Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it weird that we’re being congratulated on our baby’s sex?

133 replies

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 09:25

We had our 20 week scan this week. My overwhelming feeling is just sheer gratitude that nothing has been picked up as a health concern - I have friends who haven’t been so lucky including friends who have had to TFMR at this point, so I didn’t go into it with any other hopes than baby being ok.

We already have a one year old DD and due to the small age gap/the fact we only plan to have two we decided to find out the sex of this baby, which we didn’t with DD. Neither of us had any preference at all, to my mind we either got one of each or DD got a sister, and frankly both outcomes were brilliant. Baby is a boy and I’m super excited.

Since we’d found out, we mentioned it in passing to close family (siblings, parents) and since then we’ve been getting heaps of messages off other friends and family to congratulate us on the baby’s sex. Haven’t posted it on social media or mentioned it to anyone other than immediate family who had asked directly, but they’ve obviously passed it on (both sides, this isn’t an in-laws bash!) And I don’t mind that they’ve passed it on, it’s not a secret, I just generally assumed no one except the parents really gives a damn about it Grin

Am I being U to find the fact we’re getting loads of congratulatory messages bizarre? I could understand people messaging to say they’re glad the baby seems healthy, and obviously once baby is here, but ‘congrats on what’s between its legs’ seems a bit… odd? DH thinks I’m massively overthinking it, but I feel like congratulations is only appropriate when the alternative outcome is less good (ie congrats the baby is here safely). I will say I’m the sort of person who wouldn’t dream of giving a gift until a baby has actually arrived - I feel a bit uneasy about it tbh, maybe due to my friends’ experiences - so for me it’s in a very different category to birth announcements.

DH says I’m being snippy because I’m reading it as ‘a second girl wouldn’t have been as good’ and people are just pleased for us. I’m sure there’s no malice but I think being congratulated on something that a) is 50/50 and b) doesn’t really matter either way is really odd! AIBU?

(Just to say if I am U I promise to take it on the chin and this definitely isn’t a ‘gender disappointment’ post. More a ‘sex wtf’ post Grin)

OP posts:
yellowtwo · 07/01/2022 11:31

It is just something people say, but my experience of having two girls is similar to what Bolshybun is saying. I had people say to me, is your partner disappointed, he might have liked a boy. You can try for the boy next time, and so on.

chipsinonehandpieinother · 07/01/2022 11:25

@Mouseonmychair

To be fair congratulations on having a baby is hardly the biggest achievement. There have been billions born over history it hardly getting a first from Oxford.
That's the sort of thing I used to say before I had kids. 'Rats manage to have babies too. Its not that amazing, is it?' I'd think. Grin

I don't say that now. I think babies are brilliant!

Bolshybun · 07/01/2022 11:24

I voted yanbu cos I got plagued by my husbands family that they wanted a boy once we announced we were pregnant, as they had no grandsons. They made a huge deal of ‘getting their boy’ after our 20 week scan and in the end I did say I was just happy the baby was healthy after our first pregnancy was complicated. So I am fully aware I am answering your question from my own experience!
Congratulations on the new addition xx

Thoosa · 07/01/2022 11:22

to my mind we either got one of each or DD got a sister, and frankly both outcomes were brilliant.

You are somewhat buying into the nonsense, though. Why do you think of a girl having a sister or (the dreaded) “one of each” as good outcomes?

I remember getting a lot of the “one of each!” congratulations after DC2 was born and was completely bemused.

Any healthy baby is an “excellent outcome” isn’t it?

PinkPomeranian · 07/01/2022 11:20

I've definitely said, "Congratulations!" or "Oh how lovely!" when told whether baby is a boy or a girl, without caring either way. It's nice, welcome news either way. Maybe "Oh right." just sounds a bit flippant or uninterested as a response?

However I do think some people are a bit obsessed with boys or girls, or one of each, depending on their own feelings. We only have girls and have been on the receiving end of stupid comments from strangers, like, "Better luck next time," "What a shame," or "Are you gonna try for a boy?" Hmm And quite a few people asked my kids whether they wanted a brother or a sister, which we swiftly put a stop to as it's not as if we could send it back if it wasn't what they wanted.

I'm glad all looked healthy at your scan, OP. Good luck for the rest of your pregnancy. Smile

emmaluggs · 07/01/2022 11:19

Massively over thinking it.

JanuaryPinks · 07/01/2022 11:15

Yeah like everyone else said, they’d have made a positive comment no matter what the outcome. You’re definitely over thinking this. Once the baby is born people will comment on his size (big or small), hair (presence or lack), eyes (colour, whatever it is). No need to get worked up about any of it.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 07/01/2022 11:12

You are massively overthinking it.
Tbf didn't find out the sex with any of our 3 girls so probably dodged a bullet.
But if someone said "molly and Bob are having a boy". I probably would say we'll done, one of each!
So shoot me!

mumshouse · 07/01/2022 11:09

I viewed a male colleague differently after he greeted the news that a nephew would be coming after two nieces with "Oh, it will be worth visiting one of their babies finally!"

bcc89 · 07/01/2022 11:07

People are congratulating you just as they would if you'd been told you were having a girl. They're excited it's a boy in the same way you're excited to be getting a son, I wouldn't reach anything else into it.
They obviously and rightly are joining in your excitement to find out the sex.

MrsReeves · 07/01/2022 11:07

@45redballoons

I'm pregnant with my first just now, I'm asked at least once a day if I know what it is. I'm past the scans now so hopefully I'll stop being asked if I'll find out. I was going to ask just so I could shut people up, but I genuinely don't care. If I accidentally refer to it as a he or she people start squeeling.

I suppose people are just trying to show an interest so you know they care, but it is irritating.

I didn't find out the sex with any of my 3. I used to answer "do you know what it is?" With either "it's a baby" or "either a boy or a girl" Grin
Antsgomarching · 07/01/2022 11:02

They are trying to find nice things to say to you to be supportive. Other peoples pregnancies aren’t that exciting so they are just showing that they are still taking an interest. You are seriously overthinking it.

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 11:01

@MollysDolly

I appreciate you said you haven't been outwardly snippy with people, but unless you keep it that way, I think they're going to assume you're disappointed and would have preferred 2 girls.

And looking at the size of your opening post and considering some of your answers, it does look a bit like that to me.

That's exactly how I read it too.

I am (honestly!) logging off now to focus on work, but I just wanted to say it definitely isn't this. I'm so excited for my boy. I just see so many posts on here telling people 'no one really cares about baby's sex except you', and found it weird to receive messages. But I totally accept I am BU. And now I will go focus on my scary spreadsheet Smile
OP posts:
KirstenBlest · 07/01/2022 11:00

Only read the OP.

Par for the course I'm afraid. DSib has two of the same, I have two of the same

We both got the 'Aren't you disappointed it wasn't a...?' and 'You might get a [boy/girl] next time)

People are twats

Seeline · 07/01/2022 11:00

I get it OP

You didn't 'announce it', you simply told your parents. Now you're getting messages from all over congratulating you on the sex of your baby. I think it's weird. Goodwill messages, say pleased it's healthy, or things are progressing well OK, but it's not a face to face conversation, or even something you have said in a particular message to others.

I don't get these massive gender reveal parties either.

I'm just getting old I think.

elliejjtiny · 07/01/2022 10:58

It's just something people say. I'm sure they would be equally pleased for you if you were having another girl.

I've got 5 boys, people always say I must be mad, "didn't you want a girl then?" (like I had a choice!) or ask me if I'm going to keep trying for a girl. It's just normal small talk, although the lady who offered condolences when my healthy ds3 was born was rude.

Dollywilde · 07/01/2022 10:58

[quote Phrowzunn]@Dollywilde thank you. Sorry if I was snippy. I’m so frightened. Good to hear about your DH. Although I have a 4yo and the thought of trying to explain to her that she needs surgery on her heart makes me want to cry! Your husband must have been so scared. But we’ll cross that bridge if we come to it I guess. Best wishes for the rest of your pregnancy, and remember to try and see the good in people before the bad. Honestly, most people are just trying their best to be nice.[/quote]
@Phrowzunn Oh I can't imagine either Flowers If it's any consolation my DMIL has said it was much, much worse for her than for DS when he had the op. Apparently his main overriding memory is getting an autographed football from his favourite club as he was on the local children's ward! Best wishes to you too and really hope it's not as serious as first thought.

OP posts:
Sally872 · 07/01/2022 10:58

@Skeumorph

'Oh a BOY how amazing, one of each!'

'Oh a GIRL how amazing, sisters, you can't beat it, they'll be so close'

This is how people congratulate

Completely agree with this.
GroggyLegs · 07/01/2022 10:55

YANBU but I feel the same as you, you can't lose second time round.
Either you get your 'perfect pair' 🤮 or 'they'll be best of friends' (as my 2 irritate the life out if each other constantly & deliberately).

There's definitely a minor social value put on having different sex kids though, as if it's anything other than sperm roulette.

People look shocked when I say I'd want a third boy. Boys are ace.

Grida · 07/01/2022 10:55

A very large number of people are completely open about wanting at least one of each gender so it isn’t really surprising that people congratulate you.

CoastalWave · 07/01/2022 10:51

@SeeminglyOblivious

Some people desperately want both boys and girls (or just girls) and project that onto others ime.

When we announced ds3's birth, comments included:
'Oh hun, I really had my fingers crossed for a girl for you this time [sad face]`
'Ah bet you're gutted! At least the boys will be pleased though!'
'Do you think you might have one last try for a girl?'

Honestly it was so bizarre.

Being honest though. ALL of my friends who have had 2 of one gender have tried for a third to balance the mix.

Do people honestly just try for a third and have no preference at all? Or deep down are they really hoping it's a boy or a girl?

I think possibly people presume (sometimes incorrectly) that the only reason you would want a third child is if you don't already have one of each?

Just curious.

On the flip side, I have one of each and people very openly make comments like oh well at least you don't have to have any more babies - so presume that's the point of having two.

PinkSyCo · 07/01/2022 10:50

Oh for goodness sake, you were the one who asked about the baby’s sex so it clearly does mean something to you. Stop picking on people when they’re only trying to be nice ffs.

godmum56 · 07/01/2022 10:50

I am not going to say yabu but I've done it myself when told the sex of the expected baby....I say oh how lovely for xxx (older child) to have a little brother or similar....a congratulation that mentions the sex but only in passing if it was something like "phew glad you got a boy this time" or similar, I'd be upset but not for general comments.

Phrowzunn · 07/01/2022 10:47

@Dollywilde thank you. Sorry if I was snippy. I’m so frightened. Good to hear about your DH. Although I have a 4yo and the thought of trying to explain to her that she needs surgery on her heart makes me want to cry! Your husband must have been so scared. But we’ll cross that bridge if we come to it I guess. Best wishes for the rest of your pregnancy, and remember to try and see the good in people before the bad. Honestly, most people are just trying their best to be nice.

CoastalWave · 07/01/2022 10:46

Massively massively overthinking it.

What did you want them to say?? Have you ever written on a post where somewhere says they're having a girl/boy - Wow great that it's still healthy.

Erm no. Brilliant, one of each or ooh brilliant girls love having sisters.

It's just conversation.

Best buckle up for parenting two kids of a different sex for the rest of your life - the comments don't stop!