Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is fairy tale of New York a sackable offence ?

240 replies

Veeveeoxox · 07/01/2022 09:36

My OH played fairy tale of New York the censored version on a zoom Christmas party, he works in IT contracting moved from financial services to the public sector. They are now saying many people got offended and hurt by the song and they are wondering if he's a good cultural fit for this department .

AIBU to think this is absolutely ridiculous ? My OH is already looking for another job as the field is such in high demand he's not worried. They also waited until today to tell him instead of a month ago when the supposed incident happened.

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 07/01/2022 11:04

They are now saying many people got offended and hurt by the song and they are wondering if he's a good cultural fit for this department .

I love the song so this is a case of, there must for the grace of God go I...

However. I'm also self-employed and am wondering how your husband reacted to being told the song selection had caused offence. As a self-employed contractor with no employment rights, in his place I think I would have inwardly eye-rolled (big-time) but outwardly given it mea culpa, so dreadfully sorry for causing offence, won't do that again, etc, etc, ad nauseam.

Was your husband possibly a bit argumentative when the situation was brought to his attention? Did he perhaps not give the impression he was taking the bollox complaint seriously?

theNumbersStation · 07/01/2022 11:01

They are at it.

I’m not sure I would want to work with a bunch of arseholes that can supposedly take offence at a song that has already been censored.

I suspect in reality it is for other reasons altogether. In which case I wouldn’t want to work with a bunch of arses that go ‘cultural differences - so no comeback’ rather than just being truthful.

Ponoka7 · 07/01/2022 11:01

Although I don't have an issue with it and can't see why anyone would object.

Sonex · 07/01/2022 11:01

that is very true. I remember it being bleeped out on the radio not long after it was released, mid nineties at least.

Ponoka7 · 07/01/2022 11:00

@JorisBohnson2
"Do we have to censor all historical songs/films/books now in case someone gets offended."

It isn't just people being offended. We don't want the next generation hearing new slurs to throw at people. If certain slurs stop being in everyone's hearing, especially children, they die out.

CorrBlimeyGG · 07/01/2022 10:59

Did it really offend people in huge numbers for thirty years before this was acknowledged? And is it now the hurt is being properly dealt with?

Or have people decided recently that it contains certain words which MUST be considered offensive, and therefore everyone should join in the concern about the said offence?

@HesterShaw1 The censored version was first released in the early nineties, so this is far from a new issue. The recent issue is actually the opposite, people trying to claim this is a new 'snowflake' issue when in fact it was highlighted decades ago.

phishy · 07/01/2022 10:58

@Veeveeoxox

My OH played fairy tale of New York the censored version on a zoom Christmas party, he works in IT contracting moved from financial services to the public sector. They are now saying many people got offended and hurt by the song and they are wondering if he's a good cultural fit for this department .

AIBU to think this is absolutely ridiculous ? My OH is already looking for another job as the field is such in high demand he's not worried. They also waited until today to tell him instead of a month ago when the supposed incident happened.

It doesn't really ring true. Who is 'they'? Who is wondering and why are they gossiping about it instead of tackling it directly with him?
whynotwhatknot · 07/01/2022 10:58

absolutely ridiculous and its the censored version-wit the shit they play on the radio now i dnt get the criticism over ftony

MyDcAreMarvel · 07/01/2022 10:57

Yes calling someone a reference to a bundle of old sticks and lazy is so offensive. And he didn’t even play that version!

Jumpingintomenopause · 07/01/2022 10:56

If this is in writing he has a valid case for constructive dismissal!

Sonex · 07/01/2022 10:55

I have heard three versions of this song incidentally - and I hear each one every Xmas period (it is an awesome song!):

The original with the line "you scum bag, you maggot, you cheap lousy faggot" - sang by Kirsty McCall to Shane McGowan.

The one with the faggot word beeped out

The one where they have somehow changed it to
"you scum bag, you maggot, you're cheap and you're haggard"

metro.co.uk/2020/11/19/fairytale-of-new-york-edited-lyrics-to-be-played-on-bbc-radio-1-13619568/

www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/whats-on/music-nightlife-news/pogues-fairytale-new-york-lyrics-19307294

So there are plenty of options out there to protect peoples feelings. It was written in 1985 though when casual homophobia was rife so I suppose it does reflect a historical era pretty accurately. I am never sure whether it's really better to just erase the past or keep it standing so that we don't repeat past mistakes. I mean is anyone proposing we erase the holocaust and pretend it didn't happen? I think the same people complaining about this song lyric would be outraged at the very suggestion.

It's also about down and out elderly alcoholics and I think verbal abuse is a pretty real facet of that condition. And nobody seems to mind that much about the misogynistic c word slur that women regularly have yelled at them.

ExtremelyDetermined · 07/01/2022 10:54

Ridiculous. Admittedly it's a bloody awful song but this is a massive over-reaction, it gets played everywhere.

godmum56 · 07/01/2022 10:54

the music was used in this years Kevin the carrot advert for goodness sake

Metabigot · 07/01/2022 10:53

Do we have to censor all historical songs/films/books now in case someone gets offended.

I would understand if this had been produced in the current era, but we can't go back in time to make everything inoffensive.

Ridiculous.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/01/2022 10:52

I'm surprised they sang without any changes. I adore the song but I think the "faggot" slur isn't really something I want to hear

'Old slut on junk' is OK though?

(Not that I have a problem with the song, it's one of my all time favourites)

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 10:52

I dont think its particularly snowflakey to not want to hear the word "faggot" in a Christmas song if you are a gay man. I'm old enough to remember when it was often the precursor to an assault and I bet many gay men are too.

But the censored version, what's the problem?

steppemum · 07/01/2022 10:51

Well, I am 54 so not snowflake and pretty robust, but I do think the 'faggot' insult is pretty outdated now, and on mainstream radio etc I think it is appropriate that that word is censored out.

I've just looked at reports about it. Radio 1 mostly plays censored version. Radio 2 mostly plays the uncensored version.

But your dh played the censored version, so the company has not a leg to stand on.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 07/01/2022 10:46

Welcome to snowflake culture. And it will get worse. Pretty soon it will be like living in China and we will have to check everything we say for fear of losing our job and being “cancelled” from society…

BobMortimersPetOwl · 07/01/2022 10:45

So much depends on why people were offended.

Tal45 · 07/01/2022 10:43

That is one of my favourite Christmas songs!

I would ask them to tell you what specifically people were offended by as all the offensive words had been censored. I would also ask them to explain exactly how he is not a 'good cultural fit' when he censored out the offensive words.

The wokeness in this country is just getting fucking ridiculous.

JSL52 · 07/01/2022 10:42

Ridiculous

Dixiechickonhols · 07/01/2022 10:40

If he’s a contractor he’s not employed so can be asked to go for any reason. It’s why contractors are paid more no rights/sick pay etc. Hopefully he can get new role in next few weeks and move on.
I wouldn’t find it offensive, radios pay it but it sounds like an excuse to get rid - if not that they’d have said something else.

Postchristmasflab · 07/01/2022 10:40

He is a contractor they can get rid for anything at any time as long as they stick to the exit agreement in the contract between them and I assume his Limited company. Ex contractor here, I have had contracts terminated without warning because the company decided that particular project I was working on was going to move to later in the year and they didn’t have any alternate work.

But it’s still a shitty reason

cstaff · 07/01/2022 10:39

So do these offended people get offended every time they hear it in a store, on the radio or TV or at a Christmas Market and if so do they complain to the management each time. Jesus wept.

Momicrone · 07/01/2022 10:39

I love the song, I'd rather remove all the misogynistic crap that's out there about hos and blow jobs

Swipe left for the next trending thread