Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance straight to GC, skipping childless DC

318 replies

Shuk · 06/01/2022 22:10

How would you feel if your parents left money to your nieces & nephews but not you or your siblings, and you don't have DC, but have possibly had more financial support as an adult than your siblings (though not as much as their dc will inherit)

YABU - no one is entitled to anything
YANBU - this isn't fair and likely to cause considerable upset

For context it's not my parents, and I have DC who would benefit. I think this is hugely unfair.

OP posts:
steff13 · 07/01/2022 02:19

But say you had had two children. You gave 10,000 to one of your children. Your estate was worth 200,000. Would you give all 200,000 to the child that didn't get the 10,000?

No, but that's also not what the parents are doing here. The grandchildren are individuals separate from their parents.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 07/01/2022 02:18

I think it’s a very sensible idea. It doesn’t make sense to have to wait until you’re in your 50/60’s to have any financial help. If every generation was to do this, the family would become very wealthy as each generation would have a nice little nest egg to start their adult life with and invest in property etc.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/01/2022 02:16

I dont think people should be talking about inheritances, as in who in a family inherits something, and who doesn't. No one in my family would do such a thing.

If you're leaving everything equally to your children, then I agree that there's particular no need to discuss it; but surely it's better that everybody understand the reasoning behind less obvious decisions rather than families being torn apart after the loved one has gone?

If I'm interpreting the thinking behind your comment fairly, if anything, I think it's the less-close families that don't discuss money.

Others will disagree, but I believe that personal financial planning shouldn't only incorporate your own lifetime, but should also include where your money will go after you die and the effects of receiving (or not receiving) that money on your loved ones.

It always amazes me when you read on MN how many parents will do everything possible to help their children succeed whilst they're little (as you would, of course, expect); but then the very suggestion that you might want to leave behind those same (now adult) children with precious memories of you AND a fair share of your money as an inheritance to help them in their continuing life is frequently met with outrage that said children should have the audacity to hope that would be your desire.

I agree that some people are very distasteful about it and almost seem to be just waiting for their parents to die; but I don't think it's unreasonable or grabbing to expect that, once your beloved parents' assets are no more use to them whatsoever, they would choose you (and any siblings) as the people for it to pass to.

If you're happy for your legacy to potentially be one of resentment, confusion and worries that you didn't really love people whom you very much did, then never ever discuss it whilst alive; but that's most certainly not my personal choice.

TheHoptimist · 07/01/2022 02:08

@Kisskiss

If the kids are financially stable, then passing assets directly to grandkids is way more inheritance tax efficient
In what way is it more tax efficient? In the UK?
1forAll74 · 07/01/2022 02:01

I dont think people should be talking about inheritances, as in who in a family inherits something, and who doesn't. No one in my family would do such a thing.

HappyDays40 · 07/01/2022 01:49

My MIL has divided money between her three children equally and the sale of the house will go the same way. One of her children has one child, another has none and the other has three. She says that she will divide between her children and they would need to portion up their share in their own family. It us not her issue at all that one of her children chose to have three. She says that uts their problem Grin

CoolShoeshine · 07/01/2022 01:44

I’d divide it equally between the DCs, that is what would happen by law if one was to die without a will (assuming there was no spouse). The it would be up to the DCs with offspring I’d they wanted to share it with them.
Also I’ll it is quite likely that the childless DCs will leave their estate to nieces and nephews, so they will benefit in the long run.
Although I can appreciate that life isn’t always that easy, and if one DC was very wealthy and another very poor then that would need to be addressed personally before death if the poorer one were going to be bequeathed more.

Cameleongirl · 07/01/2022 01:17

I wonder whether the childless son has received more financial support from his parents than his siblings realize? Pure speculation, but that’s what I immediately assumed when I read your post.

In DH’s family, for example, I think one of his sisters has received significant financial support-I don’t know how much, but it wouldn’t surprise me if my IL’s will reflect that.

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 01:06

@Kisskiss

If the kids are financially stable, then passing assets directly to grandkids is way more inheritance tax efficient
It's not about being tax efficient, though. It's about a sibling perceiving that they're not being treated equally because they don't have children. If I were that sibling and you tried to explain tax intricacies with formulas and pie charts, I might be tempted to beat you with them.
Kisskiss · 07/01/2022 01:01

If the kids are financially stable, then passing assets directly to grandkids is way more inheritance tax efficient

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 01:00

@Tigertigertigertiger

My in-laws have told their 3 adult children they will be doing this.

All inheritance straight to grandchildren, none to children.

Their money, their choice. Their adult children respect their decision.

Do all the children have children of their own?
Bunnycat101 · 07/01/2022 00:56

I think that would feel very unfair. I’d also say the parents of the children do benefit indirectly (by not having to save for them; knowing they are financially secure) so in my mind it isn’t fair for one side to benefit massively and the other to get nothing.

In the circs of the OP, I don’t think I’d necessarily do 50% child and 50% grandchildren which would technically be fairest on all sides but would want child 1 to have at least the same as each GC if not more.

Tigertigertigertiger · 07/01/2022 00:55

My in-laws have told their 3 adult children they will be doing this.

All inheritance straight to grandchildren, none to children.

Their money, their choice. Their adult children respect their decision.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/01/2022 00:40

I don't think anybody is disputing that it's their choice to leave the money to whomever they wish.

We're just discussing what does and doesn't seem fair - and the kind of decisions that will leave immense hurt and can cause family divisions as a direct result.

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 00:40

@steff13

Because it's still going to their siblings families. It's benefitting their siblings by benefitting their children.

But the parents have already given the childless child financial support directly.

But it's not as much as the GC will inherit. But it's immaterial. It's about how leaving someone out makes them feel, not about totting up a balance sheet. But say you had had two children. You gave 10,000 to one of your children. Your estate was worth 200,000. Would you give all 200,000 to the child that didn't get the 10,000?
LondonQueen · 07/01/2022 00:36

No one should expect an inheritance. If the GP's want to leave it to the DGC, that's their choice.

Nancydrawn · 07/01/2022 00:34

Very unfair.

Each of the children's family units should get the same amount. If there were four children, each family unit should get a quarter.

That can then be subdivided amongst the grandchildren in each family unit.

So, for instance, if there were three children, then: family A, B, and C each get a third. Family A splits that third between their two (grand)children; Family B gives it all to their single (grand)child, and Family C keeps it.

Because you don't know what will happen after you die. Family C (your brother, I take it) could have two kids and they would be entirely unprovisioned under the current rules.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/01/2022 00:26

There was a thread on here quite a while back where DGPs (OP's DPs) had left a substantial amount of money specifically for private education for OP's children. OP had one sibling, who was adamant that she was never going to have children. The DGPs died and then OP's DSis had a change of heart and did end up with a couple of children. She assumed that the money was for the private schooling of all of the DGCs.... except that firstly, there wasn't enough to pay four children's ways through school and secondly, OP's children had been specifically named as beneficiaries. It caused a huge amount of pain.

It's far from uncommon to have DGC who are born after you have died - in the above situation, additional DGCs could equally have been OP's younger children, born after the DGPs had gone, and that would have been heartbreakingly unfair.

We actually knew a family where the surviving DGP decided to leave everything split 9 ways:
DS1, DIL1, DGC1, DGC1 (family 1) - 4 ninths each;
DS2, DIL2, DGC2, DGC2 (family 2) - 4 ninths each;
DS3 (happy bachelor, no DC) - 1 ninth.
None of them particularly well off (but nowhere near the breadline).
Contrary to what you might imagine, DS3 (a very kind, generous man) thought this was an excellent idea and completely fair.
DS2, on the other hand, was furious as, rather than his family receiving 4/9 of the money, he wanted to have 1/3 (3/9) - less - but all to himself.

I really don't see any fair alternative to leaving equally between your children only, unless there are very specific reasons and everybody is in agreement (e.g. one child is severely disabled and will need lifelong financial support - but even then, you can't know if one of your other DC will have a massively life-limiting accident after you have died). If they so choose, there's nothing stopping any of your DC from passing it all straight on to their own DC if they want to.

Selfishly, I think there are certain benefits to only having one child - makes things like this far more straightforward!

EmmaGrundyForPM · 07/01/2022 00:25

I suspect that we are facing a situation like this with my FiL.

DH is an only child, his father is married to someone who has 3 children, all of whom are in their 50s and 60s. My FiL and his wife have hinted that any inheritance will go directly to the GC. We have 2 adult DC and one of the other step siblings has 2 adult DC, the other two step siblings are childless. I think it's incredibly unfair on them, but suspect that my PIL think that the money will be better going to the young adult GC to help get.them on the property ladder etc. Personally I'm thinking the best outcome might be that any possible inheritance is eaten up.in care fees.

EnidSpyton · 07/01/2022 00:24

I don’t see the problem with this. I wouldn’t be upset at all if my parents left their entire estate to my sister’s children. I love them like my own and would be delighted to see them get off to a good start in life. I know how much my parents adore their GC and what it would mean to them to know they are leaving them well provided for.

They have been consistently generous throughout mine and my siblings’ adult lives. We have all been supported through the education we needed to have our desired careers, and we were all helped onto the housing ladder. We are all financially secure already thanks to them. So our parents owe us nothing when they die. Their money belongs to them to do as they wish with it. They have never begrudged us anything and I wouldn’t begrudge them the ability to leave their money to whom ever it gives them comfort and joy to do so.

I don’t understand the grasping nature of people when it comes to wills. I also don’t understand jealousy of nieces and nephews. Maybe not everyone feels the same way as I do about mine, but I would leap under a bus to save mine any day of the week. I’d fully support my parents giving them their entire fortune if that’s what they wanted - I want them to have the best life possible. My parents already did that for me so passing it onto the next generation seems only right.

It’s not about favouring the child with DC as the child themselves get nothing - their children do, as separate legal entities. I would not feel slighted or less loved if my sister’s children got all my parents’ money - I know if I had chosen to have children, mine would get the same. It’s not a personal snub.

LittlePearl · 07/01/2022 00:11

@TheHoptimist

My parents both inherited from their parents and retired in their 50s, they go on about how wonderful it was, how it allowed them to pay off their mortgage, spend time with their grandchildren, travel the world etc.

They have left to their grandchildren. Have to say I do find hard to understand why- my sisters and I would also love to retire to spend time with grandchildren.

But ultimately it is their choice. Equal split amongst grandchildren- 3 children have differing numbers of children- so not an equal split to each family branch. (1, 2 and 3)

That sounds hard, I would struggle in this situation TheHoptimist.

I think it's fairest to leave to children, although my parents also made provision for all their grandchildren in their wills.

If I inherit anything I will pass some on to my children but I'd like the opportunity to do this myself. I'd find it hard to be bypassed altogether.

OP, I think the situation you've described could be very damaging for family relationships. I've seen families torn apart by disputes over wills and perceived unfairness. it's not just the money, It's the symbolic value and what it represents.

PurpleDaisies · 07/01/2022 00:06

@Saffy123456

It doesn't matter -
Care to elaborate?
Piggy42 · 07/01/2022 00:06

I think it’s unfair and may cause big family upset.

Saffy123456 · 06/01/2022 23:59

It doesn't matter -

PurpleDaisies · 06/01/2022 23:56

Each family branch gets something in that situation @TheHoptimist. Nobody is totally left out.