Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it weird that we’re being congratulated on our baby’s sex?

133 replies

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 09:25

We had our 20 week scan this week. My overwhelming feeling is just sheer gratitude that nothing has been picked up as a health concern - I have friends who haven’t been so lucky including friends who have had to TFMR at this point, so I didn’t go into it with any other hopes than baby being ok.

We already have a one year old DD and due to the small age gap/the fact we only plan to have two we decided to find out the sex of this baby, which we didn’t with DD. Neither of us had any preference at all, to my mind we either got one of each or DD got a sister, and frankly both outcomes were brilliant. Baby is a boy and I’m super excited.

Since we’d found out, we mentioned it in passing to close family (siblings, parents) and since then we’ve been getting heaps of messages off other friends and family to congratulate us on the baby’s sex. Haven’t posted it on social media or mentioned it to anyone other than immediate family who had asked directly, but they’ve obviously passed it on (both sides, this isn’t an in-laws bash!) And I don’t mind that they’ve passed it on, it’s not a secret, I just generally assumed no one except the parents really gives a damn about it Grin

Am I being U to find the fact we’re getting loads of congratulatory messages bizarre? I could understand people messaging to say they’re glad the baby seems healthy, and obviously once baby is here, but ‘congrats on what’s between its legs’ seems a bit… odd? DH thinks I’m massively overthinking it, but I feel like congratulations is only appropriate when the alternative outcome is less good (ie congrats the baby is here safely). I will say I’m the sort of person who wouldn’t dream of giving a gift until a baby has actually arrived - I feel a bit uneasy about it tbh, maybe due to my friends’ experiences - so for me it’s in a very different category to birth announcements.

DH says I’m being snippy because I’m reading it as ‘a second girl wouldn’t have been as good’ and people are just pleased for us. I’m sure there’s no malice but I think being congratulated on something that a) is 50/50 and b) doesn’t really matter either way is really odd! AIBU?

(Just to say if I am U I promise to take it on the chin and this definitely isn’t a ‘gender disappointment’ post. More a ‘sex wtf’ post Grin)

OP posts:
WalkingOnSonshine · 07/01/2022 10:45

People are weirdly obsessed with the “perfect” family being 2 kids, a boy and a girl.

I’ve had quite a few people ask me when I’m having another & if I’d like a girl next - assuming that we are stopping at 2 and are desperate for a girl.

A friend has 2 boys and has been asked multiple times if they would think about trying for another, just so she “gets” her girl.

Funnily enough friends that have 2 girls don’t get asked if they want a boy.

I suppose it’s a bit like the gender disappointment threads on here. There’s such a societal expectation that Dads want boys & Mums want girls.

MollysDolly · 07/01/2022 10:44

I appreciate you said you haven't been outwardly snippy with people, but unless you keep it that way, I think they're going to assume you're disappointed and would have preferred 2 girls.

And looking at the size of your opening post and considering some of your answers, it does look a bit like that to me.

That's exactly how I read it too.

Somethingsnappy · 07/01/2022 10:44

@Dollywilde

Fair enough! I guess for me ‘congratulations’ when people hear that you’re expecting and then ‘congratulations’ when baby arrives safely is the standard. Most of the people I know haven’t found out the sex (we’re one of the first to become parents among our friends, and families I don’t recall anyone finding out) so I wasn’t expecting it - I don’t recall anyone telling me their unborn baby’s sex as an announcement. Fully accept that I am the weird one though and this is just small talk! DH has been informed and is delighted Wink
So what did you expect the response to be then? If nobody had said anything, you'd be disgruntled too! It would be weird to announce the sex and then have nothing much in response.
thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2022 10:43

Even I think you're overthinking and I'm a rabid feminist. People aren't fundamentally all that interested in the sex, they're just happy for you.
Smile sweetly and move on.

mumda · 07/01/2022 10:42

People mostly don't care but feel the need to say something. You gave them a really easy way to respond.

UrsulaBursula · 07/01/2022 10:42

Just say thanks…no need to over think it

I mean, really Hmm

WorraLiberty · 07/01/2022 10:42

Sorry, to clarify, I was talking about the length of your opening post.

In one breath you're saying it's not a big deal but in another breath you're making a very big deal of it.

It's good you're not doing this in real life because I expect you really will come across to people as though you're disappointed you're having a boy.

Somethingsnappy · 07/01/2022 10:41

@herewegoagainst

I'm pretty sure everyone would have congratulated you either way. "two girls, how lovely they'll be so close and have a friend for life." "One of each, thats the dream you've got a full set now how lucky" etc. You're over thinking this!
Yes, this. And also, you've told them OP. You've found out the sex and told people, so really, congratulations is the standard response. The baby isn't born yet, so they can't congratulate you on the baby itself. They can only congratulate you on the piece of information received. 'A boy, how lovely, now you have one of each!' or 'A girl, how lovely, a sister for DD!'. I'm not really sure what you expect the alternative to be?

But you're hormonal and pregnant, so you're forgiven Grin

greenlynx · 07/01/2022 10:40

You are overthinking. I think people are just saying generic comments. As you announced that it’s a boy this time people are commenting on this. They don’t know anything else just baby’s sex what else they can say? And I personally wouldn’t congratulate on baby’s health at this stage, it would sound a bit strange.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 07/01/2022 10:39

People say things because they feel its the done thing.

It's highly unlikely that anybody really gives a shit what sex your unborn baby is!

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 07/01/2022 10:36

It's just small talk, and showing interest in the other person's news
"one of each - brilliant!"
"two the same - that's so lovely!"

It would probably be a little weird if on being told the sex of someone's unborn baby I said "meh" or made some other suggestion that it's not particular interesting or commentworthy, even though I might feel that way.

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 10:33

@WorraLiberty

Well as DD was a surprise all the 0 - 3 months stuff is unisex but unless DS is planning on heading to nursery in all of the dresses DD is currently outgrowing in age 12 - 18 months, then yes, he will need more to be purchased. Saving starts here Grin

You're buying clothes now for your unborn baby that he won't be able to wear for a year to a year and a half?

See I just think you're being a bit economical with the truth. You were interested to find out the sex of your unborn baby, which is fine - lots of people do this.

What's strange is that you think it's weird when other people show an interest.

I appreciate you said you haven't been outwardly snippy with people, but unless you keep it that way, I think they're going to assume you're disappointed and would have preferred 2 girls.

And looking at the size of your opening post and considering some of your answers, it does look a bit like that to me.

Fair enough @WorraLiberty. DS is a surprise baby and finances have been a bit of a worry (I did mean more about buying clothes later down the line, I know babies aren’t babies for long!) but as this thread has shown I’m an overthinker so I suppose that all makes sense.

Length of answers is because I am massively procrastinating from a work project (and I also hate threads where people say OP is wrong and they disappear…) but also entirely fair enough Wink

OP posts:
thebigpurpleone · 07/01/2022 10:31

You obviously did care though because you found out. People are just being kind. You're overthinking.

mafted · 07/01/2022 10:30

It was important enough for you to find out 'what's between it's legs' it's surely important enough for people to pass comment on.

Unless people are saying "oh thank goodness it's a boy can't stand your daughter" I don't see the issue.

WorraLiberty · 07/01/2022 10:29

Well as DD was a surprise all the 0 - 3 months stuff is unisex but unless DS is planning on heading to nursery in all of the dresses DD is currently outgrowing in age 12 - 18 months, then yes, he will need more to be purchased. Saving starts here Grin

You're buying clothes now for your unborn baby that he won't be able to wear for a year to a year and a half?

See I just think you're being a bit economical with the truth. You were interested to find out the sex of your unborn baby, which is fine - lots of people do this.

What's strange is that you think it's weird when other people show an interest.

I appreciate you said you haven't been outwardly snippy with people, but unless you keep it that way, I think they're going to assume you're disappointed and would have preferred 2 girls.

And looking at the size of your opening post and considering some of your answers, it does look a bit like that to me.

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 10:29

@Phrowzunn oh gosh, what a scare for you - I really hope baby is ok. I’m not trying to find things to be upset about but can completely see why it would look like that given the seriousness of your news, it really puts it in perspective. I will be happy, and keep everything crossed for you and your DC. Flowers (really sending you good wishes - if it is a hole in the heart, just wanted to say that DH had a septal defect identified at birth back in the late 80s, had surgery aged 4 and is a fit and healthy 30-something now who ran the London marathon last year - just in case a positive story would help while you’re processing your news).

OP posts:
MollysDolly · 07/01/2022 10:24

DH thinks I’m massively overthinking it

Your DH is right.

As PP said, "oh, a boy, how lovely"...."oh, a sister for DD, how lovely"...

It's just how people congratulate. You sound a bit precious.

Phrowzunn · 07/01/2022 10:22

I had my 20wk scan yesterday and they’ve said they think there’s a hole in the baby’s heart. We have two DD already but didn’t find out sex as we don’t mind either way and we want to wait for the surprise. If I knew you I would think that your finding out the sex meant you cared and might appreciate a message on the subject. Honestly, your baby is healthy and you are not disappointed by the sex (as I understand some people can be) but you are still reaching to find something to be upset about? I just can’t imagine trying to put a negative spin on your friend’s and family’s well wishes. Just be happy!

Seahawk80 · 07/01/2022 10:21

@Laiste my sister had a v similar reaction to her 3rd girl from an older relative- they were so happy with another girl but it did upset her.

MrsTimRiggins · 07/01/2022 10:20

It’s just something to say in reply to being told news which doesn’t affect them in any way whatsoever. That’s not to say they aren’t happy for you, but that they’d have been happy either way.
Let’s be honest, it wouldn’t be very nice if they just said ‘oh right’ and moved on without commenting at all would it?

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 10:20

@WorraLiberty

my motivation for finding out was more ‘oh god do I need to buy more clothes’

Do newborn boys need more clothes than girls?

Well as DD was a surprise all the 0 - 3 months stuff is unisex but unless DS is planning on heading to nursery in all of the dresses DD is currently outgrowing in age 12 - 18 months, then yes, he will need more to be purchased. Saving starts here Grin
OP posts:
TheDuchessOfMN · 07/01/2022 10:19

Even though I never had a preference for myself, I’ll admit that I’d secretly think there’s something “lucky” about having both a boy and then a girl or vice versa. It’s probably because I assume it’s quite unlikely, statistically, if you’re to only have 2. I know it’s all just silly gender nonsense anyway Smile

SeeminglyOblivious · 07/01/2022 10:19

Some people desperately want both boys and girls (or just girls)
and project that onto others ime.

When we announced ds3's birth, comments included:
'Oh hun, I really had my fingers crossed for a girl for you this time [sad face]`
'Ah bet you're gutted! At least the boys will be pleased though!'
'Do you think you might have one last try for a girl?'

Honestly it was so bizarre.

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 10:18

”well it’s a shame it’s another boy, but at least he doesn’t have something wrong with him”

Crikey @PinkPiranha11. I’d have been tempted to say “well, except the grandmother he’s stuck with…” (in my dreams. I am obviously nowhere near this quick-witted in real life).

@Itsalmostanaccessory I promise I haven’t said anything to anyone about this IRL except in chatting to DH about how weird I find it but I will stop being snippy and accept the majority verdict that it is just what people say!

OP posts:
Echobelly · 07/01/2022 10:16

I agree with pps, it's just something to say really. I didn't find out sex before birth but when I had DS a lot of people were 'How nice, one of each'. And it was nice, not on account of gender just to have the 'variety' of one of each. Not that oldest (13) can seem to decide what gender they are from week to week after all that anyway as is the way these days! Grin