Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling the family home- who gets what. Please help !

343 replies

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 11:28

Bob was with Sarah for 15 years . They have two children . They lived together in a big family home . Bob left when they split . The mortgage is in Bob’s name . Bob pays the mortgage .

Bob lives with his wife in their house with their son . Bob and wife pay the mortgage here . It is a financial struggle .

Sarah lives in the family home with Sarah and Bob’s children . Sarah is getting married and her new partner is moving in. Sarah’s partner is mortgage free ( he has a bungalow ) he will rent this to his son now that he is living in Bob and Sarah’s home .

Sarah wants half of the house when Bob sells it. Bob is happy to do this however Bob paid the deposit for the house from inheritance and is paying off £25k credit cards that Sarah and Bob racked up.

Should Bob still pay the mortgage when Sarah’s partner moves in?
Legally, does Bob have to wait until their youngest child is 18 before he can sell the family home ? Should Bob take off the deposit and half of credit card debit before he splits the profit from the house sale with Sarah ?
Legally does Bob have to give Sarah half ?

Bob pays the legal amount of child support and uniforms , shoes and extras . Kids stay with Bob 2 nights a week.

For clarification they were never married and house is solely in Bob’s name .

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 06/01/2022 14:18

Why should Sarah get any of the equity out the house?
She's never worked or paid towards in even in the last few years when she could have worked, but didn't and has lived rent free.

He really needs legal advice.

housemaus · 06/01/2022 14:17

Bob is getting the piss taken out of him and needs a lawyer.

Embracelife · 06/01/2022 14:15

Sarah can move I nto the new partners house.
Kids move all tge time
There is no inalienable right yo stay in ond house all childhood
hey were never married and house is solely in Bob’s name

Sell the big house
If bob happy to give d half away take it

Gonnagetgoing · 06/01/2022 14:11

Interesting that Bob's kids appear to be of school age re the uniforms, child support and staying with him 2 nights a week so therefore until they start paying jobs (don't think I would count jobs they got whilst they were at college/uni to be paid towards running costs of a house).

Agreed with @MissFranKubelik - at least Bob is doing the right thing financially by his kids but it appears that now he's a bit pissed off or his new wife is, or you are (the mum) by the situation. If it is you (mum) pissed off then butt out.

CarrotVan · 06/01/2022 14:10

Sell the house, offering first refusal to Sarah and NewBloke

Repay the mortgage company

Pay off all the remaining joint debts

Bob keeps the next £25k from his inheritance deposit and the total of the joint debts that he has paid off to date.

The remainder should be split by working out how many years they both lived there as a couple (15) and how many years Bob has paid the mortgage since so if Bob left 5 years ago he gets 20 shares of the equity and Sarah gets 15 shares.

comingintomyown · 06/01/2022 14:08

@Purplecatshopaholic

Well done Bob for going above and beyond, at least at first, but he is being taken for a mug now. Sarah needs to get a job, and Bob needs a backbone and a lawyers appointment. I actually feel very sorry for his wife and other child/children.
Agree
MissFranKubelik · 06/01/2022 14:06

Bob is a good man. He's giving Sarah the rights she would have had if they were technically married. You should be proud you raised someone who knows how to do the right thing.

A plan of action should be set in place, legally to deal with the next few years. And of course, morally, it is not right that two adults will inhabit the house where Bob pays the mortgage. Everyone needs to do the right thing.

Dreamstate · 06/01/2022 13:59

Bob obviously needs legal advice.

If it were me I'd sell the house and split as the total amount as:

25k deposit back to Bob
X amount to pay off debt
X amount of equity built up from Bob paying off mortgage to go to Bob

Then what's left if basically pure profit which can be split 50/50 if he wants to be generous.

Offmyfence · 06/01/2022 13:58

@Ylfa

Bob should be more careful with his knob.

Why has he made even more children if he is struggling?

Bob should be more careful with his partners and getting involved with non working leeches. Hopefully his new partner isn't of the same Ilk.

Hope bob and his knob are enjoying his new partner. Glad he despite having had the piss taken out of him has moved on!

GrandmasCat · 06/01/2022 13:58

Honestly… solicitor is a must. These things are NOT black and white but definitively, the fact that they were not married doesn’t totally exclude Sarah from getting part of the house, especially if she has been paying for repairs or part of the mortgage, but this has to be mandated by court, it is not an automatic right.

A court could have easily mandated for Sarah to stay in the property until the kids were out of mandatory education if she was able to pay the mortgage on her own or with Bob’s help provided that Bob had still enough resources to house himself as well. But again, it is not an automatic right.

One thing that is an automatic right though is for Bob and Sarah to rebuild their lives, re marry if they wish and get a second set of children. The children from the first and second marriage have exactly the same rights irrespective of being born from the first or second marriage. Trying to imply that rebuilding their life after a failed relationship or have more children is something they shouldn’t do it is short sighted, narrow minded and utterly judgemental unless you are advocating for forced celibacy after a split or want to bring back the times when divorcing was forbidden.

Bob’s wife has as much right to have a view on finances as Sarah’s partner. This doesn’t mean they have a right to dictate what happens next, but they definitely have a right to have an opinion.

Gonnagetgoing · 06/01/2022 13:55

Just seen that Sarah doesn't work. Has she never worked? Was she a SAHM/W for many years when the kids were young so didn't get a chance to go back to work/study/build a career?

So many questions...

Gonnagetgoing · 06/01/2022 13:54

Why did Bob leave the family home especially if it was so big to allow Sarah to live there and then subsidise her for some bills?

Bob should have seen a solicitor from the get go, or sorted something out with a solicitor or married Sarah, because at least then, he would have more leverage.

Yes, he's been nice and fair helping out Sarah and their kids but it is not their fault that Sarah has now moved on, with a partner who is at an advantage and it's also not fair on Sarah and her kids (if they're adults over age of 18, they technically don't have a right to have a home provided for them) that Bob has moved on, remarried and got a young child and a smaller home.

Would be interesting to hear Sarah's side of the story not the biased mum's/Bob's side.

toobusytothink · 06/01/2022 13:54

Ok so my ex was/is like Bob and really supportive - allowed me to stay in the family home and pays half the mortgage. But … there is a clause in the agreement that forces a sale should I ever remarry or cohabit with someone else and this is very common and even if they had legalised everything he would have been advised to include this. So it should be a trigger to force the sale now in my opinion. And if I did want to move in with someone I would fully expect my ex to stop paying his share of the mortgage and for the house to get sold.

kittensinthekitchen · 06/01/2022 13:54

@ButtOutBobsMum

GrinGrin

bowlingalleyblues · 06/01/2022 13:50

The situation with the new partner moving in, and renting out his own house (and keeping the money!) while Bob struggles to pay his mortgage and Sarah doesn't work, exposes the unfairness of the situation. It's the ideal time to have this conversation (that should have been had when Bob and Sarah split or when Bob remarried). Sorry Bob's mum for talking about Bob dying, but if he were to die his wife could end up owning the former house (that Sarah also thinks she owns). He needs to sort out a more definitive arrangement, or he isn't doing Sarah any favours.

HoppingPavlova · 06/01/2022 13:49

Also, why is Sarah moving the new man in while her children are in their exam years?

Exactly this also.

Lockdownbear · 06/01/2022 13:48

I really think Bob needs to see a solicitor.

Reading this I think he's the sole owner of the house that Sarah and kids are in. Kids sound old enough for Sarah to have got some sort of work in the last few years.

Would it be an option for him and wife to move into the house Sarah is in and for Sarah to move into Bill's house ?

Giving the older children the option do they want to stay with Mum elsewhere or stay with Dad in the house.

Other option he sells at market rate to Sarah and Bill.

He definitely shouldn't be subsidising two other adults.

Another question at what point was he planning to stop paying?
What happens if his kids go to uni - who pays?

Purplecatshopaholic · 06/01/2022 13:47

Well done Bob for going above and beyond, at least at first, but he is being taken for a mug now. Sarah needs to get a job, and Bob needs a backbone and a lawyers appointment. I actually feel very sorry for his wife and other child/children.

HoppingPavlova · 06/01/2022 13:47

It is hard as Bob’s children are in vital school years and Bob worries about the effect selling the house on them will have however currently Bob is living in a tiny house with his wife and baby and needs to think what effect this will have .

It sounds as though Bob is a decent guy, however, he really should have wrapped it until his children were past the vital school years and then started a new family when selling up would not be as disruptive for existing children.

BungleandGeorge · 06/01/2022 13:43

Is Bob paying the mortgage out of the child support total? Or is he paying the mortgage on top of the full amount of child support due? Who pays the upkeep on the house? I think morally she is probably entitled to a share but I’d be advising Bob to get legal advice too to work through what is fair to both

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 06/01/2022 13:39

@PearlD

I'd say that Sarah needs to book an appointment with a solicitor Smile
I think that need is just a little bit more urgent for Bob, don't you?
dworky · 06/01/2022 13:39

I think Sarah is a very relieved woman.

bonetiredwithtwins · 06/01/2022 13:37

@Ylfa

Bob should be more careful with his knob.

Why has he made even more children if he is struggling?

Why should Sarah have the financial capacity to have more children all because Bob is paying her mortgage. Sarah needs to get a grip of her own life

Bob needs a lawyer

FairFuming · 06/01/2022 13:32

@MaeRainbow

Bob should sell the house, keep deposit + credit card debt, then split the remainder 50%.

ASAP!!!!

Thus is exactly what I was going to say. All debt paid off deposit given back and all costs of selling done then she can have a share of the profits. Its been really nice of him to allow them to live there that long.
MaeRainbow · 06/01/2022 13:29

Bob should sell the house, keep deposit + credit card debt, then split the remainder 50%.

ASAP!!!!