much less than other employee. Obviously said no. I explained I knew about the discrepancy in pay with other colleague and I wanted the same hourly rate.

They apologised and agreed on the spot and back dated it to the start of that month.

If you dont ask, you dont get!

DollyDingleberry · 07/01/2022 13:43

[quote Randomname85]@TorringtonDean yes I’ve seen her signed contract.

Thanks all for your input, I’m not very good at being assertive or advocating for myself so I wanted to gauge whether I was overreacting. the reality is though, I’m not actually unhappy with my salary - it’s actually a really very good salary for the job and I wouldn’t have even thought have asking for a raise before her hiring so that makes me wonder if my motives wouldn’t be right asking for a raise tbh.[/quote]
This is exactly why she's paid 12 THOUSAND POUNDS more than you.

Unless you're on £100K+, that's a MASSIVE difference in your wages.