Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Pope Francis is talking out of his arse here?

219 replies

CounsellorTroi · 06/01/2022 20:17

Says couples who prefer pets to children are selfish. It’s a bit rich from someone who effectively chose not to have children when he became a priest.

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/05/pope-couples-choose-pets-children-selfish

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 07/01/2022 12:10

YANBU. I usually really like Pope Francis but this is just an offensive thing to say- it’s bad for the environment to have loads of children - and it contradicts what he said a few years ago about Catholics not needing to breed like rabbits!

It’s also intolerable for a man who doesn’t have children, and will never experience Fatherhood, let alone pregnancy and it’s attendant horrors to declare people should have more children. It’s women who end up bearing the brunt, and nowadays quite frankly most of us would rather do other things - and we shouldn’t be blamed for that.

TheABC · 07/01/2022 12:05

If the Pope is in favour of families, he can end celibacy within the Church and allow priests to marry.

Until that point (and until women can ascend the clerical hierarchy, just as men can) I am going to discount what he says on this issue.

MabelsApron · 07/01/2022 12:02

Funny how we only seem to need to have a spiritual discussion about what people without children are doing. Parents are just automatically assumed to be spiritual.

Why does it matter to anyone else if I got a dog instead of having a child? Why does that require an existential discussion on how I’m using my time on earth? Can’t you just be happy with your own lot and leave me alone to create my own version of a family?

heyhoehey · 07/01/2022 11:57

Thanks, @WrongWayApricot, I think I understood this perspective more now, although I don't necessarily agree entirely with it. But them I'm not Roman Catholic!Smile

LastInTheQueue · 07/01/2022 11:55

Like any religion, Catholicism relies on new intake. Indoctrination, rather than conversion, provides the numbers needed.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 07/01/2022 11:51

But I also think that not having children and devoting your life to prayer and service is different to not having children because you want a dog instead.

People don't get dogs because they choose them over children.

Plenty of people simply don't want children and do want a dog. They haven't had to make a choice between the two. Children aren't on the table at all for many people, for many reasons.

Toddlerteaplease · 07/01/2022 11:50

Archipiscoupss is not impressed!

To think Pope Francis is talking out of his arse here?
WrongWayApricot · 07/01/2022 11:48

@heyhoehey

Isaiah 54:1-6

The Message

"Spread Out! Think Big!
54
1-6 “Sing, barren woman, who has never had a baby.
Fill the air with song, you who’ve never experienced childbirth!
You’re ending up with far more children
than all those childbearing women.” God says so!
“Clear lots of ground for your tents!
Make your tents large. Spread out! Think big!
Use plenty of rope,
drive the tent pegs deep.
You’re going to need lots of elbow room
for your growing family.
You’re going to take over whole nations;
you’re going to resettle abandoned cities.
Don’t be afraid—you’re not going to be embarrassed.
Don’t hold back—you’re not going to come up short.
You’ll forget all about the humiliations of your youth,
and the indignities of being a widow will fade from memory.
For your Maker is your bridegroom,
his name, God-of-the-Angel-Armies!
Your Redeemer is The Holy of Israel,
known as God of the whole earth.
You were like an abandoned wife, devastated with grief,
and God welcomed you back,
Like a woman married young
and then left,” says your God."

So the Bible suggests procreation is not everything. This shows how someone's influence can still spread far and wide without having biological children. In fact you'd probably have more time for other people.

Why would the Pope say what he did?

Because the Pope outranks the Bible in Catholicism. It's not like other types of Christianity where the Bible is used to refer to for everything. The Pope is supposed to be on an uninterrupted line back to the apostle of Jesus and is there to interpret the word of God in an ever developing world. He can deviate from the Bible and tell Catholics which parts are relevant and which aren't. Necessary because the Bible contradicts itself over and over again.

I'm lapsed and agree that people shouldn't have children they don't want. But I also think that not having children and devoting your life to prayer and service is different to not having children because you want a dog instead. I think there is a spiritual discussion that could be had on how meaningfully our time is spent in a world where convenience is freeing us more than ever before. But the answer isn't to just have children imo.

JaneJeffer · 07/01/2022 11:39

@WindyState

He's the pope and a member of the catholic church.

Being a bit unhinged comes with the territory.

What, all 1.3 billion of them?
Ohfortheloveofgodwhatnow · 07/01/2022 11:22

I think el papa might just be softening us up to tell us he’s got rid of the cat cos he has a few offspring knocking about Grin

heyhoehey · 07/01/2022 11:11

@Porcupineintherough, something which the Bible passage, I quoted earlier, I think alludes to.

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 11:07

Maybe the Catholic church could concern itself with the lives of the millions of children in the world who live and die in poverty before it encourages the faithful to bring more children into the world. Even if it just worried about the Catholic ones that'd be an improvement.

MabelsApron · 07/01/2022 11:02

The only reason anyone can come up with for not having kids being selfish is that we’re not adding to the next generation that’ll support us and wipe our arses when we get old.

Which is one reason I can’t wait until euthanasia is legalised. This argument will finally have to end, and we’ll be able to turn it right back on those who’ve thrown it at us for decades - we paid large amounts of tax for the healthcare, education and welfare of your kids, knowing we’d not benefit from them in old age. That’s as far away from selfish as it’s possible to get.

MabelsApron · 07/01/2022 10:54

@Smorgasborb

The UK as one example, has a multi-million pound pet industry while 4.3 million children live below the poverty line

So the answer is less children. More education in contraception (catholic church against) freely available abortion options (catholic church against) more sex education (Catholic Church against) rather than the vilification of people with pets. The Catholic Church is at fault here.

People with pets can love their animals and give to animal and human charities at the same time. I do. It's not a zero sum game.

This with bells on.

The implication is that those with money and no children need to stop having pets (no joy or companionship for you, it’s your own fault you don’t have a proper family) and start giving away all your money to those with children or those in poverty.

Or have kids and hope they don’t end up contributing to the number of those already in poverty?

It’s all bloody infuriating.

heyhoehey · 07/01/2022 10:53

Isaiah 54:1-6

The Message

"Spread Out! Think Big!
54
1-6 “Sing, barren woman, who has never had a baby.
Fill the air with song, you who’ve never experienced childbirth!
You’re ending up with far more children
than all those childbearing women.” God says so!
“Clear lots of ground for your tents!
Make your tents large. Spread out! Think big!
Use plenty of rope,
drive the tent pegs deep.
You’re going to need lots of elbow room
for your growing family.
You’re going to take over whole nations;
you’re going to resettle abandoned cities.
Don’t be afraid—you’re not going to be embarrassed.
Don’t hold back—you’re not going to come up short.
You’ll forget all about the humiliations of your youth,
and the indignities of being a widow will fade from memory.
For your Maker is your bridegroom,
his name, God-of-the-Angel-Armies!
Your Redeemer is The Holy of Israel,
known as God of the whole earth.
You were like an abandoned wife, devastated with grief,
and God welcomed you back,
Like a woman married young
and then left,” says your God."

So the Bible suggests procreation is not everything. This shows how someone's influence can still spread far and wide without having biological children. In fact you'd probably have more time for other people.

Why would the Pope say what he did?

OneTC · 07/01/2022 10:41

"Catholic pontiff strongly in favour of making babies SHOCKER!"

Said no one ever

plinkplinkfizzer · 07/01/2022 10:38

It really is astonishing how much the Catholic Church is worth Shock

youvegottenminuteslynn · 07/01/2022 10:28

www.wsj.com/articles/vatican-uses-donations-for-the-poor-to-plug-its-budget-deficit-11576075764

Disgusting. The hypocrisy is staggering.

ChaToilLeam · 07/01/2022 10:21

We’re not short of people on this earth. We’re not short of children. What is terrible is that so many of them live in poverty.

I’m not taking any advice from the head of one of the wealthiest institutions on earth on this.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 07/01/2022 10:19

@newusername2009

I read that to choose not to have children because you place your material comfort and "perfect" life above having a child is selfish.

Genuine question - why? If someone doesn't want a child for any reason why is that selfish? Why are the obligated to do so? And more importantly, why do you want children to be born to people who don't really want them?

Smorgasborb · 07/01/2022 10:18

@newusername2009

On all the comments about abuse, I don't find them funny to joke about because they happened to real people. The vast majority of the clergy are deeply ashamed of these and parishes now have safeguarding rules in place to protect against similar abuse.

The priests who committed the abuse have likely condemned themselves to hell for the wickedness of their actions as well as all the people they have turned away from the church as a result of their actions. By the way schools & orphanages have a lot of abuse also - again this has to be addressed but should we close them all down?

With regards to Pope Francis, not his greatest fan, but I don't read that he is saying don't have pets or that every woman must have multiple children and stay home to serve her husband. I read that to choose not to have children because you place your material comfort and "perfect" life above having a child is selfish. I know many people who say they would have another but are going to get a dog instead to complete their family - I agree with Pope Francis on this. So many of us strive for material possession and perfection which is not possible.

A child is the ultimate in material possessions.
CounsellorTroi · 07/01/2022 10:16

With regards to Pope Francis, not his greatest fan, but I don't read that he is saying don't have pets or that every woman must have multiple children and stay home to serve her husband. I read that to choose not to have children because you place your material comfort and "perfect" life above having a child is selfish. I know many people who say they would have another but are going to get a dog instead to complete their family - I agree with Pope Francis on this. So many of us strive for material possession and perfection which is not possible.

Not everyone who chooses not to have children does so because they value material comfort and possessions more. Some just don’t want to, some know they wouldn’t make even “good enough” parents.

OP posts:
LampLighter414 · 07/01/2022 10:15

I think the way the world is going one thing the vast majority of people can agree on is that we don't need the population to keep increasing endlessly

He is out of touch

newusername2009 · 07/01/2022 10:10

@Threewheeler1

Having kids doesn't prove that you are some sort of extra caring human specimen. People without kids still have relationships, friendships and family and navigate their way through this world in exactly the same way all humans do! Some of the most community minded, integrated, sociable people I know have no kids. And I don't believe that people generally see their pets as a substitute for a child, it's entirely different. Why doesn't the Pope actually address the issue of climate change for once, and the impact that it will have on millions of his community who are already living in poverty?
Not everyone is made to have children and you are absolutely right that it doesn't make them a lesser part of society. When I was at school a large number of my teachers didn't have children and thought of their teaching as an all consuming vocation in life - I don't think you can read the Pope's comments as applying to absolutely everyone!

Again plenty of people have children and are awful parents - he is making a general comment rather than addressing every single case.

newusername2009 · 07/01/2022 10:05

On all the comments about abuse, I don't find them funny to joke about because they happened to real people. The vast majority of the clergy are deeply ashamed of these and parishes now have safeguarding rules in place to protect against similar abuse.

The priests who committed the abuse have likely condemned themselves to hell for the wickedness of their actions as well as all the people they have turned away from the church as a result of their actions. By the way schools & orphanages have a lot of abuse also - again this has to be addressed but should we close them all down?

With regards to Pope Francis, not his greatest fan, but I don't read that he is saying don't have pets or that every woman must have multiple children and stay home to serve her husband. I read that to choose not to have children because you place your material comfort and "perfect" life above having a child is selfish. I know many people who say they would have another but are going to get a dog instead to complete their family - I agree with Pope Francis on this. So many of us strive for material possession and perfection which is not possible.