Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance straight to GC, skipping childless DC

318 replies

Shuk · 06/01/2022 22:10

How would you feel if your parents left money to your nieces & nephews but not you or your siblings, and you don't have DC, but have possibly had more financial support as an adult than your siblings (though not as much as their dc will inherit)

YABU - no one is entitled to anything
YANBU - this isn't fair and likely to cause considerable upset

For context it's not my parents, and I have DC who would benefit. I think this is hugely unfair.

OP posts:
gsaoej · 07/01/2022 09:55

Definitely the way to a family rift.

You leave stuff equally to your own dc
If you decide to leave stuff directly to gc, those gc need to receive the share that their parent would have received.

Anything else and there will be fighting

Clymene · 07/01/2022 09:54

@Doomscrolling

My parents are dividing their estate between the grandchildren, in trust until they are 30. (Eldest GC is 23, youngest 16)

This seems a great idea to me - as their DC we are doing ok but don’t have much savings, so can’t help the DG into the property ladder in a meaningful way, whereas an inheritance from their grandparents would mean they all have a reasonable deposit for a house.

Do all your siblings have children?

I will pass my inheritance onto my children to enable them get into the property ladder. The same way my parents did for me. I think it would have been really unfair if my grandparents had split their estate between my generation. It would have meant 3/4 of their estate went to my dad's family which seems very cruel when my aunt and uncle wanted more children but suffered years of secondary infertility.

VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2022 09:52

@Clymene

Nice bit of selective quoting there *@VanGoghsDog - you missed out (including grandchildren) which followed 'anyone else' in @Mountaingoat12*'s post
I didn't miss it out, I noted she also said "anyone else". Don't be silly.
VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2022 09:51

You need to be wary of thinking wills can be continually updated - they cannot be updated once the writer loses their faculties.

This was an issue with my mum because she's 81. My brother I suppose night have more kids, but more likely his wife will leave him and take their daughter back to her home country and never be seen again. Will my mum really still want the ex DIL getting a share of her estate? (And how will I, as executor, find her?) It might be too late to do anything about it if my mum has gone dotty. I tried to get her to think about this, and loads of other possible scenarios, but she just wouldn't.

Clymene · 07/01/2022 09:51

Nice bit of selective quoting there @VanGoghsDog - you missed out (including grandchildren) which followed 'anyone else' in @Mountaingoat12's post

ajandjjmum · 07/01/2022 09:47

@Walking4You

One big issue I have with skipping a generation is that, depending in the ages of the children and GC, some GC might well receive nothing at all I’d they are ‘born too late’….
My parents Wills were written before all of the DGC were born, but there was simple legal wording to cover the arrival of future GC, so that they wouldn't be excluded.

Having said that, we all need to remember that a Will isn't a document that's made once and left - it should be amended as people grow older and family structures change.

Doomscrolling · 07/01/2022 09:47

My parents are dividing their estate between the grandchildren, in trust until they are 30. (Eldest GC is 23, youngest 16)

This seems a great idea to me - as their DC we are doing ok but don’t have much savings, so can’t help the DG into the property ladder in a meaningful way, whereas an inheritance from their grandparents would mean they all have a reasonable deposit for a house.

VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2022 09:42

[quote Clymene]@VanGoghsDog - the £500k limit also applies to grandchildren. [/quote]
Yes, but not "anyone else", which the post included.

Clymene · 07/01/2022 09:40

@VanGoghsDog - the £500k limit also applies to grandchildren.

Walking4You · 07/01/2022 09:39

One big issue I have with skipping a generation is that, depending in the ages of the children and GC, some GC might well receive nothing at all I’d they are ‘born too late’….

Walking4You · 07/01/2022 09:36

I think it’s impossible to say in general what is or isn’t fair. It depends on the amount of money involved for each GC, how well off are the dcs, if they have provision for their retirement etc…

There are situations where giving to the dcs will be much fairer.

Eg my gran gave the inheritance to her dcs which was really necessary for at least 3 of her 4 dcs who were struggling a lot financially (for very different reasons. One was dead so money went to her dd, one had a chronic illness that stopped them from working, one was a single parent).

Some situations where giving most/all of the money would be fairer
Eg DH as an only child. We are financially secure, retirement sorted so giving the money to the dgc makes much more sense iyswim.

You also have the issue that some people will be uncomfortable giving the inheritance to their dcs out of fear they will get divorced so half of it will ‘leave the family’.
(I personally think that inheritance should NOT e part of the common assets when divorcing u less it has been used to support the family eg in buying the family house. But that’s a different topic really)

BertieBotts · 07/01/2022 09:35

Ah I see, well, yes, but that rather relies on the parents not wanting it for themselves! I suppose that comes down to the trust issue.

Yesthatscorrect · 07/01/2022 09:35

Someone I knows elderly relative is planning to do this. When they wrote their will the childless adult child was very well off. The other adult child has been a single parent and never earned a lot, although always worked hard and also provided all the care for the elderly relative.

The rich childless one now has lost everything and stands to inherit nothing. They don't even know.

Liverbird77 · 07/01/2022 09:34

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Clymene · 07/01/2022 09:33

[quote BertieBotts]@Clymene not all parents have money just lying around to help their DC buy a house.[/quote]
No of course they don't. But the poster was implying that their grandparents do. So if the grandparents pass their cash to their children, they the. will have the money 'lying around' to help their children won't they?

GnomeDePlume · 07/01/2022 09:33

I agree that communication is important. Much better tackled any feelings of hurt now than have them added to the grief after death.

I think some people dont communicate because they dont want to have to deal with the feelings of hurt. They would rather not have to bother about it especially if they know that what they are planning is going to be hurtful.

I suspect that to an extent DB2 was counting on getting a share of DM's estate. In a way I feel a bit sorry for him. DB1 has always been the 'golden child'. DB2 has always been seen as 'the problem child'. DB1 has a lot of influence over DM and would rather see DM's estate go to GCs than see DB2 get any part of it.

On the plus side, I suspect that DB1's plotting is going to bite him. Once DM is gone DB1 will likely want to move back to his home town. A share of DM's estate would have made this much more affordable. Having influenced DM to construct a rather silly will he now wont be getting that share!

VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2022 09:33

@Clymene

Mountaingoat12

I am pretty sure there are tax advantages to leaving the main residence to children as opposed to anyone else (inc grandchildren).

Leave your money split equally between your children and they can decide whether to pass it on.

There aren't.

There most definitely is a tax advantage in leaving the main residence to direct offspring. It is not included fur inheritance tax purposes up to something like £500k.

If you leave it elsewhere it's part of the estate so there is more tax to pay.

00100001 · 07/01/2022 09:32

@Ozanj

GP to skip dc to pass to GC are usually doing it as one last power trip in my experience. It just doesn’t happen in families with healthy relationships
Happened in our family. Not a single person thought anything of it.
BertieBotts · 07/01/2022 09:29

@Clymene not all parents have money just lying around to help their DC buy a house.

VanGoghsDog · 07/01/2022 09:27

@JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn

I don't understand this 'skipping a generation' thing. Why not split equally between the children, they can then give what they choose to their children (the grandchildren). The money could also help provide the grandchildren with a better childhood. I'd be very unhappy if money was sat doing nothing waiting for a grandchild to be old enough to inherit it while I was struggling to meet the day to day costs of living.
Well, it depends, doesn't it?

My niece and nephews grandparents on the other side have all agreed to skip a generation. There are five GC, two from one and three from another. The first generation are all well off, no needs at all. The five GC are all adults ranging from 18 to 33, one of whom has a career in the arts and will never have any money, another has worked hard but struggling to get on property ladder, the remaining three a bit more settled due to better off parents but still, the money would be useful.

If it is left to the direct offspring and they don't immediately move it down the line, or do so but die within seven years, assuming their estates are over the IHR limits (they very much will be) then it just adds to money that IHT gets paid on. Skipping a generation is a type of IHT planning.

On my side, however, we are three siblings. One has no kids, one has two, one has one. The two are over age thirty, the one is aged four.

Originally my mother wanted to write her will to split everything seven ways between three siblings, three GC and one DIL (there are no other spouses). I said no.

So in the end we agreed she would split three ways, between the three siblings, but the sibling with two DC gets one third of her third, with her kids also getting a third of that each, the sibling with one DC getting a third of his third while his wife and child get a third each too (mad), and the childless sibling (me) gets a third in full.

It's bonkers but at least this way I get my full third. I don't "need" it as such but it would make my retirement easier (course she might not have much left to leave, and that's fine, but unlikely).

The driving force for all this nonsense is my mother wanting my brother's wife to inherit so she "has her own money". At least it's only coming from my brother's due share this way!

If she skipped a generation, I'd get nothing. I'll leave all my estate to my niece and nephew (the two who are adults now) anyway, so they'll get it in the end, or it'll be spent on care.

diddl · 07/01/2022 09:25

A child hasn't been disinherited for being childless though as none of the children are inheriting.

mindutopia · 07/01/2022 09:23

I would be really upset with anyone giving a large sum of money directly to my children. I am NC with my family (they have a lot of money and I would have been in a position to inherit quite a lot - I'm an only child and mum's partner is NC with his children and GC).

I've been very direct with my mum that I am perfectly happy to never inherit anything, but I absolutely do NOT want that money to go directly to my dc. I think maybe it would be different if we were talking £5000. We'd probably be talking more £500K each. I think it's hugely inappropriate to put an 18 year old in a position of coming into that much money without having the life experience and maturity to know how to cope with it. I suspect she'll still leave it to them out of spite. Hmm I think if children are actual children, unless there is a backstory, it's more appropriate for that money to go to the adults who can keep it safe for them.

But in this case, yes, I think it's really hurtful to leave someone who doesn't have children out of the will entirely.

chipsinonehandpieinother · 07/01/2022 09:23

I hope FIL does give his money direct to grandchildren rather than his children ( my H). The kids need it more.

ajandjjmum · 07/01/2022 09:21

@Ozanj

GP to skip dc to pass to GC are usually doing it as one last power trip in my experience. It just doesn’t happen in families with healthy relationships
Sorry, but you're talking rubbish. Every family is different.

My DP's did exactly that and discussed it with DB and myself when they were making their Wills, to make sure that we agreed. We did - it made sense. DH and I and my DB and his DW are comfortable and don't need more money. As it worked out, the inheritance our DC received helped them all get a foot on the property ladder.

My family have very healthy relationships - the reason being that we talk and we're not totally selfish.

Aprilx · 07/01/2022 09:17

I cannot vote because I don’t think the two options are opposite and mutually exclusive. I could say YABU because I firmly believe nobody is entitled to anything. But I also think that it is wrong and divisive to disinherit a child because they are childless themselves in favour of their siblings children.

If somebody is going to leave their estate to the family, as most people do, I don’t see the logic of skipping a generation. Take that to its natural conclusion down a line and every other generation is skipped over, just why? If the child of the deceased wants to help their offspring get onto the housing ladder, then they are free to share.