Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Pope Francis is talking out of his arse here?

219 replies

CounsellorTroi · 06/01/2022 20:17

Says couples who prefer pets to children are selfish. It’s a bit rich from someone who effectively chose not to have children when he became a priest.

www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/05/pope-couples-choose-pets-children-selfish

OP posts:
MindfulnessHelps · 08/01/2022 20:05

@stairway
That is awful. Sorry to hear that is allowed by mumsnet

stairway · 08/01/2022 19:37

MindfulnessHelps I’m afraid to say that often similar stuff is said about Muslims and Islam all the time on mumsnet.

MindfulnessHelps · 08/01/2022 19:15

Smorgasborb
Why are we giving airtime to this head of an abusive cult?

I have complained about this comment, and Mumsnet see no problem.
I wonder would they let a similar comment about the Islamic religion stand?

You can have your view on the Catholic Church. I have no problem with that. There is no need to be offensive about it.

TeaAddict235 · 07/01/2022 22:21

@MmeSosostris the topics i mentioned are very much so connected to the church, and the Catholic church indeed. Many of the communities which are such staunch supporters of the Catholic Church are found in Africa and Latin America where these topics are so pertinent. These are daily topics which affect the lives of the financial contributors to the Vatican.

I am not only a Christian, but have heritage in the above mentioned communities. I have been an active member of a free church, a Church of England, And the Pentecostal Church; at various points in my life. I have a reverend for an aunt and various pastors for uncles, so I think that I am clued up as to the word on the Christian streets. If the pope has really so much to share, why does he stay quiet on my non exhaustive list?

I can send you a you tube link to my church service if yer like. Zoom church or Zurch as it is known in the inner circle? Wink

MmeSosostris · 07/01/2022 22:05

@TeaAddict235

Racial injustices
Women's rights
Poverty and wealth in developing countries
Dictatorships in Africa
The drugs and arms trade in Latin America
Child trafficking in Europe and Asia

What connection are they to the Church?

If anything, the Church has been vocal about many of those things and urged change - particularly racial injustice , drugs and arms (very vocal), dictatorship (massively vocal as always has been, child and adult trafficking (always vocal on this).

The RC church is constantly talking about these things and the problems that create them, ways to resolve them and who and what create the obstacles for change but I think you have be involved in a church community to see this.

TeaAddict235 · 07/01/2022 20:20

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I wondered if it was a preamble to announcing that he has a hoard of secret children from a series of affairs

Doubtful, but even if such children existed I don't imagine we'd hear about them given the Vatican's taste for secrecy

As was once said, "A Catholic priest is called 'Father' by everyone except his own children, who are obliged to call him uncle"

Love the final paragraph here @Puzzledandpissedoff . Very very true! Uncle this and uncle that! When Uncle had had his way with the young beauties of the town.

I do wish the pope would say something about the following:

Racial injustices
Women's rights
Poverty and wealth in developing countries
Dictatorships in Africa
The drugs and arms trade in Latin America
Child trafficking in Europe and Asia

Now that he has let us know the word on the street in the Vatican, how about he considers what the real world is facing.

thenightsky · 07/01/2022 19:49

@stairway

Italy will need a more open immigration policy going forward. I’m not surprised the Pope has said this, even 1 child policy China is trying to encourage three children now.
Bloody hell.
Why2why · 07/01/2022 19:42

The West has had its time in the lead. The East is rising and a strong but sensible population growth has been at the heart of it. Human capital is a key strength of some of the nations that are growing in economic and political strength.

I saw his comment as one based on fear of the increasing strength of other parts of the world.

SpeedRunParent · 07/01/2022 19:34

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

I don’t know how he came out with this as he seemed quite reasonable until this point!
Reasonable? The man claims to be god's representative on earth. Unreasonable on so many levels.
NewYearNewKale · 07/01/2022 19:32

I did at one point idly Google "Is Pope Francis a Catholic" and came up with some genuine hits written by rather annoyed very conservative Catholics!

Strawberrycreams4eva · 07/01/2022 19:28

It was only a matter of time before people realised that Pope Francis is a Catholic.

RandomLondoner · 07/01/2022 19:24

Do the people claiming declining population is a problem have any numbers to back up their claims? (To be clear, I'm not disputing that there will be decline, I'm disputing that decline is a problem.)

What proportion of young people do they think it will take to look after old people, given a specified rate of population decline?

Why does it matter if the economy shrinks, as long as GDP per person is not decreasing?

WindInTheWillows7 · 07/01/2022 18:59

Dogs and cats are not somehow more environmentally friendly than children. Their diet is almost 100% meat. The pet business (producing masses of plastic toys and non-decomposable products) is one of the biggest industries in the UK.

heyhoehey · 07/01/2022 18:55

And as far as the Pope goes, I suppose he felt it was a message that needed saying to his congregation at this particular time. I'm not part of his congregation and even if I was that particular message might not have been applicable to me. As I say, the Bible shows how not having biological children can be a good thing. For some, the Pope's message might prick their conscience as they have made a more selfish choice but many's choice to remain childless does not come from selfish motivations, I would think. I suppose it's an antidote to the claims having children is selfish, at least.

heyhoehey · 07/01/2022 18:49

I find this ironic given that Orthodox Judaism views having children as a religious imperative and women who do not have them for whatever reason have zero status.

I think that is exactly the reason this is said! @CounsellorTroi. Basically, it is balance. There is a context whereby not having children is good. People say the Bible contradicts itself, I don't believe it does if you take into account the context for everything. In one context one thing is right but in another the opposite action is right.

Lifetheuniverseandeverything · 07/01/2022 17:49

He should consider the children his church and their ilk murdered in Canada and across the globe and shut the fuck up.

CounsellorTroi · 07/01/2022 17:43

@heyhoehey

Isaiah 54:1-6

The Message

"Spread Out! Think Big!
54
1-6 “Sing, barren woman, who has never had a baby.
Fill the air with song, you who’ve never experienced childbirth!
You’re ending up with far more children
than all those childbearing women.” God says so!
“Clear lots of ground for your tents!
Make your tents large. Spread out! Think big!
Use plenty of rope,
drive the tent pegs deep.
You’re going to need lots of elbow room
for your growing family.
You’re going to take over whole nations;
you’re going to resettle abandoned cities.
Don’t be afraid—you’re not going to be embarrassed.
Don’t hold back—you’re not going to come up short.
You’ll forget all about the humiliations of your youth,
and the indignities of being a widow will fade from memory.
For your Maker is your bridegroom,
his name, God-of-the-Angel-Armies!
Your Redeemer is The Holy of Israel,
known as God of the whole earth.
You were like an abandoned wife, devastated with grief,
and God welcomed you back,
Like a woman married young
and then left,” says your God."

So the Bible suggests procreation is not everything. This shows how someone's influence can still spread far and wide without having biological children. In fact you'd probably have more time for other people.

Why would the Pope say what he did?

I find this ironic given that Orthodox Judaism views having children as a religious imperative and women who do not have them for whatever reason have zero status.
OP posts:
stairway · 07/01/2022 17:33

Italy will need a more open immigration policy going forward. I’m not surprised the Pope has said this, even 1 child policy China is trying to encourage three children now.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/01/2022 17:31

I wondered if it was a preamble to announcing that he has a hoard of secret children from a series of affairs

Doubtful, but even if such children existed I don't imagine we'd hear about them given the Vatican's taste for secrecy

As was once said, "A Catholic priest is called 'Father' by everyone except his own children, who are obliged to call him uncle"

RantyAunty · 07/01/2022 17:17

@Smorgasborb

Why are we giving airtime to this head of an abusive cult?
All these religions need to go the way of the dinosaurs. Christianity, Catholic, Islam, Judaism, Hindu, etc. all cults.
Mischance · 07/01/2022 16:27

Let's be honest - I could not give a flyer what he has to say.

CanIPleaseHaveOne · 07/01/2022 16:18

[quote Porcupineintherough]@CanIPleaseHaveOne so why are their do many children living in extreme poverty in the slums of South America? The church is rich but its main efforts here seem to be denying the poor access to contraception and persecuting women for seeking an abortion.[/quote]
I think that poverty exists across all religions - Christians, Muslims, Jews, Hindus, etc, and sadly across most of the world.
Religious belief will not define your financial status.

I am strongly in favour of contraception and access to abortion. Indeed, had I not had access to a safe abortion as a young woman my life would have been entirely different, and I am pretty sure not in a good way.

That being said, it seems to me that if the head of the Catholic church is against contraception, abortion, death sentence etc it consistant with their belief system.

WrongWayApricot · 07/01/2022 16:06

@MabelsApron

Funny how we only seem to need to have a spiritual discussion about what people without children are doing. Parents are just automatically assumed to be spiritual.

Why does it matter to anyone else if I got a dog instead of having a child? Why does that require an existential discussion on how I’m using my time on earth? Can’t you just be happy with your own lot and leave me alone to create my own version of a family?

I said spiritual discussion could be had. It doesn't matter, it doesn't require an existential discussion on how you're using your time on earth. I am happy with my lot and haven't engaged directly with you about your version of family. I don't know why you're making my opinion about you.

When I said a spiritual discussion could be had, I meant that people who are spiritual could have a lot to say about meaningfulness in life now that so much more time is available because of modern conveniences. From contraception and childcare to air travel and amazon, the average adult in the West has more time than previous generations. It doesn't matter what you do with your time. It could matter to spiritual people how they spend their own time now that they have much more choice in how they spend it.

DynamiteFilledRadish · 07/01/2022 15:50

I agree with him - lavishing all your love on an animal does have an element of selfishness (I say this as someone who loves her pets to bits, especially when I was ttc and had a miscarriage), as animals will not challenge your bad behaviour and are not difficult to love, unlike children. Animals require less sacrifice and are less all-consuming. While some people have children for the wrong reasons, generally speaking procreation and raising children does require a great deal of self-effacement

I really cannot get my head around this at all. Do you understand what selfish means? Having a child is the most selfish thing ever. You are choosing to bring a person into this world, for them to have a few years of (hopefully) happy childhood and then to have to find something they don't hate to work at to feed themselves until they are old enough to retire and then die. That's it. You have a child because you want to. To fulfill your desires and wants. They have to then navigate their way through a life on this planet because you chose to put them here. How is that not the absolute definite of selfishness?

ThinWomansBrain · 07/01/2022 15:49

I wondered if it was a preamble to announcing that he has a hoard of secret children from a series of affairs.
Hypocritical old goat.