Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance straight to GC, skipping childless DC

318 replies

Shuk · 06/01/2022 22:10

How would you feel if your parents left money to your nieces & nephews but not you or your siblings, and you don't have DC, but have possibly had more financial support as an adult than your siblings (though not as much as their dc will inherit)

YABU - no one is entitled to anything
YANBU - this isn't fair and likely to cause considerable upset

For context it's not my parents, and I have DC who would benefit. I think this is hugely unfair.

OP posts:
LaBelleSausage · 06/01/2022 23:11

My grandmother fell out with her identical twin sister over this scenario.
She had two children, her sister had one, her brother had none.

Money was left 2/3 to my grandma and 1/3 to her twin, nothing for her brother.

Her twin suggested that half of the money given to my grandma should go to their brother.

The fallout was so bad that they never spoke again and I first met my great aunt at my grandma's funeral.

I feel like maybe this situation would work for some families but it can easily go very badly.

Returnoftheowl · 06/01/2022 23:10

If the childfree sibling doesn't know then that is extremely hurtful. They'll likely feel hurt by their parents and also hurt by the other family member who did know. That seems unnecessary cruel by the parents.

TenoringBehind · 06/01/2022 23:10

MIL has done this with her will and it has caused a lot of resentment amongst dh and his siblings. We have 2 children, SIL has five, BIL has three.

All three children would prefer that the money went to them instead. Dh and BIL think it’s unfair that SIl’s children get 50% of everything between them.

WTF475878237NC · 06/01/2022 23:09

Yes absolutely. If the adult hadn't had children and had also not received a comparable amount in advance this would be hugely hurtful because of the sentiment.

Bellie710 · 06/01/2022 23:08

My parents have left everything to me and my siblings and they are trying to do it as equal as possible, my Dh parents MIL wants everything to go to the GC FIL thinks give to your own kids and they provide for their kids. My DM was completely screwed by her siblings over her parents will and all I have said to my parents is I give no shits what they do with their money but do not leave us to sort it all out!

PurpleDaisies · 06/01/2022 23:07

It wouldn’t be the money that would be hurtful. It would be the lack of care for anyone that hadn’t managed to reproduce successfully.

WTF475878237NC · 06/01/2022 23:07

@FreezerBird have your parents considered holding the money in trust for each grandchild until a certain age?

I agree it seems fair if taking into account the help adult children have received.

Tayegete · 06/01/2022 23:05

I think it should go to the DC split equally and then they can pass it on to their children if the want to / can afford to / have children. We have 2 dc and the eldest has a disability and has made a career choice that means money is always likely to be a struggle for her but I still can’t bring myself to give DS less as I think it would be really hurtful.

2Rebecca · 06/01/2022 23:03

My father has discussed his will and things are divided equally between my 2 sibs and I. I think that is fairest. How many children we chose to have is irrelevant. It is our job as parents to provide for our children. I think you only skip a generation if you hate your kids

Shuk · 06/01/2022 23:01

@Returnoftheowl

This sounds like an easy way to start a family rift. If be hurt if I was the childless sibling. Of course it's their money to do what they want with. But I'd feel that I'd been shown as the least important family member, therefore I would expect to take a much lesser caring role in their old age than those clearly favoured by the parents.
Childfree DC doesn't know Sad
OP posts:
Returnoftheowl · 06/01/2022 22:59

This sounds like an easy way to start a family rift. If be hurt if I was the childless sibling.
Of course it's their money to do what they want with. But I'd feel that I'd been shown as the least important family member, therefore I would expect to take a much lesser caring role in their old age than those clearly favoured by the parents.

Selttan · 06/01/2022 22:57

My parents will as it currently stands is a set amount left to the two grandchildren and the rest which is the bulk split between my sister and I.
Even though they've helped raise their grandkids I think they've done it this way as they know I will be leaving everything of mine to the grandchildren.
I'm
Not sure if they'll change it though as since it's been done my sister is a now drug addict.

Although I hope they enjoy their money now and there's not much left.

budgiegirl · 06/01/2022 22:57

On mumsnet, no one is entitled to anything from an inheritance, ever.

In real life, most people I know would be very upset by this. Unless there's a very good reason, it seems fairest to me to leave equally between children. Then, if the beneficiaries wish to, they can pass on to their children, nieces, nephews etc as they see fit. I really can't imagine a situation where I would leave my estate (such as it is!) to my grandchildren rather than children (other than a small cash gift). I have no idea how my children's circumstances may change in the future, after I'm gone.

2Rebecca · 06/01/2022 22:54

If 1 child has no children, 1 child has 1 child and a 3rd child has 4 children then the 3 adult children's parent is effectively giving one of his chilldren's offspring 4/5 of his money. It should be split equally between the 3 children, with money removed possibly if you have been given loads earlier that the others haven't had. It shouldn't be a race to produce the most sprogs to get the most money. The planet is still overpopulated.

AlizeeEasy · 06/01/2022 22:52

as a childless adult this would be upsetting. I know my parents have decided to split inheritance equally among me and my siblings. Even though my siblings have multiple children, my parents attitude is that they chose how many kids to have but they had no input in the life choices me and my siblings made so whether we have kids or are already wealthy makes no difference to what we get.

ivykaty44 · 06/01/2022 22:51

You can understand why in some other countries the will is guided to not disinherit family members

JustLyra · 06/01/2022 22:49

Has the childless DC been consulted about it?

I know two families with will set ups like that but the childless DC suggested it in both cases

Drunkpanda · 06/01/2022 22:46

Bad idea.
Also, is the sibling without children possibly going to have them later? As they could end up with dc not mentioned in the will who would receive nothing.

margotsdevil · 06/01/2022 22:43

I suspect we are likely to be in a similar situation. Other siblings have received more financial help and use parents as unpaid childcare frequently - and only make effort when childcare is required or it's a birthday etc. We are childfree and make a lot of effort to spend time with parents, but are fully expecting to be cut out of will in favour of grandchildren. It is not a nice feeling.

Melroses · 06/01/2022 22:43

It depends on whether the grandparents have given their children money during their lifetime.

My MIL did this - the plan was that she used up her tax gift allowance each year giving money to her children, then the rest was for care home fees, then when she died the residue would be divided between grandchildren as a nice thing to remember her by.

It does need regular review as things change, and also good communication about the intentions.

If the childless child is not part of the decision making process, it would be rather awkward.

errnerrcallnernnernnern · 06/01/2022 22:42

Very unfair.

whynotwhatknot · 06/01/2022 22:41

no i dont think its fair its like punishing one because they didnt provide gc

Kshhuxnxk · 06/01/2022 22:40

Either spend it all before you go or leave it equally to your children.

Iamanicepersonreally · 06/01/2022 22:37

I think it’s hurtful. I wouldn’t say anything but I’d be upset

Smallkeys · 06/01/2022 22:36

My DF left to me and my siblings and a specified amount to each grandchild. So one sibling got a bigger proportion more kids other no kids but at least some money was received by all :-)

Swipe left for the next trending thread