Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate with a raging passion those flashing cycle lights

181 replies

turnaroundtime · 06/01/2022 20:40

Why in anyone's God's name are those things allowed. They are so bright and distracting that if some one walked out in front of my car I wouldn't see them due to being blinded by an oncoming cyclist with their flashing strobes of death.

OP posts:
Onetraumaatatimeplease · 07/01/2022 16:19

As an epileptic driver I hate them. I hate them.

ivykaty44 · 07/01/2022 16:08

ChazsBrilliantAttitude

I'm perplexed why there is so much anti-cyclist vitriol on Mumsnet

How is it anti-cyclist vitriol to state that strobing lights are more problematic than solid ones?

read the words - rage and hate, time and time again these words are used on mn in threads about cyclists

To hate with a raging passion those flashing cycle lights (155 Posts)

Akire · 07/01/2022 15:01

It’s amazing how saying you spent rest of day with blinding headache and vomiting after few seconds of these lights in your face … yet bad you you being all mean to cyclists!! We managed without strobes before seriously don’t know how they are allowed.

eastegg · 07/01/2022 15:00

@alloalloallo

Of course there is the risk to eg epileptics who are just going about their business not driving but still don’t want to have a fit brought on. (Although I appreciate the thread was originally about the effect of the lights on drivers).

Yes. This!

Passengers in cars, buses, pedestrians walking by

My DD has absence seizures and has huge issues with strobe lights like these. As posted earlier, we were in slow traffic and followed by a bike with a very, very bright, strobe-like front light. She had several seizures before I could pull over and let the bike pass.

The seizures are absence seizures so not particularly dangerous at the time, but when she has several she ends up with her muscles spasming and her hands lock into fists, her wrists lock, sometimes her knees or feet. Both hands locked after the above incident (3 weeks ago). One had unlocked after a couple of days, the other is still locked. It’s very painful, pretty disabling and causes lots of ongoing damage to tendons, etc.

Well there we are. Can everyone who says these strobing lights are fine please read allo’s post?
JojobaFromOctober · 07/01/2022 14:41

I'm perplexed why there is so much anti-cyclist vitriol on Mumsnet

It's just a reflection of the UK I think. The UK is a very cyclist-unfriendly country by European standards, in infrastructure but also in general attitudes. My own mother is always muttering darkly about bloody cyclists despite the fact that two of those bloody cyclists are her own children.

Brainwave89 · 07/01/2022 14:33

Keen cyclist here. The challenge I think is that cycle lights have improved immensely in quality over the last 10 years. Some are indeed now super bright. This by itself is not a problem provided the light is not set so that it shines directly into the eyes of oncoming traffic. However, some are, and it can be quite a problem if you are driving. Some further guidance might be useful. This being said, I have had cars take me out twice in 20 years of cycling. Immediately after impact the first thing the driver said was "sorry I did not see you". This is really common. So we cyclists will use reflectives and flashing lights to make sure this cannot happen.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/01/2022 14:25

@ivykaty44

I'm perplexed why there is so much anti-cyclist vitriol on Mumsnet

goodness help you if you're a cycling step mum...Shock you don't stand a chance on here

How is it anti-cyclist vitriol to state that strobing lights are more problematic than solid ones? I don't have such a problem with a flashing rear light as they are red so less intense. It's the strobing white lights that are a problem. The cycling article above suggested that flashing rear lights and solid front lights are a good option.
ivykaty44 · 07/01/2022 14:18

I'm perplexed why there is so much anti-cyclist vitriol on Mumsnet

goodness help you if you're a cycling step mum...Shock you don't stand a chance on here

WindyState · 07/01/2022 14:18

Again the number of people who are at risk of reactions to flashing lights at the kind of frequency that bike lights flash at is incredibly small, and these people will be at risk from flashing lights from all manner of sources. We can't legislate for everyone.

This is not to minimalise the problem; but the fact that a tiny number of people may be harmed by flashing lights is not massively relevant to a debate as to whether flashing lights should be run by cyclists or not. People have to manage the risk, we can't prevent cyclists being more visible to drivers by using appropriate lighting just on the off chance a pedestrian with a adversion to flashing lights might be walking past, for the same reason that we can't immediately ban ICE because someone with a noise sensitivity might need to walk next to traffic, or someone with asthma has issues with air pollution.

JojobaFromOctober · 07/01/2022 14:13

I have mine on a sort of pulse setting rather than fully flashing, but they are not particularly bright as I ride almost exclusively on lit paths and roads if it's dark. I just have them to draw attention to myself but I know they aren't blinding as I can comfortably look at them myself.

I agree OP, I hate super bright lights on cars or bikes or anything else, and flashing is worse with that kind of high intensity light. I have a really bright light for riding on unlit paths, but I angle it down and have it on a steady setting. Those super bright lights are for seeing where you're going, not being seen, and should be used accordingly imo.

alloalloallo · 07/01/2022 14:03

Of course there is the risk to eg epileptics who are just going about their business not driving but still don’t want to have a fit brought on. (Although I appreciate the thread was originally about the effect of the lights on drivers).

Yes. This!

Passengers in cars, buses, pedestrians walking by

My DD has absence seizures and has huge issues with strobe lights like these. As posted earlier, we were in slow traffic and followed by a bike with a very, very bright, strobe-like front light. She had several seizures before I could pull over and let the bike pass.

The seizures are absence seizures so not particularly dangerous at the time, but when she has several she ends up with her muscles spasming and her hands lock into fists, her wrists lock, sometimes her knees or feet. Both hands locked after the above incident (3 weeks ago). One had unlocked after a couple of days, the other is still locked. It’s very painful, pretty disabling and causes lots of ongoing damage to tendons, etc.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 07/01/2022 14:00

Hate them as both a migraine sufferer and a driver. (The migraine generally arrives the day after the trigger before anyone says I shouldn’t be driving.)
They do definitely make the cyclist visible from further away but also make it harder to work out what they are doing.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 07/01/2022 13:51

Cars' ridiculously bright headlights bother me more.

Be grateful cyclists are using lights, so many don't.

eastegg · 07/01/2022 13:48

@WindyState

Legal bike lights do not flash fast enough and are not bright enough to cause problems to the vast majority of people at risk, and for the tiny minority where it may be a problem it's likely they cannot drive anyway.

The balance of risk is massively in favour of cyclists being seen.

Of course there is the risk to eg epileptics who are just going about their business not driving but still don’t want to have a fit brought on. (Although I appreciate the thread was originally about the effect of the lights on drivers).
Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 07/01/2022 13:28

YANBU when it's dark a flashing light pointed straight at you means you can't see anything. They're a bloody nightmare.

WindyState · 07/01/2022 13:20

Legal bike lights do not flash fast enough and are not bright enough to cause problems to the vast majority of people at risk, and for the tiny minority where it may be a problem it's likely they cannot drive anyway.

The balance of risk is massively in favour of cyclists being seen.

Migrainesbythedozen · 07/01/2022 13:12

That's why there are warnings at functions/amusement park rides that some rides have 'strobing lights'. They're generally not used in everyday life anymore, and when they are there are warnings so people with Epilepsy know not to participate/view that display.

Migrainesbythedozen · 07/01/2022 13:10

YANBU and strobing lights could cause epileptic seizures for epileptics.

lljkk · 07/01/2022 12:17

When we were in USA 2 weeks ago... someone on Freeway (very congested) was hassling other drivers by flashing... hunting lights? It was a giant light bar like this picture. Whole 'nother world out there...

To hate with a raging passion those flashing cycle lights
megletthesecond · 07/01/2022 12:08

Well, to be fair, they should have flashing and constant lights. They're vulnerable and should be lit up like an Xmas tree.

Grenlei · 07/01/2022 11:48

@JuergenSchwarzwald

I agree they are too bright. And I don't like the current trend for pedestrians to wear them, either. A small light is fine.

However, the much bigger issue is the white lights on many cars which are far too bright and are dangerous.

Yes, what is it with these brilliant white lights all new cars seem to have? I'm sure they're lovely for the drivers and illuminate the road ahead but they're bloody awful for everyone else.

A car with those ultra bright headlights stopped to let me pass on a narrow stretch of road the other night, I was also driving uphill which somehow made it worse, I felt completely blinded and ended up passing him at about 2mph because I basically couldn't see (before anyone pipes up, I have my eyes tested regularly, wear glasses for reading only at a prescription of about +0.5. So no eyesight issues!)

sbhydrogen · 07/01/2022 11:43

I am both a cyclist and a driver, and I find them massively distracting. Yes, I can see you're there but I find it hard to see anything else due to the strobing. Perhaps it wouldn't be so bad if they had a continuous light as well.

I like the green cycle icon projection light that they have on the Boris Bikes in London. I find that works really well when I am a pedestrian!

WindyState · 07/01/2022 11:37

@megletthesecond

Yanbu. Flashing lights make it harder to spot the cyclist. They should use a constant light. (Walker here).
Not true.

Numerous studies have shown that flashing lights are spotted earlier than static lights, especially when against a backdrop of car headlights/ street lights etc.

When I commuted by bike I would run both flashing and static lights, angled appropriately. I couldn't care less if other people find them annoying. If they do, that means they have actually seen me.

OneTC · 07/01/2022 11:14

Flashing lights make it harder to spot the cyclist

This is simply not true

They can cause problems with telling how far away they are, but a flashing light increases the chances of you being noticed (as a cyclist) much earlier in the encounter, rather than just another constant light

hibbledibble · 07/01/2022 11:12

I cycle with a bright light, albeit not flashing. I also wear high vis. It's important to be seen as a cyclist, and even with this I have drivers and pedestrians on the road who have near misses or overtake too close.

I'm sure if cyclists didn't have lights, people here would also be complaining about them.

Cycling is environmentally friendly, and reduces congestion on the roads and public transport, as well as pollution. It's healthy as well.

I cycle considerately, following the rules of the road, always have high vis and a helmet on, and have third party insurance.

I'm perplexed why there is so much anti-cyclist vitriol on Mumsnet.

As both a cyclist and a driver, I see a lot more bad behaviour from motorists than cyclists. Daily I have cars overtaking me while practically skimming my elbow.