Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wish the school would change their curriculum occasionally?

87 replies

Potatosaladfiend · 06/01/2022 17:54

Sort of lighthearted as I pour a (large) glass of wine.

We have three children, two year gap apiece. Lovely village school. We enjoy supporting learning at home.

The school seem to rotate their curriculum on a year A/year B basis.

This means that, for example:
Child 1, yr 2 topic, 4 yrs ago was the Crimean war.
Child 2, yr 2 topic, 2 yrs ago was the Crimean war.
And (you can see where this is going!), child 3 is in year 2 this year, surprise surprise, it’s the Crimean war.

It’s the same every year, every topic is identical to what the elder child studied at the same age. We’re hitting the same topics three times over.
I don’t blame the teachers for this at all, I understand that it saves time on planning, they’ve obviously found some fantastic resources as the same ones appear every time.

But I’m sick to death of the same subjects; the kids have heard it all before and surely (surely?!) the teachers must also be completely fed up with teaching the same things over and over again.

I know IABU and this is the consequence of having three children but lord give me strength for another year of Florence Nightingale. I really wish they’d switch it up a bit and let us loose on the Romans or the Egyptians, or basically any other topic!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 06/01/2022 21:38

@Pedalpushers

I wish I'd studied the crimean war at all! I'd heard of Florence and Mary but didn't have any idea what the crimean war was until I looked it up a few weeks ago after an episode of Dr Who. I would consider myself pretty educated as well Confused

I actually don't remember doing any history at primary except Egyptians. I learned everything from my Horrible Histories books, guess they didn't have one on Crimea.

I was irritated by that sort of thing when I was at primary school. For example we had a WWII week in Year 3 where the teacher just went "well it wasn't all about battles" and we spent the entire week on the Blitz and evacuation. Not a mention of anything going on beyond the Home Front; no Dunkirk, no U-boats, no Stalingrad, no Berlin. No mention of WHY bombs were falling on London.

I vaguely recall the sole lesson we had on the Crimean War in Year 1/2 (it was mixed year groups at the time). We were just shown the episode of Magic Grandad. From what my six year old brain took in from the video, the Crimean war was caused because two armies happened to pass each other at a crossroads. The rest of it just covered a visit to the field hospital.

Takeoutyourhen · 06/01/2022 21:24

Teachers have to use the national curriculum but have a lot of variety to choose from, however they can be creatures of habit and if the resources and planning are already there to be used it can be simpler to carry in using them.

Sowhatifiam · 06/01/2022 21:13

You would soon moan, OP, if the expectation was that your Crimea War costume changed to a Greeks costume changed to a World War 1 costume.

Balanced12 · 06/01/2022 20:57

I agree OP mine are 5 years apart and the activities they complete appear to be exactly the same, I'm much more relaxed about dressing up second time around!

PicaK · 06/01/2022 20:56

But the beauty of this is that if you store your first lovingly made papermache depiction of a Florence Nightingale ward (or Castle or Egyptian pyramid etc) you can just dust it off 2 years later....

ChocolateHoneycomb · 06/01/2022 20:49

Teaching the same children exactly the same topic at the same level multiple times = something has gone wrong

Teaching the same children exactly the same topic at a higher/more detailed/more complex level than previously = normal
(E.g. the human body)

Teaching different children the same topic when they are in a given year group = a curriculum.

If your kids are in a state school, year 2 should be very similar for all of them.

Bit baffled at the issue tbh. Some areas of education will be studied by almost everyone because they are ‘on the curriculum’, deemed important, are fundamental to build more knowledge on etc.

Puffykins · 06/01/2022 20:40

My children had exactly this and actually I loved it and so did they because they'd discuss the topics with their sibling and DD would get really excited about e.g. her turn to do Titanic.... also I only made one model bakery pertaining to where the Great Fire of London started, but it got taken in to school by each of them in turn.

CaptainMerica · 06/01/2022 20:17

@Iamnotthe1 yes, you are right. I am in Scotland, so we follow the curriculum for excellence, which is different. I believe it is also less prescriptive.

echt · 06/01/2022 20:16

As a recently retired English teacher of 40+ years, both in the UK and Australia, I can see one aspect of English that guarantees repetition. In the UK, the schools have to supply the texts. What this meant was being on a carousel of having them to complete a text before handing it on to the next teacher. Every year the books were repaired and replacements bought out of the teeny tiny budget.

While the schools don't set the texts, only choose from the list, I wonder if that is part of why the list is so unvarying. It would be surprising, as the government doesn't give toss about state education mostly. What I can echo is what other teachers have said about refining knowledge and approaches.

In Australia, where all texts and materials for all subjects are supplied by the parent, English exam texts change every four years, though not all at once. I found it very stimulating to have new work to grapple with, though could be very knackering, with six new texts a year at one point.

My personal favourite was the poetry of Chris Wallace-Crabbe, about whom there was nothing written so I had to interpret everything myself with the class. They loved it, amazingly.

An un-favourite was the commitment to Australian texts, one very year every year group. Big island, small country, so inevitably some sub-par shite worked its way in: I'm looking at you "Jasper Jones". Hmm

LondonQueen · 06/01/2022 20:14

The curriculum is changing constantly!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 06/01/2022 20:10

My DDs have attended 4&5 schools respectively. This has lead to my elder DD studying WWII three times. And DD2 twice. Since DD2 is only Yr4, there's time for it to appear again on her Primary school curriculum...

CouldIhaveaword · 06/01/2022 20:03

It has it's benefits. Make a model of a cell/roman fort/natural disaster for homework...or get your older brother's one out of the cupboard from two years ago, blow off the dust and submit that.

Pieceofpurplesky · 06/01/2022 19:49

All you naysayers! Inspector/Animal Farm/Macbeth may have been on the curriculum for years but they are great stories and the kids love them. I have been teaching all three for over 20 years and I am not bored. We mix it up with new texts too! Each year where I work do one modern text, one older 'classic' and a play every year. They love English.

JuniorMint · 06/01/2022 19:37

[quote spanieleyes]@SisterJude

My son is a tax accountant. He completes the same returns every year. But every return is different to each other, so the figures he puts in, the adjustments he has to make, the outcomes are all unique and individual. Given that each child is also unique and individual, what teachers have to put in also changes and varies- even if they are completing the same tax returns![/quote]
Great analogy, thank you @spanieleyes Daffodil

spanieleyes · 06/01/2022 19:34

@SisterJude

My son is a tax accountant. He completes the same returns every year. But every return is different to each other, so the figures he puts in, the adjustments he has to make, the outcomes are all unique and individual. Given that each child is also unique and individual, what teachers have to put in also changes and varies- even if they are completing the same tax returns!

MrsLargeEmbodied · 06/01/2022 19:28

yabu
you are not the one at school

likeafishneedsabike · 06/01/2022 19:27

@FoxgloveSummers

I feel your pain! I was bored stiff of hearing my brother grumping about Animal Farm and pissed off when I had to do it myself. The unchanging curriculum does seem utterly bizarre as a PP said when believe it or not quite a few decent plays and novels have been written over the past 50-70 years.
Grumping about ‘Animal Farm’? Did he not understand it?
SisterJude · 06/01/2022 19:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

toomuchlaundry · 06/01/2022 19:15

@RiverSkater ever heard of differentiation, intervention?

Horst · 06/01/2022 19:12

Our school does the rainforest in year 2 and year 5 que my 5 year old trying to happy tell me about poison frogs while my 10 year old is like yeah did that twice now. I’m sat here like yup your brother did it twice there too only once more to go Wine

BarefootHippieChick · 06/01/2022 19:10

@capercaillie

DS just starting Macbeth for English GCSE - I also did it 30 years ago for GCSE!

And me - both English and Drama! Double whammy!!

fabulouslyglamorousferret · 06/01/2022 19:08

@RiverSkater

I've noticed that my DD2 is doing the exact same lessons DD1 did! Three years apart. So much so that DD1 says 'keep that space/ sea scene I made as DD2 can reuse it when she does space / sea etc.. 😂

I'm wondering where all the lesson planning time goes 😂

ALL that planning time?! .. it goes on internet shopping and drinking tea in the staff room 👍🏻

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2022 19:08

On the upside, I have been able to rehash the same topic dress - up day outfits three times.

^^
Sorry, I’d missed that you’d already said this!

JuniorMint · 06/01/2022 19:05

@Potatosaladfiend

Ah of course I know I’m being unreasonable, I did say it was lighthearted.

I come from a teaching family and I get it. I know it saves time and energy and I’m really grateful.

I think what’s impacting my, ahem, lack of enthusiasm this year more than ever is that we’re hitting the 2020 homeschooling topics again.

We do discuss school topics quite a lot at home and they are set particular reading, worksheets and projects every week. I will of course put on my enthusiastic face when I’m being told all about the same things, and helping with same projects, again.

It’s actually not about saving time and energy, OP, and to imply that’s the only reasoning behind why topics are chosen- that they create the least work for the staff, is a bit rude. Ok, no one wants to create extra work for themselves but the main objective is to follow the National Curriculum with progression across the school and no repetition. You do realise that a child with no siblings won’t have done the Crimean War topic before and if the topics were randomly changed around then they might never do it? Just because you have three children that’s why you’re hitting the same topics three times. Did you get bored when your second and third child took their first steps because you’d seen it all before with your first child? Grin (Slightly lighthearted in response to your slightly lightheartedness Wink)
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2022 19:05

I’m glad they do a lot of the same topics as you can keep the costumes they wore for dress up days - many are quite unisex or can be made so!