Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Pope Francis is talking out of his arse here?

219 replies

CounsellorTroi · 06/01/2022 20:17

Says couples who prefer pets to children are selfish. It’s a bit rich from someone who effectively chose not to have children when he became a priest.

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/05/pope-couples-choose-pets-children-selfish

OP posts:
Lizzy1980 · 07/01/2022 10:03

@WindInTheWillows7

He's the head of the Catholic Church, an organisation which is staunchly in favour of procreation and children. What he said wasn't shocking or inappropriate at all. I agree with him - lavishing all your love on an animal does have an element of selfishness (I say this as someone who loves her pets to bits, especially when I was ttc and had a miscarriage), as animals will not challenge your bad behaviour and are not difficult to love, unlike children. Animals require less sacrifice and are less all-consuming. While some people have children for the wrong reasons, generally speaking procreation and raising children does require a great deal of self-effacement. Leaving aside those who cannot have children and instead channel their need to love and nurture onto their pets (which I sympathise with) , I do agree with him on some level - in Japan people have more dogs than children; luxury, absurdly priced petshops are ubiquitous as people opt to spoil their animals rather than go through the ordeal of raising a human being. Of course that is selfish on some level.
There are many people with both children and pets. It’s not a choice, pets or kids. Not everyone wants or likes children. Are they selfish for not having them? Labeling someone as selfish (on some level) for living the one and only life they have the way they choose is pretty unkind.
ginghamstarfish · 07/01/2022 09:54

Not sure anyone should take notice of what a Catholic figurehead says, particularly about marriage/having children etc, given their usual views on these topics, and in light of the many, many child abuse scandals (and surely many more which have not been allowed to come to light).

WindyState · 07/01/2022 09:52

He's the pope and a member of the catholic church.

Being a bit unhinged comes with the territory.

PleasantBirthday · 07/01/2022 09:45

I am a bit confused as to why anyone finds this offensive. He was talking to the people who want to take some notice of him, which he is perfectly entitled to do. What he can't do is compel anyone to take any notice or change their lives in any way so what is the problem with him saying something you don't agree with? You can just unsubscribe.

noirchatsdeux · 07/01/2022 09:44

My first thought when I heard it was 'oh great, another stick for my very Catholic mother to beat me with'

I've had two abortions as I intensely dislike babies/children. Never made any secret of it, don't feel any sort of shame about it. I had the sense to realise it when I was 9, vowed I wouldn't have children and stuck to it.

Having children because your religion says you should, when you aren't slightly maternal and will turn out to be a abusive neglectful parent - looking at you, mother - is far more selfish as far as I'm concerned.

So yeah, he can fuck right off.

UserBot989 · 07/01/2022 09:43

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

I don’t know how he came out with this as he seemed quite reasonable until this point!
Same, I was surprised by this comment.

The news makes it clear that not everybody has the emotional or financial resources to care for a child. Bringing them in to the world and then failing to nurture them is not something that anybody in a position of power (his voice is heard) should be doing. Really crazy message to try and put out there.

todaysdilemma · 07/01/2022 09:41

I see this as him meaning, not enough catholic or christian women are having children, compared to other faiths, mainly islam. Probably worried about future of the Vatican reading stuff like this.

www.independent.co.uk/news/world/muslim-babies-outnumber-christian-births-2035-islam-relgion-popular-fastest-growing-a7669576.html

Matterti · 07/01/2022 09:38

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation you win the thread! Grin

the80sweregreat · 07/01/2022 09:34

Not read the whole thread ;
Why doesn't he allow Catholic priests to marry and have children?
Change the rules ?

Toddlerteaplease · 07/01/2022 09:19

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation my cats are also both Catholic!

Toddlerteaplease · 07/01/2022 09:19

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation

One of my cats is a Catholic. She's not going to be happy when she hears about this.
One of the Archdiocese's is run by two cats. They will be furious!
kmblark · 07/01/2022 09:16

@MmeSosostris

He has previously made a comment about women/motherhood. Where does that leave those who can’t have children/gay people who can’t adopt or are single?
The Catholic Church isn't famously concerned about the rights and welfare of gay people.
MrsWinkly · 07/01/2022 09:15

Having kids doesn't prove that you are some sort of extra caring human specimen. People without kids still have relationships, friendships and family and navigate their way through this world in exactly the same way all humans do! Some of the most community minded, integrated, sociable people I know have no kids.
And I don't believe that people generally see their pets as a substitute for a child, it's entirely different.
Why doesn't the Pope actually address the issue of climate change for once, and the impact that it will have on millions of his community who are already living in poverty?

Toddlerteaplease · 07/01/2022 09:14

I love Pope Francis.
But that does seem an odd thing for him to say.

Smorgasborb · 07/01/2022 09:02

@WindInTheWillows7

He's the head of the Catholic Church, an organisation which is staunchly in favour of procreation and children. What he said wasn't shocking or inappropriate at all. I agree with him - lavishing all your love on an animal does have an element of selfishness (I say this as someone who loves her pets to bits, especially when I was ttc and had a miscarriage), as animals will not challenge your bad behaviour and are not difficult to love, unlike children. Animals require less sacrifice and are less all-consuming. While some people have children for the wrong reasons, generally speaking procreation and raising children does require a great deal of self-effacement. Leaving aside those who cannot have children and instead channel their need to love and nurture onto their pets (which I sympathise with) , I do agree with him on some level - in Japan people have more dogs than children; luxury, absurdly priced petshops are ubiquitous as people opt to spoil their animals rather than go through the ordeal of raising a human being. Of course that is selfish on some level.
Don't be absurd. There is nothing more selfish then procreating. You are not doing this for the benefit of humanity but for your own reasons. No one cares if it means you are more thoughtful as it's only towards to your own offspring. Overpopulation is the main reason for climate change and why this planet may not exist to permit your precious children to live a life that doesn't end In them gasping for clean air or water.
Ceramide · 07/01/2022 08:58

Yet again it is infertile people who are told they should adopt. Why not suggest it to fertile people, who are equally able to apply?

Having a pet or child is a false dichotomy. Pets are an interest some people have, while someone else might enjoy sport, gardening or going to the pub. They aren't a 'child substitute'.

pointythings · 07/01/2022 08:57

It's what religions do - make sure their faithful breed to keep the numbers up and growing. Why expect anything different?

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 08:56

Given how over-populated the world is (and getting worse) I think choosing childlessness is one of the best things you can do for both the planet and your fellow human beings. It's no more selfish than having children because you want them.

WindInTheWillows7 · 07/01/2022 08:52

He's the head of the Catholic Church, an organisation which is staunchly in favour of procreation and children. What he said wasn't shocking or inappropriate at all. I agree with him - lavishing all your love on an animal does have an element of selfishness (I say this as someone who loves her pets to bits, especially when I was ttc and had a miscarriage), as animals will not challenge your bad behaviour and are not difficult to love, unlike children. Animals require less sacrifice and are less all-consuming. While some people have children for the wrong reasons, generally speaking procreation and raising children does require a great deal of self-effacement. Leaving aside those who cannot have children and instead channel their need to love and nurture onto their pets (which I sympathise with) , I do agree with him on some level - in Japan people have more dogs than children; luxury, absurdly priced petshops are ubiquitous as people opt to spoil their animals rather than go through the ordeal of raising a human being. Of course that is selfish on some level.

silentpool · 07/01/2022 08:37

Western countries want to promote expensive housing, high childcare costs and hold down wages, all while bemoaning the low birth rate. I wonder where the problem is? Grin

plinkplinkfizzer · 07/01/2022 08:29

Isn't the Catholic Church one of the wealthiest organizations in the world ? That adoption racket must have made them a lot of cash . They must miss it .

youvegottenminuteslynn · 07/01/2022 08:20

The UK as one example, has a multi-million pound pet industry while 4.3 million children live below the poverty line

But that isn't money that would go towards those children is it? If the people who had pets had children instead, because the cost of children is ridiculously higher than that of pets, there would be more children below the poverty line. More pressure on resources such as schools, hospitals, doctors etc. How is more children a solution to existing children being poor? We spent millions on cosmetics. If we didn't, those millions wouldn't be able to solve the crisis of children living in poverty because they wouldn't be funnelled directly to those kids. Especially if you're suggesting people just keep making new ones!

KTB19 · 07/01/2022 08:18

@Snoozer11

Well of course.

Your pets can't fill up the collection plate, but your children can.

Absolutely spot on and cats/dogs cant fill the void of a perverted priest either.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 07/01/2022 08:16

@SlamCrump

I understand his point that there is something potentially wrong morally with society that, to take the UK as one example, has a multi-million pound pet industry while 4.3 million children live below the poverty line.

Have you been to the Vatican? I was disgusted that a religion with so many followers living in poverty had such unimaginable wealth on display. I grew up Catholic but never believed.

My visit absolutely convinced me that the cognitive dissonance required to follow a religion with such wealth at the top that could be used for good is something I cannot partake in.

If the religion was to start now, with that difference in wealth and power within the structure and a leader saying people (let's be honest, women) who don't have kids are selfish, it would quite rightly be called a cult.

Smorgasborb · 07/01/2022 08:11

And if so many children live below the poverty live is it the fault of childless pet owners?
I paid over £60k in tax last year. As far as a I know I took nothing out (bar the cost of two Covid vaccines) . If it all went to those children I'd be delighted. So where did it go? Pensions mainly. NHS costs. The military. Some went to child benefit. I can't change that. Only the government can.