Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what effect attachment parenting has on adults

65 replies

Pinklilly123 · 07/01/2022 09:31

I’m asking this to any of you who were parented this way by your own parents OR those who used this style as a parent and have an adult child. It’s obviously difficult to be sure that everyone who uses attachment parenting was parented this way EXACTLY all the time but if you were parented within this parenting ‘bracket’ roughly what’s your experience as an adult.

Asking out of interest really. I’ve unintentionally used various parenting styles with my children and the results vary but only one is nearly an adult so can’t say how parenting styles have affected them all growing up yet really.

I understand that parenting styles aren’t the only factor that determine how a child develops but they are a massive contributing factor aren’t they?

OP posts:
SmallElephant · 11/01/2022 10:24

I think my parents leaned towards attachment parenting - breastfeeding, lying with me to help me get to sleep, very child centred (although my mum worked full time for financial reasons from when I was 5).

I think I'm a fairly well balanced adult with good self esteem, good job, happily married, close to my parents etc.

I parent my DC in a fairly similar way but slightly stricter due to DH's influence.

R3ALLY · 11/01/2022 10:23

Totally agree @Darkstar4855 - my parents didn’t do the AP stuff on paper but were loving, supportive and present and that was enough. It certainly cheered me up when my first birth didn’t go well… it doesn’t all depend on the first few days and weeks

Username916 · 11/01/2022 10:15

I was not attachment parented. I would say the opposite. Was never allowed in my parents bed, was in my own room from the start, cried it out etc. Very much was a child to be seen and not heard. Quite strict rules. I actually have a memory of crying for my mum through the night in the dark. Then when my mum had my youngest sister 5 years later she changed her tune. Very attachment parent style. Attached at the hip. Co sleeping. Gentle parenting etc.

What resulted is my sister is a happy, confident young woman, secure in her choices and close friends with my mum. They often go for dinner or drinks together and shopping or weekends away. My sister can hold a conversation with anyone.

I am an anxious mess, very self critical. I am desperate to please my mum and suffered horribly with depression and suicidal thoughts from 12 until I was 20. I suffer quite badly from anxiety still now at 33.

I am on paper more successful than my sister because I am constantly trying to prove myself so have a well paid job, nice house and kids. My sister works in a low paid bar job. But in my eyes she is the success.

Darkstar4855 · 11/01/2022 10:11

I think it’s hard to measure because attachment parenting comes in all shapes and sizes. You can breastfeed, babywear and co-sleep but still be relatively disengaged; equally you can do none of those things and still be a responsive, nurturing and emotionally attached parent. It’s not just about what you physically do, it’s how you engage with them on an emotional level that matters.

R3ALLY · 11/01/2022 10:09

I was born in the 70s, CS under GA and my mother didn’t see me for a day let alone do skin to skin. I was formula fed and in my own room from birth. We adored each other, she was the best mother I ever met, my friends and relatives adored her and, although I did some things differently, if I could be half the mother she was I’d be doing very well.

FourTeaFallOut · 11/01/2022 10:05

I think some people become accidental attachment parents because their baby and child runs more anxious from the outset and it's an effective solution to bring comfort and calm. So there can be some chicken-egg to the debate.

But I have no truck with not saying no to a child and offering the kind of boundaries that bring security. I'm sure some people who adopt ap and take it to extreme lengths could trip up an otherwise settled child.

Hemingwayscatz · 11/01/2022 10:01

Want to also say that my Mum put me in my own room from birth and left me to cry. She bottle fed from the start because breastfeeding is ‘weird’ in her opinion and she put rusks in my bottle from 6 weeks to make me sleep through the night Hmm. I was also weaned at 3 months, she said that was the advice back then. I am a very anxious person and struggle with MH in general, also not particularly close to my family. Not sure whether there’s a link to my clearly traumatic early years being left to scream myself to sleep but there you go!

Hemingwayscatz · 11/01/2022 09:58

I followed AP with all of my DC because I just found it easier. Only one out of five is an anxious child but she was basically born anxious, she was always a very serious baby and remains serious to this day. I don’t think it has anything to do with the fact I wore her in a carrier or co-slept because the others aren’t anxious at all, quite the opposite in fact. She’s just who she is, a bit of a worrier.

ancientgran · 11/01/2022 09:51

@jellymaker

I have watched my friends children growing up who have had this type of parenting. It turned from attachment to helicopter parenting as they got older. Her children are highly anxious. Her 7 year old still can not be alone or sleep alone. It feels like despite the fact, she never stops believing in this approach, her children are unhappy. Children need to know that they are not always the centre of the universe.
For all you know they might be more anxious if she'd done things differently. Despite what the Jesuits might say a 7 year old isn't the finished article.
FourTeaFallOut · 11/01/2022 07:21

I was breastfed, co-slept, got carried in a sling - but not all the time - I had a pram too. I had an extended family who lived close who looked after me when DM went to work. I think I was probably raised akin to attachment parenting style but without any great aim to endorse a particular strategic method.

What can I say? It's not like you get a sliding doors crystal ball and can see the differences in outcome. It doesn't insulate you from the trials and tribulations that life throws at people. But my default setting is happy and relaxed, I'm confident, I have good attachments with all my family. I don't feel like I need to put a great deal of effort into feeling content. And I chose to parent in broadly the same way. I'm hopelessly unambitious though and a terrible day dreamer, I could while entire days napping in a sunbeam given the chance. Nobody is perfect. There's no parenting style for that.

jellymaker · 11/01/2022 07:07

I have watched my friends children growing up who have had this type of parenting. It turned from attachment to helicopter parenting as they got older. Her children are highly anxious. Her 7 year old still can not be alone or sleep alone. It feels like despite the fact, she never stops believing in this approach, her children are unhappy. Children need to know that they are not always the centre of the universe.

Thegiftthatkeepsongiving · 10/01/2022 23:02

Before I went on maternity leave a colleague told me to read up about attachment parenting, as she was a foster carer and had seen the impact of children who lack a secure attachment. She didn’t mean having to bedshare or baby wear to the extreme but more being responsive to the baby’s needs and being consistent and having clear boundaries.

I came across this useful video that explains the different types of attachments as a result of the type of parenting we experience in the early years: I definitely notice the difference with people who clearly are securely attached and when you ask about their childhood compared to myself and the inconsistencies with my parents growing up.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 10/01/2022 22:55

I didn't have time for that, I was a single parent and had to work full time from when he was 6 weeks old so a routine was best for us. But my DS was very sweet natured and slept a lot.
We slept in the same room but never in the same bed because I'm a very heavy sleeper and may well have crushed him in the night.
He's 40 now and we are very close, I live with him and DiL in a multi generational household.
DiL is the matriarch as I'm too soft.

KO81 · 10/01/2022 22:47

I was child number four after a few years gap, so my parenting style was “meh, she’ll be alright, she’ll just copy the boys. Remember to leave food out.”

I survived having big brothers who either punched me or punched other people who were nasty to me.

We were very rural so despite having possibly the opposite of attachment parents, we’re all successful and have families and have a very affectionate, sarcastic relationship and are all pretty good cricket bowlers.

I suspect there are successes and failures in equal measure, whatever ‘parenting style’ people had.

OrangeShark27 · 10/01/2022 22:39

@Jellycatspyjamas I don't think anyone has said attachment style parenting is the only way to form an attachment with your child. Or people won't form an attachment with their child if they don't follow that style. It's basically just a name for a theory/collection of parenting behaviours.

FrecklesMalone · 10/01/2022 22:27

In my experience the friends of mine who attachment parented their kids now have 20 year olds and late teens and quite a few are anxious children. However, quite a lot of the parents are anxious so perhaps they would have been no matter what. A few of them who coslept and balked at CCing where so absolutely knackered after a few years of babies and toddlers that they moaned constantly in earshot of their kids.

PinkPlantCase · 10/01/2022 22:25

@SnackSizeRaisin

All parenting is attachment parenting - infants are hardwired to form attachments to caregivers.

True but the term refers specifically to physical closeness between mother and baby: practices such as baby wearing, long term breastfeeding, Co sleeping and a mother who responds to all the baby's wishes, doesn't go to work etc
Bottle feeding, putting baby in own room at 6 months, using a pram, putting baby in nursery at 1 year, sleep training, following routines would be the opposite.
IMO both styles can be fine. Most people probably do bits of both.

I can’t help OP but I’ve just realised that we do an odd mix in our house.

Co-sleep, lots of baby wearing and breastfeeding but I went back to work at 6 months so DS is in full time nursery.

I like to think the contrast is complementary Grin

schoolsoutforever · 10/01/2022 22:10

I don’t think they called it attachment parenting but my mum read Dr Spock (I think that was his name), bf both of us, and I regularly slept with her (my poor old dad had to go to my bed!) when I was scared. I have a averagely successful life now but had lots of issues (anorexia, uni drop outs etc) and my brother is deeply troubled. It think this is due to nature predominately rather than nurture but I think it’s not a recipe for successful children by itself. Having said that I’m very close to my mum as an adult so in that respect it was good.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/01/2022 21:55

True but the term refers specifically to physical closeness between mother and baby: practices such as baby wearing, long term breastfeeding, Co sleeping and a mother who responds to all the baby's wishes, doesn't go to work etc
Bottle feeding, putting baby in own room at 6 months, using a pram, putting baby in nursery at 1 year, sleep training, following routines would be the opposite.

I know what the wankery behind the phrase is, but none of those things in an of themselves promote attachment.

Attachment is about attuned caregiving, responding to your child’s needs, providing emotional containment and developing emotional regulation. Parents do that in all kinds of ways.

ESGdance · 10/01/2022 21:51

Attunement IMHO is a more useful concept - where the caregiver is attentive to the child’s needs and responds to them whilst at the same time nudging and supporting towards self soothing and self assured independence.

“Engulfing” care giving is as much an issue as ambivalence.

Encouraging and supporting DC to follow their own direction whilst being accountable, respectful and responsible to themselves and others - seems like a way to go.

I don’t have a definition of attachment parenting - if it means growing emotionally secure and independent DCs all well and good - if the focus is on the sole physical experience it sounds restrictive and “cookie cutter”

Mamette · 10/01/2022 21:51

@Jellycatspyjamas

All parenting is attachment parenting - infants are hardwired to form attachments to caregivers. Whatever wankery sits behind whatever parenting style, the child will be forming an attachment and developing an attachment style that will inform their relationships into adulthood. Babies attach to their parents.
Agree. And forming a secure attachment has nothing to do with co-sleeping. You might co-sleep and have a securely attached child but those two things are not cause and effect. DD will be 21 this year, she is at Uni and very independent. I always put her needs first as a baby and small child, and for DD those needs included her own cot from quite early on. She still loves her sleep and her own space.
SnackSizeRaisin · 10/01/2022 21:49

All parenting is attachment parenting - infants are hardwired to form attachments to caregivers.

True but the term refers specifically to physical closeness between mother and baby: practices such as baby wearing, long term breastfeeding, Co sleeping and a mother who responds to all the baby's wishes, doesn't go to work etc
Bottle feeding, putting baby in own room at 6 months, using a pram, putting baby in nursery at 1 year, sleep training, following routines would be the opposite.
IMO both styles can be fine. Most people probably do bits of both.

Rightshoardingsaurus · 10/01/2022 21:38

In some ways, attachment parenting for me has been marred, due to the negative association to some (in)famous people who publicly advocated and virtually preached it. The people I know who keep ramming it down my throat, seem not quite genuine and it reeks of performance parenting. I remember even on MN how some people found it super hypocritical of Peaches Geldorf to lecture people on parenting, while at the same time injecting smack, keeping drugs, syringes and paraphernalia in the house, while parenting two small babies. Not to mention her youngest spending something like 17 hours 'attached' next to her body.

That said, I suppose I personally adopted a mixture of parenting styles but did tend to make my DC sleep in their own rooms from when they were toddlers. My DM worked from when I was young and I feel it helped me to be more independent to not be with her non-stop.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/01/2022 21:31

All parenting is attachment parenting - infants are hardwired to form attachments to caregivers. Whatever wankery sits behind whatever parenting style, the child will be forming an attachment and developing an attachment style that will inform their relationships into adulthood. Babies attach to their parents.

ancientgran · 10/01/2022 21:16

I did it with my youngest two. One is super confident and can seem a bit hard, the other is a worrier and needs lots of support. So that proves just about nothing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread