Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling the family home- who gets what. Please help !

343 replies

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 11:28

Bob was with Sarah for 15 years . They have two children . They lived together in a big family home . Bob left when they split . The mortgage is in Bob’s name . Bob pays the mortgage .

Bob lives with his wife in their house with their son . Bob and wife pay the mortgage here . It is a financial struggle .

Sarah lives in the family home with Sarah and Bob’s children . Sarah is getting married and her new partner is moving in. Sarah’s partner is mortgage free ( he has a bungalow ) he will rent this to his son now that he is living in Bob and Sarah’s home .

Sarah wants half of the house when Bob sells it. Bob is happy to do this however Bob paid the deposit for the house from inheritance and is paying off £25k credit cards that Sarah and Bob racked up.

Should Bob still pay the mortgage when Sarah’s partner moves in?
Legally, does Bob have to wait until their youngest child is 18 before he can sell the family home ? Should Bob take off the deposit and half of credit card debit before he splits the profit from the house sale with Sarah ?
Legally does Bob have to give Sarah half ?

Bob pays the legal amount of child support and uniforms , shoes and extras . Kids stay with Bob 2 nights a week.

For clarification they were never married and house is solely in Bob’s name .

OP posts:
reesewithoutaspoon · 06/01/2022 16:45

Either Sarah and new husband need to pay rent on the house or Bob needs to get legal advice . If Bob died, then the house would go to Bobs new wife and she could throw Sarah, her new husband and her step children out of the house and force a sale. So at the very least Bob needs to sort this out and get his head out of the sand to protect his children

ivykaty44 · 06/01/2022 16:42

Bob and Sarah need to seek legal advice

possibly mediation is the way to go

Sarah's boyfriend needs to pay bob rent at market value for half the house?

Lockdownbear · 06/01/2022 16:33

@Pinksparke

Lastly , I feel entitled to have a slight opinion being as I have bailed Bob and Sarah out many times over the years and without me passing on inheritance there is no way they could have afforded the deposit on the house or the legal fees for it .
Firstly don't view the money you passed on as inheritance - it was a gift from you. You may have inherited it, but passing it on was from you.

Bob most definitely needs proper legal advice. On the best way forward, whether that be a proper tenancy agreement, or moving Sarah out so he can sell.
Given ex / kids / don't mix business with pleasure renting to them probably isn't the best idea.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 06/01/2022 16:32

Bouledeneige read the thread or at least the OP’s posts.

Bouledeneige · 06/01/2022 16:31

All assets and debts should be split equally between Bob and his wife. But don't they have an agreement already in place from their split - why was he paying the whole mortgage? Were they married?

SpaceshiptoMars · 06/01/2022 16:21

I'm assuming Bob's new wife works full-time, even with the child?
Who owns the house Bob is currently living in?

Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 16:18

Lastly , I feel entitled to have a slight opinion being as I have bailed Bob and Sarah out many times over the years and without me passing on inheritance there is no way they could have afforded the deposit on the house or the legal fees for it .

OP posts:
Pinksparke · 06/01/2022 16:14

I feel that , until there is an official and final split, it is unfair on everyone
-Bob and his wife are struggling

  • Sarah is probably stressed deep down , wondering what she will get and anxious as one day the house she s home will have to be sold .
  • Sarah’s new partner ,I believe , is probably not fully aware of the real financial details and may be shocked to find them out . I think he maybe shocked to realise once married he will have a lot of responsibility to take on and he will need to reconsider the agreement with his son that he can live rent free in the bungalow .

It is hard . My son I feel, whilst honourable , puts his head in the sand as he knows Sarah and children will be extremely upset when the day comes where the house goes up for sale . He knows this will cause animosity .

However , Bob got married and had another child so he knew a day would come where the situation would have to be finalised .

Bob is also a great dad and I believe the children are old enough to not belive a negative narrative that their dad has ‘ thrown them out !”.

Modern families are very tough .

I am sure Sarah is kicking herself for not marrying Bob but it was evident after a few years they could not get along and spent years arguing but staying together for ‘ the children ‘.

OP posts:
Bluebluemoon · 06/01/2022 16:13

Sarah is slightly on back foot as they weren’t married and isn’t on deeds/mortgage.

Sarah isn't slightly on back foot - Sarah is up shit creek without a paddle (as long as Bob goes and gets the legal advice he should've got when they first split).

YOUNG GIRLS TAKE HEED: this is why you should ideally marry before having children - and I'm not saying this to be judgemental - it's a situation I fell into myself.

LakieLady · 06/01/2022 16:11

I think Bob should move back in to his house, and OP should update us with how that goes. Grin

That would make quite a good basis for a sitcom, if it hasn't already been done.

theemmadilemma · 06/01/2022 16:06

Since spousal maintenance usually ends on remarriage, I'd view it that way.

CM etc. remains in place, but either the family home is sold, or it becomes now a rental situation (not mortgage payment) with the newly married couple paying rent to Bob.

kittensinthekitchen · 06/01/2022 16:03

@Pregnagainagain

Hi Bob’s wife Grin
What? Bob is married to his MOTHER??? 🤯
BoredZelda · 06/01/2022 16:02

Bobs mum is entitled to look out for Bob. Why should Bob have another man live in his house rent free?

Because that is what he is choosing to do. She isn’t looking out for him, she is judging him.

A4513 · 06/01/2022 15:59

Sarah and Bob need to sever their financial ties if they’ve both moved on to new partners.

This. Long overdue and needlessly messy. Not helped by muddying the waters around what people can and cannot do legally.

Legal jurisdiction matters.
Being married here matters.

They both need to look out for themselves, but in general they need to split up properly i.e. finances included, because they've been half-arsing it.

Pregnagainagain · 06/01/2022 15:56

Hi Bob’s wife Grin

UniversalAunt · 06/01/2022 15:56

“ Sarah won't be homeless as she is about to marry a guy who owns his own property, and is apparently so awash with cash that he'll let someone stay there rent free.‘

Oooh, good point there.
Well played.
Thankfully Bob is a honourable sort.
Mum of Bob has her head screwed on & supports the goodwill between the families.

Lockdownbear · 06/01/2022 15:54

@BoredZelda

This is Bob’s mum.

Bob’s mum needs to butt out and remember Bob made his own decisions and be proud he wants to do the best for his children.

Bobs mum is entitled to look out for Bob. Why should Bob have another man live in his house rent free?

Bobs mum has 3 DGC she is right to see all three are treated fairly.

UniversalAunt · 06/01/2022 15:46

‘ Legally, does Bob have to wait until their youngest child is 18 before he can sell the family home ? NO, unless agreed as part of a legally binding agreement

Should Bob take off the deposit and half of credit card debit before he splits the profit from the house sale with Sarah ? What name is on the credit agreements? That person is legally liable to repay, married or not So Bob needs to calculate what of that debt is his & what is hers. If he has paid her debt as a favour, then Sarah needs to pay that back to Bob.

Legally does Bob have to give Sarah half ? NO, unless bound by a legal contract or divorce settlement

kittensinthekitchen · 06/01/2022 15:44

People either don't read, or have poor comprehension skills.

BOB WANTS TO GIVE SARAH HALF THE VALUE OF THE HOUSE

Bob's mum doesn't think he should.

UniversalAunt · 06/01/2022 15:38

‘ Bob respects that Sarah is the primary caregiver and has always looked after the children whilst he went to work to earn the money to pay the mortgage - so he believes she is entitled to half of the house .’

Bob has generously supported his children by providing them with a good roof over their heads, he has gone above & beyond what is required to provide for his children. Once they have split, he iis not obliged to support Sarah & she chooses not to work. Should one of the children have a condition that bars Sarah from working to be economically independent, then that would be different. Sarah will have received child benefit, any benefit due to mothers at home with children under the age of x - she has not been without income. Sell that house now & split half to Bob & half to the children to be held in trust - obviously specialist legal advice required - so that they are housed.

Did Bob do Sarah some wrong & he have been overly generous as a result?

Both Bob & Sarah need to wise up about this situation. At the moment, any sense of security is resting upon shifting sands.

If Bob were to die suddenly intestate, his whole estate would go to Mrs Bob & she could take ownership & dispose of as she pleases.

If Bob wishes to protect all of his children, he needs to see a lawyer now.

Sarah’s new fella - he’s looking for a free ride or what? Why should Bob work so that he has a roof over his head & his son lives in a rentable property free. They are taking the piss out of Bob.

Ohthatoldchestnut · 06/01/2022 15:37

May have been mentioned, but if this is in the UK and if Bob hasn't been living there for a long while, he may well get taxed on any increase in value of the property if it were to be sold as he would no longer have principal private residence relief against capital gains tax. He needs good legal and tax advice.

Derbee · 06/01/2022 15:21

I think Sarah is taking the piss, because Bob has allowed it. Bob needs legal advice, and he needs to protect his assets. Sarah needs a job by the sounds of it, or needs to agree with her new partner that he’s happy to take over her care from Bob.

UniversalAunt · 06/01/2022 15:19

Ugh, like all the best parking threads, this complexity needs a diagram.

lunar1 · 06/01/2022 15:16

Sarah needs to move out of bobs house and support herself with income and maintenance. She's moving in with a new partner so they need to figure out what they can afford.

CombatBarbie · 06/01/2022 15:15

If Sarah wants to remain in the home then Bob needs to sell her the house which her and her new partner get a mortgage to do so. If he think Sarah should have 50% then I would seriously consider Bob takes of his inheritance and half the debt then give her back what's left.

Or he sells to someone else and gives her share after inheritance and debt is deducted.

Time for Sarah to get a job and stop being a freeloader.