Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that time off with ill DC should still be split even though I WFH?

186 replies

HardbackWriter · 06/01/2022 14:22

I have a 3 year old and an 11 month old and have just returned to work after my second maternity leave. DH and I both work four days a week - he's a teacher, I work in an office job but I've been working from home since March 2020 and it doesn't look like it's going to change anytime soon (I have actually requested to have some time in the office but my employer is reluctant and my request has dragged on with no resolution). Pre-covid, when we both worked out of the home, we split days off when DC1 was ill pretty rigidly 50-50, with some flexibility if one or the other of us had something particularly big on when it was 'our turn'. This morning DH made a comment that made it clear that he thought that from now on he'd only take time off work for ill DC if I had one of those 'notable/big' things on, as otherwise I could just do a bit of work around the DC and then make up the time later (I control my own diary and my job is more of a 'get the tasks done' than a clock-watching type one), whereas for him he has to have the day fully off. I was a bit taken aback/cross at this, but now I'm not sure if he's being the reasonable one? He's right that this is possible for me (though it ends up with me working until midnight, and potentially having to rearrange or drop out of meetings last minute) and not for him, but I also really don't think it'll make me look professional and engaged at work and it feels inherently a bit unjust (but is this petty of me?). It's inevitably going to be a pressing issue because both children have spent this entire winter being ill, and I'm sure there's loads more to come. AIBU? How do other people arrange this?

OP posts:
ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 06/01/2022 16:45

We have a similar set up OP and I do most sick cover as I wfh in a pretty flexible role. I usually give my line manager the choice of me taking annual leave or working around the DC and she always says work around DC if I can. With an 11 month old it's tough but the older they get the easier it is. I have a 2 year old and a 5 year old DC and don't think it's too bad caring for them whilst working, if they are too ill to be in nursery or school it usually means they are quite lethargic, sleep a lot and spend a lot of time watching TV. School closures and covid burst bubbles was tricker though trying to do both whilst they were full of energy so Dp split that evenly.

Sirzy · 06/01/2022 16:39

@DirtyDancing

50/50. Simple.
It’s not always that simple when it comes to one specific task.

Overall the split of the load should be around 50/50 but there are always going to be other factors - such as job flexibity - at play when it comes to individual tasks. I think the 50/50 no matter what mindset risks making life much more difficult for everyone.

DirtyDancing · 06/01/2022 16:35

50/50. Simple.

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 06/01/2022 16:35

@madisonbridges

I get that office workers can take annual leave when their children are sick but how do teachers get time off teaching? Do they take annual leave and then go in during the holidays? Or is there some sort of compassionate leave? Who funds the cover of their leave? Does it come out of the school budget or do LAs pay for it?
Unpaid leave often or they lie and say they are sick. It’s rubbish. One of many reasons that teaching isn’t particularly family friendly!
guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 06/01/2022 16:34

@LividLaVidaLoca

I’m a bit torn here.

I’m a teacher and it’s REALLY hard to be off. Huge impacts on lots of people.

Though it seems like you would also be disadvantaged, and would bear the brunt of this.

I think you need to talk about this honestly and openly. Could he eg take on the brunt of childcare over the weekend if you had to work evenings or something?

As a teacher I’d agree it’s really tough to take time off, but that should be ‘evened out’ somehow. When my kids are sick I come home as soon as school finishes (Head teacher is fine with this and appreciates my husband taking the brunt of care) and then look after the kids from 3.45ish, cook dinner and put them to bed etc (normally we share this). So that he can have a decent stretch of work time. I also have the kids at the weekend if he needs to catch up/regain sanity.
saraclara · 06/01/2022 16:30

Males have a very strong tendency to see themselves as main bread winners, and consider their work to be more important than yours after kids.
If the shoe was on the other foot, he'd find another way to argue why you should look after the kids still.

Why do you assume that? He did 50:50 until recently, and it's only Covid meaning that OP is at home, and his school is (presumably) in dire straits for staffing like most are, that has changed the arrangement.

I maintain that it's unfair to instantly jump to sexism, when there are clear practical reasons why, at least in the short term, one partner is in a better position to look after the children, than the other.

Apart from anything else, OP can get that day's work done (eventually) if she has the kids. Her DP can't

Lunde · 06/01/2022 16:29

DH and I always split time off for sick kids - alternate days

We were lucky to have our kids in Sweden where time off for sick kids is a legal right

madisonbridges · 06/01/2022 16:28

I get that office workers can take annual leave when their children are sick but how do teachers get time off teaching? Do they take annual leave and then go in during the holidays? Or is there some sort of compassionate leave? Who funds the cover of their leave? Does it come out of the school budget or do LAs pay for it?

mindutopia · 06/01/2022 16:27

I agree, I do think it has something to do with flexibility and ability to work from home (rather than actually regularly doing it). Our set up is similar ish. I do most of the sick days, unless I have something big happening or to prepare for, or I need to be in the office that day.

Dh is self-employed, so a day off means making no (or less) money. I'm employed in a very flexible role that involves lots of wfh (including pre-COVID). I always tell my employer that I have sick kids home with me and it's never been an issue. We all do it. My line manager wfh doing sick days with her dog! But we are in an industry where it's not 9-5 and as long as the work is done, then it doesn't really matter unless I missed a big meeting or deadline. I take those days as paid like a normal working day. I often work in the evenings anyway so the time is always made up in the long run.

Dh absolutely steps in as needed though. Even when he had COVID, he would drag himself from bed to the couch and keep the dc alive for a few hours so I could catch up on work. And he would take on more in evenings and weekends as needed if I needed to work. But I think I would want to be transparent with my employer and I would definitely expect support when I really needed it (big presentation coming up, travel, etc.)

RobotValkyrie · 06/01/2022 16:24

YANBU, this is the thin edge of the wedge, OP.

Males have a very strong tendency to see themselves as main bread winners, and consider their work to be more important than yours after kids.
If the shoe was on the other foot, he'd find another way to argue why you should look after the kids still.

It's his responsibility to arrange 50% time off for sick kids. If he can't do it himself, he should arrange cover, like a babysitter. Or maybe he should find a job more compatible with his role as a parent?
Don't give in, OP.
Or if you do, make sure you're largely compensated through holiday care arrangements.

Heruka · 06/01/2022 16:22

I am in a kind of similar position where DH locums so doesn’t get paid for a day off, and is a higher earner than me. My work is also more flexible and less likely to let people down than him. So it is a bit of a no brainer that I take the time but it still feels unfair as it does inconvenience me, and like you say, they are ill a lot, and I’ve no choice. I’ve said to DH I accept this is the situation but ask that he accept it feels a bit unfair and make sure to recognise and support what I’m doing. He mostly does…

2021expecting · 06/01/2022 16:21

YANBU yes your job is more flexible but not any less important, you still deserve to get proper time to complete your work. Yes if it was a day here or there that would be grand but if the full responsibility falls to you, that's quite unfair.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 06/01/2022 16:21

When dc are ill dh looks after them as he works from home. I’m in a hospital so unless there’s a risk it’s covid I go to work. My job is less flexible although if dh had a really important presentation I’d come home to cover, it’s unlikely that would be all day. It balances out because it used to fall all on me when dh was working an hour away.

CharlotteGoldenblattYork · 06/01/2022 16:19

OP, I totally agree with you and how you feel. I would be really pissed off about your DH just deciding what was going to happen and dictating that to you. And also the fact that he's been leaving you to do the bulk of the domestic load during your maternity leave. It all smacks of him ultimately thinking that his job is more important than yours.

I would come to an agreement to cover the sickness at home, but as other posters have said, make it clear that he will have to leave work bang on time, come straight home, take over domestically and childcare-wise, and then catch up with his work in the evening whilst you are catching up on your work.

saraclara · 06/01/2022 16:19

I do think that right now, it's even harder for a teacher to face phoning in to claim leave for dependents. We're at the point where classes will be sent home or schools shut. And then many more people will be faced with having to WFH with their kids around, or take time off themselves (possibly also in a job where their place of work is barely able to function) and lose money.

I think, particularly for the next couple of months, you have to suck it up (and get him taking over the home stuff when he gets back)

Cocomarine · 06/01/2022 16:18

13 weeks of the year, he should ALWAYS step in when they’re unwell - does he?

I think as a general position, it’s probably fair that you use your flexibility. But you do need to look at it on a case by case basis and overall impact. You need to keep your own good standing and good will. So if a day comes when you’re feeling like you’re a little on thin ice, or you have an important meeting - he still has to step up.

He also needs to balance the days when you’ve had to work late - doing the evening shift with the kids, maybe giving you time at the weekend.

Definitely sounds like a watchful eye is needed! I would be taking a note too… not to be petty, but you do need to watch how much time you’ve taken.

SarahAndQuack · 06/01/2022 16:17

I voted YANBU because it would worry me he presented this as an automatic entitlement of his, rather than having a discussion. If you did go back into the office, in a year or two years or five, it might be very hard to shake the idea that your time has automatically been defined as flexible.

If you'd had a discussion, it'd be different.

If you do have that discussion, could you ask him what quid pro quo he's going to offer, if you sacrifice your work time? DP and I did that - my work used to be totally flexible and hers very lab-based and fixed. The deal we made was I did the childcare bits but when she came home, she had to give me a fixed, uninterrupted time for me to work properly, and I'd get to go upstairs without distractions and work. That's just an example and god knows we're not any kind of perfect, but maybe useful to prompt you to think what you'd like to discuss?

msgloria · 06/01/2022 16:16

@saraclara

I know a female teacher who picks up all the sick child term time care as her DP apparently doesn't get paid in his job if he takes time off for child care. It seems so often that it's the man's job that's positioned as the most important

That's not about whether he's a man or not though. If the sexes were reversed it would still be sensible for the one who still gets paid, to stay home. So as far as the family budget is concerned that job IS the more important.

And despite the many attempts in this thread to paint this as a sexist issue, many of us have said that in our experience it often IS the man who stays home if he has the more flexible job/has paid leave.

Her school is no longer prepared to accommodate it, so any further time off in this academic year will be unpaid. As I understand it, the school has to pay out twice each time she's off - to cover her pay plus the cost of a supply teacher. So there is an impact on her employer. Having a blanket policy that one of you will be the one who takes time off because it's paid doesn't seem right to me.
LadyoftheWoods · 06/01/2022 16:15

This is our situation. My DH is a Head of Dept in a secondary. If he's off with the kids he gets the third degree- is there anyone else who could have them, how long will they be off etc etc. He still has to plan and send in cover so it's a massive pita for him and the school.

He looks after them during every holiday so the lack of flexibility has a flip side. If it's a 1 day illness then I take it off/ work flexibly, any longer and we share it equally. Works for us. I used to be a teacher so I understand it's not his fault.

saraclara · 06/01/2022 16:15

[quote DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes]@Cyw2018 I’m in England and sadly it isn’t. The policy has this clause written into it; there is no legal requirement for time off for dependants to be paid and our boroughs policy was amended a couple of years ago to state it was paid for the first four instances in an academic year or for the first four instances IF there was still adequate cover budget. Obviously written like that because the borough is skint. And this isn’t even an academy, there are academies where you wouldn’t get those first four paid/if there’s a cover budget.[/quote]
My LA cut time off for dependents from five days max a year, to two. And this was some time ago. I've since retired and it wouldn't surprise me at all if it's been further cut or stopped altogether.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/01/2022 16:14

I think it’s tricky, presumably your job is important and you have tasks that need to be done which would make caring for two infants difficult. If you care for them during the day you still have work in the evenings/weekends to make up, or have to take time off work to care for them. So you have both the caring for sick children and your workload to carry - when would you then have time for your own self care which is needed to keep you in good health. I know I’ve really struggled to do the caring and the working (similar situation in that as long as I work my hours the timing of when I work is mostly less important.

Tbh I’d still be looking for him to carry his weight with sick children - your work doesn’t stop because your children are sick and while you might be physically at home, your time is not your own in the same way as his time isn’t his own. The profession really is irrelevant - most employers need their staff to be working, and absence has an impact on others and on you. The difference is the impact on you in terms of needing to find time to fit in work around caring commitments, which I know can be very tricky. I’d be looking for him to continue with your existing arrangements which mean you both take the hit on time, reliability etc. It may be difficult for him, but it’s difficult for you too.

Opal8 · 06/01/2022 16:12

As long as its not 50/50 in school holidays I regrettably agree with pp yabu

jamsandwich1 · 06/01/2022 16:11

I think YABU sorry, as long as if in school holidays and you’re working he does it all. Both DH and I are doctors and it’s bloody impossible when the kids are off. If one of us worked from home I think we’d have to suck it up.

DeclareThePenniesOnYourEyes · 06/01/2022 16:06

@Cyw2018 I’m in England and sadly it isn’t. The policy has this clause written into it; there is no legal requirement for time off for dependants to be paid and our boroughs policy was amended a couple of years ago to state it was paid for the first four instances in an academic year or for the first four instances IF there was still adequate cover budget. Obviously written like that because the borough is skint. And this isn’t even an academy, there are academies where you wouldn’t get those first four paid/if there’s a cover budget.

Comedycook · 06/01/2022 16:03

This is a tricky one. I can understand his point of view...I voted yabu