Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance straight to GC, skipping childless DC

318 replies

Shuk · 06/01/2022 22:10

How would you feel if your parents left money to your nieces & nephews but not you or your siblings, and you don't have DC, but have possibly had more financial support as an adult than your siblings (though not as much as their dc will inherit)

YABU - no one is entitled to anything
YANBU - this isn't fair and likely to cause considerable upset

For context it's not my parents, and I have DC who would benefit. I think this is hugely unfair.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 06/01/2022 23:55

But the parents have already given the childless child financial support directly.

I don’t think that matters. Their enduring memory will be that their parent didn’t want to leave them anything when they died.

Supersimkin2 · 06/01/2022 23:54

The GP don’t love the DC they’ve left out.

That’s what everyone thinks, inc the DC.

They’re right.

TheHoptimist · 06/01/2022 23:54

My parents both inherited from their parents and retired in their 50s, they go on about how wonderful it was, how it allowed them to pay off their mortgage, spend time with their grandchildren, travel the world etc.

They have left to their grandchildren. Have to say I do find hard to understand why- my sisters and I would also love to retire to spend time with grandchildren.

But ultimately it is their choice. Equal split amongst grandchildren- 3 children have differing numbers of children- so not an equal split to each family branch. (1, 2 and 3)

Changemyname18 · 06/01/2022 23:54

Have seen this in a family I know, where inheritance was split equally between all grandchildren, but for the reason that grandparent was no longer talking with one of their children, but were still in contact with the grandchildren from this line of their family. Therefore they didnt want the child they no longer spoke to, to inherit, and thought then it was 'fairer' that none of their 3 children would inherit, and all passed directly to all grandchildren. However, for fairness this doesn't work either, as they had three children and 8 grandchildren. So rather that inheritance being split into 3rds for each line, it is split half, quarter and quarter, as one child produced 4 grandchildren for them, and the others 'only' had 2. The 4 grandchildren siblings therefore have a bigger proportion of inheritance than if it was shared out from their parent as a 3rd of the total.
Crikey, this is confusing, i needed to draw out a diagram! If my maths is right, the 4 sibling grandchildren gained 1/8, when via their parent it would have been 1/12. The 2 sibling grandchildren gainef 1/8, when via their parents it would have been 1/6. Should the 2 sibling grandchildren have been penalised just because they don't have more siblings?

steff13 · 06/01/2022 23:52

Because it's still going to their siblings families. It's benefitting their siblings by benefitting their children.

But the parents have already given the childless child financial support directly.

Ohisitreally · 06/01/2022 23:45

My darling Mum left most of her estate to me and my sister...our brother was disinherited because of his rubbish behaviour towards lovely Mum .
Grandchildren all got a few thousand each ..all good here .

backtolifebacktoreality · 06/01/2022 23:44

One of my sisters has one child. My brother has four. I've told my parents that i think it's unfair to split the money between grandchildren as my brother's family will get a lot more. They are going to leave it to their adult children who can decide what they do with it!

LessTime · 06/01/2022 23:42

Assuming no disabilities or special need for money I think inheritances should always be split evenly between children with adjustments if some children have received much more financial help. If a grandparent wants to leave money to a grandchild it should come out of the grandchild’s parents share.

I think there is something unkind to overlook childless children.

I say this as someone with more kids than my siblings.

madisonbridges · 06/01/2022 23:40

How are they valued less? The money isn't going to the children who gave them grandchildren, it's just going to their grandchildren.
Because it's still going to their siblings families. It's benefitting their siblings by benefitting their children.

You're looking at this from a logical point of view, but families aren't about logic. They're about feelings. I have a couple of friends who were told by their mothers that they were not going to inherit as much as one of their siblings. Neither of my friends desperately needed the money so that wasn't an issue. What was an issue was that they felt that their parent was choosing a sibling over them and that hurt. You might be logical and say the mother was helping the neediest out most. But sibling dynamics are complicated. They inspire the most basic feelings. If you feel your parents, the people who are supposed to love you most, chose someone else over you, it can feel like rejection.

I0NA · 06/01/2022 23:39

I know a family with two DD - one was married with two children and the other was single. The single DD would have loved to be married with children but it never happened for her and she was very sad about it.

When the parents died they divided their estate 5 ways - one fifth to each of their DD, the son in law and the GC.

Apparently they thought this was fair but the single Dd was devastated. It was just another way of her parents pointing out that she was a failure without a husband and children.

I’ve no idea how people can be so cruel to their own children ☹️☹️☹️

ChicCroissant · 06/01/2022 23:36

Oh dear, the OP's situation seems the worst possible solution to me!

One sibling (not the OP's partner) has had more financial support from their parents, but that means that the supported child's siblings now get nothing and it goes straight to their children instead. I can see that smarting a bit - yes, it's absolutely true that no-one is entitled to any legacy, but the parents look to have favoured one of their children (assuming that they did actually get financial help, as the OP doesn't seem certain).

Splitting the estate between the siblings seems fairest to me, even if the share for the supported sibling is reduced to take into account anything they may have received earlier.

AcrossthePond55 · 06/01/2022 23:36

@Shuk

Childfree DC doesn't know

^^This is what is unfair, that the childfree sibling doesn't know.

The parent has the right to do as they wish with their money, but to 'blindside' one of their children is just cruel and cowardly. Even if all the siblings are being treated equally in that they, themselves, will receive nothing. My assumption is that this is being left to the DGC either in trust so their parents have no access to it or that the DGC in question are adults.

I think your parents should be strongly encouraged to tell the childless sibling their plans.

ajandjjmum · 06/01/2022 23:31

@2Rebecca

My father has discussed his will and things are divided equally between my 2 sibs and I. I think that is fairest. How many children we chose to have is irrelevant. It is our job as parents to provide for our children. I think you only skip a generation if you hate your kids
I can promise you that my parents didn't hate me - they loved me dearly.

They also discussed their intentions in detail, and DB and I were happy for them to leave their Estate to our DC, as we were both perfectly comfortable. Communication is key.

SquirrelG · 06/01/2022 23:31

I strongly believe that no-one should be expecting an inheritance, however in cases like this YANBU. I'm not a believer of skipping a generation anyway, but when one member of the next generation has no DC and is effectively shut out I thing that is wrong, and likely to cause bad feeling and is especially wrong.

shinynewapple21 · 06/01/2022 23:27

I never understand this really . If the thought is that the generation in their 50s don't need the money for themselves then surely they will use an inheritance to support their own DC anyway.

Ifonlyiweretaller · 06/01/2022 23:24

Our parents are splitting their money equally between all their children. We asked that our inheritance from both sets of parents to go straight to our children, rather than to us. But our siblings will all get their proportion direct to them, and it's up to them what they then do with it.

Biker47 · 06/01/2022 23:24

@madisonbridges

I would be so upset. I'd feel I was valued less because I'd had no children.
How are they valued less? The money isn't going to the children who gave them grandchildren, it's just going to their grandchildren.
Biker47 · 06/01/2022 23:23

@TenoringBehind

MIL has done this with her will and it has caused a lot of resentment amongst dh and his siblings. We have 2 children, SIL has five, BIL has three.

All three children would prefer that the money went to them instead. Dh and BIL think it’s unfair that SIl’s children get 50% of everything between them.

I would be telling your husband and his siblings to grow up, their own children aren't being treat any different to all the other kids in your extended family, your two children are presumably getting the same split as your brother in laws 3 children and your sister in laws 5 children. It's not as if the sister-in-law is inheriting the lions share directly herself, and your husband and brother are being palmed off with smaller shares because of how many kids you each have, it's going to all of your independent children equally.

The way you're saying they're reacting probably makes it a good decision what your mother in law has done, sounds extremely grabby.

madisonbridges · 06/01/2022 23:17

I would be so upset. I'd feel I was valued less because I'd had no children.

Lifeisforalimitedperiodonly · 06/01/2022 23:15

I think any inheritance should be split between children irrespective of whether there are any grandchildren. Then they leave to their children and so on. It's really the only way to avoid arguments.

As for people getting more or less than their siblings because of money being given previously - the best way is to try and ensure that children are given money equally at the time. My friend's brother was useless with money and their parents were always bailing him out with a few hundred here and there. Whenever they did, they made sure my friend was given exactly the same amount.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 06/01/2022 23:14

I don't understand this 'skipping a generation' thing. Why not split equally between the children, they can then give what they choose to their children (the grandchildren). The money could also help provide the grandchildren with a better childhood. I'd be very unhappy if money was sat doing nothing waiting for a grandchild to be old enough to inherit it while I was struggling to meet the day to day costs of living.

Jisforjuggling · 06/01/2022 23:14

I started a thread a while ago about inheritance. In summary my mum proposes to cut me out of her will because I ‘don’t need anything’ (according to her). It has caused a HUGE family row. The vast vast majority of posters said that the only way to divide a will fairly was equally between the children, irrespective of how much money they had. Anything other then that sets up a hirerarchy of favouritism.
OP the proposed will you mention is grossly unfair and will only result in the left out child feeling they are less valued because they didn’t have children.

Clymene · 06/01/2022 23:13

Urgh this is horrible. Being rewarded for fecundity is what the pope does, not parents

TataMamma · 06/01/2022 23:12

My grandparents left everything divided equally between grandchildren. But it was what their children wanted, and they had 2 kids who both had 3 kids so everything was equal in that sense. When my mother inherited from her mother, she altered the will so everything got divided between her own children and she got nothing.
I hope to be in a situation where I do the same, when my parents pass on, although obviously a) it's their decision - they may leave it all to next doors cat :( b) it depends on my own financial situation; c) ages of kids is also important.
I think though if one child was childless I'd personally want to give them something, unless they were really well off. Certainly I think it should be discussed with them - if they've got their own home, nice pension and are close to nephews and nieces they might not be bothered anyway, but not discussing it at all sounds like it could create long lasting wounds.

I0NA · 06/01/2022 23:12

YANBU. I have left everything to my children equally. It will only go directly to any GC if my child predeceases them.