Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling the family home- who gets what. Please help !

343 replies

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 11:28

Bob was with Sarah for 15 years . They have two children . They lived together in a big family home . Bob left when they split . The mortgage is in Bob’s name . Bob pays the mortgage .

Bob lives with his wife in their house with their son . Bob and wife pay the mortgage here . It is a financial struggle .

Sarah lives in the family home with Sarah and Bob’s children . Sarah is getting married and her new partner is moving in. Sarah’s partner is mortgage free ( he has a bungalow ) he will rent this to his son now that he is living in Bob and Sarah’s home .

Sarah wants half of the house when Bob sells it. Bob is happy to do this however Bob paid the deposit for the house from inheritance and is paying off £25k credit cards that Sarah and Bob racked up.

Should Bob still pay the mortgage when Sarah’s partner moves in?
Legally, does Bob have to wait until their youngest child is 18 before he can sell the family home ? Should Bob take off the deposit and half of credit card debit before he splits the profit from the house sale with Sarah ?
Legally does Bob have to give Sarah half ?

Bob pays the legal amount of child support and uniforms , shoes and extras . Kids stay with Bob 2 nights a week.

For clarification they were never married and house is solely in Bob’s name .

OP posts:
Forestdweller11 · 06/01/2022 15:14

There is no mersher order. They weren't married. Sarah is taking the piss really.

Gilly12345 · 06/01/2022 15:10

Bob is getting stitched up and needs a good solicitor.

blubberyboo · 06/01/2022 15:07

Bob obviously does still need to continue paying the mortgage while it exists because it’s in his name. To not pay it would mean he goes into default and the debt would never fall to Sarah or her new man.

He should draft them up a rental agreement and get a consent to lease from his lender.
If they are not willing then he should sell it at which point he would need to be prepared for Sarah to stake a beneficial interest in the property and he’ll have to pay her something

Mrstamborineman · 06/01/2022 15:06

I meant free from mortgage not free free. As in Nothing to pay. His children still need maintenance obviously

Mrstamborineman · 06/01/2022 15:06

When Sarah marries or new bf moves in bob is free. Depends if this agreement was legally binding mesher order.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 06/01/2022 15:03

Tell Bob to get legal advice.

It is commendable of him that he has had this arrangement in order to benefit the children. However, it is completely unreasonable to expect him to fund another man's children's rent!

I think you are rightly concerned as his mum OP. I would be too.

JSL52 · 06/01/2022 15:01

@Pinksparke

Bob will continue to pay child maintenance, school and uniform , pocket money and pay for a holiday for the children at least once a year. Bob also always is the one to pay for laptop , phone contracts and school trips .
Bob should always pay maintenance whether Sarah remarries or not.
3mealsaday · 06/01/2022 14:59

@TheGoldenWolfFleece

Sarah is essentially squatting in a house she doesn't own and has no right to occupy. Bob needs to see a solicitor.
Bob's children live there. Are they squatting too? As their parent, Bob is equally responsible with Sarah for housing them.
TheGoldenWolfFleece · 06/01/2022 14:53

Sarah is essentially squatting in a house she doesn't own and has no right to occupy. Bob needs to see a solicitor.

CharlotteRose90 · 06/01/2022 14:50

Judging from that she wouldn’t be owed half of his house and it was his and he paid solely for it however I think he could be decent and give her a percentage of it.

BoredZelda · 06/01/2022 14:41

This is Bob’s mum.

Bob’s mum needs to butt out and remember Bob made his own decisions and be proud he wants to do the best for his children.

RobertsRadio · 06/01/2022 14:37

Bob should sell the house, keep deposit + credit card debt, then split the remainder 50%.
ASAP!!!!

This is exactly what I would say to Bob. Time for Sarah to get a job and for her and Bungalow Bill to fund their own accommodation.

RedskyThisNight · 06/01/2022 14:35

@RoyalFamilyFan

Bloody hell! Maybe Bob actually wants his kids to have a roof over their head and not be forced to live in a one-room B and B. Op you are obviously the new wife. I am a child born of a father and second wife. They shit on the first family financially and my half-siblings lost out big time. I still judge both of my parents for this.
Not obvious that OP is the new wife.

Very obvious that you haven't read the thread.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 14:35

@EatDrinkEatDrink

If they weren't married why is his ex gf still in the house he's paying for? If she hasn't been paying the mortgage, isnt even on the mortgage and isn't married she has no claim on that house. She needs to buy a house with her new husband and give bob his house back. Bob sounds like a pushover.
Why would Bob have no responsibility to house his own kids?
BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 06/01/2022 14:34

@maddening

Sell it and split 50 50 imo, they were together 15 years, deposit and paying off joint unsec debt is neither here nor there after 15 years.

Bob should not be paying mortgage once the new chap moves in though, surely better to sell and split before.

Had Sarah paid the deposit and paid of the debts I can assure you in would not be looked at as 'neither here nor there'!
EatDrinkEatDrink · 06/01/2022 14:32

If they weren't married why is his ex gf still in the house he's paying for? If she hasn't been paying the mortgage, isnt even on the mortgage and isn't married she has no claim on that house. She needs to buy a house with her new husband and give bob his house back. Bob sounds like a pushover.

RoyalFamilyFan · 06/01/2022 14:26

Bloody hell! Maybe Bob actually wants his kids to have a roof over their head and not be forced to live in a one-room B and B.
Op you are obviously the new wife. I am a child born of a father and second wife. They shit on the first family financially and my half-siblings lost out big time. I still judge both of my parents for this.

Whatinthelord · 06/01/2022 14:25

@Pinksparke

All I will say in defensive of my son is that Sarah still doesn’t work and relies heavily on Bob to ‘cover ‘ things . Certain bills etc . Bob however is the one who always caves in so I can’t blame her for asking when Bob gives .

There is no awful situation and all parties get along - I am just concerned. That is all . Thanks for all of the support . I will make no further comment .

I’d say a sensible thing would be for Sarah’s new partner to contribute financially, maybe in the form of Hal cost of rent.

Really though I think it would have been sensible for this all to have been sorted out at the time of separate, seems like a messy situation.

However if everyone involved is happy then I’d just stay out of it.

NewMessageFrom · 06/01/2022 14:24

@Runnerduck34

Both Sarah and Bob need legal advice. Bob shouldn't leave his DC in a difficult position. I think as Sarah is now getting married they should sell the house and split assets 50/50, Sarah should have got her name on deeds and mortgage, but morally if not legally I think Bob should behave as if they were married as they were together 15 years and have DC together. Deposit and credit cards not relevant after all this time.
Deposit and credit cards not relevant after all this time.

So Bob loses out twice? Once on the deposit, and secondly sucking up the debts?

Nope thats not fair

Sarah is now marrying someone else, who has equity in another property.

Bob should calculate how much is fair to give of the equity (or value increase over last 15yrs) and sell house and give Sarah that.

All the time continuing the CM

JuneOsborne · 06/01/2022 14:24

Sound like you raised a good man. But this is Bob's business, not yours.

I'd be wondering if Sarah and her new man could buy Bob out of the house? He carries on with maintenance and laptops and stuff, but has the cash while Sarah has the house which seems to be what Bob wants for his kids.

mumshouse · 06/01/2022 14:23

*pervades here

mumshouse · 06/01/2022 14:22

Bob needs to get legal advice. He needs to go in with a list of "what happens if"s.

Main one is what happens if/when his ex's partner and children move in and Bob carries on paying the mortgage.

His ex should really have come to him with the attitude of "things are changing, so how should we proceed". I hope she didn't present it to him as a done deal.

I don't agree with this awful attitude that even pervades her of "They split up and weren't married? Why on earth didn't he fling her out onto the street?" In matters like these what is morally right counts for a lot more than what is technically legally right. It's morally right to keep a child's family life as consistent and normal as possible, as long as it can be afforded.

At a minimum now, his ex and partner should be prepared to pay Bob rent. The partner would be severely taking the piss - collecting rent on a property and living free of charge in a property someone else is paying the mortgage on.

Collaborate · 06/01/2022 14:21

I have gone through this entire thread noting some of the errors made by previous posters in advice.

If they weren't married then sarah is Bob's tenant however if she has been contributing towards the mortgage for years then she will be entitled legally to some equity.

Not correct. Not only has she not been paying the mortgage but even if she had that would be most unlikely to have created for her a beneficial interest in the property.

Sell it and split 50 50 imo, they were together 15 years, deposit and paying off joint unsec debt is neither here nor there after 15 years.

Sarah is entitled to nothing, so Bob should offer precisely that.

The house needs to be sold or Bob pay what is needed to Sarah and move back in.

Bob owes Sarah nothing.

Best thing would be to sell the house now and decide a fair division of assets. If Sarah is going to be the main carer for the children going forward, that's probably 50/50 despite Bob putting down the deposit (15 years with kids is a committed longstanding relationship)

What is fair? 50% if they were married, sure, but they weren't. Would you gift half the value of a house to your ex?

Did Bob write into the mortgage he would get that 25k back? If not Sarah may be entitled to half.

He didn't need to as he is the sole owner.

Butt out Bob's mum

I would say Bob's mum has the right to be interested in what happens to Bob.

For what it's worth, as a family lawyer, advising clients on these issues day in day out, Bob can force the sale of the house and pocket all of the proceeds.

Sarah won't be homeless as she is about to marry a guy who owns his own property, and is apparently so awash with cash that he'll let someone stay there rent free.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 06/01/2022 14:19

@RoyKentsChestHair

The only thing I can say for sure is that Bob should not be paying the mortgage on a house that Sarah’s new partner moves into while he rents his house out. Otherwise Bob is essentially subbing his ex’s new partner’s son with free rent!!

Sarah and Bob need to sever their financial ties if they’ve both moved on to new partners. The old arrangement worked when Sarah was a single mum and Bob was keeping a roof over his DCs heads.

I was Sarah. I never moved my DP in so my ex is still on my mortgage (although I pay it, my earnings aren’t high enough to actually get a mortgage, so he’s only on it in name really). Had I ever moved my DP into my home I would not have expected my ex to remain on it, much less pay for it, so that DP’s kids could get a free ride.

This.

In spades!!!

AcrossthePond55 · 06/01/2022 14:19

Legally Bob doesn't have to do anything other than pay the child maintenance (unless there is some sort of legal child order in place). Morally it sounds as if he's been a stand up guy who wanted to be sure Sarah and the children had a good roof over their heads. There are threads upon threads where one member of a splitting couple just kicks the other member out with nothing, often with children in tow.

But things are changing now that Sarah will have a new DH to 'provide' for her. If the house, in and of itself, is a good investment for Bob I'd start charging Sarah and her new DH rent. There's absolutely no reason why they should live there rent free. If he wanted to charge a slightly lower rate because he pays a lower amount of maintenance as he's been providing a 'free' home for the children in the past he can do so or he can raise his maintenance payments to cover the cost of 'shelter' for his DC. If Sarah and her new DH feel they can get a 'better deal' renting elsewhere, then they can move.

If the home is not a good investment or if Bob and his wife are seriously 'doing without' to keep a roof over Sarah and the children's heads, then the house should be sold. But I'd think that if Bob charged the new couple market/reasonable rent then his and his wife's own financial situation should improve.

If the house is sold and Bob wanted to give Sarah a share, I'd definitely pay off the CC debt first, assuming of course that the debt was really was accrued by both of them. But if, for example, a car was purchased with it and Bob kept the car I wouldn't consider that 'joint' debt. The inheritance is a greyer issue for me. If they were together at the time of the inheritance and it was used by Bob to purchase a 'family home' then I wouldn't deduct it from the proceeds. By purchasing a family home, he in essence 'gave' the inheritance to the the family. But if he purchased the home before the relationship started, then I'd deduct it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread